I am concerned about the one-sidedness of the petitioner’s view, because doing what he seeks is impossible without having reached scientific conclusions. His written submission to the committee states:
“Mixed Stock Fisheries cannot be deemed ‘sustainable’ unless one can be certain that all the salmon killed in such fisheries are destined for rivers which have sustainable surpluses.”
That is not correct, and it is not clear and balanced. Working out a sustainable harvest will be done on the basis of the stocks of salmon. It is a migratory species and the stocks will have to be measured in several different ways.
The sentence that I quoted just does not grab the reality; it is a partial view. I do not think that the committee would like to take the petition forward on that basis. From what I hear from members, I think that we need to get scientific information. The Scottish Parliament information centre could provide us with some background, but we are looking to the Government’s review to include scientific information. Whatever we say on the petition, we should convey to the Government that we need scientific information to clarify what a sustainable harvest actually is.
At this point, the petition should remain open, as the salmon stocks situation is inconclusive and we have more questions on it. For example, as Dave Thompson said, we need scientific information about the impact of seals on salmon stocks. Such questions need to be answered, so I suggest that we keep the petition open until we get answers to our questions. We can speak to the petitioner in due course, which could be once we have the outcome of the review, or whatever. However, it will be helpful for us to suggest to the minister what we need to know about, which can be fed into the review. Is that fair enough?