Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Island Lifeline Ferry Ports (Parking Charges) (PE1722)

Thursday 12 November 2020 Public Petitions Committee About 10:30–11:15 Petitions 39 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The second continued petition for consideration today is PE1722, lodged by Dr Shiona Ruhemann, on behalf of Iona and Mull community councils and others.

The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island proof transport infrastructure by ensuring that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports at which there are essential lifeline services, and that any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.

Members will be aware that we previously noted Mike Russell’s support for the petition. Mr Russell has recently reiterated his strong support for the petition via email correspondence to the clerks.

At our last consideration of the petition in September, we considered written responses from the Scottish Government and the petitioner, and agreed to invite the Minister for Energy, Connectivity and the Islands to give evidence at a future meeting.

Members might wish to note that we have since received a further written submission from the petitioner, which is included in our committee papers. The petitioner highlights that the use of island community impact assessments

“in no way equates to addressing the substance of the Petition, and must not be used as a reason for considering it addressed.”

I am pleased to welcome back the Minister for Energy, Connectivity and the Islands, as well as Paul Maxton, who is a senior islands expert at the Scottish Government; and Chris Wilcock, who is the head of ferries at Transport Scotland.

Before we move to questions, I invite the minister to provide a brief opening statement.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

Thank you, convener. I am pleased to be here to answer your questions in consideration of petition PE1722.

As you outlined, the petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island proof transport infrastructure by ensuring that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports. As you said, the ferries are essential lifeline services, and I know that you have had a strong interest in the wellbeing of island communities over a long period. Any proposed island parking charges should be subject to rigorous impact assessment. I also recognise that local authorities are independent corporate bodies and that therefore Scottish ministers have no remit to intervene in their day-to-day duties.

Committee members will be familiar with section 8(1) of the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018, which introduced the public sector duty that requires relevant authorities

“to prepare an island communities impact assessment in relation to”

policies, strategies or services. The commencement regulations to bring section 8(1) into force were laid in the Scottish Parliament on 3 November and are due to come into force on 23 December. Concurrently, the review of decisions regulations required under section 9(1) of the 2018 act were also laid on 3 November and are due to come into force on 23 December.

I can report that the guidance associated with the island communities impact assessments is currently out to consultation, with a closing date of 9 November. That guidance will be in place for when the ICIA duties are brought into force. In the interim period, I emphasise that the expectation has been that, wherever possible, the Scottish Government should operate in the spirit of the 2018 act and take island issues into account when developing or reviewing policies, strategies or services that we provide. The regulations will empower island communities to challenge decisions that are made by relevant authorities in respect of ICIAs, and they will provide a robust and proportionate framework for the review of ICIAs, based on transparency and accountability.

The regulations are participatory, as they allow island communities to make third-party representations following publication of a review. They provide an additional focus for relevant authorities in carrying out their island communities impact assessments, by ensuring that they consider the uniqueness of each island, provide benefits for island communities and improve accountability.

I hope that that helps to set the scene. I am happy to take questions from the committee.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you; that is very helpful. I expressed concerns that there seems to be some slowness in bringing in island communities impact assessments.

Regardless of that process, I will ask something very specific. Do you think that ferries are lifeline services to those communities, and that, as such, in any set of circumstances, people should not be charged for using the ferry terminal car parks?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

We recognise that the overwhelming majority of the ferries that we provide are lifeline services. For any islander, a ferry is a lifeline service, and they could be regarded as providing a lifeline service for some of the mainland communities that are served, because of their isolation.

We recognise that it is an important concern and that it seems unfair to communities that different parking charge policies are applied at different ferry terminals. That might seem discriminatory and damaging to islands in some respects. As I mentioned in my opening remarks, local authorities are independent corporate bodies, so we are trying to tread a path between recognising their autonomy in making those decisions and providing a legislative framework that allows for those decisions to be reviewed. ICIAs will provide that.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Therefore, you accept the argument that, if ferries are lifeline services, free parking at ferry terminals makes sense for island communities, and not having that will have a major impact. Why would a local authority choose to charge if it felt that there was any other option?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I do not want to second guess local authority decisions. There might be circumstances in which modest charging is required in order to ensure turnover of car parking, if people are using car parks for purposes other than as passengers attending the ferry terminal. I will not criticise local authorities that take decisions to put in place car parking charges; it is for them to make that decision. However, as I said in my opening remarks, going forward, we want them to consider the uniqueness of the situation and whether alternatives can be used by the local community, because, if the ferry terminal car park is the only place in which people can safely park, that might create more financial hardship for those who have to use it.

Therefore, rather than prejudge the situation in every locality, we want to ensure that, in each case when councils are considering putting in place charging, a robust impact assessment is undertaken to ensure that the measure is proportionate and fair and is not causing hardship.

10:45

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

What would happen if a local authority came back to you and said that the only reason that it was doing that was because its budgets were under massive pressure? The petitioners argue that the charges are discrimination and that there is a postcode lottery. What could the Scottish Government do to help the local authority not to discriminate?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I have alluded to this, but it is important to stress that councils are rightly separate entities from the Scottish Government. They are independent corporate bodies, and it is for them to decide how they manage their day-to-day business. That means that they will sometimes take unpopular decisions that are not supported by all in the local community. It is for locally elected representatives who are accountable to the local electorates to make those decisions on behalf of the constituents whom they represent. We can only argue—

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You and I both know that the vast majority of the income comes from the Scottish Government. If local authorities say that charges are being introduced because of budget pressures, how can the Scottish Government help in that regard? Does it have a responsibility?

To frame the question slightly differently, given that the financial pressures might come from budgeting choices at Scottish Government level, and if you accept that ferries are lifeline services, are there ways in which you can constrain or limit the choices that local authorities have on parking at ferries?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

As I said, I accept that, in the vast majority of cases, ferry services are lifeline services. Not all services are classed as such for the purposes of CalMac Ferries’ cascade policy and so forth, but almost all the services are lifeline services. The point that I am trying to get across is that we certainly respect and have to recognise the decisions that are taken locally.

I acknowledge your underlying point that many local authorities face huge financial pressures, as does the Scottish Government, particularly this year. We are all having to make tough choices on spending priorities. I would regret it if any local authority was in a position in which it felt that it had to impose parking charges for financial reasons. As I say, I hope that the local authority would take into account the wider impact of such a decision on the buoyancy of the local economy as well as taking into account the equalities impact and the impact on those who are on modest incomes.

It is hard to be definitive but, obviously, we support the general principle that you are setting out: we would like parking charges to be avoided where there is no choice for consumers as to where they can park. However, I know that a number of local authorities have made the point to the committee that they feel that they have had to introduce charges for financial reasons.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

You said that the impact assessments will come into force on 23 December, but the petitioners are strongly of the view that that

“in no way equates to addressing the substance of the Petition, and must not be used as a reason for considering it addressed.”

The petitioners are of the view that, whether or not there is an impact assessment, it will not address the substance of the petition. Do you think that an island communities impact assessment might have addressed the substance of the petition, or do you agree with the petitioners that the local authority would just have gone ahead and introduced charges anyway?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

Obviously, that is hard to judge. Parking charges on Mull, such as those at Craignure, and any associated statutory processes or assessments, are matters for Argyll and Bute Council. Road traffic legislation provides local authorities with powers to develop specific parking charging schemes where they regard that as being appropriate for particular areas. However, I do not dismiss the convener’s point about the financial drivers in this case, as has been reported. CalMac does not charge for parking at the ports that it operates on behalf of Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd and has no plans to do so. That gives an indication of where we consider the direction of travel should go, although we respect local authorities’ rights in this area.

I will give a wider answer on what we are doing to address the petition. We are developing the islands connectivity plan to succeed the Scottish ferries plan, which runs from 2013 to the end of 2022. It is likely to differ from the current format of the ferries plan and will be developed in the policy context that is provided by the recently published “National Transport Strategy: protecting our climate and improving lives” and the national islands plan. Those strategies are aligned to the Government’s purpose and national outcomes.

The islands connectivity plan will be closely linked to the emerging strategic transport projects review 2. That will consider islands connectivity more broadly, having regard to all forms of transport—aviation, ferries and fixed links—to connecting onward travel, with a particular focus on active, public and shared transport.

I would hope that, in situations such as the one that we face in this case, there will be other means by which we can avoid people having to use car parking through their using active, public and shared transport. The plan will also reflect the Government’s commitments to achieve net carbon neutrality and for setting out pathways towards zero-carbon or low-carbon emission levels and services.

On whether that adequately deals with the petition, island communities impact assessments, as members might know, can be applied retrospectively. I appreciate that there has been concern about the length of time that it has taken to develop ICIAs. It is a complex process. Paul Maxton leads on that and is very much at the heart of that work.

The regulations will be enforced from 23 December. As I said, there is a retrospective element to them. If an application is made to review a decision, that can be progressed retrospectively. Perhaps Paul Maxton might want to comment on the powers that we have to deliver that.

I appreciate that that is perhaps not a perfect answer to Gail Ross’s question, but I am trying to get across that we are doing a range of things to offset the need for parking through STPR2 and our wider national approach to transport and sustainable active travel. The framework that we are putting in place through the implementation of the island communities impact assessments provides a route by which appeals on decisions can be made—in cases where an ICIA has not been done previously, of course—to consider whether a policy is fair for the community in question, or whether it is potentially damaging to their interest.

Perhaps Mr Maxton might wish to comment on the retrospective aspects of the legislation, to give confidence that that could be applied in this situation.

Paul Maxton Scottish Government
link

The review of decisions regulations will apply to existing and new policies, strategies and services.

There are a number of grounds on which an application can be made. In the Argyll and Bute case, no ICIA was carried out and there does not appear to be any published explanation as to why. In circumstances in which there is no published decision of an ICIA, nor an explanation as to why one was not carried out, the applicant can request a review at any time after the decision has been made. There is no time limit, so as not to prejudice an applicant in those circumstances.

In circumstances in which an ICIA has been carried out but there is no published explanation, a three-month time limit applies from when the decision was made. That would also be the case in other circumstances in which an ICIA has been carried out but the applicant is not happy with aspects of its content.

I understand that the regulations will go before the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee on 9 December. By way of distinction, what I have just told you about the regulations does not take away from section 14 of the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018, whereby a local authority can apply to Scottish ministers to seek a retrospective ICIA in respect of national strategies and legislation. There is a distinction to be made there with what is proposed in the regulations. The regulations will apply so that the applicants will be island residents or community-controlled bodies, or a relevant local authority. Within the terms of the regulations, therefore, the scope for calling for a review is much wider.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Minister, in your opening remarks, you stated that the Scottish Government should be or is operating within the spirit of the 2018 act. Even though the island community impact assessments do not come into operation until 23 December, all public authorities should be operating within the spirit of the 2018 act, whether or not they can do it retrospectively.

This is more of an opinion than a fact or anything else. Would it not have been a better solution if the local authority had agreed to issue some sort of parking permit or pass to people who use the ferries? That might have deterred people who do not need to use the car park. It seems to me that there are solutions to the problem that simply have not been considered.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I do not want to second guess the processes that have taken place in Argyll and Bute Council, but I recognise the point that Ms Ross makes: that there are ways in which the needs of regular travellers and those who depend on the lifeline ferry, perhaps for medical, work or education reasons, could have a discount. That is a matter for the council, as is the charging regime, and it could consider whether there might be better ways of going forward. I am sure that we can lend support to the local authority or get advice from Transport Scotland officials about other practices that are deployed elsewhere.

As I say, we have taken CalMac’s position with regard to its own ferry services. It does not charge for parking on car parks that are owned and operated by CMAL, because it is trying to build patronage and encourage people to leave their cars behind and use active travel when they get to their destination. We are exploring how we can improve access to sustainable active travel options on CalMac services.

Even though, in this case, an islands community impact assessment does not appear to have been done, I agree with Ms Ross in the sense that I encourage all public authorities that are covered by the 2018 act to act as though the ICIAs were already in place, because they can be retrospective. It is probably a wise move to anticipate that a potentially unpopular decision might be reviewed, and to at least factor into your thinking as you develop your policy the things that you will have to consider, acting as though the ICIA is already in place. I am pleased to say that there has been good practice in the legislative proposals of the Scottish ministers—starting with Kevin Stewart, who has been followed by many other ministers since—because the policy decisions have tried to implement the principles of the ICIAs in advance of regulations coming into force.

We have learned a lot through that process and it has been helpful to my officials, who inform me about what we have done on ICIAs. I am therefore grateful to colleagues who have taken that bold step to do it early. It protects their policies against future reviews, because they have already factored in the concerns about the impacts on the islands of developing policies, thereby hopefully preventing any need for review. For example, Transport Scotland has done a lot of work on the national transport strategy to take into account the needs of island communities in framing its policy.

11:00

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

To some extent, you have addressed my question. You have indicated that various departments are currently acting in the spirit of the 2018 act, before the assessments have been introduced, but can you give some concrete examples, rather than talking in the abstract? Perhaps you could write to us with a list of such work that has taken place.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

In the interests of time, I am happy to get back to the committee with examples, but to answer Mr Mason’s question directly, I will give a couple of examples in which we have acted as though island communities impact assessments were in place.

Kevin Stewart was a pioneer in undertaking work on the recent Fuel Poverty (Targets, Definition and Strategy) (Scotland) Act 2019. Very helpfully, we learned a lot in that process through acting as though an island communities impact assessment was in place. We were successful in looking at the issues for that legislation, because we were aware that some of our island communities have much higher levels of fuel poverty than mainland communities have. Higher fuel poverty levels are common in many rural areas, particularly in the north, so we specifically took account of the needs of communities, in that respect.

Another example is the on-going work on the strategic transport projects review, which will be completed in two phases. The first phase will look at active travel and locking in the good behaviours that have resulted from Covid, and the second phase will look at the investment opportunities. The process around island communities impact assessments has been very much at the heart of that work, in order to future proof it.

Island proofing has also been very much at the heart of the development of the Covid route map and the strategic framework, which have been deployed recently. As members might know, we now use much more tailored responses that take account of local prevalence of the disease and local conditions. That has allowed island communities to have a little more freedom, at level 1, than if we had taken a national approach.

Those are examples of where we are already taking that spirit forward. I am happy to get back with more examples of what we have done, in order to give the committee confidence that the principles are being deployed in advance of the regulations coming into operation.

Paul Maxton Scottish Government
link

I will add to what the minister has stated. Island communities impact assessments have been very much at the heart of Government. The Scottish Government has been giving policy-lead seminars in order to raise awareness, and we have been giving regular advice to policy colleagues on a wide range of matters. A few examples of matters on which we have commented recently are the deposit return scheme, producer responsibility for recycling and packaging, the heat and buildings strategy and, through Covid, the vaccination strategy.

A huge amount of work is going on in relation to ICIAs. We are working very closely with our stakeholders through the partnership working group, which consists of the six island authorities, and the islands strategic group, which includes the chief executives and leaders of the six island authorities.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Does Tom Mason have any further questions?

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

No. It would be good if the minister could send us a letter with a list of examples.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I declare an interest as a former councillor for Argyll and Bute Council. At that time, I was aware that financial pressures were beginning to build and of the need for the council to look at potential revenue-gaining areas, so I am fully aware of what has been going on.

Argyll and Bute Council told the committee that financial pressures led it to consider the introduction of parking charges. That relates to the comment that I have just made about when I was a councillor. The committee understands that local authorities have autonomy over their own budgets and that they receive specific funding support from the Scottish Government for internal ferry services. I know that from when we have set budgets, before. However, it is clear that the council was forced to explore parking charges as an option in the face of the challenging financial situation. How can the Scottish Government assist local authorities to avoid introducing parking charges in the future, bearing in mind what we have already discussed?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I recognise Mr Corry’s local interest and knowledge. I made the point that I am cognisant of the fact that, as other public bodies are, local authorities are under enormous financial pressure, particularly because of the pandemic, although the public finance environment was already challenging for all of us, including the Scottish Government, and has been for a decade.

However, we have tried to take what we hope will be decisive action to commit additional resources to local authorities in response specifically to Covid. Some £382 million of additional funding is being provided to local authorities. On 8 October, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Ms Forbes, announced a package of financial flexibilities for Scotland’s local authorities that, in theory, could be worth up to £600 million over the next two years. I appreciate that, at local level, the scale and nature of the benefits will vary. The Scottish ministers and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities are also close to finalising a lost-income scheme that will be worth an estimated £90 million.

We believe that taken together those Covid-19-related measures bring the value of the overall support package for councils up to approximately £1 billion. The current local government finance settlement for 2020-21 provides an increase in day-to-day spending of around £589 million and recognises that individual decisions are available to local authorities in managing their budgets and allocating financial resources on the basis of local need.

We believe that we are providing support to councils. Obviously, we continue to listen as the particular pressures that they face in the current financial year become more evident as time passes and individual services come under more pressure. I hope that the talks between COSLA and the Government are fruitful and that the additional £90 million of support can help.

Mr Corry might have been referring to a longer-term issue around financial sustainability post-Covid and the need for parking charges, for example, in that context. I have not discussed that matter specifically with Argyll and Bute Council, but I hope that we can get to a position in which those charges would be less necessary for the local circumstances.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Does the Scottish Government accept that lifeline services are its concern, so assistance should be given to local authorities to reflect that financially, as the situation requires? In particular, I ask the minister to reflect on what the convener said about there being no choice for island residents.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I certainly acknowledge that the situation is much more challenging where there is no alternative place to park and passengers have no options on where they may park their cars. There might be free, or cheaper, alternatives to a council-owned car park. In the case of Mull, I do not believe that that is the case, so the situation is more challenging for commuters who use the service. I understand why the petitioners have raised concerns.

As I have said, our approach is that CalMac should not charge for car parks that it controls, for reasons to which Mr Corry and the convener have alluded. Lifeline services are lifeline services; we try to make it as easy as possible for consumers to use them.

With the convener’s permission, I invite Chris Wilcock, who is head of our ferries unit, to give an overview of what is happening on engagement with local authorities, including Argyll and Bute Council, on the general principle that Mr Corry and the convener have referred to, because that might be a factor that will come through in the strategic transport projects review or other strategic documents that Transport Scotland will be taking forward.

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

I would echo a number of the points that the minister made. I would also reflect points that came across from the petitioner in relation to our plans. We do not charge at existing car parks that we have control over through CMAL or CalMac Ferries Ltd. The reason is that, although we are keen to encourage people to travel to the port by active travel or public transport if possible, if it is not possible, we want them to have options that mean that they do not have to take their vehicle on the vessel, so that we can free up deck space. From our perspective, with any such proposal we would expect to consider things such as its impact on affordability, particularly for people on low incomes, and its impact on deck space.

There are two elements to the wider engagement that we are having with local authorities. We are currently speaking to the local authorities that run lifeline ferry services—that is a factor for Argyll and Bute Council and for Orkney and Shetland councils. Obviously, we have given them funding in the past, and we are engaging with them on what funding will be required going forward in what is a particularly tight budget situation.

We will also engage more widely, not just with local authorities but with communities and stakeholders across the piece, as we roll out the islands connectivity plan. As the minister has articulated, we are keen to look beyond just the ferries plan and ferry services; we will look at other modes. In particular, we will consider aviation. We want to build on lessons from the national transport strategy and the strategic transport projects review. Where appropriate, we will explore things such as fixed links and other elements. We will be involved with local authorities on all those aspects.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Shetland Islands Council has called on the Scottish Government to island proof transport infrastructure through fair funding for ferry services, on the basis that if fair funding had been delivered previously, difficult decisions about car parking charges might not have arisen. How do you respond to that?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

First, just as I acknowledged the issues with regard to Argyll and Bute Council services, I acknowledge the situation for Shetland Islands Council. We are sympathetic to the significant financial challenges that all local authorities in Scotland face. It perhaps sounds unsympathetic to say so, but at the moment, local authority ferry services are the responsibility of the authorities. However, we recognise the growing financial challenge that they face in delivering those services and maintaining service quality.

For local authorities that are responsible for running ferry services, in the current financial year, we have provided £11.5 million of additional support over and above the money in the local government financial settlement that, under the funding formula, goes to them specifically to operate ferry services. I acknowledge that that does not meet the full cost of operating their services, but we have been increasing the percentage support to local authorities year on year. Over the past three years, we have put in place a total of £32.5 million of extra funding to support them.

As Mr Wilcock suggested, we are having on-going dialogue with Shetland Islands Council, Orkney Islands Council, Argyll and Bute Council and Highland Council, in advance of the draft budget being published, on their on-going needs for the next financial year. I acknowledge the challenges that they face, and I know that it is not easy for them. We hope to get to a position in which the services are genuinely sustainable, but that will obviously be wrapped up in the budget discussions that we will have in the near future.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

What other relevant transport-related policies are in place to protect vulnerable rural and island communities from the impact of the rising cost of living?

11:15

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

As I and Chris Wilcock have mentioned, the work that we are doing on the islands connectivity plan is of particular importance. Any work that we do on that will be subject to preparation of an ICIA.

We are developing the islands connectivity plan to succeed the current ferries plan. In addition, the national islands plan is now in place. It takes a human rights approach—if it was a stick of rock, that would be what you would see if you cut it open. At the heart of the national islands plan is how we reflect the needs of islanders and make sure that our policies are fair to islanders. I take that very seriously, so the islands connectivity plan will be critical. To an extent, though, everything that we do in the Clyde, Hebrides and northern isles ferry services contracts is done to support island communities and communities on remote peninsulas on the mainland.

A core theme of the work that we do is consideration of the impacts on islanders. We do not always get it right; we occasionally identify issues, but we try to respond and to fix them as they arise. We take very seriously indeed our responsibilities to the island communities—not just in Argyll and Bute, but across the whole of Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I apologise to Maurice Corry—I should have called him back in.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

Thank you, convener—apology accepted.

I want to follow up on my question about Argyll and Bute Council and David Torrance’s question about funding. Mr Wilcock made a comment about fixed links. Some years ago, the Scottish Government held a review, as a result of which bridge tolls were removed throughout Scotland. That decision was based on the unfairness of the geographical issues that were faced by people who had to commute regularly for jobs and so on.

I have a question that is related to the one that I asked the minister about lifeline services being the concern of the Scottish Government. Given the Scottish Government’s policy of bridge toll removal, would it not be fair for lifeline car parks, such as the Craignure car park on Mull in my home area of Argyll and Bute, to be considered in the same way throughout Scotland? Should particular cognisance not be taken of that in the impact assessment? I invite the minister to comment, and any of his officials who would like to do so.

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

That is a fair question, the principle of which I understand. You make the comparison with charges for fixed links, the public policy on which is that we should remove those, where we can do so. I am pleased that we have been able to do that.

That ties in with the approach that CalMac takes in recognising the importance of maintaining accessibility to services. Through the road equivalent tariff, we have tried to bring down the total cost of journeys for passengers with vehicles. We have taken a number of measures to improve accessibility and affordability. In the circumstance in question, the decision was taken by the local authority rather than by the Scottish ministers. I am not dismissing the point that you and the convener have made about the financial pressures on Argyll and Bute Council; indeed, I have outlined some of the ways in which we are trying to help the council.

As Mr Maxton outlined, the council’s decision could be reviewed once the regulations come into force on 23 December. If there is unfairness—I stress the word “if”, because I cannot prejudge the matter—in the policy position, that would revealed in any subsequent review.

I take the point that Mr Corry makes, which we can consider as part of our forward look at policy. I do not know whether Mr Wilcock wants to comment on whether that has been looked at already; I am not aware of whether it has been. The issue is certainly one that we can bear in mind in the future. Where CalMac delivers services from ports that are owned by CMAL, we have taken the decision not to charge passengers for parking their vehicles at those locations.

Chris Wilcock Transport Scotland
link

I would echo what the minister said. I note the parallels that you flag up, Mr Corry, which would have come within the trunk road network, so the decisions would have been within the remit of Transport Scotland and the Scottish ministers. The issue that we are discussing at the moment—we are focused on the Argyll and Bute example—is one for local authorities. Those car parks are not within our control, so the issue is very much for local authorities.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In conclusion, although there has been a lot of discussion about impact assessments, it is important to highlight that the petitioners do not believe that those, in themselves, will resolve the issues that are raised by the petition. We have had an interesting discussion about impact assessments, but the petitioners are concerned with a fundamental issue. The petition urges the Scottish Government

“to island-proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services”.

It then says that there should be impact assessments. It seems that the Scottish Government agrees with the petition—the cabinet secretary has agreed that these are lifeline services. In that case, why cannot you simply agree to implement what the petition is calling for and make it not an option for local authorities to charge for car parking at ferry terminals, on the basis that the Scottish Government agrees that these are lifeline services for island communities?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I recognise that that is a fair question to ask in the context of what has been discussed today. We need to think about how we can take forward a dialogue with local authorities, either individually or collectively, about the issue. As Mr Wilcock has confirmed, and as I said earlier, we recognise the autonomy of local authorities. All members of the committee would be concerned if Scottish ministers were to start stomping over existing arrangements for local authority autonomy in making such decisions.

We can take the issue into account in the work that we are doing on the islands connectivity plan to see whether any measures could come out of that to address the anomaly, where it arises in a small number of locations, in order to ensure that there is parity of treatment for the people whom Maurice Corry identified, who have to make important journeys. However, I do not want to state what we will do in that regard just now.

We have to recognise the limits of our powers to intervene in issues around local authority-owned car parks, but there is perhaps room for discussion with local authorities about how best to address the issue through the islands connectivity plan and STPR2, which we have also discussed. We should see whether there is any scope for using a positive approach to encourage the use of sustainable active travel, so that people leave their cars behind and perhaps use more sustainable forms of transport onwards from the ferry journey. That is part of our thinking around the encouragement of sustainable active travel.

I cannot give any promises, but I recognise the point that you are making, convener, and we will try to come back to the committee with anything that we can learn from the islands connectivity plan and STPR2 processes.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

As you know, minister, I only ever ask reasonable questions. It would be useful if you could provide details of the work that is done around the issue.

On the issue of dialogue, everyone recognises the autonomy of local authorities. However, if the Government has a fundamental policy that ferries are a lifeline service and, therefore, recognises that car parking at ferry terminals is part of accessing a lifeline service, it is possible that local authorities will have to accept Scottish Government direction in that regard. There are other examples of that happening. The financial dependence of local authorities on the Scottish Government is a separate issue, but, in terms of the law and policy, there are things that local authorities have to abide by and recognise.

Let us look at the issue from the petitioners’ point of view. If the Scottish Government believes that ferries are fundamental to the operation of transport with regard to the sustainability of island communities, is it not the case that you agree with the petitioners? Should you not therefore simply be saying that although we can have a conversation about the funding challenges for local authorities, charging for car parking at ferry terminals is unacceptable? It would not be acceptable if a local authority decided to act against anti-discrimination legislation in terms of access and so on, so why is it acceptable for them to charge for access to a lifeline service?

Paul Wheelhouse SNP South Scotland
link

I have great sympathy with the point that you are making, and with the petitioners’ arguments. Our position is that, in practice, where it is practical, CalMac does not impose parking charges. That is a clear example of what we want the direction of travel to be in that respect. I do not want to prejudge any discussion that we will have with local authorities, but I can give an undertaking to try to work on the issue further and come back to the committee with the results of any positive discussions that we have with the local authority and with colleagues in Transport Scotland, as well as with wider local authorities that have an interest, such as Shetland Islands Council, which, obviously, feels strongly about the issue, too.

At this point in time, I do not want to rush to judgement. However, I certainly have great sympathy with the point that you are making. We recognise that, in many cases, people are on low incomes and, therefore, parking charges can be an additional cost that they might want to avoid.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you for that. You have given us a lot of your time, which we appreciate, and we note that you have committed to come back to the committee on various issues.

Because I am conscious of time, rather than going round the committee for views just now, I suggest that, as we decided to do in relation to the previous petition that we discussed, we should reflect on what has been said today and, once we have received further information from minister and responses from interested parties to what they have heard today, discuss all of that at a later meeting. Is that acceptable? I think that people are generally agreeing to that.

I thank the minister and his officials, Mr Maxton and Mr Wilcock, for their attendance. We particularly appreciate the minister’s attendance, as he has been here for a double session, and we have also spent longer on the petitions than we expected to. However, we hope that you understand, minister, that these are issues that the committee takes an interest in, in terms of representations that have been made to us.

I will suspend the meeting for five minutes. We have quite a bit of our agenda still to get through, and we might need to think about whether that is manageable.

11:27 Meeting suspended.

11:32 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 86
  2. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 39
  3. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  4. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  7. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. 11:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.