Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01598 · Session 4

Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms

Closed Submitted 13 Jan 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
4,382 online signatures with a country
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.

What the petitioner did first

Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Jun 2016
    2 mentions
  2. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention
  3. 29 Sep 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 26 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  5. 14 Dec 2016
    1 mention
  6. 21 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  7. 12 Dec 2018
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,382 online signatures
  1. England1,819 41.5%
  2. Scotland1,202 27.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 20.7%
  4. Wales172 3.9%
  5. Northern Ireland58 1.3%
  6. Ireland48 1.1%
  7. United States22 0.5%
  8. Netherlands15 0.3%
  9. Canada14 0.3%
  10. France13 0.3%
  11. 41 other countries111 2.5%

Comments

431 comments, oldest first
431 comments · showing 351–400
  1. Barry Gibson 6 Feb 2016
    How long will it take before the realisation comes home that radical reform is required to preserve wild fish stocks!!
  2. william chisholm 6 Feb 2016
    well done for this petition, much needed.
  3. rory maguire 6 Feb 2016
    Estuary netting should be a major concern in protection of the Atlantic Salmon and Sea Trout stocks.
  4. William Jodrfell 8 Feb 2016
    Delighted to support such an important petition
  5. john braithwaite 8 Feb 2016
    In order to preserve stocks ALL netting for salmon should be banned, and on the main east coast rivers it should be fly only
  6. Arnold Slater 8 Feb 2016
    Farm salmon sea lice destroying wild salmon and sea trout stocks,will destroy game angling tourism and Scottish jobs.
  7. george younger kennedy 8 Feb 2016
    Pleased to support.High time Scottish Government took some real action to control the fish farming industry.
  8. David John Watson 8 Feb 2016
    Here in the SW of Scotland salmon and sea trout numbers have plummetted over the last decade. It has been long established that parasitic lice from Fish Farms have destroyed the majority of smolts passing out to Sea but more recently I have seen returning adult fish plastered with sea lice. There is only one source that could be responsible for this.
    The cause is obvious and the solution
    - closed containment- is sensibly achievable.
    It is hard to believe that a Government which purports to represent Scotland is presiding over such an environmental, social, and economic disaster.
  9. Joan Jordan 8 Feb 2016
    Time people in responsible positions acted responsibility!
  10. Nick Charlton Smith 9 Feb 2016
    The evidence has been available for some considerable time. Excessive numbers of Fish farm Sea lice are killing our native salmon and sea trout
    - and effective control is required. The precautionary principle should be paramount in any decision making by the Scottish Government. Commercial pressure from the fish farmers must not be permitted to prevent effective controls to ensure the survival of these iconic species across Scotland as a whole.
  11. Andrew Wildblood 10 Feb 2016
    If government continues to dither over this issue it will be too late and our ancestors will rightly asked 'how was that allowed to happen'. Given the volatile nature of the oil market, a responsible government should be looking more carefully at preserving other local and sustainable valuable natural resources.
  12. Philip McWalter 10 Feb 2016
    Fish farming is destructive to the environment unless fully contained and preferably on land where it can be totally monitored and overseen easily.
  13. D W Roxborough 10 Feb 2016
    this has been going on since the 80's with out any intervention , it's about time that this was addressed,before any other regulations i.e. current reform, takes place D W Roxborough
  14. Iain Macdonald 10 Feb 2016
    With a little thought and investment, the lice issue can be dealt with. On land farms is one of many options. For to long the lice, and disease issues are swept under the table. This is not an illusion, we can stop this madness now before we wipe out our entire species. Angling and the farming industry can both survive if we act now. Does anyone want to see more evedence in the decline of wild fish the likes off what we see on our West Coast rivers.
  15. David Walker 10 Feb 2016
    Until Salmon fish farming is moved on shore in full closed containment there will always be huge problems for wild Salmon
  16. Stewart Cameron 10 Feb 2016
    If the Wild Fisheries Review and the map showing the category 3 rivers hasn't stirred some form of doubt in the minds of our politicians managing our environment i dispair. With any luck China will be producing their own farmed salmon soon and the industry will become unsutainable and wither.
  17. Eric R wardle 11 Feb 2016
    There will be no salmon river fishing if the Government do not sort this out. A big loss of jobs tourism etc.
  18. Andrew Moore 11 Feb 2016
    we must do everything possible to protect our native fish stocks, and particularly the genetic diversity of wild salmon and sea trout. Wait and see is not an option unless we want to see the failure of our wild fish as a pot6ential consequence. As a minimum we should be setting the standard for good practices, rather than lagging as at present.
  19. Robert Mitchell 11 Feb 2016
    Sea lice kills everything after a short time. Just look under the cages.
  20. Mr Kenneth Barry Maylor 11 Feb 2016
    The Scottish government do not appreciate the damage done by fish farms to wild salmon and sea trout stocks and whole river systems have been wiped out.
    The sea bed below the cages is completely devoid of life other than female sea lice the number of which are astronomical and a complete disgrace.
  21. Richard Collins 12 Feb 2016
    In the SALSEA project pity they were unable to undertake tracking of the migration of smolts from the point of leaving their native rivers into the marine environment. As far as I know the theory that smolts from SW Scotland and indeed NW England migrate through the W and NW Scotland fish farming areas has yet to be substantiated. But very expensive to undertake, I guess !
  22. Tom Castle 13 Feb 2016
    Surely the scientific evidence that irresponsible fish farming is destroying wild salmon runs is now irrefutable. Time for action before it's too late!
  23. James Russell France 14 Feb 2016
    This problem is also affecting Cumbrian rivers.
  24. Pierre Rumeau 15 Feb 2016
    I'm fortunate enough in not having this problem were I fish in Scotland (the Dee). But, having fished for seatrout in Ireland for the last thirty years, I saw them disappear where cages were installed with the few remaining being lean and overinfested. I had to change my holiday location to find some still healthy populations.
    Regarding the remote populations of the West Coast, considering what happened to the aquaculture in Chile, what will happen if the wild populations of migratory and coastal fish disappear, if the aquaculture is not sustainable any more and there is no transfer funding from dwindling petrol benefits? Would tourists still visit or would they prefer the sun of milder places?
  25. Chris Dawbarn 15 Feb 2016
    I have had personal experience of a good west coast salmon fishery being ruined by the effects of farmed salmon.
  26. Neal Mallett 16 Feb 2016
    This is a known and irrefutable problem that needs action now
  27. David Sandford 16 Feb 2016
    Further to Pierre's comments, now that Salmon Farming is being better "controlled" in Connwe are
  28. Jams Rennie 16 Feb 2016
    Salmon farms through uncontrolled sea lice populations are destroying Scotland's wild salmon and sea trout runs.
  29. Chris Tunnicliffe 16 Feb 2016
    Restoring sustainable populations of wild salmon and trout, together with protecting their traditional migratory runs in both Scotland and Wales, has to be a priority for the Wildlife and Fisheries departments of both these countries as so many other species depend on their condition and availability for their own sustainability.
  30. Kim Sawyer 16 Feb 2016
    Lice infestation is a recognized killer of migrating wild salmon, grilse, smolts and seatrout. Some measure of control must be introduced.
  31. Peter Floyd-Spong 16 Feb 2016
    Having spent some time reading Fisheries around the country, part of a Oceanography degree, I feel that there are too many unanswered questions over farmed salmon to be sure adequate protection for our wild stock. Though yet to partake myself in salmon fishing in Scotland, it is and hopefully will remain a major source of income for Scotland, especially if the people decide to leave the Union.
  32. Tony Rea 16 Feb 2016
    Wake up Scotland and protect one of your greatest resources, both historical and from the point pf view of depleting tourist income. Why are you not protecting your wildlife ?
  33. Brian Moffat 17 Feb 2016
    Support vital
  34. Simon evans 17 Feb 2016
    I organise parties to travel to Scotland to fish for salmon. I used to take a week on the west coast and one on the East. I no longer fish on the west coast (river Aloirt and Loch Eilt). This is costing Scotland £2,500 a year
  35. Rupert Leigh-Wood 17 Feb 2016
    Why does Scotland have such disregard for Wild Salmon? Very sad.
  36. Ian Calcott 17 Feb 2016
    Most Scottish salmon farms are Norwegian-owned. Why are regulations here less stringent than on Norwegian fish farms? More infamous policy decisions by the SNP Government ?
  37. John Brook Riley 18 Feb 2016
    Since 1985 I have witnessed good improvements to the Upper stretches of the Aberdeenshire Don, however the general trend of salmon catches are down. While this river does not suffer from salmon farming issues, it is like all others seeing the effects of by catch with the makeral and herring fishery. I do hope we can see progress to reduce this adverse effect.
  38. W Whitbread 18 Feb 2016
    The negative impact of sea lice from salmon farms stretches far beyond the west Highlands and Islands.
  39. James Bidwell 18 Feb 2016
    This is so important and we all need to do something before it is too late
  40. David Burton 18 Feb 2016
    I saw a badly fungal infected salmon on the Frome in Dorset in mid January. Not sure if this was sea lice related, but it was a sorry sight to see and clearly something needs to be done.
  41. Robert Sandison 20 Feb 2016
    Half of Scotland's farmed Salmon come from Shetland .The wild sea trout and salmon are near extinct in Shetland now.
  42. John R Newall 20 Feb 2016
    Since 1956 to date I have fished various west coast rivers from Campbeltown to Tongue primarily for sea trout with occasional salmon caught. In the early years of my endeavors I could more or less guarantee catching a sea trout every time. The collapse of the sea trout population in our rivers coincided with the advent of these fish farms and scientific evidence supports this. If this unbridled expansion is allowed to continue in a few years there will be no sea trout on the west coast. Surely our natural resources are more important than the profits of a Norwegian company.
  43. Dave Redwood 20 Feb 2016
    Immediate action, if not already too late, must be taken. The current situation is a Scottish disgrace.
  44. Ian Eckersley 20 Feb 2016
    The west coast fisheries of Scotland were beautiful freshwater and marine environments supporting large runs of Salmon and seatrout providing some of the best fishing in the world. It supported many jobs in hotels shops, gillies and the supporting infrastructure. For any government to allow the destruction of these pristine environments is unacceptable and an urgent change of policy is required to control salmon farming to ensure the marine environments and the fish and crustaceans they support receive the protection they deserve. Hopefully if fish stocks return then jobs will also be created therefore helping the local economies and communities.
  45. David Abel Smith 21 Feb 2016
    The excreta from farmed salmon must have a serious adverse impact on wild salmon wanting to enter Loch Etiv on their way to the the River Awe
  46. ANDREW HIND 21 Feb 2016
    WE NEED TO ACT NOW BEFORE IT TOO LATE
  47. Jetro Lappalainen 21 Feb 2016
    "the greatness and moral progress of a nation can be judged by the way its animals are treated"
  48. Adrian Price 22 Feb 2016
    'Re-wilding' is a hot conservation term. To ignore this aspect about Wild Salmon is to ignore conservation. Sea lice are a menace and poorly run fish farms are an environmental disaster.
  49. Brian Stewart 22 Feb 2016
    Can we possibly beat vested interest?
  50. John Allen 22 Feb 2016
    Something that should also be addressed via the EEC providing we remain members