Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01762 · Session 5

End the killing of wildlife on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland

Closed Submitted 2 Oct 2019 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
7,056 online signatures with a country
Comments
340
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Discussions with MSPs and supporting Motions raised in Members’ Debates.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 5 Dec 2019
    1 mention
  2. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,056 online signatures
  1. England2,043 29%
  2. United Kingdom1,865 26.4%
  3. Scotland1,835 26%
  4. United States469 6.6%
  5. Wales168 2.4%
  6. Canada96 1.4%
  7. France78 1.1%
  8. Germany48 0.7%
  9. Australia47 0.7%
  10. Netherlands35 0.5%
  11. 60 other countries372 5.3%

Comments

340 comments, oldest first
340 comments · showing 151–200
  1. DIANE M KASTEL 28 Oct 2019
    Thousands of sentient animals suffer, and, die, in traps, and, snares, on grouse moors across Scotland, set in order to control predators or, so-called "vermin" that interfere with sporting pursuits!

    Do we have any right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed for recreation?

    Should any traps be permitted for use against our wildlife?

    Is it ethical, or, sustainable, or, moral to keep killing the same type of animals, year after year, in the same location?
  2. mo miller 28 Oct 2019
    it really is time to end this barbaric and outdated practice .. PLEASE let us have an end to unnecessary cruelty to wild animal who have every right to life
  3. Jo Ardell 28 Oct 2019
    Treat All Animals With Kindness And Respect, and Humaneness.
  4. Mary Enns 28 Oct 2019
    About time
  5. Elizabeth Goumas 28 Oct 2019
    This is a totally inhumane and unnecessary practice, to satisfy a few people's desire to kill their selected animal
  6. Patsi Waite 28 Oct 2019
    Killing wildlife so that shooters can kill birds is disgusting.
  7. Christina Campbell 28 Oct 2019
    Remember a country shows how far it has evolved by the way it treats its animals .....
  8. beverley blockley 28 Oct 2019
    Do something now before you allow all our precious wildlife to be slaughtered
  9. Elizabeth Payton 28 Oct 2019
    About time the Scottich Government appreciated the wildlife and stopped grouse shooting. So sad so many raptors released in Scotland mysteriously disappear.
  10. Janice Hill 28 Oct 2019
    It's time to end cruelty to animals and protect wildlife.
  11. Michelle Highfield 28 Oct 2019
    It surely cannot be right that British native wild animals are killed in order for a relatively small number of people to take part in what is essentially a 'recreational pursuit' and that animals are killed in such an inhumane manner.
  12. Jon Pain 28 Oct 2019
    It is time that animal persecution is brought under control in the UK. With climate change we are under increasing threat of losing native species. Killing animals to support blood sports is abhorent and inhumane.
  13. dale riehart 28 Oct 2019
    Trapping that murders one animal try and stop another is still just plain murder. You have to be smarter than just a plain murderer if you want to solve a problem.
  14. Susan Flanders 28 Oct 2019
    No wildlife should suffer for the cruel enjoyment of humans' so called 'sport'.
  15. Desiree Silverstone 28 Oct 2019
    The greatness of a nation and its moral progress can be judged by the way its animals are treated. Gandhi
  16. Lorna McAllister 28 Oct 2019
    Hunting and shooting are anachronistic barbaric pursuits. They have no place in the 21st century in a civilised country like Scotland.
  17. Jackie LeBret 28 Oct 2019
    We must protect our precious wildlife, nature takes care of itself .
  18. Joanne Chidley 28 Oct 2019
    We need to stop and his
  19. Nikki Green 28 Oct 2019
    These animals should be protected, please do the right thing. Thank you
  20. Holly Ducharme 28 Oct 2019
    This needs to stop
  21. John Keith 28 Oct 2019
    Wild LIFE
    The clue is in the name
  22. Graham Moodie 28 Oct 2019
    Please put an end to this mindless slaughter of wildlife in the name of "country sports"
  23. Eric Lorriman 28 Oct 2019
    Wildlife matters to a lot of people just as much as hunting does to hunters. Strike a balance for goodness sake,stop trapping it's barbaric.
  24. Peter Sains 28 Oct 2019
    Lets stop the slaughter of animals to enable the wealthy to pursue their bloodlust pleasures.
  25. Irene Blackwood 28 Oct 2019
    As a Scottish resident and national I am pleading the Scottish Government to ban the horrific traps that are used to kill wildlife in this country.
  26. natasha salgado 28 Oct 2019
    Please stop the appalling killing. Animals have just as much a right to be here and live peacefully even more than humans as they all were here 1st. It's disgusting that mankind does not recognize this. PITIFUL.
  27. Carol gardnet 28 Oct 2019
    End cruel killing without delay
  28. Sandy Leaf 28 Oct 2019
    Stop killing our precious wildlife.
  29. Angeline Sieb 29 Oct 2019
    This is so wrong. We have to stop all the killing. They have a right to live their life just as much as we do.
  30. Karena Kirk-Drain 29 Oct 2019
    PLEASE STOP THIS HORRENDOUS PRACTICE NOW!!
  31. Merry Robinson 29 Oct 2019
    GOD told NOAH to SAVE THE ANIMALS NOT THE PEOPLE so we need to RESPECT HIS CREATIONS!
  32. Merry Robinson 29 Oct 2019
    GOD told NOAH to SAVE THE ANIMALS NOT THE PEOPLE so we need to RESPECT HIS CREATIONS!
  33. natasha buzak 29 Oct 2019
    Cruelty of man have no boundary.
  34. DAVID SMART 29 Oct 2019
    Why are animals being cruelly killed for the benefit of people who pay to kill another animal?
  35. Mark Lund 29 Oct 2019
    The term vermin is so outdated, and subjective, in the 21st C. The reason for calling this wildlife, vermin is because some of it may, MAY! impact on the obscene numbers of overbred, protected, and invasive species that are shot for the fun, entertainment, by a relatively few number of mostly wealthy people who think they own the countryside, and therefore have limitless powers to destroy our wildlife for their fun, and the destruction is seemingly carried out by those who have no respect for the wildlife, or in their terms, vermin, for purely monetary reasons. This needs to stop and the illegal killing needs to be punished with fewer loopholes for the best lawyers to take advantage off.
  36. Margaret Beckett 29 Oct 2019
    These poor animals need as much help from these cruel people and the pleasure they get from inflicting such awful cruelty
  37. Jan Russell 29 Oct 2019
    Stop the senseless killing of animals.
  38. Barbara woodrough 29 Oct 2019
    I do not think , humans have the right to kill any animals.
  39. Ian Workman 29 Oct 2019
    he crucial need everywhere is to achieve a Balance in Nature, where all species survive and prosper. This of course includes ourselves, man, homo sapiens, us. We have through the centuries changed all this for sport and recreation. Not just to feed and clothe ourselves and our families. This has been the principal reason for the unbalance and the suffering and extinction of most other species. There is a need for respect to avoid a landscape devoid of any other wildlife at all. This is especially true on the shooting estates. Full of eye catching scenery but lifeless. It's been proven that city centres have a better Balance which, although good for city dwellers, it's very sad for the huge areas of moor and farmland in our country. It is time to change before it is too late. Probably won't happen in my lifetime but let's preserve something for our descendants. Prove to them that most of us do actually care, we do want people to enjoy our countryside. So let's get the ball rolling. The shooting estate employees have so many opportunities in the thriving tourism and photography markets. There's no need for unemployment concerns. The Estate owners and managers have shown their opportunism. They just need some persuasion to follow alternatives. It's been done elsewhere, it can be done here. But it is down to the law makers to set the baseline then it's the policing to ensure we stay on track. So, please, seriously consider this petition to at least get us all on the right track to achieve the so crucial Balance.
  40. Susan Duncan 29 Oct 2019
    I've always been proud of my Scottish heritage, but this cruel killing of "predator" animals is nothing of which to be proud. Surely Scotland can do better.
  41. Deborah Anne Moore 29 Oct 2019
    Please stop the unnecessary killing of these birds and any other innocent animals.
  42. Jennifer Gold 29 Oct 2019
    I stand by the request to call on the Scottish Government to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland.

    The ethics and sustainability of the routine and repeated killing of the same species in the same location must be investigated.

    Also I support the banning of snares, Larsen traps and certain other types of live traps outright, and all spring traps on animal welfare grounds.

    I support a stronger mechanism to ensure proper scrutiny of all practices undertaken by hunters, shooters and those who trap, torture and kill animals.

    It has been proven many times that those who cause pain and suffering to animals, also are capable of causing this pain and suffering to humans. The improvement of these laws not only prevents cruelty to animals, it can prevent cruelty to humans too.

    I look forward to hearing from you.
  43. Eleanor Haining 29 Oct 2019
    Those so called sports belong in the past Cruely of this nature is stomach churning
  44. Mairi Donald 29 Oct 2019
    Snares should have been banned a long time ago. How can we call ourselves animal lovers when we still permit snares
    - they are not humane at all. C'mon Scottish Government, lead they way with the snares.
  45. Yvonne Rothwell 29 Oct 2019
    I am an animal lover and I abhor any cruelty especially when it is for the benefit of hunters killing other animals. All traps should be banned everywhere in the UK
  46. June Mackay 29 Oct 2019
    No need for these barbaric practices to keep going, what a cruel horrific thing to do to any animal.
  47. claire Ridges 29 Oct 2019
    Killing wildlife for sport or entertainment is, in my opinion, both cruel and wrong and I want the practices to end as soon as possible.
  48. Brenda Dyson 29 Oct 2019
    Supporting OneKind for the sake of wildlife. The earth is not just for humans!
  49. Gary Brian Prescott 29 Oct 2019
    It is always appallingly sad to cycle around the moorlands of Scotland, as I have on many occasions, and seen a dearth of wildlife due to the slaughter of anything that might mean that the murders of Red Grouse won't have the numbers they need for their sick sport. I hope that one day that the Scottish government will lead the way to stopping the evil perpetrated on the moors.
  50. Debbie Hunter 29 Oct 2019
    In humane act no need