Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Scottish Wild Salmon (PE1547)

Wednesday 3 June 2015 Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee About 11:00–11:15 Petitions 10 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The next item is petition PE1547, from Ian Gordon and the Salmon and Trout Association, on the conservation of Scottish wild salmon. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed before 1 July and to end coastal netting of mixed-stock fisheries.

The committee has heard back from the Minister for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform following its decision to write to her on the petition as part of the wild fisheries review. We also have a response from the petitioner on the correspondence.

I refer members to the paper and invite their comments.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

I have considerable sympathy with the first part of the petition, which talks about a ban up to a certain date in the year for a five-year period. However, the second part of the petition, which focuses on one sector, is unfair.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

The minister has made it fairly clear that she intends to go ahead with her consultation. I think that the committee agreed with that. It might have to be quicker than had been talked about, but it is not possible to reach a conclusion on the matter until the consultation is over.

One thing is clear: if there is to be any reduction in or suspension of take, it will have to apply to all the sectors and not just one. It is unreasonable to expect one sector to take all the pain. If that comes back as an issue after the consultation—as it will do—major change will have to take place for everybody who is involved in taking salmon.

Dave Thompson SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

I agree with Mike Russell. We have to let the consultation take its course and consider the matter after that.

There is an associated issue on which we perhaps need to get a bit more information. Recently, I saw some information about the number of salmon that are being taken by seals. It is a phenomenal amount and it looks like more scientific evidence is becoming available on that. Perhaps we need to get more information and do a little bit of work on the impact of seals on salmon stocks because there is no point in doing anything about netsmen and anglers if huge amounts of salmon are disappearing in the high seas and round the coasts because of the seals.

I make it clear that I am not taking a position on that, but I would like more information on the latest science.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Those points are well made. If we need more information, that will lead us to a certain conclusion at the end of the discussion.

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

The sustainable harvest of wild salmon is extremely important. Other committee members, including the convener, have made that point in the past and might well do so again.

The petition is something of a blunt instrument in that it has a certain date on it up to which there should be no killing of salmon. The catch-and-release process has functioned much better, but I agree with members that all sectors should take the pain, and pain there will indeed be.

When we heard from the minister on the wild fisheries review, I had concerns about the scientific research, and her letter about the petition highlights the concerns about science. I want to be sure that there is robust scientific evidence on which the Scottish Government can make future decisions about the way forward.

11:15

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

The point about the science is well made. To follow on from Dave Thompson’s point, we also need to be as assured as we can be about the impact of climate change on the migratory patterns of salmon and how that is impacting on the situation. Gathering the most robust and reliable scientific evidence from all sides is imperative.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I am concerned about the one-sidedness of the petitioner’s view, because doing what he seeks is impossible without having reached scientific conclusions. His written submission to the committee states:

“Mixed Stock Fisheries cannot be deemed ‘sustainable’ unless one can be certain that all the salmon killed in such fisheries are destined for rivers which have sustainable surpluses.”

That is not correct, and it is not clear and balanced. Working out a sustainable harvest will be done on the basis of the stocks of salmon. It is a migratory species and the stocks will have to be measured in several different ways.

The sentence that I quoted just does not grab the reality; it is a partial view. I do not think that the committee would like to take the petition forward on that basis. From what I hear from members, I think that we need to get scientific information. The Scottish Parliament information centre could provide us with some background, but we are looking to the Government’s review to include scientific information. Whatever we say on the petition, we should convey to the Government that we need scientific information to clarify what a sustainable harvest actually is.

At this point, the petition should remain open, as the salmon stocks situation is inconclusive and we have more questions on it. For example, as Dave Thompson said, we need scientific information about the impact of seals on salmon stocks. Such questions need to be answered, so I suggest that we keep the petition open until we get answers to our questions. We can speak to the petitioner in due course, which could be once we have the outcome of the review, or whatever. However, it will be helpful for us to suggest to the minister what we need to know about, which can be fed into the review. Is that fair enough?

Sarah Boyack Lab Lothian
link

That suggestion is sensible and I agree with it. The review will give us crucial scientific information. We should also wait for the forthcoming secondary legislation and consider the points in the petition when we get that legislation. However, we would like it as soon as possible so that we can get on with addressing the issue.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

That point is well made and adds to what I said. We need to find out more before we make a decision on the petition, so we will let the Government know our view and will keep the petition open. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 18
  3. 09:48 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10
  4. 09:48 Common Agricultural Policy Implementation (Application Process) Committee business · 137
  5. 11:00 Petitions Petitions · 10
  6. 11:15 Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.