Petition · PE01598 · Session 4
Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms
Signatures
1
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.
What the petitioner did first
Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
16 Jun 20162 mentions
-
30 Jun 20161 mention
-
29 Sep 20161 mention
-
26 Oct 20161 mention
-
14 Dec 20161 mention
-
21 Jun 20171 mention
-
12 Dec 20181 mention
Signatures by country
4,382 online signaturesComments
431 comments, oldest first431 comments · showing 401–431
-
David Forrest 22 Feb 2016These fish are ruining the stocks of wild fish when escapees interbreed with wild fish. They are also not good for human health as they are full of chemicals.
-
Lyall Owen 22 Feb 2016Please make every effort to sustain the salmon stocks
-
d.cosh 22 Feb 2016sea lice have destroyed the west coast of scotland rivers already
-
Warren Slaney 22 Feb 2016I worked on a Marine Harvest fish farm and used Nuvan to rid sea lice from sea caged fish. Horrendous stuff but most lice simply dropped off and floated away, to attach to wild fish.
-
john shipley 22 Feb 2016the Scottish parliament has had plenty of opportunities to do something about the salmon farming debacle and done have done about it. They just do not care .It is criminal..
-
John Coutts 22 Feb 2016Serious action needs to be taken now to control this problem before it is too late.
-
Mark Broughton 22 Feb 2016We need to get behind this petition whether we fish or just like our rivers.
-
John Richens 22 Feb 2016How can the Wild Atlantic Salmon, so synonymous with Scotland, be treated with such contempt by the Scottish Government ?
-
HAMISH LINDSAY 22 Feb 2016the test is hopeless virtually unreadable!
-
Mark Whitehead 22 Feb 2016It is disgusting that salmon farming uses the ocean like a rubbish dump and that wild salmon smolts become infested with parasites due to salmon farming in our estuaries. We have to save our wild salmon which are at critically low stocks. Wake up Ministers and bring Marine Harvest etc to heel so they stop pollution and infesting our natural resources for greed and averice
-
D.Jebson 22 Feb 2016The decline of fish in the Ribble Catchment has been going on for years. Despite increased hours of input of fishing I have not had a fish ( Salmon) for three years. On our eight miles of water on the tributary of the Ribble which is the Hodder a single salmon was caught. No further stocking is allowed by the E.A and the future looks bleak compounded by the devastation of the redds by the recent floods. We live in hope that in 2016 will see an improvement. If there is it will not be because of human help.
-
Anthony Stuart 22 Feb 2016We need action now not when it will be to late
-
Mark Chapman 22 Feb 2016This issue is already a major problem in British Columbia. Please don't let it happen in the UK!
-
Stephen Drage 22 Feb 2016The sea lice problem exists everywhere open pen salmon farms are. It is a problem worldwide. Salmon farms need to be taken out of the ocean and placed in land based, closed containment facilities.
-
Andrew. Williams 22 Feb 2016Have fished various rivers in Scotland for last 29yrs. The rivers have progressively got less migratory fish, noticeably since the appearence of salmon farming.
-
John R Cheetham 23 Feb 2016It's disheartening to see nature being treated like this
Our planet is precious, it's about time we started showing it more respect than we do! -
Nick Gough 23 Feb 2016I visit the west coast of Scotland near Oban every year, and have been doing since 1963. As a teenager I would catch plenty of fin nock and the odd sea trout. Once salmon farms were installed in the local sea loughs, sea trout have all but disappeared. I have not caught one for several years. We must do something to protect these 'nomads of the tides'
-
DON REID 23 Feb 2016Big business rules,not o.k.
-
Bruce Stanley 23 Feb 2016I think that more must be done to prevent ALL types of pollution. Salmon runs are decreasing, beaches are health risks, whales are dying, etc.. Enough is enough!
-
D. Theaker 23 Feb 2016very good program on Alba blaming the sea lice for killing salmon and sea trout on the west coast rivers.
-
charles cooper 23 Feb 20164 salmon fishing holidays booked in Scotland this year. Assume helps local indiginous communities employed rather than aquaculturists from New Zealand and itinerant Polish workers. All paid for by Norwegian cash as they're banned from polluting their own coastline.
-
Peter Mosley 23 Feb 2016Wonder if an organised boycott of farmed salmon would be effective?
-
Alastair Stobart 23 Feb 2016High time the S NP did something constructive
Rather than blaming others -
Bryan Hollinworth 23 Feb 2016There is no doubt that there has been an exponential decline, in West Coast Sea Trout catches since the introduction of Salmon Farming.
We must 'all' endeavour to protect this wonderful species. -
Andrew Kelton 23 Feb 2016The public management of the Scottish salmon farming industry has been, and continues to be, worthy of what used to be called a 'third world country'. The Scottish industry began as a free-for-all and giveaway of Crown Estate seabed. It expanded without any controls for sensitivity of location or size limits on individual facilities. It has been allowed to rubbish, without actual argument, 30 years of scientific evidence demonstrating the causal link between farm sea lice infestations and the wild salmonid demise all along the west coast. And it has been protected throughout from public scrutiny under the guise of commercial confidentiality. Surely there was (and is) a better way.
-
Euan Myles 23 Feb 2016Aquaculture does not make any sense .
Taking wild fish from the other side of the world to be dumped in to a Sea Loch in Scotland to feed and produce Sub Standard fatty Salmon and befoul the local environment and kill Sea Trout with Lice Infestation so bad wild fish stand no chance
Loch Damph and Maree are now nearly devoid of Seatrout they were plentiful until the Farms they were the Best Sea Trout fishers in Europe but sold down the river for a quick buck .
If this evidence was listened to years ago we could of saved the west coast from these ravages -
Iain Freeman 24 Feb 2016Salmon cannot be claimed to be responisibly farmed unless effective legislation is put in place to drastically reduce the sea lice problem.
-
John Wark 25 Feb 2016I agree with what has been said in Fly Fishing and Fly Tying magazine. Something needs to be done about this issue.
-
Derek Rutter 25 Feb 2016As per Andrew Flitcroft's, Editors Letter in the March 2016 issue of the Trout & Salmon. Dr Aileen McLeod may bring about some sanity to the Scottish Governments lack of understanding of the plight which the wild salmon face, Day In & Day Out,when endeavoring to enter Scottish Rivers. Let us all hope that at last there is a Scottish Minister for the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform who has a grasp of the situation and is prepared to act on it.
-
Geoff Maynard 25 Feb 2016Okay, we need farmed fish. But put them in closed systems where they can be controlled and problems contained.
-
Gareth jones 25 Feb 2016The damage is done , legislation is only effective if effectivlely monitored ie one fish farm recorded 1 escapee, he saw it with his own eye.
Fished Scotland for 40 years killed3 fish and I am the bad one??????