Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01722 · Session 5

Parking charges at island lifeline ferry ports

Closed Submitted 30 Apr 2019 Transport
Signatures
0
2,597 online signatures with a country
Comments
313
Considered
6 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to island-proof transport infrastructure to ensure that public bodies do not charge for parking in car parks at island ferry ports, which are essential lifeline services, and any proposed island parking charges are subject to rigorous impact assessment.

What the petitioner did first

Formal objections, correspondence with Council Leader, Council Chief Executive, and Executive Director Development and Infrastructure, meetings with Councillors, requests for meetings with CEO and Council Leader; formal complaint raised with Council, correspondence with Michael Russell MSP, to highlight that our concerns are not being heard by the Council.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 27 Jun 2019
    1 mention
  2. 16 Jan 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 12 Nov 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    2 mentions
  5. 10 Feb 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  6. 24 Mar 2021
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,597 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,614 62.1%
  2. United Kingdom498 19.2%
  3. England391 15.1%
  4. United States21 0.8%
  5. Wales15 0.6%
  6. Northern Ireland8 0.3%
  7. France6 0.2%
  8. Not given5 0.2%
  9. Netherlands5 0.2%
  10. Germany5 0.2%
  11. 13 other countries29 1.1%

Comments

313 comments, oldest first
313 comments · showing 101–150
  1. David Brown 24 May 2019
    Charging complicates and makes life difficult for all users. Compliance will need supported which is also costly.
  2. Mrs Patricia Murray Williams 24 May 2019
    The ferry is a life line service for Mull and the car parking charges would cause great difficulties for many islanders.
  3. Duncan Smallman 24 May 2019
    Having lived on Easdale Island and been over to Mull and Iona for work, the charges for locals and visitors alike are ridiculous and damaging to the local economy. Sends the wrong message and easily harms the iona tourist industry
  4. Barbara White 24 May 2019
    Not every ferry has connecting public transport, therefore thare are occasions when you HAVE to
    go by car.
  5. Denise Campbell 24 May 2019
    Living off Scotland mainland is expensive enough .. transport cost are high . Charging for parking residents cars is punitive on inter island routes ..
  6. David Horton 24 May 2019
    Travel to the islands is already costly. This can only reduce tourism.
  7. Bernadette Gibson 24 May 2019
    As regular visitor to Mull and Iona Having to pay to park my car for a full week would put me off visiting.
  8. Stephen Rowan 24 May 2019
    The impact on people and families with low income or receiving benefits who live on Mull & Iona would be significant as they need to reach health and other services on the mainland. By top loading the existing additional costs of living in remote island communities, Argyll & Bute Council would be scoring an own goal if these changes were introduced.
  9. Sarah Mair 24 May 2019
    I am totally against the suggestion to introduce parking charges at Scottish Island Ferry Ports. Parking at ferry ports, should not be charged for as there is no alternative for residents and their visitors and the many thousands of tourists who use these. In particular such parking is needed for those islands such as Iona where visitors vehicles are not permitted This is an abuse of the monopoly held by local authorities. I understand it may also be necessary to return to parked cars on a regular basis to 'top up' daily or weekly charges which would then incur ferry costs on top of the parking charge. This is against the spirit of policy which encourages tourists and visitors. The nature of public transport to and from these islands is such that it could not cope with the additional passengers and would simply push the parking problem further back in the transport chain and on a local basis onto surrounding approach roads and ground.
  10. Peter Williams 24 May 2019
    As parking is part of our lifeline service, charging for it would cause some people a problem
  11. David West 24 May 2019
    As a frequent visitor to Scotland and the Isles I object strongly and great sympathy to residents who rely on these ferry services
  12. Jackie Dudley 24 May 2019
    Listen to the residents they are the ones who know.
  13. Jan Mills 24 May 2019
    We have a car park at Rye harbour which is donation only
    - that is as far as parking charges should go in any community
    - but especially in areas where tourism plays an important role.
  14. Sheila McLees 24 May 2019
    This will deter many visitors from the islands as the inhabitants are very dependent on people visiting and generating much needed income. It will also impact on essential services such as healthcare.
  15. Alison Fleming 24 May 2019
    I live on the island of Jura so use the Caledonian MacBrayne ferry service from Islay to Kennacraig. The costs of travelling to the mainland and back are already prohibitive. Please do not make this worse by charging (or allowing charges to be levied by others)local people to park at Port Askaig, Port Ellen and Kennacraig ferry terminals.
  16. Hazel Maries 24 May 2019
    please share and sign this.Ferry ports should always be exempt from outrageous charges.
  17. Catherine Jones 25 May 2019
    Imposition of the proposed charges would clearly cause serious financial and social hardship to people on these islands. Please reconsider.
  18. Jean Anne howells 25 May 2019
    Too high a daily charge.
  19. iain morrison 25 May 2019
    I support this petition.
  20. Sarah mauritzen 25 May 2019
    Yet another hair brain idea to charge locals and tourists to boost the councils revenue. Have you thought of the consequences of implementing these charges and the negative impact to the local economy of the islands.
  21. Lynn MacKenzie 25 May 2019
    As an Islander myself, who does not at present get charged for parking, I would be very concerned if this practice spread. It would devastate our community as we only have a passenger ferry and must leave our cars on the mainland.
  22. Jane Cameron 25 May 2019
    To penalise islanders by charging for parking at ferry ports will impact on people moving to islands if getting on and off is made more difficult. It's not as if any revenue received will remain on the island.
  23. Ian Grant 25 May 2019
    Tourism in the smaller isles such as Iona generally involves travelling as a passenger, leaving your car at the port. This charge will wipe out this tourist trade.
  24. Antonia Nelson 25 May 2019
    I am a regular visitor to both Mull and Iona and I think this charge would affect how long people would spend on Iona and an would also be an awful disadvantage to those islanders who need to leave cars at Craignure.
  25. Ian Tibbetts 25 May 2019
    The vast majority of car park users at Mull ferry ports are residents who need to get to these ferry services for the island to be viable. Further to the blatant injustice of the additional burden on islanders, it will surely lead to unsafe parking on verges and a substantial increase in the need for parking controls and administration of penalties which would wipe out any benefit.
  26. Doreen Wilkinson 25 May 2019
    As long as permanent residents do not have to pay, visitors should expect to have to pay for parking, they will have to in their home areas.
  27. Chris Emmett 26 May 2019
    I'm a regular visitor to Iona and rely on free, long term parking.
  28. Allan Gordon 26 May 2019
    Clearly since most people cannot take their cars onto Iona the cars have to be parked at Fionnphort. It seems very unreasonable to charge a daily rate for this.
  29. Tim crick 27 May 2019
    These punitive parking charges are clearly discriminatory for those travelling to Iona, who have no option to take their cars to where they are staying on the island. It amounts to a major new tourist tax, as well as a significant additional tax on the local population as it is non-avoidable. It completely undermines the ethos and good work of the RET scheme
  30. Walter Dunlop 27 May 2019
    Parking charges, apart from all the other good reasons why they should not be introduced, will also encourage more applications for cars to be taken on to Iona
  31. Janet Jardine 27 May 2019
    Ferry car parks are essential and should remain free on small islands where public transport to ferries is not an option for those living off the beaten track.
  32. Donald Cameron 27 May 2019
    Access to our countryside should not be "wealth dependent". Indeed our Parliament has been striving for long enough against the exclusivity imposed by many rich landowners. To impose excessive parking charges mostly affects those who can least afford it .. and ironically those who would benefit most through having access.
  33. Nick Holmes 27 May 2019
    An unjust and unnecessary poll tax on Mull islanders.
  34. Alison Wotherspoon 27 May 2019
    As a regular visitor to Iona and Mull I have signed this petition to support the islanders who need the parking facilities so that they can access ferries. It is not always possible to use public transport. Charges will also make it more expensive for me to visit Iona as I stay for a week.
  35. David Smith 28 May 2019
    Parking at all ferry ports and hospitals should be free, people have to travel to work plus visit elderly and unwell relatives
  36. Andrew Morrice 28 May 2019
    I have been a regular visitor to Iona and Mull for years and have recently worked as a GP in Appin and Lismore. Islanders and those providing their services already face significant costs and logistical challenges in undertaking routine life and work. Adding parking charges will simply make life more difficult but not improve parking availability since visitors will not mind paying.
    Costs for islanders who routinely keep a car on the mainland or a larger neighbouring island would be prohibitive.
    this is an astonishingly ill-conceived move.
  37. Carol west 29 May 2019
    Do you want folk to avoid parking in town and not spending in local.shops. it will be the death of local.buisnessrs
  38. Dean Snell 29 May 2019
    This is unacceptable on a life line route for the local population. This will also impact the visitors to the Isle of Iona by hitting them with extra fees to the cost of their holiday. Totally unacceptable and the whole parking charges issue should be dropped and never heard of again.
  39. Alison Broomhead 30 May 2019
    Living in a rural island fringe area is expensive enough and more time consuming than mainland regions
    - a further cost to inhabitants will serve only to depopulate islands.
  40. Susi McDonald 30 May 2019
    It feels ridiculous to even consider charging for parking at ferry ports.
    This is essential for islands and lifeline service.
    There should also be free or very low cost parking provision in Oban for those using CalMac ferry services to encourage where possible for people to be able to travel without a car to the islands.
  41. Andrea fisher 30 May 2019
    As the parking bays by the post office and shop in Fionnphort have got parking ticket machines attached, Argyll and Bute Council are already charging visitors and for parking their cars. The longer term parking space (which is a badly maintained piece of ground) should stay free as an alternative to the ones at the front.
  42. Gemma Skillin 31 May 2019
    My country's public transport system is nowhere near reliable enough anywhere to merit parking charges being rolled out. On islands like Iona it's unfathomable and cruel.
  43. Senga Allan 31 May 2019
    Parking charges which penalise local communities are wrong
  44. Steve Small 31 May 2019
    This is a disastrous proposal that hasn't been thought through properly. It will have a desperate effect on the islands of Iona and Mull and their fragile economies, I urge Argyll & Bute Council to to stop and think about what you are proposing and the harm it will inflict.
  45. Joy Crick 31 May 2019
    As a rgular visitor to Iona to stay with family, I drive and would find the parking charges at the ferry port would make visiting even more difficult and expensive.
  46. Linda Peeling 1 Jun 2019
    We have been holidaying on Iona yearly since 1986 sometimes twice a year and hope that parking remains free, actually travelling from Norfolk is quite costly in itself without having to pay to park this could for some be the thin end of the wedge.
  47. James Peeling 1 Jun 2019
    This would seriously affect the number of people visiting the remote islands.
  48. Andrew Birch 1 Jun 2019
    The car parks are the lifeblood for islands community tourist trade and should be available free to all to encourage visitors to the islands so therefore benefiting everyone.
  49. effie Robertson 1 Jun 2019
    this must prove a great disincentive to tourism, a major source of income for the islands, as well as being a burden , one might say an unfair tax, on those who live on the islands
  50. Dorothy Sterling 1 Jun 2019
    It would be wrong to introduce car parking charges at island ferry ports. I speak as a visitor and holidaymaker
    - the charge would have a considerable impact on our travel expenses. However I have particular sympathy for the islanders who have to travel for medical and family reasons and who have no choice about where they leave their cars. Please think seriously about the impact this decision would have on so many people.