Petition · PE01722 · Session 5
Parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports
Signatures
0
Comments
313
Considered
6 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island-proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services, and any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.
What the petitioner did first
Formal objections, correspondence with Council Leader, Council Chief Executive, and Executive Director Development and Infrastructure, meetings with Councillors, requests for meetings with CEO and Council Leader; formal complaint raised with Council, correspondence with Michael Russell MSP, to highlight that our concerns are not being heard by the Council.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
27 Jun 20191 mention
-
16 Jan 20201 mention
-
10 Sep 20201 mention
-
12 Nov 20202 mentions
-
10 Feb 20211 mention
-
24 Mar 20211 mention
Signatures by country
2,597 online signaturesComments
313 comments, oldest first313 comments · showing 151–200
-
Christine Rose 2 Jun 2019As a regular visitor to Iona in early spring this would cause us a serious problem. Often when we are on Iona we can't get off for stormy weather the boats are cancelled so we couldn't get off to top up any charges. The worry about this will stop visitors to Islands and affect the livelihood of islanders.
-
Rob Jones 2 Jun 2019This will impact greatly, on the Island community, by increasing the cost of going to an appointment in Oban as a foot passenger on the ferry and leaving the car in Craignure car park. The cost of an annual pass is totally prohibitive.
-
jon clayton 2 Jun 2019I object to vagaries for the previously free car park. It will impact considerably to holidays on iona and to those who live or own property on the island but choose to leave their cars on Mull.
Therefore not only would it be a considerable extra expense but it would surely lead to more cars on the island. -
Joanne Morris 3 Jun 2019As a regular visitor to Mull and Iona I know that the parking charges would definitely deter many visitors and therefore have the opposite effect of helping to finance the area.
-
Stephen Raw 4 Jun 2019Looks like A&B Council want to actively discourage visitors.
-
Andrew Flockhart 4 Jun 2019The introduction of charges for parking at island ferry ports will discourage me and many others from visiting the islands
-
Nicola Reynolds 4 Jun 2019I am very concerned about the major impact these charges will have on the island communities of Mull and Iona where the ferry is their lifeline. Our visits to the islands helps to boost their economy as well as enabling them to to access facilities that re readily available to those who live on the mainland. Also the amount if will cost to visit for a week will mean a lot of people will decide not to visit Iona in particular.
-
Anne Sturrock 5 Jun 2019Parking charges will be to the detriment of the local community in the short and long term. People like me will think twice about visiting at all. If I had to get the service bus over Mull I couldn't stop en route for coffee or lunch or detour to enterprises in the island.
-
Jen Swift 6 Jun 2019Parking charges exorbitant. The whole affair has not been thought through. We are dependant on our ferries and being charged huge accounts to park for the day near the ferry port is ridiculous. As a for fire fighter I can forsee access issues on the main road as people will park there rather than pay the parking fees
-
Nic Broomhead 6 Jun 2019I do not agree with imposing parking charges as space is limited enough and will add excessive costs to already expensive trips to the mainland.
-
Anne McCann 6 Jun 2019This is likely to discourage people from visiting Iona. On every visit I spend money in the local gift shops so it will adversely affect the economy of the island.
-
Stephen Thomas 6 Jun 2019I've been coming and staying on Iona for the last 22 years, so have made so have made considerable use of the free car parking facility at the Iona Ferry. At £9 per day it would add a not insignificant cost to an 8-day stay on the Island. It would be very detrimental to both the tourist economy and to the economics for residents
-
Colin Ball 7 Jun 2019These carparks are part of lifeline ferry services. People have no choice but to use them if travelling by ferry for any purpose, including for essential medical appointments, and visiting children boarding in Oban. The consultation process has been completely flawed. The island of Iona was excluded from formal consultation entirely. The result of these charges is that Mull and Iona are likely to be a less attractive place to visit.
-
Rev Peter Sear 7 Jun 2019I am a member of the Iona Community. When visiting Iona I have to leave my car at Fionnphort car park. I understand that poor internet access on Iona will necessitate having to take the ferry from Iona each day in order to pay the parking charges.
-
Sarah Dinwoodie 7 Jun 2019Unintended consequences. Knock-on effects to Iona island business resulting from tourist behaviour (choosing not to visit or stay on Iona), with likely loss substantial revenue for the local economy and council (more than could be gained from parking fees at Fionnphort).
-
Stewart Blackledge 7 Jun 2019Parking charges will be detrimental towards the businesses on Iona. Asking people to return daily to renew their parking, whilst not having a weekly charge for people who are in residence for a week will discourage people from staying on Iona. It will also be detrimental to the campsite as it will limit those who are able to camp people with families.
-
Elizabeth Delafield 7 Jun 2019As a regular visitor to Mull and Iona, these charges would make it very difficult for me and my family to visit the islands.
-
Mike Small 7 Jun 2019This is a shambles which will cut off a whole community and cause havoc at Fionnphort. This doesn't make any sense.
-
Patricia Livingstone 7 Jun 2019I am a Member of the Iona Community who visits Iona regularly staying on Iona and helping in the Abbey as Musician. Earlier this year, over Easter i stayed for 11 days. The parking fees proposed are prohibitive, making trips very costly. ..and when staying for longer periods just impossible. Please reconsider.
-
Mary Duncanson 7 Jun 2019When I visit Iona, I'm usually going for a few days. As you require a permit to take your car on to Iona, I've always left it at Fhionnphort. The cost for parking would be prohibitive plus the fact there would be a need to come over every day to get a new parking ticket incurring ferry fares.
-
John Gourlay 8 Jun 2019Lots of people going to Iona? This must be stopped! Making everyone pay this kind of amount is a sure way of destroying the businesses on the island. Did the council ask the islanders about this?
-
Peter Marshall 8 Jun 2019These suggestions appear to take no account of the needs and situation of those who live and work on the islands, nor on the impact of businesses that need visitors. Penalising island residents and visitors on Mull and Iona so severely appears to be a particularly regressive and ill thought out scheme.
-
Sally Mair 8 Jun 2019Introducing parking charges at ferry ports will increase dependence on a bus service which is already inadequate for local use. The added cost to a visit to Iona is not insignificant. In addition, while I am on my way to and from the ferry I regularly divert and visit cafés and shops. If I am on a bus I will be unable to do this. If I do not drive across Mull, where should I cease to drive and leave my car? The train service is complicated and inadequate, the bus service does not meet my needs. If I do not Park at the ferry port what should I do? Those avoiding charges will simply park on the narrow roads and risk causing obstructions. This is a bad idea
-
Jennifer Ann Wright 8 Jun 2019I am very concerned about the effect this will have on the islands income, especially since not every ferry is met by a bus, I waited 2 hours in Craignure last time I visited with very little to do. If staying on Iona for a fortnight this would be an extra £100 to an already expensive trip.
-
Peter Phillips 8 Jun 2019It seems clear the local Council bodies are not aware of the tremendous task that is being undertaken on the island of Iona.
It seems oblivious to the thousands of people who go to the island seeking education, spiritual rejuvenation and friendship. The local Council does not appear aware of the ground breaking work being done on the island, season after season. To make the suggested parking proposals will inevitably lead to total disruption of the rhythm of life on Iona, so causing a breakdown in the economic life of the island. In my view this will then have an affect upon the Isle of Mull and the wider community.
Please keep the status quo. -
Nancy Livingston 8 Jun 2019I am an Iona Community Associate and fully support this petition. I have come to Iona every 2 or 3 years for the last 20 years. The proposed parking charges would have a dramatic effect on those of us coming to the island. I believe it would significantly damage tourism on Iona.
-
Sue Elliott 8 Jun 2019When staying on Iona for any length of time anyone wanting to leave their car at Fionnphort would need to daily get the ferry which is not at all practical. Without a car, visiting places off the bus route would not be possible and small businesses in these places would suffer.
-
Jillian Moore MBE 9 Jun 2019Charges at the islands of Scotland will certainly prevent my family from making our regular trips again.
-
Ewan Aitken 9 Jun 2019The parking charges as proposed for Mull will kill the economy of the island and for Iona as well. It would clearly be possible to have some kind of charge which allowed for over night and multiple night stats which was affordable, bringing in some income, rather than what is proposed which will do devastate the economy that it will in the end mean very little, if anything, comes in.
-
Janet Brown 9 Jun 2019For those working seasonally on Iona, the Fionnophort carpark makes the difference between being able to visit friends on Mull or being very restricted. Many homes and places of interest are a long distance from the bus routes and the numbers of service buses mean longer walks are not possible. As others have stated, visitors would not get around and island enterprises would suffer.
-
Catriona Roussel 9 Jun 2019parking charges will badly affect the islands and will deter tourist.
-
Helaine Ross 9 Jun 2019Islanders need tourism for their livelihood. Surely it will cost the country more financially to support them through unemployment benefits if they find they are unable to earn a decent wage. The Scottish government should be encouraging visitors from all round the world to come and see our beautiful country and, in doing so, help contribute to our economy.
-
David Norman 9 Jun 2019Age and disability prevent use of public transport and so parking charges in car parks, on top of other travel costs would put a visit to Iona out of my reach. This would be a form of discrimination
-
Ann Norman 9 Jun 2019High car park charges could adversely affect Iona's economy by deterring tourists from staying on the island for a week or more. Also it would discriminate against people of lower income,
-
Mary-Clare Watkins 9 Jun 2019The introduction of car parking charges is certain to have a detrimental effect on the economy of Iona
-
Christine Polhill 9 Jun 2019You cannot have considered adequately the effect on the islands if you persist in making these charges. For example when you stay on Iona there is often no signal to be able to make a call to update the daily charge, and this would be true for both tourists and residents. The very high nature of the charges would deter some who come to stay for awhile and make it impossible for others, and be an obscene charge for residents who cannot take their car onto Iona. Please drop this plan. C. Polhill
-
John Polhill 9 Jun 2019Basing any kind of system on Mull that depends on communications technology is a recipe for disaster.
-
Warren Bardsley 9 Jun 2019I am a regular visitor to the island and have numeorus friends there. This ruling will result in considerable hardship and should be withdrawn immediately
-
Juliet Horwood 10 Jun 2019As a regulator visitor to the Iona Community, this would seriously impede my ability to stay on Iona. When I visit I would always contribute to the Island economy in pubs, shops restaurants etc. How would Iona survive without the tourists and visitors especially to the Abbey and Community.
-
David Coleman 10 Jun 2019I need to bring equipment for presentations on Island. Parking charges would make this much more problematic.
-
Joan Jones 10 Jun 2019As a former member of the Iona Community's staff working on Iona, may I point out that seasonal staff do not have permits to take their cars across to Iona, and even if they did there is no parking space on the island. They need to leave their cars at Fionnphort all the time they are working on the island
- in some cases three years
- and parking charges would be totally unaffordable -
Anne Sear 11 Jun 2019As a visitor to Iona I know how important tourists are to the island's economy. High car parking charges at ferry ports would deter many visitors and have a huge detrimental impact on the economy of Iona and other islands. For many visitors, public transport is not an option.
-
Mark Alecock 11 Jun 2019So our life line service to the mainland to buy food and supplies will get now get more expensive. We're finding it impossible to book a car onto ferry most weeks as we don't get priority bookings as a resident. So we park and shop as foot passengers and you now plan to charge us to park. Shocking!
-
Emma Alecock 11 Jun 2019Introduction of parking charges would have a significant negative effect on our family life. The car park at Craignure is a life-line for our family, allowing us to travel to Oban as foot passengers to obtain vital provisions and access important amenities. This is particularly important given that it is becoming increasingly difficult to book our car on the ferry unless planned months in advance. Instead of promoting island life and encouraging families to live and work here, this is yet another example of introducing increased costs and more hurdles and barriers to island life and totally flies in the face of the islands bill, the intent of which is to protect us from unintended harm. The car park at Craignure is used almost exclusively by islanders and essential tradespeople and not tourists as tourists will bring their car across and drive around the island or will arrive as foot passengers if they intend to use public transport. In addition, removal of the lorry park will cause displacement of vehicles as this is in constant use by tradespeople and local businesses.
-
Nancy Somerville 11 Jun 2019I strongly object to the proposed parking charges on the Isle of Mull.
As someone living just outside Craignure, who did without a car here for almost 18 months, I can testify as to how difficult it is, especially out of season. Although bus services on the island are reliable they are infrequent and do not cover the whole island. Also they do not meet all ferries. Consequently, many residents have no choice but to use their own transport to access the ferry terminal at Craignure and for shopping in Tobermory or Fionnphort.
Access to medical treatment is of course another difficulty, unless you are lucky enough to live in Tobermory or in one of the few villages with a doctor's surgery. Also, I believe most islanders attend dental surgeries and opticians in Oban.
In other words, the car park in Craignure is a lifeline for residents from all over the island, using it to park while in Oban for medical or dental treatment, vet visits or shopping. Few if any visitors use it, as Craignure tends to be a place they pass through on the way to somewhere else.
For pensioners, a concession return on the ferry is one pound forty pence. The proposed car parking charge would increase this to at least five pounds forty pence, and more if medical appointments at the hospital or dentist (or vet) took longer than an hour.
Also, although not directly affected, I cannot make sense of the proposal to have the only lorry park on Mull in Bunessan.
I do not believe that these proposals could have been checked with the Scottish Government's Islands Bill. In fact, it appears that whoever drew them up knows nothing about Mull or island life! They are the equivalent of expecting people in Oban to pay a toll to leave or enter the town!
Please throw these proposals out, or at the very least carry out an islands impact assessment. -
John M Sutherland-Fisher 12 Jun 2019We have similar problems on the east coast where Highland Council is planning to welch on undertakings not to impose charges in public carparks in small towns which will destroy the viability of shops in these lifeline communities
-
Sonya Wratten 12 Jun 2019This will make it very difficult for young people, children and visitors to stay on Iona as a place of spiritual sanctuary and pilgrimage.
-
Sue Rawlings 13 Jun 2019This will be a disaster for the islands
- why reduce ferry costs ann then add parking charges? The islanders need visitors and the residents need a reasonable cost of living. This will really hamper both economics and lifestyle for Iona and similar islands. -
ROBERT N macleod 14 Jun 2019I own a hotel and this will impact our guests making travel more expensive. Local people will be impacted for mainland travel. Councillors were not I. Possession of all the facts.
-
Tony mclean 14 Jun 2019Going to add a lot of money every time we go across for shopping. And also if we go on holiday we can not leave our car and use public transport to he airport. It will be cheaper to drive to the airport and park there.