Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01722 · Session 5

Parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports

Closed Submitted 30 Apr 2019 Transport
Signatures
0
2,597 online signatures with a country
Comments
313
Considered
6 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island-proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services, and any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.

What the petitioner did first

Formal objections, correspondence with Council Leader, Council Chief Executive, and Executive Director Development and Infrastructure, meetings with Councillors, requests for meetings with CEO and Council Leader; formal complaint raised with Council, correspondence with Michael Russell MSP, to highlight that our concerns are not being heard by the Council.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Jun 2019
    1 mention
  2. 16 Jan 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    2 mentions
  5. 10 Feb 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 24 Mar 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,597 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,614 62.1%
  2. United Kingdom498 19.2%
  3. England391 15.1%
  4. United States21 0.8%
  5. Wales15 0.6%
  6. Northern Ireland8 0.3%
  7. France6 0.2%
  8. Australia5 0.2%
  9. Not given5 0.2%
  10. Netherlands5 0.2%
  11. 13 other countries29 1.1%

Comments

313 comments, oldest first
313 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Donald Jack 23 May 2019
    Visiting the Small Isles for work and family connections it is necessary to be able to park for several days at a time. Given that these islands are not suitable for many vehicles and special permission is required to take vehicles there, it is essential for locals and visitors to be able to park at ferry terminal in Mallaig.
  2. Colin.George Maclean 23 May 2019
    Easy soft Target! Penalised because of where you live. Tourists will be puzzled, they've already paid substantial sums to be here AND visiting businesses will not return, will they?
  3. John MacPhee 23 May 2019
    another unfair tax on local motorists.
  4. Alison Johnston 23 May 2019
    These planned high charges will badly affect the local economy in an area where living costs are already high. Working against government subsidies to keep a resident population on the islands.
  5. Richard West 23 May 2019
    On Mull not all ferries are served by public transport. A visit to Oban for medical appointments which can be of indeterminate length can result in a return ferry that is not met by a bus. Taxi fare to Tobermory is unaffordable.
  6. Alan Slater 23 May 2019
    Once again the motorist is seen as a cash cow to be milked for as much as they can
  7. Susan Knox 23 May 2019
    It's hard enough to live on an Island but to put charges on for folks who need to leave their cars at the ferry port to come over for appointments on the mainland is diabolical.
  8. Ian Wilson 23 May 2019
    Absolutely ridiculous
  9. Linda Littlewood 23 May 2019
    It is not possible for most people to use ferries without the use of a car, so charges at any level become punitive in a large number of unavoidable circumstances. Islanders have no choice at all in where they park when accessing ferries, this is not as it would be on the mainland to go to appointments at hospital as just one example. Any charges have disproportionately negative impact on people, making it more difficult for people to be here.Surely this is what 'island proofing' is all about.
  10. john craig 23 May 2019
    It makes journeys off the Island to hospitals etc very expensive
  11. Dirk Grutzmacher 23 May 2019
    It will make it very difficult for people to stay on the Isle of Iona for a week or so. The programmes in the various centres run typically for such a period.
  12. Mirren Green 23 May 2019
    I am not resident on Mull or Iona, but spend a significant amount of time on the latter every year. Parking charges of this order will make it too expensive for me to do this in the future, and doubtless have a massive affect on the local communities. Please please reconsider!
  13. Chris Jenkins 23 May 2019
    It is bad enough for visitors, but punitive for islanders.
  14. Marilyn Laverty 23 May 2019
    I travel to ferry to Oban on bus but would still have to pay to park in Tobermory car park to enable me to leave car take shopping up hill, or take a taxi, adding more expense from my meagre state pension.
  15. Heinz Toller 23 May 2019
    Encourage people to use public transport by providing free parking at key points.
    Reduce additional costs for people living on islands.
    Be guided by the letter and the spirit of Islands (Scotland) Act 2018 and uphold the law!
  16. Alison Macdonald 23 May 2019
    I have a family member who is a resident of Iona and I travel regularly by car to the island to stay.I strongly resent the charges
    - which I would have to pay for a week or a fortnights stay. I understand that I would then have to go back each day to pay the daily fee, incurring also the ferry costs. What if the ferry wasn't running
    - would I then have to pay a fine aswell? This is an outrageous charge and it would force people to park in places where charges are not applicable and cause a problem in the street surrounding the ferry terminals. Whats the point of reducing the ferry costs to encourage tourists and then slap over the top parking fees.
    - This thinking is not joined up.
  17. Sarah Ewing 23 May 2019
    Introducing parking charges will have a clear detrimental impact on all islanders and will impact on tourism and additionally sends a very negative and unwelcoming message. People will just try and find alternative places to park which will be dangerous and will cause upset to islanders affected.
  18. Stephen Glen-Lee 23 May 2019
    The parking chargers are going to prevent the council employees from attending, significantly endangering the quality of the provision in the school.
  19. Annie Warwick 23 May 2019
    We often visit Iona. We must travel there on foot. So, our car has to be parked for the duration of our stay.
  20. Sarah Macdonald 23 May 2019
    Desperate cash grab by a Council renowned for its atrocious decision making practises and financial mismanagement. Our island communities and economies are much too fragile to go imposing thoughtless, poorly researched plans like this. All this does is highlight the problems within the Council and make us all think more closely about those who supposedly represent our interests.
  21. Susan Dale 23 May 2019
    It will increase the amount of car permit applications to Iona
  22. Mike Drury 23 May 2019
    This Council initiative is morally unlawful particularly when much of the land car parks stand on in Mull were once gifted to the "People" on the Ross by the Dukes of Argyll.
    This is anti Tourism and against the true values of Island Life and their people.
  23. Ora Thomson 23 May 2019
    Frequent visitor and hoping to move nearbye .
  24. Simon Plumpton 23 May 2019
    As a visitor to Mull and a former Island resident I can totally understand why the people of Mull & Iona are against charges to car parking on the Islands. The fact that car parking has been free for our stay has been very welcome. In our case it has meant being sensible about our parking fir as long as we needed and not parking for the sake of it because it is free. I would be hopeful other visiting feel and act the same. I can understand that for residents the charging will cause untold issues. A day trip to Oban might mean a ferry parking charge of £9+ for an appointment etc All in all I would say that keeping car parking free is the way to go. The Islands are almost unique in their approach UK wide, something that makes the place even more special than it is.
  25. Martyn Howie 23 May 2019
    These charges will penalise those who wish or have no choice to leave their vehicles at the Ferry terminal. Argyll and Bute should be looking at measures to promote tourism not dis courage it. Whilst car parking charges are already levied for short term parking at Fionnphort long stay has always been free and should remain so people either visiting friends, relations or staying in hotels or guest houses have no choice but to park on Mull as visitors are not allowed to take cars to Iona. The usual cry is to use public transport well great you try it from NE Scotland where I live...it will take you two days to get to Iona and involve going to Aberdeen Glasgow and Oban involving a bus and two trains before the ferry and bus to Fionnphort try that with food for the journey and your luggage. A staying guest is a paying guest who spends money in local businesses why would you want to penalise them all they do is feed the parking meter to the detriment of local businesses
  26. William Campbell 23 May 2019
    If the Scottish Government agrees to "island-proof" the transport infrastructure, I trust steps will be taken to ensure that the socially disadvantaged in Argyll and Bute will not suffer the consequences of the council having yet another way of compensating for the cuts to their budget taken away.
  27. Norman McNab 23 May 2019
    I'm not against a reasonable charge for day trippers to Iona. However the charge proposed is unreasonable and totally wrong for those living on Iona, or spending a holiday on the island. The scheme needs to be implemented with yearly permits for residents and weekly permits for holiday makers and people involved in extended visits associated with the Abbey etc. Charges should be reasonable and not set to penalise residents of Iona and their visiting families.
  28. Malcolm King 23 May 2019
    I lived on Iona for three years and know how essential free parking on Mull was to island residents
  29. Josephine Austin 23 May 2019
    No charges. Please!
  30. Julie Ann Francis 23 May 2019
    For longer stays on Iona, this would be a travesty...
  31. Bruce Blackadder 23 May 2019
    Parking charges would mean having to leave my home of 47 years and go live on the mainland.
  32. Wendy MacManaway 23 May 2019
    Our Island depends on access from Mull. Key workers from Mull already pay a daily ferry, to have to pay parking as well represents a dramatic pay cut for them. We rely on tourism and this gives the wrong message to visitors, Running a business on an island incurs many additional costs, this is recognised by the Scottish Islands Bill. Please put the bill into action and oppose this parking tax.
  33. Elaine Hosie 23 May 2019
    Charges will have a detrimental effect to the life of islanders and to tourism
  34. Lilah Ford 23 May 2019
    Many people that stay at Iona would not be able to afford to pay charges for a weeks stay
  35. HILARY BROWN 23 May 2019
    this is such a negative high impact for no forseeable benefit or gain most importantly for the local island community. for visitors like myself it has a negative outcome. It will encourage people to randam park in places wholly unsuitable and with probable safety concerns. this is just a stealth tax on all users and has no viable credit for its inception.
  36. Mairi Dunnings 23 May 2019
    Public transport is very limited, only serving a small part of the island. Island living is more expensive than mainland living and over the years much effort has been made to retain the population. Charging for parking in the area will add yet another cost to residents who do not have access to services available in many other areas of Scotland or Argyll. It does just not make economic sense and the only benefit will be that Argyll & Bute Council generates more revenue but that will be offset by the costs incurred to manage the schemes. It is effectively a council tax that will have a much greater impact on those on lower income. Car ownership is a necessity for most rural dwellers and people who live in these areas require to prioritise running a car over other economic choices.
  37. Steven Grant 23 May 2019
    The Scottish Government, through strangulation of Council budgets, are creating a huge void in infrastructure spending for maintenance and replacement. This vacuume is now reaching an acute level by which Councils are having to resort to indirect taxation by placing charges on the few. This is unfair and will deeply impact tourism local communities and economic development.
  38. Marion brown 23 May 2019
    Free car parking is essential to island life.
    These charges will have an adverse effect on both islanders and visitors
  39. Claire Melville 23 May 2019
    Unwelcome and unnecessary costs that islanders and tourists can do without. Will cause parking chaos at peak times as people will try to park elsewhere. I'm sure the council can get the extra income elsewhere or not at all.
  40. Katie Hagmann 23 May 2019
    As someone who travels to a friends family home on the Island every year sometimes bringing furniture and items that can not be purchased locally, it is essential to be able to access the Island.
    Another option to consider would be to allow ALL cars on the Island. Either let ALL people park their cars at their accommodation or allow free parking at the ferry port.
    I know the vehicle restrictions are important and I believe they should be upheld therefore the only sensible option is to allow people to park for free.
  41. Helen Brown 23 May 2019
    Family visit leaving cars on the mainland as rely on us to drive them around the island. This means the cars on the island are reduced ferry car spaces are not needed.
  42. John Easton 23 May 2019
    Please support
  43. Scott Bowman 24 May 2019
    A ridiculous charge for tourists and locals with no thought about the impact to businesses or livelihoods. Places restricted time pressures on people and shortening the time people would stay within the wider are, so far that it would negatively effect all types of commerce. The opposite is required that dwell time increases and time locally extended. Silly stupid.
  44. Steve Douglas 24 May 2019
    This is an extremely unfair tax specifically on island residents in order to use lifeline services. It will not significantly affact visitors. There are other fairer ways to raise income for the local council , such as a small landing tax for All. OR exemptions should be made for permanent island residents on their main address ( not second homes or holiday lets)
  45. Izzie Forbes-Hurst 24 May 2019
    Please don't do this
    - don't put these lovely places out of the reach of visitors, and threaten the livelihoods of those who live there.
  46. Graham Henderson 24 May 2019
    There is no need for this. Deterring tourists and locals from various places. No one overstays at a car park. One of the attractions of the island is a relaxed atmosphere
    - this seems as a tax on visiting. Not impressed. PLease leave things as they are.
  47. Graham Smout 24 May 2019
    As a regular visitor to Iona and Mull, usually for a week or more at a time, I recognise the imposition of charges for long stay parking will impact negatively on residents and visitors in the region. It is bound to lead to problems with local people when visitors try to find a place to park and end up outside their homes.
    As a suggestion local residents should be entitled to a free long stay parking permit in designated parking areas. Visitors staying for up to a week or more should be able to purchase a long stay parking permit valid for one, two of four weeks at affordable cost.
  48. Anne Cameron 24 May 2019
    For many, cars are the only means of transport to their ferry port. Ridiculous to impose parking charges. Unfortunately, motorists are easy prey for charges. What do we get for our Road Tax?
  49. FrancesPark 24 May 2019
    This will kill the Islands as tourism will drop. Also for the people who live there, how is that going to work? Ludicrous and robbery
  50. Linda Precious 24 May 2019
    We visit the island on an annual basis. The expense to get to the islands is enough without having to pay for parking as well.