Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01722 · Session 5

Parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports

Closed Submitted 30 Apr 2019 Transport
Signatures
0
2,597 online signatures with a country
Comments
313
Considered
6 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island-proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services, and any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.

What the petitioner did first

Formal objections, correspondence with Council Leader, Council Chief Executive, and Executive Director Development and Infrastructure, meetings with Councillors, requests for meetings with CEO and Council Leader; formal complaint raised with Council, correspondence with Michael Russell MSP, to highlight that our concerns are not being heard by the Council.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Jun 2019
    1 mention
  2. 16 Jan 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    2 mentions
  5. 10 Feb 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 24 Mar 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,597 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,614 62.1%
  2. United Kingdom498 19.2%
  3. England391 15.1%
  4. United States21 0.8%
  5. Wales15 0.6%
  6. Northern Ireland8 0.3%
  7. France6 0.2%
  8. Not given5 0.2%
  9. Netherlands5 0.2%
  10. Germany5 0.2%
  11. 13 other countries29 1.1%

Comments

313 comments, oldest first
313 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Katriona Fox Lloyd 14 Jun 2019
    I think this is a very poorly thought out proposal. Anyone having to leave Iona and Mull for work, business reasons, hospital appointments and treatment are going to be seriously disadvantaged compared with people living on the mainland. The public transport timetables do not always fir with the ferry timetables, meaning that people must use cars to travel throughout the island.
  2. Anne Roberts 14 Jun 2019
    I visit Mull but driving a small camper van will make parking difficult for me with the new rules. I'm afraid that this year's already booked stay may well be a test and a last visit. We spend a fair few hundred pounds on Mull. They need visitors for the local economy
  3. Margaret Campbell 14 Jun 2019
    For Iona residents needing to cross this is grossly unfair... for pilgrims staying on Iona, this becomes a huge additional cost which, when deterring, would cause real problems to the economy of the island. There has to be some solution worked out with the people of Mull and Iona.
  4. Valerie Owen 14 Jun 2019
    I live on the island and would make it much more expensive for shoping and hospital visit this would be another tax on the islanders and effects shops hotels and tourism .
  5. Margaret Bruce 14 Jun 2019
    The impact on local people who need to travel and park in order to work is untenable. These are the very folk who serve the community and also staff the services that bring in money from tourism! This cannot be seen as fair!
  6. Bruce Blackadder 14 Jun 2019
    If the charges are imposed it would be cheaper and easier to take my car to Oban rather than use bus from Tobermory then ferry.
  7. Rebecca Gallagher 14 Jun 2019
    These charges are not about helping with the current infrastructure problems on the island and are only going to intensify these issues.
  8. Maureen Dehany 14 Jun 2019
    Any parking charges will have a devastating effect on the community on Mull and Iona and this proposed order should be quashed immediately
  9. Doris Hargreaves 14 Jun 2019
    We live on a steep hill in Tobermory, and as an OAP I need my car to get my shopping, prescription and post office.
  10. Avril Lowe 14 Jun 2019
    Charges for parking in the Ledaig car park (Tobermory) will displace cars and campervans to the Main Street, which is already overloaded, and to residential areas, making life difficult for residents.
  11. Alicia Hendrick 14 Jun 2019
    I am unhappy that Argyll And Bute Council have not considered the impact these charges will have on our fragile communities
  12. JoanMackay 14 Jun 2019
    This ruling should be withdrawn it will destro Mull and Iona.
  13. Mary Macgregor 14 Jun 2019
    Full traffic management plan required.
  14. Gillian Wilshire 14 Jun 2019
    Making island living more expensive .
  15. Eugenie Thomasson 14 Jun 2019
    This TRO is going to make living and working on Mull near to impossible. A family member commutes to Oban on the ferry for work and the car park in Craignure is literally our only choice, I also rely on the free car parks for my business and there appears to be nowhere for commercial vehicles to park anywhere, except Bunessan! It is ridiculous and makes the Council look like fools, especially the Tro for Tobermory, the town will be a shambles.
  16. Kathryn Dyer Simpson 14 Jun 2019
    As a resident of Mull, my 'lifeline services' will be much harder to use. Absolutely disgraceful that a corrupt council wants to raise money by making it harder and even more expensive to make Mull our home.
  17. Michael Hogan 14 Jun 2019
    As a Mull resident, who works on Iona for part of the year, I know how disruptive this proposal will be. Car parks are essential for those going to Oban for health appointments (I have two in the next 28 days) or for those who currently stay on Iona but don't bring their car across as it isn't 'needed'. What a bizarre situation that will be created where Iona residents will find it cheaper to bring their car onto Iona than to leave it parked up in Fionnphort! Of course this is precisely the type of decision that the 'Islands Act' was designed to prevent!
    The whole process has been organised to avoid any island input. So, Iona was deemed not to need consulting because all the car parks were on Mull, the decision was taken at a meeting rather than a hearing which meant it could take place in Oban and, for similarly spurious reasons, our community representatives were refused any opportunity to speak at the meeting. This meant that the only 'objections' the councillors had in front of them was a 'summary' of objections which the officers prepared and which was incomplete, inaccurate and partisan. I'm not able to comment on the legality of each of the actions taken by the officers but it is clear that the aim was to ensure that local communities were silenced and to ensure there any vestiges of democracy were removed.
  18. Felicity Hansen 14 Jun 2019
    I am a resident of Mull. Public transport is very limited here. It will be much more expensive for me to make shopping trips and trips for medical appointments if I have to pay for parking. I get a concessionary fare on the ferry but the effect will be more than cancelled out by the parking charges.
  19. Alan Jack 14 Jun 2019
    A family member and I are both retired teachers, having taught almost all of our working lives on the Island of Mull. Due to a number of health conditions, we require to travel to hospitals in Oban and Glasgow. Due, at times to lack of suitable ferries, we require to spend a whole day in Oban or even an overnight stay in Glasgow. Unlike people living, for example, in Oban, we already incur a cost to attend these appointments. Are we to be further penalised because we live on an island?
  20. Anne MacLean 14 Jun 2019
    Done
  21. Allyson Langthorne 14 Jun 2019
    We are penalised heavily for living on an island. Parking charges will increase the already expensive cost of living on Mull.
  22. William Arthur 14 Jun 2019
    It has been acknowledged that there is a need for some form of parking restrictions at certain locations on the Isle of Mull but to impose such draconian regulations without adequate consultation with those involved is truly undemocratic and lacks understanding. Come forth from your ivory towers you officials and councillors and listen to the people of the islands.
  23. Jeffrey Moore, 14 Jun 2019
    As an islander, I and family members have to visit the mainland for hospital appointments and have to leave the car at the port, some times for a couple of days. In addition, if visiting Glasgow or Edinburgh, it is more practical to use public transport, which means leaving the car at the port.
    In general, people will park in inappropriate places to avoid charges.
  24. Shelagh Medic 14 Jun 2019
    As visitors to Mull and Iona in our motorhome I am shocked and disgusted that we will no longer be able to park in Tobermory or for the Iona ferry. If this goes ahead myself and the majority of motorhome owners will be forced to stop visiting, this will have an impact on a lot of island businesses from campsites to shops. If we are not welcome please put a notice In the media instead of punishing the islanders
  25. Mairi Robertson 14 Jun 2019
    Can't believe you give us RET then charge us parking fees.Robbing Peter to pay Paul
  26. Alexander McLachlan 14 Jun 2019
    This would surely hurt tourism , and therefore the local communities , stupid greed ridden idea
  27. Maureen Smith 14 Jun 2019
    I could not afford the parking fee
    When going to the Mainland which
    Is frequently.
  28. Alan Day 14 Jun 2019
    I have no objection to paying a parking fee as a tourist, but it is unreasonable to expect the islanders to have to pay. Provide a free permit for islanders that is funded by those visiting the island.
  29. Rosie Swinbanks 14 Jun 2019
    the Scottish Islands should always be given added consideration before decisions are made
  30. Avril Lowe 14 Jun 2019
    Parking charges at Ledaig car park will displace vehicles to the already congested Main Street, or to residential areas, which will impact on residents. There are safety issues with emergency services needing to navigate the main st.
  31. Hugh Mac Innes 14 Jun 2019
    A huge NO to parking charges
  32. Peter Henness 14 Jun 2019
    Crazy idea, all the surrounding roads will be blocked with camper vans in the summer and the locals will be out of pocket all year long!
    Isn't the land owned by the crown anyway?
  33. Donald Scott 14 Jun 2019
    People who live in remote island communities have enough challenges financially and physically without having interference from remote legislatures adding to the problem.
  34. Jean Wilkinson 14 Jun 2019
    It's expensive enough living on an island. If I need to leave the island I leave my car in the ferry car park but & cannot afford to pay this unfair tax on island residents.
  35. Jane menzies 14 Jun 2019
    This has been rushed through by the council without them seriously considering the financial effect on the residents.
  36. Josephine Austin 14 Jun 2019
    If heading to Oban for a hospital appointment this is unexacceptable additional cost.
  37. Iain Forbes 14 Jun 2019
    Not fair on all levels..
  38. Jane Allan 14 Jun 2019
    The tariff of £9 per day is extreme. An hourly rate at reduced rate would be more acceptable but no charge for Iona residents.
  39. Mandy Eaglen 14 Jun 2019
    The proposed parking charges will create considerable disadvantage to islanders and to businesses on the island. It is disgusting and shameful that a full island impact survey has not been carried out.
  40. Denise regan 14 Jun 2019
    The council of Argyll and Bute have not listened or have any idea how this island works between the pier at craguire and now the car park fees how do they who do not even live here day to day trying to make in the season enough money for the year when winter is so quite. We mull have not been listened to at all and I feel all of mull should boycot and refuse to pay, how on earth can a worker pay £9 a day and then we're is that extra money coming from its a disgrace and Argyll and Bute should be taken to court over this if we mull took these councillors to court I'm sure we could win
  41. Lynne Noble 14 Jun 2019
    These parking charges are a tax on island residents. The introduction of RET on the ferries means the ferries are full & we have no choice but to park car to go to hospital app etc. We only have one main food store, which is expensive & will no have to pay to park to do essential shopping unlike mainland who have free parking cheap supermarkets.
    Banning camper vans from the car park will force them to use the main st causing dangerous congestion & even close the road. Last year the Main st was blocked for over 40 minutes when a delivery lorry & large camper van were going in opposite directions & could not manoeuvre past each other, with the billed up of traffic one side had to reverse the length of the street .
    This proposal is a short sighted plan by money grabbing council voted in by councillors who are not elected by our Island & have not had the foresite to investigate the situation before voting.
    We have been final given RET on the ferries only to have the benefit taken away by parking charges.
  42. Michelle Erskine on behalf of The Aarskog Foundation. 14 Jun 2019
    As a Rare Disease Charity, our patients and families come to Mull regularly, many travelling from across the UK and others from neighbouring Islands or as
    far as the US. Our families would find it unaffordable and not financially viable for them to spend
    any time here. Not all disabilities are visible in our Rare Disease community! This proposed TRO will have a huge negative impact for us.
  43. Barbara Atkinson 14 Jun 2019
    I have visited Mull & Iona fir 13 + years .
    This scheme would impact on the whine community of both islanders and visitors
    .
  44. Karen Bass 14 Jun 2019
    Having lived on Iona for 4 years I am concerned of the hardship this will bring to many, possibly cutting off transport options for some.
  45. Iain Wardhaugh 14 Jun 2019
    Find the money elsewhere
  46. Alexander Macaulay 14 Jun 2019
    An Island tax. We go on a ferry from Craignure. What choice do we have. The councillors involved must be identified and ousted at the publics earliest opportunity.
  47. Tim Dawson 14 Jun 2019
    These charges will make life really difficult for islanders, particularly those going off island for several days. Many living in the SW of Mull have to use their cars to go to Craignure because there's not a bus for every ferry. Without a car ferry delays can leave one stranded.
  48. Linda Dawson 14 Jun 2019
    This is going to hit islanders hard, particularly those needing long term parking at Craignure and Fionnphort.
  49. Susan Batty 14 Jun 2019
    I holiday on Mull & support the ferries, local shops, pubs & cafes please don't drive the tourists away as this would be detrimental for all of the above. Also please take into consideration the devastating effect this would have on all the people who call Mull their home.
  50. Morven MacLean 15 Jun 2019
    Its ridiculous, our town will not cope!