Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01598 · Session 4

Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms

Closed Submitted 13 Jan 2016 Rural Affairs
Signatures
1
4,382 online signatures with a country
Comments
431
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance.

What the petitioner did first

Since the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013, during which we gave both written and oral evidence to the Rural Affairs Climate Change and Environment Committee, Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland (S&TCS) has corresponded with Scottish Ministers and Marine Scotland, but has become increasingly disappointed at the 'business as usual' response to the need for a more robust approach to ensure the protection of wild salmonids from harm caused by the fish-farming industry.
We have communicated with and met with Marine Scotland on a number of occasions to exchange views, but without noting any significant progress or change in the regulation of the salmon farming industry by Scottish Government.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 16 Jun 2016
    2 mentions
  2. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention
  3. 29 Sep 2016
    Public Petitions Committee
    Continued Petitions
    1 mention
  4. 26 Oct 2016
    1 mention
  5. 14 Dec 2016
    1 mention
  6. 21 Jun 2017
    1 mention
  7. 12 Dec 2018
    1 mention

Signatures by country

4,382 online signatures
  1. England1,819 41.5%
  2. Scotland1,202 27.4%
  3. United Kingdom908 20.7%
  4. Wales172 3.9%
  5. Northern Ireland58 1.3%
  6. Ireland48 1.1%
  7. United States22 0.5%
  8. Netherlands15 0.3%
  9. Canada14 0.3%
  10. France13 0.3%
  11. 41 other countries111 2.5%

Comments

431 comments, oldest first
431 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Richard Banbury 21 Jan 2016
    The lack of action by the Scottish Parliament to protect these native species from this threat is a national disgrace. The technology exists to farm these fish in closed systems. These sea loch farms are also potential "reservoirs" for disease and escaped fish are genetically damaging if they interbreed with the native fish. The price of farmed salmon sold in supermarkets does not reflect the true cost when the environment is taken into account. It is not sustainable. Also damaging is the source of the fishmeal used to feed them. Wild Salmon convert more efficiently.
  2. Lewis Shand 21 Jan 2016
    With the proposed catch and release situation about to be implemented in a major part of the Scottish landmass, it is critical that the approach to salmon conservation includes each and every party involved in the species demise. I have no doubts whatsoever that the salmon farming industry has had a major role in fish decline, and should be willing to comply with measures to reduce sea lice infestation on salmonoids at all stages of their life cycle. The fact that there are regulations and these are not being enforced is just not good enough.
  3. Richard Esp 21 Jan 2016
    Action should be taken now before all Salmon will be wiped out
  4. Anson MacAuslan 21 Jan 2016
    There is plenty talk of the jobs that fish farming supports (and they are important) but no talk of all the jobs that have been lost because there are no wild salmon to catch in the rivers of the West Coast. We need to find a solution that suits both industries.
  5. Calvert McKibbin 21 Jan 2016
    The Scottish Government is presiding over the destruction of much of the west coasts migratory salmonids through their neglect to allow excessive livestock of sea lice and hence equally destructive treatments to take place
  6. Hans-Peter Ickemeyer 21 Jan 2016
    move fishfarming out of the sea to in land facilities
  7. Clive Mitchelhill 21 Jan 2016
    This has gone on for too long now and it is about time something is done about it.
  8. Ian S Rankin 21 Jan 2016
    Perhaps with an election looming anglers could use their vote to encourage action. Scientific studies and reviews appear to have made little impression on the decision makers.
  9. Diana Tym (nee Chapman) 21 Jan 2016
    That this has happened during my lifetime makes me feel extremely sad. My grandchildren will have no reason to go to the beautiful wild places in pursuit of the noble salmon which I have had the pleasure of during my lifetime.
  10. David Blackburn 21 Jan 2016
    AS A REGULAR SALMON FISHERMAN IN THE NORTH OF SCOTLAND AND AWARE OF HOW MUCH BUSINESS IS GENERATED FOR THE LOCAL ECONOMY AS WELL.
  11. Paul Needham 21 Jan 2016
    Sea lice are causing a real problem to the wild salmon stock, it's time to take action before its to late!
  12. john osbaldeston 21 Jan 2016
    Some people won't be happy 'till we've wasted the World !!
  13. Lord Crickhowell 21 Jan 2016
    Former Chairman of National Rivers Authority. Strongly support
  14. David Paterson 21 Jan 2016
    The present Scottish Government have been paid plenty from salmon farms to lobby on their behalf.
    Its time they made amends and started to police the salmon farmers and not the anglers.
    The government must act now and force the salmon farming industry to use enclosed tanks, the cost to be met solely by the salmon farming industry, or the fish farms forceably closed down on conservation grounds
    But the present scottish government dont have the courage.
  15. David Sherriffs 21 Jan 2016
    This problem has gone on for far to long, we all know what sealice have done to salmon & seatrout stocks I hope this petition will confront the SNP with how fish farms are being managed
  16. Donald Allan 21 Jan 2016
    Long over due that the Scottish government stops putting profit and trade alliances before our natural resources. Very similar blinkered approach as the government of British Colombia, Canada. Denial of the scientific facts that fish farming is seriously damaging juvenile smolt runs.
  17. Edward Steele-Wilson 21 Jan 2016
    All sea, loch and estuary based fish farms that have caused the sea lice infestation and contamination to salmonid species should be closed immediately. Only those that will practice closed containment land based fish farms should be licenced to operate.
  18. Malcolm Thorne 21 Jan 2016
    The Scottish politicians are the only ones to blame. They have no concern as they will still have their fat pensions even if wild Salmon disappear from Scottish rivers. The politicians will lose Scotland's Salmon fishing which is a huge part of its tourist industry. So enforce regulations.
  19. Bryan Herbert 21 Jan 2016
    If we walked down the street with a dog with ticks nowhere near the level that are on wild fish around those salmon farm's we would pe prosecuted and banned from owning animals. But because no one in the public sees the extent of the problem no one in power takes any notice
  20. Keith Fishwick 21 Jan 2016
    Do not go on holiday to Scotland,they where also netting salmon in the north Atlantic last spring,what a disgrace.Bow your heads in shame.
  21. Brian Wilson 21 Jan 2016
    If this was the cause of swine flu,bird flu or foot and mouth disease it would be quarantined by the government's vets but nothing ever happens to these farms they harm all the sealife for miles around them
  22. Simon P. Hicks 21 Jan 2016
    This issue has been kicked into the long grass for too long & we need to wake up to the consequences of not addressing the issue before it's too late.
  23. Sarah Dolman 21 Jan 2016
    Please consider other vulnerable marine species too, including marine mammals, in strengthened legislation and controls, such as monitored use of strengthened nets and eliminate use of shooting seals and acoustic deterrent devices that exclude porpoises from important coastal habitats.
  24. ANTHONY MARTIN 21 Jan 2016
    I am pleased to see that the Scottish Government is taking steps to restrict netting along the East Coast estuaries
  25. Robert Whinray Garnett 21 Jan 2016
    It is essential that salmon farming deploys onshore contained tanks as soon as possible to limit the increasing numbers of sealice and the increased use of chemical pesticides to control them.
  26. Richard Stronach 21 Jan 2016
    I am a strong believer that there is no scientific support for the salmon farms and that the only reason that they continue is because they make so much money for the government and the few individuals who own them. they are raping our land and seascape lets let common sense prevail for once and stop salmon farming.
  27. Robert MacDougall-Davis 21 Jan 2016
    Proper regulatory controls need to be in place and the government agency responsible for the inspection and enforcement of the required regulations must be properly resourced to carry objectively and independently regulate all salmon farms in Scotland effectively. It is very short sited not to give wild salmon and sea trout the protection they so badly need.
  28. ANDREW ROSKELL 21 Jan 2016
    Salmon farming is out of control, drastic measures need to be taken to protect wild stocks of salmon, and Seatrout.
  29. David Hewetson-Brown 21 Jan 2016
    Having been salmon fishing for 40 years we have seen the dire effect of salmon cages in estuaries.
  30. jock wood 21 Jan 2016
    you must act now to save whatever fish we have left soon our Ayrshire rivers will be devastated.
  31. John Clark 21 Jan 2016
    Meaningful effective action on sea lice and use of toxic chemicals is long overdue. The industry continually flouts the European Rules relating to environment. More jobs could be created if wild salmon were allowed to flourish.
  32. Mike Christie 21 Jan 2016
    We have to preserve them for our children and grandchildren.
  33. Philip Lewis 21 Jan 2016
    This problem has existed now for years with successive governments simply parroting the fish farming brotherhood with the mealy mouthedsidestep of "no conclusive scientific proof". Please explain the absence of almost all sea trout and pretty few salmon on any of the west coast rivers.
  34. David D Jones 21 Jan 2016
    Please wake up that land of sturgeon and salmon!
  35. david grove 21 Jan 2016
    if a salmon had black and white stripes on its head it would get all the protection required, but it hasn't, its only a fish and the majority of our population care about it even though its worth millions to the economy as a sport fish.
  36. Paul Cross 21 Jan 2016
    I live in north wales and travel to Scotland to fish for Salmon a couple of times each year, but in the last 10 years the numbers have fallen, and the decline in the last 3years has accelerated. The Scottish Government has done little or nothing to help the leisure industry but has always supported the Fish Farm managements, even though their profits all go abroad.
  37. Ian Dyer 21 Jan 2016
    As is often the case, the calculable cost to the environment is not considered against the short term economic benefit to man. The Norweigans are developing on-shore fish farming, where environmental impacts are significantly reduced. Controls on sea-lice should be suitably controlled in order to protect delecate wild fish stocks.
  38. Tony Mair 21 Jan 2016
    What is the role of lice in the food chain?
    I have no problem with farming any species so long as healthy sustainability is guaranteed. By the way, farmed salmon do not taste so good.
  39. Mark McCloy 21 Jan 2016
    Foreign countries are profiting from bad farming practices whilst are wild stocks decline !
    Closed containment must become the only acceptable practice.
  40. Richard Walton 21 Jan 2016
    The only real answer is to move to the close containment system on all salmon farms in the UK. Yes the industry will resist and yes farmed salmon will become more expensive, but it should be no part of our role in these islands to provide cheap protein to China.
  41. Hans van Manen 22 Jan 2016
    Inform the Scottish government this action is not only about Scotland but for Europe. We in the Netherlands travel to Scotland to enjoy the countryside and nature. Salmon is an essential part of that. Please make wild Salmon existence possible for the future and their generations!!!
  42. Edward de Vere Hunt 22 Jan 2016
    The desperate decline in salmon and sea trout is obvious to see for someone who takes interest in the welfare of rivers. Unless an all out effort is made to protect these ancient fish,regardless of who need to change their practices.
    Humans have become the cancer of the earth,intent on destroying its host for a quick profit,regardless of the future long term costs.
  43. ian bates 22 Jan 2016
    the fish farming around the canary island has all but gone broke ,now all we have is rotting fish farm pens ,the farmers should have to place large bonds to cover clean up and disease as the sea belongs to us all???
  44. Gary Davies 22 Jan 2016
    Act now before its to late.Like always the UK is always years behind the rest.
  45. Andrew Sayer 22 Jan 2016
    Land-based farms are not allowed to discharge dangerous waste into the sea
    - so why should fish farms be able to? Fish farms should be land based, in contained units.
  46. john ellis daniel 22 Jan 2016
    it is time the effects of over intensive farming methods, both on land and in the sea, should be identified. protocols and procedures to identify and implement corrective mitigation activities should be established.
  47. Robert barber 22 Jan 2016
    it needs sorted quickly
  48. Chris Horsman 22 Jan 2016
    Surely this is industrial pollution, it must be dealt with.
  49. Paul White 22 Jan 2016
    Wild salmon are underwater unlike seals, badgers and foxes, so their plight is unseen by the general population. As long as there is farmed salmon on the slab in Tesco etc the majority of people can't see a problem. Action is needed!!!
  50. john weir 22 Jan 2016
    The west coast of scotlands salmon and sea trout stocks have dropped by nearly 80% in the last 25yrs since the introduction of open cage fish farms, fresh fish caught in ayrshire rivers have been shown to have seriously high levels of sea lice attached which river trust scientists have claimed would have killed the fish in a number of weeks had they not moved into fresh water so if this is the case with adult salmon what chance does a smolt have, something has to be done now!