Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01762 · Session 5

End the killing of wildlife on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland

Closed Submitted 2 Oct 2019 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
7,056 online signatures with a country
Comments
340
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Discussions with MSPs and supporting Motions raised in Members’ Debates.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 5 Dec 2019
    1 mention
  2. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,056 online signatures
  1. England2,043 29%
  2. United Kingdom1,865 26.4%
  3. Scotland1,835 26%
  4. United States469 6.6%
  5. Wales168 2.4%
  6. Canada96 1.4%
  7. France78 1.1%
  8. Germany48 0.7%
  9. Australia47 0.7%
  10. Netherlands35 0.5%
  11. 60 other countries372 5.3%

Comments

340 comments, oldest first
340 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Dave Hilliard 4 Oct 2019
    Traps and snares are cruel and cause suffering.
    Please ban them outright.
  2. Gordon Wilson 4 Oct 2019
    And end driven grouse shooting altogether. Make landowners responsible for the health and diversity of wildlife on their land. Ensure that penalties are strong and enforced. Forfeit or Compulsory management of land by NGOs if nature and wildlife are not protected
  3. Sandra Hilliard 4 Oct 2019
    Snares are cruel. Please ban them.
  4. Diana Beamish 4 Oct 2019
    It is time we took more responsibility for our endangered wildlife and also showed more kindness and respect. We all have a right to live in this planet, not just humans.
  5. Christina Brenda Livesey 4 Oct 2019
    We do not and should not have the right to trap and kill any animal, unless it is an immediate threat to our life or that of another human being
    - or in some rare cases, where there is no other access to food and it is needed for survival. In the latter case, animals should only be killed in extreme circumstances and only for our immediate needs. Killing for so-called "Sport" is an abomination. It is neither ethical or sustainable to kill one type of animal (such as Grouse) in the same location, year after year.
  6. Lorraine Ross 4 Oct 2019
    I h,ve recently come across a badger with a snare around it, a most cruel agonising death.
  7. Roderick A.F. MacKay 4 Oct 2019
    We need to protect our wildlife and stop people killing animals and bird in our Scottish countryside!!!
  8. Linda- Anne MacKay 4 Oct 2019
    We must protect our wildlife from people who think killing animals and is sport. It is completely unacceptable , and a disgrace, these idiots should never be allowed to hold a gun let alone use it!
  9. Frances Button 4 Oct 2019
    Wildlife have a right to a life, stop all snares, horrible and painful let them run free.
  10. Gaby Navarrete 4 Oct 2019
    Stop the cruelty with poison
  11. Caroline McManus 4 Oct 2019
    Scotland cannot be a forward thinking compassionate country whilst snares are still legal
  12. Fiona Mackintosh 4 Oct 2019
    I would like to see an end to grouse moors altogether. Our native wildlife is disappearing at an unprecedented rate and the over management of moorland for one species for the profit of landowners is a major contributor. Grouse shooting is outdated and laughably called sport by its advocates. It has no place in a modern Scotland. How can we call out the Japanese on whale hunting when we have open season on our moors. We claim to be leading the way in climate change. Well start with our moors and get the balance back in our precious ecosystems. This slaughter in the name of sport must stop.
  13. Vicki Blake 4 Oct 2019
    Please review the animal welfare impacts on the use of traps.
  14. Dale Elizabeth Westwood 4 Oct 2019
    Give wildlife the respect and protection that it deserves, the future for our children is in your hands
  15. Pam Alvesteffer 5 Oct 2019
    It's disheartening that traps and snares are used in Scotland. Globally we need to stand strong and demand that all traps and snares be banned and laws be in place to protect wildlife and habitat
  16. Sherian Holt 5 Oct 2019
    Just leave God's creatures alone
  17. Michael watson 5 Oct 2019
    The killing must stop. A small minority killing wildlife for thesake of shooting grouse which are raised in abnormal numbers.
  18. Diana Beard 5 Oct 2019
    Too much unnecessary animal cruelty still going on. Lets love and appreciate them all. Soon there won't be any left. Mankind is very cruel.
  19. Tony Paterson 5 Oct 2019
    How can we claim to be a progressive country? Snares are indiscriminate and barbaric. They are banned in European countries
    - many of whom we would like to think we are more civilised than. And yet we think its acceptable to condemn animals to slow excruciating deaths because areas of land that cannot even be reached by most humans require to be intensively managed to the point traps and snares are left to catch them. Leave that kind wild, and leave it to the animals.
  20. Mary Betteridge 5 Oct 2019
    Grouse shooting and all killing of any wild animals on grouse moors should be banned.
  21. Miss Jade Smith 5 Oct 2019
    Thousands of sentient animals suffer and die in traps and snares on grouse moors across Scotland, set in order to control predators or so-called "vermin" that interfere with sporting pursuits.

    Do we have any right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed for recreation?

    Should any traps be permitted for use against our wildlife?

    If so, how can an instant and humane death be guaranteed?

    Is it ethical or sustainable to keep killing the same type of animals, year after year, in the same location?
  22. Christine Ladyman 5 Oct 2019
    It really is time to end the cruelty. Leave the wildlife alone, it's not here to satisfy people's urge to kill for 'fun' or profit.
  23. Alison Yates 5 Oct 2019
    Snares and traps are barbaric and cruel. Animals are left to suffer with agonising injuries. This needs to stop.
  24. Susan Cheetham 5 Oct 2019
    Keep animals safe
  25. Alistair Macfarlane 5 Oct 2019
    Stop killing innocent creatures.
  26. Pamela Rogers 5 Oct 2019
    Stop killing wildlife.
  27. Susan Wilson 5 Oct 2019
    As a biologist I abhor the development of vast tracts of countryside as monoculture 'grouse moors' for a 'sport' and cruelly trapping, snaring and killing native mammals or birds. It is unacceptable in any civilised society and contrary to any 21st century ethic of animal welfare, conservation and ecology.
  28. Eileen Easton 5 Oct 2019
    It is almost 2020, and horrific, barbaric cruelties towards our animals is still going on! It disgusts me!!
    All animals deserve to be treated humanely, and spared suffering, they do not deserve the pain suffering that humans inflict upon them.
    This horrific cruelty has to end!! Animals are a gift to us, and every animal, every single one of them, should be treated humanely, with kindness, respect and dignity!!!!
    "COMPASSION IS THE SIGN OF A NATION'S GREATNESS"!!!!!
  29. Edie Eastley 5 Oct 2019
    BAN TRAPS, BAN ALL TRAPPING DEVICES!!!!!
    UNBELIVABLE cruelty to animals!!!!
  30. Theo Odie 6 Oct 2019
    Thousands of sentient animals suffer and die in traps and snares on grouse moors across Scotland, set in order to control predators or so-called "vermin" that interfere with sporting pursuits.

    Do we have any right to kill one type of animal so that another can be killed for recreation?

    Should any traps be permitted for use against our wildlife?

    If so, how can an instant and humane death be guaranteed?

    Is it ethical or sustainable to keep killing the same type of animals, year after year, in the same location?
  31. Celia Worrall 17 Oct 2019
    Disgusting and must be stopped now
  32. Morag Sharpe 17 Oct 2019
    I agree wholeheartedly with the sentiments expressed below. Who made humans the more important species just because there are more of us
    - we have turned into the predators. Let our wildlife live in the habitat they belong.
  33. Brian Leecy 17 Oct 2019
    This disgraceful Victorian attitude needs consigning to the History Books.I am deeply ashamed and embarrassed,of what goes on in the UK.in order just to appease the rich and powerful,to have their bit of bloodlust fun at the expense of everything else
  34. Jean Nobbs 17 Oct 2019
    I fully support this petition. Mountain hares are part of the natural environment and have declined seriously because of persecution by man. The natural environment comes before the "pleasures" of hunting in any form.
  35. Silvana Fishlock 17 Oct 2019
    No member of another species should be killed for the 'sport' of humans. It is a cruel. barbaric practice which no country wishing to become fully civilised should tolerate, regardless of financial and trade considerations. The countryside can be more profitably developed than by allowing the current shameful activities, I fully support this petition.
  36. Carol Breton 17 Oct 2019
    These horrific senseless murders must stop
  37. Ron Thomson 17 Oct 2019
    Disgusting to think that this horrific cruelty to animals is still legal in Scotland
  38. Theresà Easson 17 Oct 2019
    All life is scared and should not be harmed
  39. Elizabeth Robertson 17 Oct 2019
    Traps and snares are cruel beyond belief. Please stop this barbaric practice.
  40. Christine Nesbitt 17 Oct 2019
    All animals should have the same rights and freedom to live as us sick humans
  41. DEIRDRE BYRNE 17 Oct 2019
    I WISH ALL THIS CRUELTY COULD BE STOPPED
  42. Michael Roberts 17 Oct 2019
    As a Scot, I feel ashamed that beloved wild animals are being murdered inhumanely for the sake of a handful of wealthy individuals to engage in so-called sport.
  43. Michael Dunsbee 17 Oct 2019
    Horrendous and evil, this must stop.
  44. Ros McSweeney 17 Oct 2019
    I have spent a lot of time in Scotland, mostly in the Highlands and am so disappointed to find out that Scotland has this barbaric side, it's time to put an end to it and prosecute those who act in inhumane ways.
  45. connie feely 17 Oct 2019
    where have all the deer gone from national trust lands our herd of 40 does is now 8 why the numbers were miscalculated and the cull took out most.this needs to stop. they are part of the reason tourists take photos but this year we have been asked where they are by touurists so i tell them the government killed them without checking figures no one does.
  46. pam mock 17 Oct 2019
    Barbaric
  47. Julie Douglass 17 Oct 2019
    The bloody pastimes of a few shouldn't be permitted to destroy the wildlife of these islands.
  48. Patricia Malone 18 Oct 2019
    Please leave this creatures to live as they should and stop the cruelty
  49. Phaedra Dresch 18 Oct 2019
    Killing wildlife is always wrong and killers should be in prison.
  50. Rosie Leventon 18 Oct 2019
    Appalling cruelty, I cant believe people still do this sort of thing.