The next continued petition is PE1762, on ending the killing of wildlife on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland, which was lodged by Libby Anderson and Bob Elliot on behalf of OneKind. The petition calls on the Parliament to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland. Submissions have now been received from the Scottish Government and the petitioner.
In its submission, the Scottish Government notes that it is
“determined to improve standards in the operation of snares and traps, and in particular, to improve the welfare of wildlife caught in snares”
but that it
“does not intend to ban snaring”.
Following the publication of the papers for this week’s meeting, the petitioners have been in touch. They have advised that they would be pleased if the petition was referred to the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee. However, they raise concerns about their petition being considered in the context of that committee’s work on wildlife crime. They note that wildlife crime does not focus on their concerns that the devices noted in the petition are inherently cruel when used in a legal context.
There are interesting and quite challenging issues here. The issue of animal welfare is a significant part of that. My own feeling is that we should refer the petition to the ECCLR Committee and flag up to it that the petitioners—and we would probably agree with this as a committee—do not see this as being only about wildlife crime; it is about animal welfare as well. I certainly think that it would be worth while for the work that has been done and the information that the petitioners have provided to be referred to the ECCLR Committee.
