Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01598 · Session 4

Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms

Closed Submitted 13 Jan 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
4,382 online signatures with a country
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.

What the petitioner did first

Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Jun 2016
    2 mentions
  2. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention
  3. 29 Sep 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 26 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  5. 14 Dec 2016
    1 mention
  6. 21 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  7. 12 Dec 2018
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,382 online signatures
  1. England1,819 41.5%
  2. Scotland1,202 27.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 20.7%
  4. Wales172 3.9%
  5. Northern Ireland58 1.3%
  6. Ireland48 1.1%
  7. United States22 0.5%
  8. Netherlands15 0.3%
  9. Canada14 0.3%
  10. France13 0.3%
  11. 41 other countries111 2.5%

Comments

431 comments, oldest first
431 comments · showing 301–350
  1. Moira Campbell 26 Jan 2016
    This petition has to be taken seriously to protect wild salmon!
  2. Dick Francis 27 Jan 2016
    When will the Scottish Government wake up and do something positive and fast to hopefully save the wild salmon runs into Scottish rivers? A first step and a positive one would be to ensure that the salmon farms have a very strict and tightly monitored control of sea lice numbers around the farms.
  3. Godfrey Holden 27 Jan 2016
    The value of Wild Salmon and Sea Trout to the Scottish economy in terms of income and jobs far, far outweighs that of the fish farming industry. Wise up politicians please!
  4. Graham Hart 27 Jan 2016
    It's all politics and nothing to do with the environment. These people are not interested in the environment only business. Things will only change when it's too late. That's when there are no salmon in the rivers and thousands out of work in rural areas. Maybe in years to come there might be a stocking policy in place. I'm not holding my breath.
  5. Richard John de Ville 27 Jan 2016
    Action is essential to ensure the future of wild Salmonids.
  6. Hazel Hoggan 27 Jan 2016
    Salmon need to be free from beasties. Scotland need beastie free fish. So do I
  7. Simon Collier 27 Jan 2016
    Giving the difficulty that wild salmon are facing from fish eating birds in the rivers, polution and overfishing via drift netting and other intensive fishing practices then additional stress on the population from lice by badly managed fish farms and poor legislation is disappointing and should be addressed!
  8. Andrew John Sinclair 28 Jan 2016
    We must preserve the good things that Scotland has to offer and not pollute it's Lochs with chemicals.
  9. Shane Maloney 28 Jan 2016
    Your fight is our fight.....everyone needs to shout in support of our ancient pescapalian buddies against the invading Scandic Frankenfish !
  10. Richard Shelton 28 Jan 2016
    Sea lice from the intensive cage culture of salmon have crippled the wild sea trout and salmon populations of West Highland Scotland. Furthermore, the use of dangerous chemicals in the bath treatment of lice on the farmed fish seriously threaten the larval and even adult survival of lobsters, prawns and crabs. Firm remedial action is long overdue.
  11. abigail s mainland 28 Jan 2016
    Norwegian fish farmed salmon is sold as "wild Scottish" fish. Given the level of disease, anti-biotics to counteract this, and general pollution in the sea loch farms, I personally avoid eating this at all costs. The whole industry needs to be cleaned up and stronger legislation introduced to protect our food chain and truly wild fish ..
  12. John wallace 28 Jan 2016
    Migrating salmon from irish rivers use the same water channels and so the problem is not just confined to the Scottish salmon. It's time for the governments to think further than the ' fast buck'.!!
  13. Johanna Mackenzie 28 Jan 2016
    Will the common man I ever taste wild salmon again? Salmon farming methods polute our waters and produce toxic fish.
  14. Julian Charrington 28 Jan 2016
    There is a parallel with anti-biotic and chemical "over use" on salmon and on us humans. The fish managers and our doctors have got to reign back or together we are doomed.
  15. J.P. Foley 28 Jan 2016
    I fully support ALL Efforts to Save and Stabilise ALL Wild Salmon Stocks in British & Irish Waters.
  16. Emma McDowall 28 Jan 2016
    There are less and less salmon and sea trout running up river each year and I feel that the lice in the open sea cages has a lot to do with the falling numbers .
  17. Alexander Malone 28 Jan 2016
    Salmon deserve our help. The angler on the river gets persecuted, yet the problem lies elsewhere. More needs to be done to protect the future of that amazing fish.
  18. John F. Robins 29 Jan 2016
    Successive Scottish Governments have acted as international fishmongers flogging factory farmed salmon on behalf of the mainly Norwegian farm owners. They have refused to control the filthy plague of pollution and parasites these farms create and they have sold our natural heritage, including much of our marine environment and the creatures which inhabit that environment, for a few rural jobs which will soon disappear as overproduction of factory salmon (fed on scarce wild fish stocks) has caused the price to collapse. If only politicians could see further than the next election.
  19. Marlyn Hales 29 Jan 2016
    I know there are very few wild salmon in Scotland from personal experience and fully back this petition as I believe the premise to be well founded. As an addendum, I believe the reason Norway didn't join the EEC, was to protect its fisheries.........
  20. Alastair Hume MBE 30 Jan 2016
    We must do all we can to protect our wild salmon stocks.
  21. Ian Hay 30 Jan 2016
    It is essential that wild salmon stocks are protected, to ensure that this species does not become extinct.
  22. Edward Catton-Orr 30 Jan 2016
    Copied from a fellow protester these words sum up my feelings exactly! Successive Scottish Governments have acted as international fishmongers flogging factory farmed salmon on behalf of the mainly Norwegian farm owners. They have refused to control the filthy plague of pollution and parasites these farms create and they have sold our natural heritage, including much of our marine environment and the creatures which inhabit that environment, for a few rural jobs which will soon disappear as overproduction of factory salmon (fed on scarce wild fish stocks) has caused the price to collapse. If only politicians could see further than the next election.
  23. alan mooney 30 Jan 2016
    I would echo mr roberts comments!
  24. arto meririnne 31 Jan 2016
    There is few left,should we try harder to save them
  25. Andrew Croft 31 Jan 2016
    People need to be made aware of the damage that salmon farming causes to wild salmon populations. Not only from sea lice infestations but also escapee farmed salmon breeding with wild salmon. Which is diluting the genetic integrity of wild salmon. A farmed salmon is nothing more than a mutant.
  26. Andrew L Gilchrist 31 Jan 2016
    What reason do fish farms give against closed confinement? There is good evidence it works in Canada successfully.
  27. Matthew bird 31 Jan 2016
    Again due to mans greed to profit from playing god with the life of salmon we have now created a bigger problem which is threatening the wild fish stocks with unacceptable levels of parasites which great our wild fish upon their return into the estuaries they were spawned in
    Do we really need to support supermarket salmon which is full of fat and damages our wild stocks from which carries a greater financial loss to the local economy than salmon farmers understand ......
  28. Prof Andrew Shorthouse 31 Jan 2016
    The Scottish Government seems indifferent to a declining wild salmon stock, and the deleterious effect on recreational fly fishing and the local employment (ghillies, shops, hotels, B&Bs, self catering etc which it supports. Much of this is in more remote areas desperately in need of income. Fishing in Scotland is deteriorating to such an extent that fishermen are voting with their feet and getting a better deal abroad
  29. James Leach 1 Feb 2016
    Having seen the damage done to Pacific salmon due to intensive Atlantic salmon farming on Vancouver Island, I strongly support restrictive measures on this industry.
  30. Glyn Williams 1 Feb 2016
    Please do not allow Salmon fishing to disappear before our very eyes. Scotland and Salmon fishing go together for at least they did. Think of all the businesses that depend on it. It beggars belief that the Scottish government might just allow this to slip away.
  31. jonny Shaw 1 Feb 2016
    On "my" river government have to re-visit 1950s water abstraction plant & see how it could be re-worked to allow early run fish to re-use the redds then completely cut-off
  32. Eddie welsh 1 Feb 2016
    Something needs to done now before its to late
  33. Tom Milne 1 Feb 2016
    I only hope our elected politicians take note of this serious subject and if they don't do nothing thats with their respective powers then they let themselves and our country down.
  34. Darryl campbell 1 Feb 2016
    This industry needs to take resposibilty for its actions and be hels accountable they cant keep turning a blind eye and damage the wild stocks over revenue similar things happen with our rivers all to often polluters get a slap on the wrist after causing millions of pounds worth of damage something needs done or there wont be any wild salmon left
  35. gereint mortimer 1 Feb 2016
    This needs to be addressed before its too late
  36. Nick Hart 1 Feb 2016
    Why are our fisheries so poorly protected? It is about time governments across Europe, especially those so close to home, placed common sense before greed. When it comes to wild Salmon & Sea Trout stocks I am afraid there is no buy now pay later!
  37. Alasdair Smith 1 Feb 2016
    It's been shown in loch Roag that after it had an organised sea-lice control in place that sea trout numbers increased considerably.
  38. James Mair 1 Feb 2016
    Time this issue was addressed in a serious manner, you only need to look at Norway and Canada to see the serrious implications of doing nothing
  39. Jeff Mckeen 1 Feb 2016
    if only MSPs of the Scottish Parliament could for once realise how much damage has been done to west coast salmon and sea trout stocks by Norwegian owned fish farms.
  40. Connie Robertson 2 Feb 2016
    Scotland should be protecting this very special visiting resource. To allow easy pickings for large commercial companies to net salmon at mouths of rivers and stop single fishermen fishing is a bit of a nonsense.
  41. Lawson Devery 2 Feb 2016
    A Wild Fishery Review with salmon farming deliberately omitted from the agenda clearly showed the Scottish Governments position. Please, please, please stop buying farmed salmon in support of this excellent petition.
  42. Alexander Reid 3 Feb 2016
    wiith the presence of sea lice and all those seals at Newburgh estuary we'll have no wild salmon left.
  43. Martin Tolhurst 3 Feb 2016
    Fish farming is not going to go away so it makes sense for the industry and conservationists to seek ways to work together. The measures being sought under this petition are in the spirit of cooperation and the fish farming interests are best served by mindfulness towards the wild fishery interests and not just to commercial imperatives.
  44. James percy 5 Feb 2016
    Well done for this petition
  45. Martin Johnson 5 Feb 2016
    It's high time 'best practice' salmon farming methods were used, i.e. totally enclosed cage systems, enclosed lagoon or lakes (e.g.as in Canada) or further offshore for dilution of impact.
  46. richard bibby 5 Feb 2016
    pollution parasites &toxic chemicals including in the fishes flesh are the problems.
  47. Carol Pilsworth 6 Feb 2016
    Please listen to your electorate. We want to protect our wild salmon and our Scottish Lochs from being polluted.
  48. Thomas McGregor 6 Feb 2016
    Leave improving rivers such as the Clyde alone and in the safe hands of those who have looked after them for more than a hundred years. The biggest threats come from the sea where the wild stocks are plundered by commercial fishing and smolts killed by sea lice that prosper around fish farms.
  49. Ray Hudson 6 Feb 2016
    Time is running out fast to save our Salmon
    - so please get on with it
  50. John Moses 6 Feb 2016
    The clock is ticking for the survival of wild salmon on the west coast. We need action NOW.