Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01762 · Session 5

End the killing of wildlife on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland

Closed Submitted 2 Oct 2019 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
7,056 online signatures with a country
Comments
340
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Discussions with MSPs and supporting Motions raised in Members’ Debates.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 5 Dec 2019
    1 mention
  2. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,056 online signatures
  1. England2,043 29%
  2. United Kingdom1,865 26.4%
  3. Scotland1,835 26%
  4. United States469 6.6%
  5. Wales168 2.4%
  6. Canada96 1.4%
  7. France78 1.1%
  8. Germany48 0.7%
  9. Australia47 0.7%
  10. Netherlands35 0.5%
  11. 60 other countries372 5.3%

Comments

340 comments, oldest first
340 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Rosemarie Bindon. 30 Oct 2019
    I am anti-animal traps of any description. Every animal has the right to live. Killing animals IS NOT RECREATION! It is definitely not ethical or sustainable to destroy the same type of animals annually in the same area.
  2. Alice Rose 30 Oct 2019
    We have no right to torture and murder our wildlife
  3. victor rones 30 Oct 2019
    people must start respecting animals and birds if they respect their parents
  4. George Shepherd 30 Oct 2019
    Traps and Snares should be abolished in Scotland as should the killing of any animal so that another can be killed for recreation.
  5. Janet Harper 30 Oct 2019
    Happy to sign lets hope this madness stops
  6. Trisha Waghorn 30 Oct 2019
    Please stop this use of traps.
  7. Tim Marshall 30 Oct 2019
    These animals are not vermin they are part of the ecology of the land.
  8. Susan Farquharson 30 Oct 2019
    No one should have the right to kill our wildlife just for the sake of recreational grouse shooting.
    While such activities bring money into the Scottish economy, I believe that far greater economic gain could be achieved by promoting our wildlife, and creating a sustainable environment that all can enjoy.
  9. Jane King 30 Oct 2019
    Having recently moved back to England from the west coast of Scotland I am astounded by the complete disregard of nature when it comes to making money in both countries. It is evident that human profit is being put before protecting the environment and this has got to change on many levels. The destruction of the mountain hare population on this scale is unreprehensible and if the law makers refuse to do anything about it they are complicite with the business and landowners that profit from decimating nature.
  10. Mirella Florea 30 Oct 2019
    Saving animals to save the world is my wish.
  11. Mary Bain 30 Oct 2019
    It is very wrong that thousands of our native animals are slaughtered for the benefit of the wealthy few. In some areas our hare numbers are dangerously low.
  12. George McBurnie 1 Nov 2019
    The killing of of wildlife is unacceptable. Profit through animal suffering and before a health countryside is barbaric
  13. Paul McDonald 2 Nov 2019
    No animal should be killed in this way
  14. Georgina Kane 2 Nov 2019
    Please leave our wildlife alone they should have the same right to life as we do. I ask this as they have no voice of their own and the pain they feel is the same pain as we would feel.
  15. ian workman 3 Nov 2019
    The crucial need everywhere is to achieve a Balance in Nature, where all species survive and prosper. This of course includes ourselves, man, homo sapiens, us. We have through the centuries changed all this for sport and recreation. Not just to feed and clothe ourselves and our families. This has been the principal reason for the unbalance and the suffering and extinction of most other species. There is a need for respect to avoid a landscape devoid of any other wildlife at all. This is especially true on the shooting estates. Full of eye catching scenery but lifeless. It's been proven that city centres have a better Balance which, although good for city dwellers, it's very sad for the huge areas of moor and farmland in our country. It is time to change before it is too late. Probably won't happen in my lifetime but let's preserve something for our descendants. Prove to them that most of us do actually care, we do want people to enjoy our countryside. So let's get the ball rolling. The shooting estate employees have so many opportunities in the thriving tourism and photography markets. There's no need for unemployment concerns. The Estate owners and managers have shown their opportunism. They just need some persuasion to follow alternatives. It's been done elsewhere, it can be done here. But it is down to the law makers to set the baseline then it's the policing to ensure we stay on track. So, please, seriously consider this petition to at least get us all on the right track to achieve the so crucial Balance.
  16. Dave Dick 3 Nov 2019
    I have witnessed personally over the last 5 decades dozens of cases of supposedly protected wildlife killed by both legal and illegal traps and snares on scottish managed grouse moors. Time to end this pointless slaughter.
  17. Joyce Hodgeson 3 Nov 2019
    These barbaric acts have to be stopped and stopped soon. 2019 and we are still trying to stop blood sports it is beyond belief..
  18. Jean Cole 4 Nov 2019
    ban grouse moors
  19. Eileen Easton 4 Nov 2019
    All animals deserve to be treated humanely and spared suffering, they do not deserve the atrocities that humans inflict upon them. It is almost 2020, time for all cruelties against these precious beings to end!!!!
  20. Sharon prior 4 Nov 2019
    In this world is a lot of suffering especially where animals are concerned we don't need to use traps or Snares the pain is horrendous please can we stop
  21. Kay Philips 5 Nov 2019
    Wildlife must be allowed to co-exist with people. They must be shown dignity, compassion and respect.
  22. Jim Rooney 5 Nov 2019
    Though I live in Derbyshire so close to the other killing fields I regularly travel through the Cairngorm NP to visit my gran children and see all the carnage inflicted on wildlife in the park by the purveyors of this sport.
  23. Yvonne Daly 6 Nov 2019
    Stop the slaughter of defensive animals NOW
  24. Deanna Austin-Crowe 6 Nov 2019
    only 4% of mammal life is wild we have obliterated the rest. Time to stop. Stop killing wildlife to sustain a cruel blood "sport"
  25. Brian Williams 6 Nov 2019
    As a proud Scot now living 'abroad' it saddens me greatly that my country's reputation and image is sullied by the activities of the driven grouse shooting estates. We should be celebrating our natural wildlife not slaughtering it for the sake of a profit.
  26. Mark Lund 6 Nov 2019
    This is the 21st Century, and destroying our wildlife just to increase the overproduction of game birds shot by a relatively small number of the population for their enjoyment is no longer acceptable. There is no justification, and is carried out by those with no sympathy for the animals they destroy or any notion of what is right or wrong in this practice, but worse is that they are sponsored by their wealthy employers to maintain a low predator, high target ratio which is completely unnatural in the countryside, which is where this is happening.
  27. Karin chilton 6 Nov 2019
    This is disgusting cruelty. Killing our beautiful wildlife to hunt grouse.
  28. Sheila Dorsett 6 Nov 2019
    Please end this killing. I am committed to only visiting places free from hunting and shooting. I love Scotland and am sad to have given up my twice yearly visits. Wildlife tourism is big business so there is a potential for Scotland in the future. Plus stopping this cruelty would be the right thing to do. Please..
  29. Keith Aspden 6 Nov 2019
    Please stop the killing of native wildlife to profit shooting estates.
  30. Gillian Duncan 6 Nov 2019
    We need to stop killing our natural wildlife. I live in a very rural areas and can see how empty the countryside is looking. It's shocking!
  31. Gordon Eccleston 6 Nov 2019
    There is no need to kill these wonderful animals and birds
  32. Nick Adams 6 Nov 2019
    Give an inch and these people take several mile.
  33. Karen Owen 6 Nov 2019
    This has to stop it's disgusting. All in the name of farmers making money
  34. Spencer mckee 6 Nov 2019
    This is wrong and brings shame on such a nice country.
  35. Linda Ricouard 6 Nov 2019
    I think snares and traps are cruel and barbaric and should be banned in Scotland and the entire country!
  36. Jillian Bland 6 Nov 2019
    The world's opinion of the British is that, we have killed off our own wildlife population yet we go abroad to tell them to be kind to animals and to stop killing their wildlife. Yet with a reputation like ours, how can we. We're bulldozing Forests and calling Brazil for doing the exact same thing. Killing for the pleasure of it is vile, apart from the impact this has on human lives, of which the subject is too vast to comment on here. I understand that large amounts of money is made from this uncivilised trade but we must steer away from being Savages, even the wealthiest of us, Who know that they can do what ever vile thing they want.
  37. Eric Mccabe 6 Nov 2019
    Its a no-brainer. Enforce wildlife laws that are clearly flouted.
  38. Bernard Burnett Elliott 6 Nov 2019
    This is needless cruelty and it belongs to a forgotten age.
  39. Fran Rouse 6 Nov 2019
    Please stop hunting if these beautiful animals
  40. Brenda Lauren Kilburn 6 Nov 2019
    I full support one kinds petition. I'm disappointed, personally, on SG slowness to swiftly take control of this situation. Many animals are dying and suffering immensely, needlessly. Action must be taken now.
  41. Alan Paul Busson 6 Nov 2019
    Please end this senseless killing of wild animals all in the name of brutal hunting. Times have moved on
    - we are no longer living in the 19th century.
  42. Dennis Fallen 6 Nov 2019
    This is an outdated and elite nonsense that needs to stop immediately.
  43. Daniel MCDONALD 6 Nov 2019
    End the persecution of wildlife on the moors. Moors do not exist for the leisure pursuits of a select few to shoot grouse.
  44. Vicki Noble 6 Nov 2019
    Cruel beyond words. These people need to evolve. Killing for fun is not sport, it's being a sadistic psychopath!
  45. John Willson 6 Nov 2019
    No longer acceptable in this day and age. Traps are barbaric and cruel and there use should be ilegal and the law enforced.
  46. ANDY HOLDEN 6 Nov 2019
    How long do right-minded people have to wait before the Government actually takes proper action AGAINST the killers of our of wildlfie? For crying out loud BAN driven grouse shooting NOW!
  47. Anne ursell 6 Nov 2019
    Dreadful
  48. Joanne Allen 6 Nov 2019
    We do not have any right to kill or snare animals!!
  49. Marcie Sawkins 6 Nov 2019
    No living thing should be made to suffer such traumatic end no man, no animal.
  50. Angela Hathway 6 Nov 2019
    This lust for blood is a disgrace and brings shame on the UK as a whole. The perpetrators are evil.