Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01762 · Session 5

End the killing of wildlife on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland

Closed Submitted 2 Oct 2019 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
7,056 online signatures with a country
Comments
340
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Discussions with MSPs and supporting Motions raised in Members’ Debates.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 5 Dec 2019
    1 mention
  2. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,056 online signatures
  1. England2,043 29%
  2. United Kingdom1,865 26.4%
  3. Scotland1,835 26%
  4. United States469 6.6%
  5. Wales168 2.4%
  6. Canada96 1.4%
  7. France78 1.1%
  8. Germany48 0.7%
  9. Australia47 0.7%
  10. Netherlands35 0.5%
  11. 60 other countries372 5.3%

Comments

340 comments, oldest first
340 comments · showing 251–300
  1. Caroline Hughes 6 Nov 2019
    Just STOP messing around with nature and its fauna!!! Its there for a reason and that is nothing to do with humans! Keep out of its way and stop killing needlessly!!!!
  2. Michelle Lavender 6 Nov 2019
    Just stop killing, nature will find it's own way.
  3. Debs Wirral 6 Nov 2019
    Disgusting treatment of animals have they got no respect...? David Attenborough would put them to shame!!
  4. Susan Thomas 6 Nov 2019
    The persecution of wildlife to enable thousands of birds to be bred and reared purely to be shot and killed is totally unacceptable and immoral in every way. It should NOT BE TOLERATED IN A SUPPOSEDLY CIVILISED COUNTRY LIKE SCOTLAND
  5. Chris Rigby 6 Nov 2019
    We are not the only species on this earth.
    We should respect the natural eco environment and not manipulate it for sport and greed
  6. Frances Button 6 Nov 2019
    This barbaric practice must stop. Stop all unnecessary anguish to poor animals. Stop shooting poor birds. Stop humans acting barbarically.
  7. Annette Duff 6 Nov 2019
    Stop this animal cruelty
  8. Colin McIntosh 6 Nov 2019
    This practice underlines the attitude by staff and, more particularly, owners, of sporting estates that nothing can stand in the way of their right to make money. Like the persecution of raptors, this practice has no scientific justification, impoverishes the biosphere, and causes immeasurable suffering.
  9. John King 6 Nov 2019
    Contrary to how we may like to think of ourselves, we clearly aren't a civilised society. We have allowed our traditional industries to vanish, yet hang onto the anachronism that is hunting.....often excused because it provides poor employment for a few saddoes and a few outings for the inadequates that enjoy killing things.

    Here in the southeast of England, we have pheasant shooting. The native wildlife gets persecuted just the same and many of the birds that are shot get buried as there aren't the outlets for them. And that is nothing short of outrageous.

    I am a country hick well established into my seventh decade on this earth and have been about long enough to remember that all that got shot was eaten and that we didn't have to endure the almost constant gunfire that we have now. Indeed, these hunting people discharge their weapons on, or close to public land now, without any regard for the safety of others.
  10. tony plant 6 Nov 2019
    there is no future in killing
  11. Gertrude Wright 6 Nov 2019
    Killing animals so that there are more birds to kill is senseless slaughter
  12. Linda Norris 6 Nov 2019
    Grouse moors are a scourge to wildlife, they benefit nobody but bloodthirsty, greedy morons. Our wildlife in jeopardy, time to put the moors back to their natural state!
  13. Carlo Silvestri 6 Nov 2019
    love nature!!! ban hunt!!!
  14. CAROLINE LEA 6 Nov 2019
    There is no justification to treat our precious wildlife with such cruelty. We need to preserve what we have.
  15. Paul McMillan 6 Nov 2019
    Why is this still legal?
  16. Hilary Bartley 7 Nov 2019
    Just heartbreaking , what a waste of beautiful creatures lives. Man is so cruel
  17. Jane Jenkins 7 Nov 2019
    Wildlife needs to be left alone so it can recover from the mass slaughter it has suffered over the centuries. Please, don't let us lose our wild animals!
  18. Charlotte Tupper 7 Nov 2019
    It is concerning to think other wildlife is being trapped here and these methods are harming other wildlife
  19. Ellen Prior 7 Nov 2019
    Please make sure there is no animal cruelty!
  20. Angela Reed 7 Nov 2019
    Unnecessary cruelty & suffering to life on earth
  21. Shona Harris 7 Nov 2019
    Truly disgusting and mindless
  22. Javatvasi Dasa 7 Nov 2019
    Aside from protecting the persecuted animals and birds we are protecting the children who are indoctrinated into this carnivorous culture which severely reduces their opportunities for social interaction with their environmentally conscious generation.
  23. Andrew Meakin 7 Nov 2019
    The wildlife need us to help prevent all this cruelty. The wildlife are entitled to peace and to be free from persecution
  24. Andrew Meakin 7 Nov 2019
    The wildlife need us to help prevent all this cruelty. The wildlife are entitled to peace and to be free from persecution
  25. Patricia Harmsworth 7 Nov 2019
    Absolutely shocking.
  26. Dona Crum 7 Nov 2019
    Murdering these beautiful sentient creatures just so some rich murderer can murder with impunity is diabolical and degrades the whole human race!
  27. Sandra Timms 7 Nov 2019
    I'm shocked that this barbaric behaviour towards our countries wildlife is still allowed in 2019! It has to stop!
  28. peter regan 7 Nov 2019
    why should a few tweed clad rich people,have the right to deprive people of the right to enjoy wildlife.
    This industry wipes out wildlife destroys the enviroment it's contribution to anything is negated
    by it's massive destruction to nature.
    I live near moorland that is used for driven grouse
    shooting,thankfully much of it has been stopped by the
    local water authority who own the land,but only because of the devastating floods caused by the water
    running off the scoured moors.This exploitation and
    destruction of wildife and the enviroment for a few rich
    people has to end.
  29. Evereld 7 Nov 2019
    Scotland is becoming as bad as the USA in killing animals who are merely doing what they need to do to survive. These vile traps must be stopped as must the killing of all wild animals for no good reason whatsoever. Scotland I am bitterly ashamed of you, ban the traps and the killing of innocent animals NOW please.
  30. Ursina Hack-Maclellan 7 Nov 2019
    End the useless killing of wildlife. Our natural environment must no longer be the playground of the rich.
  31. hazel linda hames 7 Nov 2019
    Should be consigned to history along with all the other rubbish the aristocracy persist in hanging onto.
  32. Carmen Cardashian 7 Nov 2019
    We destroyed their habitat to build ours and now we go killing them in their own territory too? Pathetic species we ,humans are!!
  33. Lucie Dudley 7 Nov 2019
    This barbaric cruelty must stop now x
  34. Jonathan Briscoe 7 Nov 2019
    Stop this barbaric pointless animal cruelty
  35. Roxanne Brown 7 Nov 2019
    Shame on my mother land for allowing such barbatic ways
  36. Beverley Snowden 7 Nov 2019
    Please stop killing these animals.
  37. Steve D Mitchell. 7 Nov 2019
    I am sick of seeing more and more evidence that scarce wildlife is being slaughtered so that rich can kill grouse for sport! When are the grouse to be issued shotguns? When a case comes to court, the OWNER of the estate should be required to stand in the dock!
  38. Angela Duriez 7 Nov 2019
    This is barbaric and evil and has no place in this world.
  39. Sandra Bolton 7 Nov 2019
    Something needs done, and fast. Please support this petition.
  40. Elaine Whittaker. 7 Nov 2019
    This persecution of our wildlife for greed must stop NOW!
  41. valerie C Tippett 7 Nov 2019
    they must stop
  42. Geoff Tansley 7 Nov 2019
    An embarrassing anachronism of cruelty.
  43. June McAvoy 7 Nov 2019
    I had to listen to the screaming of a suffering fox caught in a drag snare, dangling from its neck in agony for hours awaiting help from SSPCA. That sight and sound haunt me still. This cruelty is abhorrent to any civilised society. Please use your powers to put a stop to this.
  44. Sheila Lothian 7 Nov 2019
    Its disgusting & outrageous for animals to be mistreated & killed in this way, without regard for their suffering....this barbarism must stop !!!
  45. Sarahjayne Thomas 8 Nov 2019
    Barbaric and totally unnecessary!!!!
  46. Colin Davies 8 Nov 2019
    Wildlife protections are needed in Law
  47. Philip Bahia 8 Nov 2019
    I hate animal abuse and killing them for no reason is inexcusable,those who do this to animals are not human at all their murderers and evil killing God's creatures.
  48. Callum Russell 8 Nov 2019
    I'm led to believe humane control of pests is done by gamekeepers & game wardens this doesn't look like the work of either and should berightly condemned
  49. John Lumbard 8 Nov 2019
    Traps including cage traps used to trap birds should not be allowed to be used under the General Licence. Traps are also the cause of death for many non target species. Banning is the only real solution.
  50. Mark Woodfin 9 Nov 2019
    Please stop the persecution of our wild species for the sake of a few so called "sportsmen". Ban trapping and shooting of native species.