Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 451–500
  1. Richard Persse 3 Jan 2015
    Has my entry counted as a SIGNATURE?
    There is no signing box!
  2. Richard Thomlinson 3 Jan 2015
    The farming of Salmon
    - and thereby sea-lice
    - in open sea cages is doing enormous damage to the wild salmon stocks on which the Salmon-angling tourist industry depends. Please move to compulsory closed-containment salmon farming ASAP. BTW, in case you are wondering, I write this as a carpenter, not a CEO!
  3. Gerald Spiers 3 Jan 2015
    When will common sense prevail from our government regarding wild fish management.
  4. Michael Reid 3 Jan 2015
    Destroy the fish and you destroy many people's living
  5. Allan Dallas 3 Jan 2015
    We need to preserve the salmon stocks for future generations and secure employment. Farmed salmon satisfies the market requirements for fresh salmon. With the price of Salmon being cheaper that Haddock nowadays I don't understand where the market is for net caught fish.
  6. David Hardie 3 Jan 2015
    Its a pity there weren't more MSP's that were Salmon Anglers
  7. paul reay 3 Jan 2015
    Hope this gets sorted
  8. Robert Fisher 3 Jan 2015
    Salmon stocks must be protected for long term future
  9. Alistair A Kain 3 Jan 2015
    If we don't conserve the existing stock of Spring salmon by stopping netting on rivers and on estuaries over the next decade and allow these fish to spawn and replenish the stocks in our rivers then salmon fishing in Scottish rivers will be a thing of the past. Therefore Scotland will loose a resource and the Tourist Industry will suffer through many jobs being made redundant. Surely the Scottish Government would not wish further job losses just because a few netsmen cannot fish before 1stJuly and many people in the Tourist Industry will loose their livelihood because people will cease to come to Scotland to fish for Spring salmon in our rivers. Is it the policy of the Scottish Government that the few hold the many to ransom, if it is in this case Salmon Angling in Scottish Waters will no longer exist.
  10. Peter Michael Maher 3 Jan 2015
    My wife and I were going to visit Scotland this year but I may rethink our trip if the Government is not forward thinking enough to ban the netting of Atlantic Salmon
  11. Dr. Colin Howard 3 Jan 2015
    Time is running out
  12. Alan Greig 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government must act decisively now to support this petition. It must also act decisively going forwards to protect what is an increasingly threatened resource.
  13. Antony Hoare 3 Jan 2015
    I agree with the catch and release sentiments. Every River should do it and it has proven to be successful. However, the last two years............Global warming? Trawling? Netting?
  14. David Jones 3 Jan 2015
    As someone who organises an annual weeks salmon fishing for a party of 10. We are concerned at the decline in fish numbers. In part this can be put down to exploititive netting. If our party is representative, we bring in at least £5k to your economy. This is at risk if we haave a repeat this season of the previous 2.
  15. Raymond Plourde 3 Jan 2015
    The Scotish government should ban the net killing of all wild salmon
    - period and full-stop. Anglers should also be required to release all angled wild salmon
    - zero retention
    - until such a time as wild stocks have greatly recovered. To do less is condemnt the wild Scotish salmon to extinction. Smarten up!
  16. Ronald McQueen 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government should be ashamed of the way they have managing this wonderful resource by allowing these infested fish farms to operate in Scottish waters . The Norwegian owner and government have closed there own fish farms because of the problems to the salmon rivers. One just has to look at the problems in Chile the sea bed is completely void of life in vast areas and our coast line is going very quickly the same way.
    The Scotish economy could make more with jobs fom anglers. The netting is just another nail in the coffin for the poor salmon.
    I hope that our New First Minister will see the light and change direction as it is not to late .
    For the sake of our rivers, the salmon and seatrout please think again!
  17. Ian c arthur 3 Jan 2015
    Get your finger out and save what's left of our salmon befor it's to late.
  18. Ronnie Picken 3 Jan 2015
    The problems are well known, enough procrastination, time for a honest well thought through solution and get the job done properly this time.
  19. Laurent chevrot 3 Jan 2015
    The scottich government must stop immediately the fishing with net for protect the salmon run the next year the run was poor and it's necessary to take a measure for a good protection and preserve the fishing tourism in Scotland
  20. ian mallaghan 3 Jan 2015
    scotland would be a far less place if these
    silver summer visitors became
    extinct by a goverment who thinks nothing for the wellfair of this natural resourse only as a income
    by ofshore netting or salmon farms they should be held to account for what is going on and no way get away with this in2015
    these wild salmon belong to future generations
    and we should do our best to protect them for the good of scotland and every other river that atlantic salmon run
  21. Mark fortune 3 Jan 2015
    Stopping the killing of early salmon I feel is essential if we wish to save the species. However, this is only the willfull killing of salmon. The Scottish government must take note of the mounting scientific evidence regarding the damage being inflicted by aquaculture otherwise our salmon will become extinct.
  22. Elaine hayward 3 Jan 2015
    Having had 2 very poor years fishing for Salmon in Scotland it's now time to conserve stocks or we will spend our money else where !!
  23. John R Whitfield 3 Jan 2015
    Without control of the netting and habitat wild salmon will not exist in Scottish rivers and I for one see no point in paying to fish in rivers with no fish. I will take my business to a more welcoming country.
  24. Keith Oates 3 Jan 2015
    The reintroduction of netting will be a step backward for Scotland.It is against conservation principles and will result in job losses and economic decline in those areas of population adjacent to and dependent o visitors to rivers.
  25. Dave Dick 3 Jan 2015
    This appears to be a serious situation across the whole of the North Atlantic....political pressure needs to be brought urgently against those fishermen currently trawling salmon on their wintering grounds off Greenland and the Faeroes..in addition to the moratorium on rods and nets mentioned here.
  26. iain marshall 4 Jan 2015
    coastal net fishermen need to make a living as much as the estate or beat owner of a river and to take away their livelihood without some sort of compensation Is wrong, in order to protect others livelihoods .If the truth be told some of the dearest beats on the river Tay do not adear to the Tay fisheries board regulations with total disregard as money is at stake, I do however support the protection of salmon stocks in Scotland and perhaps an amount of tags per angler per season would be appropriate.
  27. Siegfried Darschnik 4 Jan 2015
    Sotland is such a beautiful country which so much potetial for tourism angling, but sadly as well with too man people neither recognizing that beauty nor that potential and politicians still going the old industrial paths of more, more, more ..... no matter what
  28. Roger Greaves 4 Jan 2015
    We must respect animals.
  29. Mr Greer Hart, senior 4 Jan 2015
    I am deeply concerned about the depletion of natural resources such as fish stocks, and in this case wild salmon in Scottish waters. A new attitude has to be adopted with regard to the commercial and sporting sides of using salmon. A thorough policy of conservation should be enforced. Future generations will have a valuable resource protected for them.
  30. James Green 4 Jan 2015
    Sometimes hard decisions need to be made, and this is one of them. Preserving these fish is essential, not only to the recreational angling world, but also to the commercial netters, whose livelihood, whether they are prepared to believe it or not, is drying up too.
  31. Lloyd Garvie 4 Jan 2015
    There seems little point killing wild sea trout and salmon for the price of their meat, when rod caught they are worth many, many multiples of that value. Add to that their declining numbers, and the Scottish Government's apparent support for netting is both perverse and wasteful.
  32. Margit Steidl 4 Jan 2015
    fishing the salmon youngsters in spring time will certainly extinguish these animals!
  33. Phil Wilde 4 Jan 2015
    I have given up my timeshare on the Tay and stopped regular trips to Dunkeld, Kelso and the west coast as the fishing is no longer reliable enough to justify the expense. I would return if I felt the Scottish government were approaching the problem in a proper joined up way.
  34. Mike Rollinson 4 Jan 2015
    The Atlantic Salmon are an indicator species and their slow demise in rivers across the country reflects very poorly on our stewardship. As the multi sea winter fish return first, this petition for a ban on their killing before 1st July will allow these biggest fish, carrying the largest amounts of eggs and milt, the best opportunity to make the spawning reds and reverse this trend. Please make it happen.
  35. Graeme Proud 4 Jan 2015
    How many more species are we going to allow man to destroy. Wild Atlantic salmon are one of our most unique species which provide a lot of opportunities to tourism.
  36. Julian Sheppard 4 Jan 2015
    Having fished the River Lochy for a number of years I have decided to fish elsewhere where fish are more plentiful and although I love the highlands years of fishing with no results by my friends and I have left us feeling that going to Scotland is a waste of time. If they are now going to start netting Salmon again I will never go back and invest my money in the local economy.

    The Scottish parliament must be crazy.
  37. Richard Peck 4 Jan 2015
    Without action by the Scottish Government a complete culture will be terminated irrevocably
  38. D.A.Brown 4 Jan 2015
    Coastal netting should not be reintroduced , do the powers that be realize what the loss of salmon angling would have on the Scottish tourism
  39. adrian mcloughlin 4 Jan 2015
    There is plenty of waste already. we over fish as it is.
  40. Guy Crawford 4 Jan 2015
    please convince our politicians to help conserve stocks of wild salmon
  41. Peter Rowland Smith 4 Jan 2015
    I fully support the proposal by Ian Gordon to stop netting of Salmon and Seatrout. This should apply to all migratory fish rivers in the UK.
  42. Tim Hicks 4 Jan 2015
    My grandmother Isobel Mc Bride of Bute would be horrified to see the complete lack of responsibility in conservation of atlantic Salmon. one of Scotland's finest resources and an integral indice of the nations environmental wellbeing. I call upon the scottish parliament to do it's duty and take every step possible at home and internationally to bring this unique and threatened species back from the brink of extinction and into a state of burgeoning stocks for the future generations of Scotland to benefit from.
  43. Jan Poulsen 4 Jan 2015
    As a Country with wild salmon on the run, you as a government should feel obliged to reassure this magnificent specimen of a fish, will survive in the future. The only way to do so is to guarantee the salmon freedom of way towards and into the Scottish rivers.
  44. Robert Finney 4 Jan 2015
    Hi Ian .Have you watched the video called salmon confidential on U tube .It paints a pretty gloomy picture for all wild salmon stocks. I would be very interested on your thoughts
  45. John D Standeven 4 Jan 2015
    Unfortunately I feel the Scottish government is more motivated by the macho image they would like to generate for themselves, fuelled by the drive for Nationalism, and their dislike for rod fishermen, (especially those from south of a line drawn on a map) rather than on the cold empirical evidence that any scientific research will produce
  46. Tom Halpin 4 Jan 2015
    We need decades more for wild fish populations to replenish themselves before net fishing and trawling can be allowed to resume
    - if ever!
  47. Mike Davison 4 Jan 2015
    Catch and release is vitally important for the protection and conservation of fish stocks. Salmon and Sea trout fishing is an important part of my life and I would like to believe that we could ensure that our future generations could experience this fine sport.
  48. Jonathan Meyer 4 Jan 2015
    As a regular visitor to the Scottish borders I speak the local businesses and in particular the grilles, whose livelihood is endangered by this policy. For the sake of the local Scottish economy it is urgent that this policy is reviewed and dropped.
  49. John Pears 4 Jan 2015
    A river caught fish is many many times more valuable to the local and national economy than a net caught fish.
  50. Dennis Greener 4 Jan 2015
    the time past long ago for mandatory catch and relese, its time to stop knocking salmon on the head and maybe knocking a few politicians on the head to maybe see some sense of the situation: Anybody not in favour of 100% catch and realese are better off not fishing the rivers to the benefit of the Fish and the rivers.