Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01598 · Session 4

Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms

Closed Submitted 13 Jan 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
4,382 online signatures with a country
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.

What the petitioner did first

Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Jun 2016
    2 mentions
  2. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention
  3. 29 Sep 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 26 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  5. 14 Dec 2016
    1 mention
  6. 21 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  7. 12 Dec 2018
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,382 online signatures
  1. England1,819 41.5%
  2. Scotland1,202 27.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 20.7%
  4. Wales172 3.9%
  5. Northern Ireland58 1.3%
  6. Ireland48 1.1%
  7. United States22 0.5%
  8. Netherlands15 0.3%
  9. Canada14 0.3%
  10. France13 0.3%
  11. 41 other countries111 2.5%

Comments

431 comments, oldest first
431 comments · showing 101–150
  1. ritchie campbell 20 Jan 2016
    Stop blaming anglers for the demise of salmon stocks
  2. Brian Lovering 20 Jan 2016
    It is appalling that the damage resulting from uncontrolled sea lice populations in salmon farms has been allowed to continue. If this problem was occurring in respect of any land based agricultural activity there would be 'uproar'. Unfortunately, because the major consequences are arising at sea and are not immediately obvious, those in position to address the issue seem to have adopted an 'out of sight,out of mind' attitude'which is TOTALLY UNACCEPTABLE. In future years, the problems arising from improper controls on aquaculture (both the sea lice problem and other issues) will come to be seen in the same light as the problems that arose from the improper controls on the use of DDT and other pesticides in land based agriculture in the 60's and 70's! Please demonstrate some responsibility and act now.
  3. Bob Burbidge 20 Jan 2016
    The Scottish Government should show true leadership and pragmatism and force the filthy fish farming industry into closed containment farms and save our dying Scottish and Welsh salmon and sea trout from extinction in our lifetime.
  4. Kenneth Reid 20 Jan 2016
    There is a place for aquaculture but not at the expense of the wild environment and the impacts it delivers. get them onshore in closed containment and really create more jobs by revitalising the west coast of the country where stocks have collapsed over the last 20 years. revitalise communities and improve quality of aquaculture products.
  5. Peter Willoughby 20 Jan 2016
    Appalling that this is taking so long to resolve when the evidence is so clear
  6. Bill Jones 20 Jan 2016
    About time something was done. I have seen natural salmon stocks decline over the last 3 decades, and I am convinced this is mainly due to sea lice infestation of smolts going to sea.
  7. Barry Jameson 20 Jan 2016
    It should be absolutely clear to the Scottish parliament that much tighter regulatory measures are needed. That does not me that the Scottish fish farming industry would be put in danger. However with the general decline in runs of wild salmon and sea trout over many years this dangerous and unnecessary additional hazard , if allowed to continue , could create an effect that would be impossible to reverse. That would be tragic and is completely avoidable. Please act NOW.
  8. David Mahony 20 Jan 2016
    The only answer to combating the SNP aversion to taking action to stop company practices that should not be permitted and would not be allowed in the foreign companies home waters is to do research proving that the revenue and employment generated by preserving wild fish coupled with a rearing industry using the highest standards would exceed the present revenues and jobs. Appeals to respect the environment and other non monetary aspects are likely to continue to be a waste of time-fund research as did the Tweed Commissioners ,Orkneys and no doubt others
  9. Robert Brewer 20 Jan 2016
    To allow the current situation to continue is criminal and is a massive shortfall of the powers that be.
  10. Paul Haworth 20 Jan 2016
    With out imeadiate action fish stocks will be near wiped out and take decades to regain numbers ! Take action now !
  11. Carl Stones 20 Jan 2016
    For it to survive it must be controlled
  12. Allan Sefton 20 Jan 2016
    Sea lice pollution means the west of Scotland marine environment is the most polluted in Western Europe. Publicity about this could greatly harm the tourist industry just as it has hugely impacted on recreational angling visitors.
  13. Jim Day 20 Jan 2016
    When is Dr Aileen Macleod Going to start been our environment Minister, and Look after our environment.
  14. Caspian Fawcus 20 Jan 2016
    The wanton neglect and destruction of our wild salmonids is criminal, short sighted and nothing short of a disgrace. It is high time the future of all our wild fish was put before short term monetary gain. Aquaculture and wild fish can both be accommodated with a little foresight and governance, please act before it is too late.
  15. Dr John Smithson 20 Jan 2016
    It is essential that the Scottish Government deals with the issue of environmental destruction by salmon farms. Sea lice levels are out of control and statutory regulations are being ignored. The West Coast economy is already suffering grievously.
  16. William Howell 20 Jan 2016
    Being a born and bred scot I am appalled the government can see no further than aquaculture and will not be satisfied until aquaculture wipes out the natural species of sea trout & salmon. Angling has and always would bring more jobs and money to Scotland than aquaculture ever will. Not surprised when we are governed by two near extinct species Salmon & Sturgeon. Time we had some real people who listen.
  17. Pat Kennedy 20 Jan 2016
    Salmon farm is a dirty industry and is no good for the wild salmon it has to stop
  18. ian Thorpe 20 Jan 2016
    Should land based salmon farms be encouraged, maybe by the Scottish Government offering subsidies or other incentives to Companies moving the farms from sea lochs to the land?
    Land based salmon farms are more environmentally friendly as sea water pumped in can be cleansed of impurities including sea lice before it is returned to the sea.
  19. John Hamilton 20 Jan 2016
    Closed Containment would be the best answer, possibly converted redundant oil tankers?
  20. John AC Martin 20 Jan 2016
    One just needs to look at the statistics on healthy salmon stocks. There is a strong correlation between rivers in the West of Scotland with decimated salmon stocks and the location of high density salmon farming. Repsect our marine environment for our children's sake and avoid a dead sea.
  21. Martin Molyneux 20 Jan 2016
    We will not be coming up to Scotland spending our hard earned money again until something is done.
  22. Mike Milligan 20 Jan 2016
    We must take action now before it is too late
  23. OLIVIER DEVICTOR 20 Jan 2016
    Planet Earth is a combination of natural ecosystems and man continues to destroy them .
    It is time that for the future of our children that we start to repair our wrongdoings. Salmon farming as it is practised today is very wrong.
  24. Jeremy G H Mackrell 20 Jan 2016
    I have stopped traveling to fish for salmon in the Scottish rivers due to the serious reduction in numbers of fish.
  25. Matthew Calvert 20 Jan 2016
    The SNP government seem to be in denial about the adverse consequences of fish farming due to lice. I hope the petition stimulates some useful action from them.
  26. bob Heddle 20 Jan 2016
    even the sea trout in orkney are sometimes covered in lice,so presumably some die when young
    The number of salmon farms and the associated disease and filth always seem to increase
    Im surprised that M&S Waitrose etc don't say something about this
  27. Derrick Cooper 20 Jan 2016
    If we don't do something who will, time to act befort it's too late.
  28. Anthony Swannell 20 Jan 2016
    I have been very disappointed with no fish over the last few years fishing on the South Esk. Presume this is due to the factors you mention and not my ineptitude.
  29. jeremy hemming 20 Jan 2016
    I am amazed this action hasn't been pursued earlier
  30. Mike Dickson 20 Jan 2016
    It is beyond belief that this state of affairs can be of any political advantage. This must be dealt with before we lose one of our most primeval species, along with countless others before. Man has a dreadful record of selfishness!
  31. Allan Cuthbert 20 Jan 2016
    Inland factory farming, as being used in Canada by native Canadians is less damaging to the environment and equally profitable. Farming in teh sea is now unnecessary and damaging to teh environment
  32. Peter Morris 20 Jan 2016
    Vital that action is taken now otherwise already low stocks will be wiped out with no return. Enforce the regulations. If not what is the point in having them!
  33. Graham Feilden 20 Jan 2016
    I will not fish in Scotland until there are proper controls on salmon farms
  34. Thomas Lowes 20 Jan 2016
    An eco system that took millennia to develop can be destroyed in only a few months, please support this petition.
  35. Ian Winstone 20 Jan 2016
    Long overdue.
  36. Harold David Hill 20 Jan 2016
    Terrible infestations in Loch Torridon
  37. Michael Black 20 Jan 2016
    We must act before it is too late.
  38. Roger Bisby 20 Jan 2016
    I have seen the sea lice problem in Sutherland first hand. It really needs to be sorted.
  39. Tony Ingle-Finch 20 Jan 2016
    I recognise that the salmon farming industry as and must continue to be s vital part of the Highlaands & Islands economy. However, the industry must be sustainable and regulated accordingly.
  40. John Stephen Faith 20 Jan 2016
    Please support this vital initiative for the preservation of the wild stock of Salmon, being such an important element of the Scottish highlands economy
  41. Gordon Cosh 20 Jan 2016
    Action is required urgently to conserve wild salmon stocks in Scottish waters.
  42. Peter Lennie 20 Jan 2016
    "the wildlife of to-day is not ours, we have it in trust for those who follow us " from King George VI
  43. Mike Grace 20 Jan 2016
    Like Whisky, Wild Salmon and Trout are the very essence of Scotland
    - No Salmon, No Scotland!
  44. Guy Adams 20 Jan 2016
    As someone who spends a great deal of time (and money) travelling to Scotland to fish, and whose visits help keep Scottish people in jobs, I sincerely hope the Scottish Parliament acts before it's too late...
  45. Patrick Gibson 20 Jan 2016
    Show some courage by doing what you know is necessary to protect wild salmonids
  46. Rob Pitcher 20 Jan 2016
    It is vital that necessary controls are put in place to reverse the damage being caused by large scale salmon farming to our wild stocks.
  47. Cai Williams 20 Jan 2016
    This is yet another example of Man's appalling selfishness.
  48. John Lynch 20 Jan 2016
    One of the most amazing spectacles us humans can observe is the migration of Sewin and Salmon,I feel so sorry for those that have not observed this miracle! Anything that endangers it even alters and disturbs those wonderful fish,has to be a crime against humanity if it denied our children from the pleasure of such an amazing event!
  49. Rodney Timson 20 Jan 2016
    Save our wild salmon before it's too late.
  50. Peter Keyser 20 Jan 2016
    Agree with Allan Cuthbert
    - the way to go must be land based fish farming. It is more expensive and needs a sponsor (the Government?) but what price the environment?