Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01762 · Session 5

End the killing of wildlife on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland

Closed Submitted 2 Oct 2019 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
7,056 online signatures with a country
Comments
340
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to conduct a full review of the animal welfare impacts of the use of traps and snares on grouse moors and elsewhere in Scotland.

What the petitioner did first

Discussions with MSPs and supporting Motions raised in Members’ Debates.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 5 Dec 2019
    1 mention
  2. 10 Sep 2020
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 23 Feb 2021
    1 mention

Signatures by country

7,056 online signatures
  1. England2,043 29%
  2. United Kingdom1,865 26.4%
  3. Scotland1,835 26%
  4. United States469 6.6%
  5. Wales168 2.4%
  6. Canada96 1.4%
  7. France78 1.1%
  8. Germany48 0.7%
  9. Australia47 0.7%
  10. Netherlands35 0.5%
  11. 60 other countries372 5.3%

Comments

340 comments, oldest first
340 comments · showing 301–340
  1. Pat O'Sullivan 10 Nov 2019
    This is Not sport or animal control. It is organised barbarism. Get it stopped
  2. Alistair Godfrey 10 Nov 2019
    Animal cruelty is against the law, but it persists. The law has been tightened, but persecution continues. Current legislation and how it is failing needs to be examined, reviewed and new measures implemented.
    In some areas we have not progressed beyond the Victorian mentality of game management. Enlightened practices need to replace them.
    All traps need to be banned.
    The case for retaining grouse moors is difficult to support. The control of deer needs another approach. Humane deer control is a requirement to maintain ecology and has the potential, if carried out resonsibly, to be a sustainable practice.
  3. Andrea McAdoo 10 Nov 2019
    Absolutely unconscionable, reprehensible, repugnant, despicable an evil act of barbarism, PLEASE INVESTIGATE & BRING THE CRIMINALS TO JUSTICE THE GUILTY PARTY OR PARTIES TO JUDGEMENT FOR THE JUSTICE OF THESE PRECIOUS SENTIENT SOULS, LIVING BEINGS, PREGNANT MOTHERS, INFANTS, YOUNG & ADULTS WHOM SUFFERED UNTOLD & UNIMAGINABLY CRUEL NEGLECT, ABUSE, TORTUROUS DEATH UNDER YOUR ARCHAIC LOOSE AT BEST RULES AND LAWS WITH ABSOLUTELY NO PROTECTIONS UNDER YOUR LAWS!!!!
  4. Fay van Dunk 11 Nov 2019
    There is no justification to wilfully end an animal or bird's life. We have no right. Until we understand that animals are not inferior we will continue to be ignorant and continue to kill them
  5. deborah theobald 12 Nov 2019
    ban traps and snares
  6. Julia Kaminski 12 Nov 2019
    Snares are unbelievably cruel, and do we really want a future without wildlife? No!
  7. Josephine A Munro 12 Nov 2019
    I feel strongly that there is no appetite in modern Scotland for such animal cruelty, we have moved on from such behaviour and our people now care about animal welfare and expect our laws to reflect our feelings.
  8. Tracey Hunter 12 Nov 2019
    This disgusts me that men and woman want to kill animals for sport go play football and hockey you snobs leave the animals alone
  9. Carole Elizabeth Hough 12 Nov 2019
    Nationally our wildlife is under threat as never before. The beautiful Scottish hare is endangered & yet over 26,000 are killed in the name of sport. It is time that your government took some responsibility for the appalling & barbaric use of traps & snares that should be condemned to history!
  10. Margaret Gill 12 Nov 2019
    Stop this cruelty now
  11. Jean robinson 12 Nov 2019
    Our wildlife needs protection
  12. Sarah Pitt 12 Nov 2019
    I would like to see a completely different approach to managing grouse moors and farmland where this trapping continues. it is totally acceptable in the 21st century to let healthy animals suffer in this way and leave them to do so for so long. II would go even further and ban recreational shooting unless it provides food for the person who shoots i.e. a quota at least for shooting birds should be bought in
    - no more than 2 birds per person.
    Have landowners not read the figures
    - British wildlife has declined by between 50-70% since the 2nd World War. We should not be taking out numbers either by trapping or shooting but nurturing our precious wildlife and the biodiversity it brings these lands so that their numbers can recover and a natural balance can be maintained.
  13. Jennifer Thomson Scotland 12 Nov 2019
    It's time to safeguard the wilidlife in Scotland from hunters and those involved in bloodsports
  14. Constance Gotsopoulou 12 Nov 2019
    Please stop this barbaric behaviour we are in the 21st century. Killing sentient being should be illegal!
  15. Priscilla Littmoden 12 Nov 2019
    Stop this cruelty. Every animal had the right to live
  16. Anne Stark 12 Nov 2019
    I have been campaigning against grouse shooting for years now. Lets hope the constant the constant awareness raising by petitions like this will lead to a total ban. The sooner the better.
  17. Elizabeth Cooper 12 Nov 2019
    Disgusting behaviour must stop NOW
  18. Claire Kordas 12 Nov 2019
    Cruelty has no place in our world
  19. Rue Ekins 12 Nov 2019
    The destruction of wildlife including the ongoing persecution of raptors and mountain hares in pursuit of grouse shooting is an appalling stain on Scotland's reputation. There is no place for such a 'sport' in modern society if it depends on illegal activities and unsustainable killing of wildlife to secure its market. Completely unacceptable and the perpetrators should be held to account.
  20. Colin Wright 12 Nov 2019
    It's a disgrace it's happening in our country,,!!!
  21. Audrey Kaufman 12 Nov 2019
    Please show compassion!!
  22. Brigitte Bleyer 12 Nov 2019
    Animals don't have a voice, so you will never stop hearing Mine
  23. Sallie Johnson 12 Nov 2019
    This is the 21st century, not the Dark Ages. We need to join the rest of humanity and stop the slaughter.
  24. Lorraine Lowry 12 Nov 2019
    This madness has to end!!!
  25. Angeline lucas 12 Nov 2019
    They put money before wildlife. These grouse moor owners are a disgrace
  26. Sonja Chance 12 Nov 2019
    ALL murder of wild life should be banned it is disgusting and yes it is MURDER.
  27. Anne grant 12 Nov 2019
    Things have taken such a toll on our natural and beautiful animals we have to wonder what this life would be like without these glorious creatures ,they have a right to live and give us such a pleasure just in the wonder to our hearts to see them free and safe ,man has got to step back a bit and learn to live with what they have now instead of the pounds sign ,if they have to control the over breeding of certain species bring in a natural predator to control them ,the circle of life is a natural way ,I know they have predators but if they are not enough bring in more ,I am not nieve I know you have tried many ways to control these problems ,but think harder to find a more natural way to do it ,I know I have gone on a bit but I fear for the future of our wonderful gifts God has given us ,and Animals all over this wonderful creation we have been given to take care of now don't have a chance when Man starts to take over what was there homes ,think what you are going to do and make a difference today ,I wish you well and hope my thoughts are worth while x
  28. Sharon Hopkins 12 Nov 2019
    Why is this barbarity still allowed in 2019? Many animals and wildlife are caught in traps, snares and other disgusting and cruel devices which are designed to ensure nothing interrupts shooting interests. It's also a vile and warped past-time for people with low mentality and inadequacy, it's all about power. We should be targeting companies that make traps and snares although many are home-made. I cannot imagine the terror, pain and suffering endured by creatures caught in these primitive and despicable devices.
  29. Mr Colin Jeffrey 12 Nov 2019
    Native British wildlife is under threat from many sides and all native species must be properly protected for their own sake and for their important place in the eco system and not sacrificed for the financial gain of vested interests such as the hunting, shooting or fishing lobbies.
  30. Linda Teasdale Pluchard 12 Nov 2019
    We need to make laws stronger .Our wildlife needs all the help it can get.
  31. Jan Webb 12 Nov 2019
    We must protect our beautiful wildlife and learn to live alongside them. They are such special beings and I abhor they way in which they are killed.
  32. Sharon L Ridlon 12 Nov 2019
    Needless killing of any animal is a disaster to nature
    . Their needs to be a balance.
  33. Carole Fraser 13 Nov 2019
    This is sheer brutality these Animals suffer a Herendous Death it's just vile Evil and very cruel stop this mass murder of these endangered species .
  34. Francisco Sanchez Molina 13 Nov 2019
    Gamekeepers are legally able to set cruel and outdated traps and snares to kill animals that are predators to red grouse, as they want as many red grouse available as possible for commercial shooting.

    Foxes, weasels and stoats are regularly targeted, but these traps are indiscriminate and domestic cats, dogs and badgers are also trapped. Tens of thousands of animals are killed each year on driven grouse moors.

    This cruelty has to end. Animals deserve to be respected.
  35. Betty (Elizabeth) Lee 13 Nov 2019
    When I walk on the moors I would like the chance to see Hen Harriers, Golden Eagles, Hares, Badgers and other British animals. The moors look pretty dead to me
    - and I can guess why!!
  36. Lynn Milne 13 Nov 2019
    We need to protect our wildlife not destroy it in barbaric ways.
  37. Suzanne Spiers 13 Nov 2019
    I am angry that wild indigenous animals are wantonly killed, often in very cruel ways, by human beings who have no regard for the fact that all indigenous animals have an important role in keeping ecosystems healthy. Take one animal, plant or insect out of that ecosystem, and the ecosystem is disrupted.

    Please take the time to learn about the importance of helping indigenous animals to live as part of the natural environment.
  38. Linda Gunnell 13 Nov 2019
    Wild life needs to be preserved for all our futures
  39. Fiona Ord 13 Nov 2019
    The sad picture says it all.
  40. Patricia Wood 13 Nov 2019
    Our wildlife is under enough stress and this is an elitist pastime which takes a huge toll . It needs to stop causing death for sport is disgusting.