Thank you for allowing me to come and speak to the petition again on behalf of Mary Ramsay, whom we all know, and all the other people behind the petition—a lot of people support it. There is a sense of frustration that magnetic resonance-guided focused ultrasound technology—I am not going to say that again—is not available in Scotland although it is in England and in other places throughout the world. Add to that the fundraising campaign to make the equipment available to the whole of Scotland and you can see why campaigners with essential tremor and their families are anxious that the committee and the Scottish Government see the benefits of the therapy and how it can also save money for the NHS.
At the committee meeting on 16 January this year, the convener stated that the national specialist services committee would welcome a reapplication with new evidence. INSIGHTEC’s submission, which the convener just mentioned, provided that evidence with supporting documents. That is the same evidence as NHS England reviewed to produce a clinical commissioning policy for England that proposes treating up to 150 essential tremor patients per year if they are unsuitable for deep brain stimulation, which is what Mary Ramsay had.
Deep brain stimulation is already commissioned in Scotland for essential tremor. NHS England’s clinical commissioning policy says there is good evidence that the focused ultrasound technology is as effective and no less safe than deep brain stimulation and that, at £12,990 per patient, is around half the cost of deep brain stimulation, so there is a big saving to be made as well.
The Scottish Government is aware that clinicians in Dundee are exploring the purchase of equipment, and discussions are on-going with NHS Scotland national services division regarding the development of a service that it would be great to have in Scotland, because patients here could receive state-of-the-art minimally invasive neurosurgery for some of the commonest causes of tremor and there would be the chance to make Scotland a world leader in using the technology.
Campaigners have asked me to show committee members a short video of a patient’s experience of undergoing the treatment. Furthermore, the treating neurosurgeon, Professor Nandi, who is a leading medical expert in the field, is prepared to provide oral evidence to the committee if it feels that that would be helpful when it considers how to progress the petition. Mary Ramsay asked me to make a plea to the committee—as she always does—to keep pushing for the technology to be made available here. She says:
“For me, and my part, if focused ultrasound helps someone avoid what I went through, I will fight to my last breath to get it.”
That is a measure of the petitioner. This will not benefit her—as, I think, I have said before to the committee—but she will not let up. She is trying to ensure that nobody has to go through what she went through, and the treatment could change the lives of many people.
I urge the committee to keep the petition open, to look at the video and to take evidence from Professor Nandi. Hopefully, we can get the treatment available for people in Scotland.