The next petition is PE1722, on parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports, by Dr Shiona Ruhemann, on behalf of Iona and Mull community councils and others. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to island proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services, and that any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.
Since our last consideration, we have received submissions from the Scottish Government and the petitioner, which are summarised in the clerk’s note. Michael Russell MSP has contacted the clerks to offer his strong support for the petition, stating:
“Lifeline ferry ports are just that and barriers to local people being able to use the lifeline should not be permitted. The principle needs to be established and then the detailed discussion can take place about particular locations where there are barriers still in place”.
The Scottish Government’s correspondence of 2 and 9 March 2020 responds to the committee with an update on progress on the commencement of island community impact assessments and on the specific issue of funding, which is a particular challenge for island communities. The Government states that the intention is to implement measures
“as early in 2020 as possible”,
and that, in the interim period, the Government
“should be operating in the spirit of the Act and taking island issues into account when developing or reviewing policies, strategies or services.”
We are also told that
“the Islands Team is assisting their Scottish Government colleagues ... with advice on whether to carry out an ICIA.”
On the funding issue, the Scottish Government has said:
“It is the responsibility of individual local authorities to manage their own budgets”.
However, the Government recognises the financial pressures on local authorities and says that local authorities receive funding support for internal ferry services through the annual grant-aided expenditure calculation and additional funding.
We have received a late submission from the petitioners, which has been sent to us separately. The submission highlights that the options for action as they are set out in our paper do not include the option to support the substance of the petition.
My feeling is that the whole point of the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 was to understand the impact on islands of local authority and Government policy and to understand the particular issues that islands face. I feel strongly that people ought not to be charged for parking to use a lifeline service and that that situation is different from people parking at a shopping mall or whatever. I have great sympathy for the petitioners in that regard.
My question for the Scottish Government is this: if it was a fundamental aim of the Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 to island proof policy, why has there been a delay? I recognise the challenges to the Government at the moment, but I would have thought that that would be a priority.
Do members have any comments?
