Petition · PE01722 · Session 5
Parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports
Signatures
0
Comments
313
Considered
6 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island-proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services, and any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.
What the petitioner did first
Formal objections, correspondence with Council Leader, Council Chief Executive, and Executive Director Development and Infrastructure, meetings with Councillors, requests for meetings with CEO and Council Leader; formal complaint raised with Council, correspondence with Michael Russell MSP, to highlight that our concerns are not being heard by the Council.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
27 Jun 20191 mention
-
16 Jan 20201 mention
-
10 Sep 20201 mention
-
12 Nov 20202 mentions
-
10 Feb 20211 mention
-
24 Mar 20211 mention
Signatures by country
2,597 online signaturesComments
313 comments, oldest first313 comments · showing 251–300
-
Denise Regan 15 Jun 2019I find Argyll and Bute council a disgrace to be the cause of destroying people's businesses whom have worked for years Totally wrong in how you all have conducted yourself in ignoring the Isle of Mull
-
Kathryn Maccallum 15 Jun 2019These are islands whose economy is dependent on Tourism . With Calmac struggling due to an elderly fleet and now charging an exorbitant charging fee tourism and local businesses will be affected . I thought all the Pirates had left the West Coast but I see they have a base at Kilmory .
-
Val slaven 15 Jun 2019Life line for the islanders snd to the economy. Locals should have petmits especially when working and vital supplies will increase its like anothet tax .
-
Angus Stewart 15 Jun 2019An ill-considered ransom operation that will exasperate our problems.
-
Ruth Harvey 15 Jun 2019Please reconsider these proposals which appear discriminatory and could have an intensely detrimental affect on island life.
-
Brian Jones 15 Jun 2019I am a resident of Mull and feel that the Scottish Government will have let their citizens down if this is not addressed. The amount of support given to the islands in the past will count for nothing if these charges are enforced. It is a LIFELINE issue.
-
Andrew Tomison 15 Jun 2019This charge overnight will make a day trip on foot to oban for most of us 3 times as expensive and no doubt in thd short term cause traffic congestion on the roads in Craignure until the roadside is made no parking as well
This decision should be reversed -
John Wilshire 15 Jun 2019How on Earth are we as pensioners expected to pay to park our car at Craignure when goig to Oban for Hospital appointments etc.have never heard of this horrendous idea on any other Island.
-
Julia Jeffree 15 Jun 2019£9 a day is extortionate and will cause real difficulties for people who choose to cross on ferries as a foot passenger and need to leave their car at the terminal for several days.
-
Tracey Campbell 15 Jun 2019Disgusting behaviour from Argyll and Bute Council it should be thrown out life is hard enough on the islands
-
Helen Stace 15 Jun 2019The islanders of Mull and Iona have presented copious evidence re how bad this is for the islands and it has been totally ignored. Shameful!
-
Kirsty Blackhall 15 Jun 2019As a resident of an island i can safely say that it would be a disaster for all islanders to have to pay for parking at ferry ports. If we need to go to hospital, the dentist or opticians we have no option but to use the car parks available. We don't choose to park there for fun. We need these car parks in order for us to access the same health are facilities as the residents of mainland Scotland.
-
Mrs Wendy Lloyd 15 Jun 2019As someone who works from home but has to travel on and off the island for work quite a bit this will seriously restrict my travel options already managed under a tight budget. This is a very counter intuitive idea if wanting to boost island economic activity.
-
Shelagh Reade 15 Jun 2019Island life.. it is different to Mainland living and Argyll and Bute Council should know this. Will be detrimental to all the businesses on Mull and Iona.
-
Shona Stirling 15 Jun 2019Totally ridiculous idea ,will cause more problems than it will solve !
-
Sally Clegg 15 Jun 2019Not only will the parking charges deter tourists but they will seriously affect locals. The plan is ill considered and very possibly unworkable. Shame on A&B council.
-
Moira MacGilp Westland 15 Jun 2019please help us to prevent these unfair charges being imposed on us by A&B council who have not listened to our objections and the reasons
-
Iain Mackenzie 16 Jun 2019As volunteer it worries me that we will struggal to get our vehicals parked if we get a call out! We already struggal for parking as it is!
-
Susan Spreckley 16 Jun 2019Island life has its difficulties and sadly the council seems to be hell bent making life even more difficult. I fail to understand why car parking charges are being forced on a community that clearly does not want or need it.
-
Sally Miller 16 Jun 2019introducing these charges will significantly affect both locals and tourists in a detrimental manner
-
Ronald Ferguson 16 Jun 2019Support for lifeline services is crucial for island communities.
-
Eileen Bright 16 Jun 2019As regular tourists to the island I expect. To pay for parking. However I think it is so wrong to expect people who live and work on the islands to pay.
-
Deborah Harper 17 Jun 2019We are regular visitors who have a property on the island, we support the community fully and think these charges are disgraceful. The island is becoming a victim of its own success!
-
Mary Corbett 17 Jun 2019Parking charges will have a massive impact on our fragile island communities. People trying to survive on lower incomes will find visits to Oban impossible. We already pay so much more for our basics of food and fuel due to cost of delivery. The parking charges will affect tourism and everyone will try to park elsewhere to avoid paying, resulting in parking chaos and dangerous situations. The council should be trying to support us, not damaging the delicate balance of our economy.
-
Sheila Mcrae 17 Jun 2019The charges at the car park at Fionnphort are unfair as visitors must park there as they cannot take them on the ferry
-
steve davies 17 Jun 2019I have to go off island a lot to attend appointments and on many occasion stay overnight and the parking cost would be prohibitive.
-
Ruth Cameron 17 Jun 2019I am a native of Mull and Just because I do not live there anymore I want to support the ones that do ,as I know things like this ludicrous scheme will bring to islanders. Governments have not idea the impact will have especially when tourists are involved as well .People will just stop coming and then where will thing's be . Are the government going to subsidise locals for loss of earnins! I don't think so . Every decision that is made has an impact on everyday island living which can be hard enough without these do gooders trying to get brownie points!
-
ANNMARIE WELLS 17 Jun 2019My family live on Mull and will have a detrimental affect on their lives.This charge is an outrageous tax on the people of Mull and should be cancelled forthwith.
-
Ruth Cameron 17 Jun 2019As a native of Mull i know the impact this will have on the island and the people that live there messing with there everyday lives, it's disgusting and the so called powers that be have not got a clue!
Someone is obviously trying to score Brownie points here are they not ! -
Laura wood 17 Jun 2019Does the government not get that the more they charge for parking and fairs the less people will come visit leading to poverty in the area and business closures
-
Stan MacMillan 17 Jun 2019These suggestions appear to take no account of the needs and situation of those who live and work on the islands, nor on the impact of businesses that need visitors. Penalising island residents and visitors on Mull and Iona
-
Jacqueline Daly 17 Jun 2019Disgusting behaviour of the Argyll and Bite councillor s Living on Mill is already a lot more expensive than the mainland and to pay 9£for parking is disgusting when we have no other choice
-
Christian Maclean 17 Jun 2019Travelling to Iona by public transport us impossible for most people in the Highlands. I live relatively close to Inverness but the bus timetable to Oban means that it is impossible to reach or return from Iona in a day. My brother runs a successful eco hostel there, and I often work on Iona. I have no option but to travel by car. This move penalises people who don't have other options but more importantly, will put off tourists already concerned at the high travel costs to get there. His will impact directly on islanders struggling to run businesses in a remote rural location.
-
Elspeth MacArthur 17 Jun 2019As a grand daughter of Iona I appreciate, and strongly support, the need for the islanders to be able to sustain their livelihoods
- threatened by this completely unthought through proposal. -
Ann Evans 17 Jun 2019It is already more expensive and more difficult when living on an island and any hospital appointments etc will mean an much greater cost for people who can ill affford ir
-
Hylda Marsh 18 Jun 2019We have a shop at on the Main st with 3 staff who all drive and live out of town.
-
Steve Hankinson 18 Jun 2019These extra charges can have a drastic negative effect on visitors and the community. We need to show a welcome not another cost.
-
Karen Howden 18 Jun 2019Detrimental to local trades and businesses, including day trippers. Further increases costs for locals to live on an island.
-
Helen Dewar 18 Jun 2019A sure fire way to ensure the island population dies off in record time.
Yet another reason for young people with families not to live here. Not only is there no housing for people wanting to move here but now the people that do live here are being charged to come to work every day or to do their shopping.
Why spend a fortune on surveys asking how to encourage young people to live and stay in Argyll and Bute and then give them less and less reason to want to. Ridiculously bad management. -
Stuart Davidson 18 Jun 2019A total lack of consideration by the council in terms of Islander Impacts that demonstrates why the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 was required !
-
Jo Holland 18 Jun 2019This is an ill-conceived idea and will bring much harm to so many people who depend on tourists for a living.
-
Kirsty Fisher 19 Jun 2019Ridiculous!
-
Jana McLellan 19 Jun 2019The suggested parking charges would have a very negative impact on our fragile island community. Already we have fewer tour bus groups and fewer cruise ships coming to Iona and last year the island economy was 10% down.. Visitors are not allowed to bring cars to Iona, so they have no choice, but to leave their cars in Fionnphort... It would have a huge financial impact on seasonal staff as well. For hospital- and other appointments and to visit our children in Oban Highschool we have to sometimes take the car and leave it in Craignure. The busses don't connect with all the ferries- especially not in winter time...
-
Mike Seymour 19 Jun 2019This may be seen as a convenient revenue generator but no one is thinking it through.. The Impact to every day supplies and food stuffs let alone local port business affects the islands inhabitants first and secondly The travel and tourism
of essential visitors to the region.
I have worked in travel and tourism for many years handling national tourist boards here and abroad and seen the 'turn off' effects of parking charges. -
Jayne Charnock 19 Jun 2019This decision if it goes ahead will decimate a fragile community
-
Michelle Mcewan 19 Jun 2019Outrageous decision by councillors to vote this into action. If allowed too ago ahead, I am convinced it will have a devastating affected on the Islands economy and Place a further strain on islanders.
-
Jane Fowler 19 Jun 2019These changes will have a drastic effect on locals and visitors alike. At a time when we want to boost the economy in rural areas this is a very negative step to take.
-
Mary Duncanson 19 Jun 2019As a regular visitor, I often stay for a few days. Apart from adding to the cost of my stay, I would be expected to come over to Mull from Iona on a daily basis to pay the daily parking charge incurring further expense with a daily return ferry fare. These charges are ludicrous and will have a detrimental effect on the island economy
-
Iain Thomson 19 Jun 2019The parking charges are not good news for the island. It has become a cash cow for A and B council.
-
Diana Graham 19 Jun 2019Unfair tax on Islanders to be able to live their lives