Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 401–450
  1. Michael Breneol 3 Jan 2015
    Atlantic Salmon stocks are precariously low. Time to stop all commercial exploitation and angler retention.
  2. nick pellatt 3 Jan 2015
    As a kid growing up in Scotland i used to be taken with my Dad to watch the salmon leaping up the rivers ,it is one of the most beautiful sights from nature. These fish travel for thousands and thousands of miles across seas to spawn in the exact spot they were spawned themselves ... This is not about mans right to angle it is about preserving something that has happened for millions of years . Please give them a chance to do this for another million years the poor fish have enough to worry about with estrogen levels in the water ,pesticides ,pollutants etc etc . Thankyou and I hope you see sense on this issue and help preserve for future generations of BONNY BONNY SCOTLAND
  3. Geoff franks. 3 Jan 2015
    Its obvious to anyone except it seems the Scottish Government. that all netting must cease. attention must then turn to the cleaning up of the farm salmon scandal. wekll we live in hope.
  4. Michael Dewdney 3 Jan 2015
    I would far rather there was a total ban on killing wild salmon throughout the season and that all fish should be returned with the exception of farmed escapees.
  5. jondi laurence O Byrne 3 Jan 2015
    Save our salmon, the time is now.
  6. David Cosh 3 Jan 2015
    The beat I fish on the west coast of scotland has dropped its average catch from 400 fish a season to 60 over the last 15 years. It is time the Scottish government got its act together or there will be no salmon left in Scotland
  7. Jim Nichol 3 Jan 2015
    It is u as the Scottish goverment who are killing our salmon by acting in a stupid and ignorant manor
  8. mark hastings 3 Jan 2015
    I have signed this petition because across the world the home of wild salmon is Scotland
    - it is a natural tresure and it is a traversty that this iconic fish is under threat in its spiritual home. No kill before July will help but the Scottish government really needs to grip fish farming. Closed cages are essential otherwise juvenile fish will continue to pick up sea lice when leaving their home rivers and will then never return. Wild salmon in Scotland has its days numbered unless urgent action is taken.
  9. Bruce Doucette 3 Jan 2015
    Thank you for allowing me to help support this petition,as an avid flyfisherman here in eastern canada we to are experiencing very low return rates to our rivers,and to help in stopping the off shore fishery is something that all governments need to examine.
  10. neil munro 3 Jan 2015
    just totaly agree with these measures hopefully maybe we can get back to the good old days were everyone can be happy, but that will not happen unless something is put into action
  11. George Watson 3 Jan 2015
    I have travelled to Scotland from the US each year since 2006. I come with from 1 to 3 companions to fish for salmon in the Highlands, staying a minimum of 2 weeks. We rent cars, stay in hotels, take our meals, pay our ghillies and for beat rentals....it gets expensive. Wild salmon are the lure that brings us here. We release the few we catch and hope that another angler will enjoy the sport of catching it later.
    A wild salmon is too valuable a resource to be netted and sold at the fishmonger, particularly when farmed salmon are very available.
    Netting these wild fish is economic suicide for Scotland. I con't understand why that is not as obvious to others as it is to me.
  12. William Thomson 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government should hang their heads in shame for being the largest contributor to the demise of wild salmon stocks, particularly on the west coast of Scotland. All aspects affecting the species from netting to habitat and pollution must be addressed before it's too late.
  13. Paul Tregunno 3 Jan 2015
    Wild Atlantic salmon are under serious threat. Urgent action is required now if future generations are going to be able to enjoy visiting Scotland to see or catch a salmon. Many local industries depend on the tourism the salmon bring to Scotland. All parties must play their part to protect and enhance existing salmon stocks, before it is too late.
  14. Jacky Collenette 3 Jan 2015
    If the runs have been poor for the last two seasons it makes every sense to ensure the maximum measures are in place to help re.establish a good number. This is best achieved by not fishing out what is potentially the Wild Salmon in such short supply.
    This measure is a common sense approach to up the numbers which hopefully will spawn and keep the cycle alive and what a wonderful that will be.
  15. Eric Craig 3 Jan 2015
    I fully support this petion it makes so much sense.
  16. Thomas Thomson 3 Jan 2015
    We all need to work together to save our salmon
  17. Peter Yardley 3 Jan 2015
    I live just south of the border so believe that this will affect the river Tweed near me. All rivers need protection cause when the salmon are gone they are gone for good!!!!!!!!!
  18. Brian Parker 3 Jan 2015
    Until we have reached the point where we have sufficient runs of salmon up our rivers we should do as much as we can to protect them.
  19. David Dixon 3 Jan 2015
    I love Scotland & this magnificent country will be very much the poorer in every sense if the gift of wild salmon is squandered.The relevant agencies know what needs to be done to stop exploitation & rod fishermen will play their part in carefully releasing any catches. We then need to properly address marine losses of anadromous fish.Please support Ian Gordon & the S.T.A(Scotland) in their sensible request.
  20. Nigel Rowland 3 Jan 2015
    I have stopped visiting Scotland to fish preferring Ireland who make greater efforts to protect their salmon.
  21. MICHAEL LEATHER 3 Jan 2015
    thousands of jobs in Scotland are linked to the sport of salmon fishing.The vast majority of fishers are showing their support of their sport and the people employed by catch and release. For the Scottish Government not to listen to reason and therefore act in an equally positive manner is diabolical.
  22. David Porter 3 Jan 2015
    The nets should not be reintroduce until the fish stocks have vastly inproved .
  23. Joe Alexander 3 Jan 2015
    It's way behind time to stop netting of any sort be it drift or fixed nets. Or will it be the same old story of politicians sitting on their hands doin nothing (again) until it's way too late when there will be nothing left to protect.
  24. Andrew MacGregor 3 Jan 2015
    Can anyone tell what happened to the report on salmon promised in February on opening day as response to Ian's campaign, guess data too sensitive to publish. I would certainly join any campaign or demo designed to embarrass anyone suspected of putting politics before wild salmon near Gordon in 2015 maybe?
  25. Eric Macdonald 3 Jan 2015
    I find it terribly sad that we have to organise a petition to persuade the Scottish government to protect the last wild Scottish salmon stocks.
    In years to come what excuse do we give our grand children that our generation oversaw their extinction?
  26. Sarah Barnes 3 Jan 2015
    Stop the exploitation of the wild salmon, we must act now preserve them.
  27. Rob Brownfield 3 Jan 2015
    Whilst the Scottish Government tells us how important wild salmon are to tourism and the environment, they continue to contradict their own policies by extending netting seasons and quotas as well as encouraging salmon farming by Norweigen companies, telling us we need to expand farming to meet the demands of Japan. There appears to be no joined up thinking at all. I fully support a no kill policy.
  28. JEAN BARZIN 3 Jan 2015
    SAVE one of the last atlantic salmon stock .The runs are very poor everywhere in Europe.
  29. Seamus Nee 3 Jan 2015
    Wild salmon are too valuable to be slaughtered by either nets men or anglers
  30. Peter Keyser 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government needs to show that it really is committed to saving the wild salmon stocks. I see few signs to date spelling disaster for rural jobs the rural economy and the health of our rivers.
  31. James Miller Ross 3 Jan 2015
    Why should we travel from Southern England and pay £2500 per week to catch and release wild salmon for conservation reasons when commercial nets are killing thousands of salmon with no quota controls in place. The nets will kill the Scottish salmon fishing tourist industry through pure commercial greed.
  32. David Magill 3 Jan 2015
    Salmon stocks everywhere are too low to contemplate any resumption of commercial netting. Mixed stock fishing is especially unacceptable for the obvious reasons accepted by Europe when formulating the salmon legislation and which persuaded the Irish government to cease drift netting
  33. Dirk Barendregt 3 Jan 2015
    Do not make pounds of of this living gold
  34. Willie Sutherland 3 Jan 2015
    Being a Ghillie for the last 10 years I have seen a steep drop in catches on the Ness in that time. My fishers are doing there bit having returned over 95% of salmon caught last year. They don't breed to well in the pot or languishing in the freezer and their survival is more important than having a tasty dinner.
  35. Michael Cole 3 Jan 2015
    If this goes through what a retrograde step for salmon and conservation in general. Reduction in jobs with ghillies hotels river owners pubs tackle shop the list goes on. Short term gain LONG term loss
  36. John Gardiner 3 Jan 2015
    It is about time to stop the netting before its to late also a cull on the seal and goo sander population
  37. Philip Burnham 3 Jan 2015
    It is vital to control the in-river catch of Scottish salmon and to completely eliminate coastal netting of mixed stock salmon in order to preserve recreational salmon angling, which is so vital for the Scottish tourist industry
  38. Richard Johnson 3 Jan 2015
    Time this practice was brought to an end! Should have happened years ago. The writing is on the wall
  39. margaret anne evans, Bride of Yehashuah. 3 Jan 2015
    Scotland leads in renewable energy. Please protect biodiversity and sustainable fisheries also. Thanks.
  40. Kenneth Annand 3 Jan 2015
    This petition is implying that anglers taking the odd fish for the pot are in some way responsible for the decline in Atlantic Salmon, which is nonsense. The last people we want telling us how to manage our Salmon stocks is the Scottish Government. They have, so far, shown a total disregard for wild salmon in Scotland, preferring instead to support aquaculture and netting. The fish farmers will be laughing all the way to the bank and signing this petition in droves.
    Any decision regarding killing salmon should be left to the individual river boards, NOT POLITICIANS who know nothing about wild salmon.
    The biggest problem facing Atlantic Salmon is marine mortality, that is where attention should be directed. Not, to anglers or even netsmen, who could never make salmon extinct by their efforts, even if they wanted too.
    I shall NOT be signing this and would urge any thinking anglers to do the same.
  41. david edward alan jones 3 Jan 2015
    Please, please think before you permit the netting of wild salmon, particularly the spring fish. The rod anglers who visit Scotland every year, quite often three and four time in a season have all accepted and embraced catch and release. It would be an unmitigated disaster for the Scottish Government to allow netting again after such a long period. If we were talking about elephants, tigers and the like there would be an outcry. Please think again, don't have the demise of this wonderful wild creature on your hands for ever and a day.
  42. James Duffy 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government has persistently ignored all conservation measures self imposed by the angling fraternity and chosen to encourage coastal netting and fish farming without concern for wild salmon it's time it changed its attitude to conservation.
  43. Charles Ratcliffe 3 Jan 2015
    Give our migratory fish a chance
  44. James Duffy 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government has persistently ignored all conservation measures self imposed by the angling fraternity and chosen to encourage coastal netting and fish farming without concern for wild salmon it's time it changed its attitude to conservation.
  45. DCM Blackburn 3 Jan 2015
    It is much better for the Scottish economy if rod fishing is preserved
  46. David Mair 3 Jan 2015
    SOS (Save Our Salmon)!
  47. Paul Clancy 3 Jan 2015
    We produce great standard farmed salmon,which carried out correctly will not damage the environment. Wild Atlantic Salmon have enough challenges to face with out this highly efficient method of fishing still being permitted
  48. Michael smith 3 Jan 2015
    metting is a disgrace
  49. Francis M B Palmer 3 Jan 2015
    Something needs to be further done to decrease the growth of Salmon farms, especially on the West coast. They destroy the fauna, and there is NO natural regeneration. I'm sure that you know the arguments.
  50. behier guillaume 3 Jan 2015
    il faut dire stop aux carnages..........
    I must say to stop the bloodshed