Petition · PE01598 · Session 4
Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms
Signatures
1
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.
What the petitioner did first
Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
16 Jun 20162 mentions
-
30 Jun 20161 mention
-
29 Sep 20161 mention
-
26 Oct 20161 mention
-
14 Dec 20161 mention
-
21 Jun 20171 mention
-
12 Dec 20181 mention
Signatures by country
4,382 online signaturesComments
431 comments, oldest first431 comments · showing 51–100
-
Peter Lyons 19 Jan 2016About time!! Just need to deal with the seals, mergies, goosanders and bumbling scientists and we might be getting somewhere at last.
-
Stuart Graham 19 Jan 2016Signed
-
John lynch 19 Jan 2016Instead of the exec handing subsidies to the ff industry why not invest in land based farming. This type of farming is no different fron agricultural farming. If farmers pollute then the get fined or jailed. If they use illegal pesticides ditto. Just because ff is out of sight DOES NOT absolve there environmental and legal responsibilities. The industry needs to become a good neighbor and co habit with the angling industry which is in its self a cornerstone to local economies.
-
Christine Strain, Scotland 19 Jan 2016Great idea.
-
John Smith 19 Jan 2016Hows about I stick 10 blood sucking leaches on you and see if you survive a year
-
Paul Rouse 19 Jan 2016The scientific evidence over a considerable period demonstrates the farms have a huge detrimental impact on migratory fish and the ecosystem. It is critical that serious, meaningful measures are taken directly. Fish farms must not be allowed to continue in such an un regulated 'wild west' fashion.... killing off the wild Western Scottish salmon and sea trout populations.
-
Kenneth Hanks 19 Jan 2016Will anything ever be done that is not just for the benefit of the salmon farming industry
-
Paul Jones 19 Jan 2016Responsible use of precious environmental resources must become a requirement of this
industry. It has shown it will not do that voluntarily and to make politicians act to compel action, when they have for so long ignored our lobbying, will be hard. But if not now, when? Good luck. -
george renwick 19 Jan 2016Everyone knows about the sealice problem affecting our wild salmon .
But the government try to keep it covered up !!!!!!! -
Charles Harman 19 Jan 2016I have seen the decline of salmon and sea trout stocks in rivers I once fished on the West coast of Scotland, in Ireland and also in Norway. The common factor in every instance is the location of salmon farms close to the river mouths. In all these cases, the reduction or loss of the recreational fishery will inevitably have led to the loss of local jobs and income. And In spite of efforts by the salmon farming lobby to deny it, the overwhelming weight of scientific evidence points to a causal link between fish farms and the decline in wild fish numbers. I travel to Scotland at least twice a year, spending money not only on the fishing itself, but also on local accommodation, food and drink etc. At present I only fish rivers on the East coast of Scotland. I would love to return to the West coast, but it is very unlikely that I will do so while stocks of migratory fish are in their current state. It is long past time for salmon farms to be relocated away from the mouths of rivers that support runs of migratory fish
- and preferably to an onshore, closed containment system. -
alex richmond 19 Jan 2016Let"s hope this gets some attention from SG when they finally admit catch and release is not the answer
-
William Logan 19 Jan 2016Finally, S&TCS believes the evidence supports the need for a renewed focus on moving to full closed containment of farmed salmon production in Scotland, with complete 'biological separation' of wild and farmed fish. I totally agree but will Scottish government have the courage to make it happen?
-
greg price 19 Jan 2016Its an outrage this has gone on so long, someone is reaping rewards , sadly its not our natural river stock!
-
Ed Dixon 19 Jan 2016Once the Kings and Queens of the River have been sacrificed in the name of commerce, they can never be replaced.
-
Gary Eccles 19 Jan 2016Good luck
-
Henry Giles 19 Jan 2016Fact: sea lice kill wild fish, especially clouds of lice that attach to young sea trout migrating in coastal waters, also smolts out to sea. Help to stop the rot.
-
Charles Jeffrey 19 Jan 2016If there was such a thing as Health and Safety for salmon these fish farms would have been closed down ages ago. CLEAN UP YOUR ACT or CLOSE DOWN !!
-
MARK EYRE 19 Jan 2016Wild fish have their place and so too do farmed, but not the same place.
-
Jamie Hyslop 19 Jan 2016Salmon farms should be land-based
- no excuse for open cage farming
- the technology exists -
Barrie Matterson 19 Jan 2016This issue needs to be dealt with urgently to save wild species and protect the Scottish tourism industry.
-
Henry Thompson 19 Jan 2016Please put an end to this environmentally damaging dirty business
-
Martin Webster 19 Jan 2016Why is business allowed to make money by causing serious damage to one of Scotland's most precious natural assets? Move to 100% onshore closed containment within 5 years.
-
Alan McRobb 19 Jan 2016Time this government woke up, smelt the coffee and admitted that they have turned a blind eye to the abuses of the aquaculture industry for too long.
-
Steven Cooper 19 Jan 2016Stocks have been depleted by these farms with excessive lice and also escapees diluting the wild genes of the native salmon
-
Peter Lyons 19 Jan 2016About time too. Now just the seals, mergies, goosanders and bumbling scientists to deal with similarly. Some hope.
-
James walsh 19 Jan 2016Fish farms wiping out wild salmon stocks
-
Neil Upton 19 Jan 2016The sea lice problem of Salmon Farms is a blight on the character of all who refuse to believe it has had no effect on the wild stocks of salmon and Seatrout.its time to act and act decisively.
-
Graham Strachan 19 Jan 2016We have watched the desecration of our wild salmon stocks for long enough!
-
Rachel Carmichael 19 Jan 2016Something needs done now to protect the future of wild salmon before its too late...something should have been done sadly long before now but pound signs are more important it seems.
-
James Wilcox 19 Jan 2016The insanity of marine-based salmon feedlots must end
-
Russell Boyd 19 Jan 2016I fully support this petition and urge the Scottish Government to make changes to this industry which has decimated our wild Salmon and Sea Trout populations.
-
Steve Brown 19 Jan 2016It's time the Scottish Government looked at the bigger picture and stopped focusing on short term financial gain, the west coast rivers in particular have been devastated by the effects of open cage salmon farming!
-
Gareth Bourhill 19 Jan 2016This has went on too long and impact on wild migrating smolts has been known and ignored by governments because they wil not stop further farms and blame kin river explotation.just look at marine Scotland's proposed categories of salmon rivers and you have a simple answer all West Coast rivers are Cat 3 and this is where Al the farms are compared to Cat 1 rivers on the East coast where there are no farms
-
Mr Lawrence Crompton-Howe 19 Jan 2016It is a international disgrace that Scotland promotes a national product that so dangerously harms its own natural resources.
Now is the time to end the carnage that is caused by the Farmed Salmon industry and this must be done quickly to rebuild the integrity of Scotland and the Scottish Government. -
Cameron Chapman 19 Jan 2016Precedents are set in Canada where corrupt practice led to ecological disaster.
The Government in Canada was forced to admit that the scientists who expressed their concerns about Government practice, were correct.
I hope the levels of subterfuge and corruption in Scotland will not prevent us from saving this Iconic World Treasure, the Atlantic Salmon. -
Paul Mcgeoch 19 Jan 2016Thanks it done hopefully something will get done now
-
Paul Mcgeoch 19 Jan 2016Thanks it done hopefully something will get done now
-
Matthew Cashin 19 Jan 2016Our legislators have a duty and responsibilty to protect our natural heritage for our children.
-
Ray o connor 19 Jan 2016Governments go on about how rod and line fishermen must put fish back and not harm fish stocks then sit back and watch big corporations go on a mass killing sprea in the name of profit
-
Mark Colman 19 Jan 2016Long overdue, and the denial of it has been criminal and hypocritical by this Government.
-
Donald Rice 19 Jan 2016We laws to force the aquaculture industry to publish farm-specific lice data. Until then, we have no chance of improving the current disastrous situation.
-
Brian Wright 19 Jan 2016Please stop poisoning our marine environment and endangering our wild natural fish.
-
Mick Bell 19 Jan 2016I very much doubt whether Scottish politicians care at all.....
-
Simon Ftton 19 Jan 2016The Scottish government should be ashamed by its lack of action to protect a vital natural resource that is probably worth more to its economy than Norwegian owned battery farms.
-
John bell 20 Jan 2016We should as much as we can to help one of the best fish in the world, every little bit helps
-
John lawson 20 Jan 2016A national disgrace that we allow these Norwegian fish farms to pollute our oceans and kill our young wild salmon. Why are the people charged with protecting our seas and rivers not acting ..The science is already available showing these farms are killing our wild fish...
-
Ed Maudling 20 Jan 2016Would you allow a floating intensive pig farm in your sea lochs? Time to move to close containment on land
-
John Binns 20 Jan 2016Why won't you listen to the obvious. John Binns
-
Andrew William donald 20 Jan 2016Time to protect our wild stocks.
-
Allan W. Berry. 20 Jan 2016My own Petition PE96 failed to lead to a credible scientific inquiry, highlighting the fact that political control of marine environmental science in Scotland ensures Scotlands largest marine polluter is under protection by government.