Petition · PE01598 · Session 4
Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms
Signatures
1
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.
What the petitioner did first
Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
16 Jun 20162 mentions
-
30 Jun 20161 mention
-
29 Sep 20161 mention
-
26 Oct 20161 mention
-
14 Dec 20161 mention
-
21 Jun 20171 mention
-
12 Dec 20181 mention
Signatures by country
4,382 online signaturesComments
431 comments, oldest first431 comments · showing 151–200
-
John Robins 20 Jan 2016sea lice thriving around Fish Farms have decimated the wild salmon and sea trout stock of too many rivers. Please take action.
-
Jeremy Henderson 20 Jan 2016Please listen to what we are collectively saying to save our wonderful salmon stocks that are now dangerously low. We need to understand that the dangers are largely man made and are widespread not just from fish farms.
-
Calum MacRae 20 Jan 2016I worked in the salmon farming industry for some years before leaving it because I was disgusted and horrified with the industrial use of pest control chemicals and the sea lice issue. That was over 35 years ago and nothing has changed. I have followed this issue since then and what has become clear is that money matters to politicians the environment does not.
-
Roger Williams 20 Jan 2016I spend considerable money angling in Scotland. My Spring visits are over as from 2015 because of no salmon in the river. Autumn will follow if trends continue.
-
Mick newman 20 Jan 2016We must protect of fish
-
Elizabeth Leitch 20 Jan 2016It is vital that action be taken immediately otherwise all wild salmond will be wiped out. Enforce the Regulations.
-
David Nattress 20 Jan 2016I live to close to Milford Haven to remain complacent about what is happening in Scotland.
Give the Welsh Government half a chance to give the go-ahead to a proposal for net farms in Welsh waters and they will take it. -
Seamus Condin 20 Jan 2016Same problems here in Ireland.
-
Mike Harrison 20 Jan 2016It's about time we sorted out the Scots with their abuse of the salmon and trout waters!
-
Ivan Hargreaves 20 Jan 2016The SNP seems to see no value whatsoever in Scotland's natural heritage. They seem happy to lose it if it means they can claim to be providing jobs in isolated places. There's a saying that you don't know what you've got 'til it's gone. Well, the wild Atlantic salmon, that most enigmatic of all wild creatures, has almost gone from the rivers of Scotland, and the SNP don't care about what they're about to lose.
-
Bob Cox 20 Jan 2016When dealing with DEFRA expects nothing unless it has apolitical advantage to their minister, fisheries management is not something that they understand!
-
Roy Peaker 20 Jan 2016If the Scottish government's past record is anything to go by, they will not want to listen to bringing any legislation to bear upon their salmon farming industry.
-
eck sneddon 20 Jan 2016time people in this country stopped turning a blind eye to this problem.too many do-gooders protecting seals and increasing fish farms poor anglers get the blame for taking one for the pot.
-
John Coutts 20 Jan 2016The aquaculture industry has effectively wiped out serious game angling from the west coast of Scotland and is in dire need of regulation of the kind which persists in Norway.
-
Bruce Stenhouse 20 Jan 2016What appalling neglect. Is it a case of "English Money Spoken Here"?
-
Nicholas James 20 Jan 2016There is massive potential in wild Scottish migratory fish. Any farming that damages this is shortsighted and short changing the Scots environment and by long term cultural and financial detriment.
-
mike ashwin 20 Jan 2016Great work and long overdue. NW fisheries know only too well the damage to migratory stocks negotiating these waters. Wild healthy river stocks is a prize worth fighting for.
-
Gareth Homfray-Davies 20 Jan 2016End the rhetoric. Time to act.
-
Geoff Hardy 20 Jan 2016I cannot believe that we have reached a state of affairs where it is even necessary to resort to a petition in order to get something done.
-
Pete lawson 20 Jan 2016All salmon farms by Salmon containment on land
All wind farms off shore not on the hills -
alan roe 20 Jan 2016These Norwegian fish farms need reining in they are destroying native fish by virtue of the biopolution they create
-
MICHAEL PILGRIM TAAITT 20 Jan 2016The transfer of sea lice to wild Atlantic salmon from fish farms must be contained. Norway's preventative measures is a good lead to follow.
-
Niall Morrison 20 Jan 2016Long overdue!
-
John Green 20 Jan 2016The future for Sctland's wild salmon is in the hands of a government who regards farmed salmon as been more important than the wonderful heritage of natures majestic salmon
-
William Findlay 20 Jan 2016All fish farming should be done in closed cages on land to fully protect the enviroment
-
Kenneth Barry Maylor 20 Jan 2016Fish farms off the west coast of Scotland have completely ruined the west coast rivers and lochs of their wild salmon and sea trout.
The amount of female sea lice present on farmed salmon is far in access of permitted levels and is a disgrace.
The farms also prohibit the safe passage of salmon smolts from Europe and the the UK and many fish do not even reach their feeding grounds due to the impact of sea lice. The Scottish government should be ashamed of allowing fish farms to continue to destroy habitats on the west coast which doesn't just affect migratory fish but complete ecosystems. -
Tam mcdonald 20 Jan 2016Ban fish farming as they decimating wild salmon stocks for years
-
Anthony Rees 20 Jan 2016I may not live in Scotland but the long term effects will be felt all around the UK for mans greed.
-
John Rush 20 Jan 2016The damage done by fish farms is known to all but ignored by politicians. Please save our wild migratory fish. Bring back the anglers and jobs to Scotland.
-
drummond shaw 20 Jan 2016plse control salmon farms
-
Anthony Roberts 20 Jan 2016The warning signs in the form of the ever diminishing stocks of salmo salar are flashing ever brighter, and unless urgent action is taken NOW it will be too late.
-
Stevie Munn 21 Jan 2016Don't lose our wild fish. Fish Farms should be on land not sea. Less damaging to the environment.
-
Shona Muir 21 Jan 2016Time to step up and save one of Scotland's most iconic species.
-
Francis Sandison 21 Jan 2016This is far more urgent than Wild Fisheries Reform or catch & release.
-
Stephen Barker 21 Jan 2016Salmon farming needs far more stringent regulations
to protect the wild trout and salmon,we must act now before it is to late -
Paul Davidson 21 Jan 2016The infestation of juvenile salmon and sea trout must be controlled immediately, it has been ignored for far too long by the Scottish Government.
-
Angus Sutherland 21 Jan 2016How much longer must we wait before positive action is taken? Many rivers in the fish farming catchment have little time before their salmon and sea trout stocks become extinct
-
John D Smith 21 Jan 2016Salmon can be farmed much more safely than the open cage system in use at present. The method currently used is devastating to wild salmon and it is morally wrong!
-
paul bristow 21 Jan 2016We all understand Scotland's desire to earn additional revenue from its great history and tradition of wild salmon fishing but offshore fish farming is killing the golden goose and bit by bit the public is waking up to the fact the salmon farm industry is causing huge environmental damage. This is a fact made far worse by the knowledge that on shore closed containment salmon farming would with a basic filtration system remove all the environmental problems and in doing so allow Scotland to position its product as a premium environmentally safe food source. So rather be dragged kicking and screaming by public pressure and EU rulings in to phasing out off shore salmon farming be proactive, be smart, get ahead and move now to onshore closed containment farming.
-
Nick Winter 21 Jan 2016This problem has been known about for years. Effective action is long overdue to protect our wild fish.
-
Rob Baker 21 Jan 2016Scotland, get your act together before its to late !
-
Martyn Rix 21 Jan 2016The damage caused by sea lice from salmon cages to wild sea trout and salmon has been know for many years, and it is a scandal that no action has been taken before.
-
chris atkinson 21 Jan 2016I cannot imagine that a salmon farmed from the sea is worth anywhere near the same value as one caught in rod and line to the economy.
Since the decline of Scottish salmon, I have taken to fishing Ireland, where on average I spend around £1500 a year directly into the Irish economy. I am sure Ireland, with bought out nets, will be happy to take up Scotland's slack. Lets hope they wake up before its too late for the Scottish pleasure fishing industry -
MATTHEW CLIFFORD PATON 21 Jan 2016THINGS ARE TOUGH ENOUGH FOR WILD SALMON ,LETS NOT EXPOSE THE EVER DWINDLING WILD SALMON TOWARD THE HIGH CONSENTRATIONS OF SEA LICE CAUSED BY ANY FISH FARMS ANYWHERE.
-
David Carrick 21 Jan 2016It is time that government officials got their heads out of the sand and sort these problems out before the damage is irreparable.
-
George Holmes 21 Jan 2016It is very important that we do everything possible to protect the Atlantic Salmon
and every efforts must be used to protect our salmon -
John Ford 21 Jan 2016Very pleased and thankful for your initiative here in trying to protect our environment from rampant commercialism. Well done!
-
Wendy Halliwell 21 Jan 2016I am in support and very much hope that actions will be taken soon before all the stocks have disapeared and vanished forever
-
Graham Moffat 21 Jan 2016They must take action now before it is to late
-
Chris Heap 21 Jan 2016Isn't it time we had a body looking after fisheries interests which is detached from DEFRA. Such an organisation should be like the HSE and be able to deliver truthful outcomes rather than political clap trap!