Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 501–550
  1. John Brownlie 4 Jan 2015
    No action, No fish, No anglers, No jobs. The rural economy facing disaster.
  2. Mike Parker 4 Jan 2015
    Fish stocks and the marine environment are so fragile, people need to understand the massive impact we are having on them on a global scale. This is one step to show that you understand and are doing something about it.
  3. john goreham 4 Jan 2015
    A lot of the tourist trade relies on revenue from salmon fishermen which is already suffering from declining stocks. Although I much prefer Scotland I like many other fishermen will think strongly about fishing in Scandinavian countries that offer much better chances of catching fish which is what we pay for, which is a shame as Scotland has so much more to offer.
  4. Ron moore 4 Jan 2015
    Please preserve your assets before it's to late
  5. David higgs 4 Jan 2015
    People should restrict themselves to eating farmed Salmon for at least the next five years, it wont hurt them and will help Salmon conservation.
  6. Jean-Yves Simon 4 Jan 2015
    no protection means no wild salmo salar anymore anywhere that's simply it
  7. Denis Halstead. 4 Jan 2015
    As usual the sport fishing fraternity are bending over backwards to try to correct the destructive do not care attitude of Politicians. The damage is done at sea, lack of adult salmon on the feeding grounds produces opportunities for other species to consume the surplus food with the result of an ever decreasing supply for the salmon and consequently fewer and fewer salmon returning. This has happened with COD on the Grand Banks of Nova Scotia. The only hope for the Atlantic Salmon is to send more fish to the feeding grounds or we will lose them altogether.
  8. Richard Kingston 4 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government should stop all coastal netting immediately and make all rod and line Salmon fishing "catch and release". the Scottish Government should also insist that all salmon farming moves to onshore closed containment farming, thereby stopping the infestation and decimation of wild fish stocks. Finally, rod and line fishing on a Sunday should be allowed. The combination of all of the above would have a massive positive impact on fishing tourism in Scotland.
  9. Peter Keeling 4 Jan 2015
    It is a scandal that there is still netting of salmon anywhere off our coast. The species has seen year on year decline and soon there will be no fish left to catch other than farmed. I have this year decided not to return to fish the Dee as stocks are so poor on that river now and the cost keeps on going up despite the problems. The industry is in its death throes and it is folly to think otherwise.
  10. Gerard Watts 4 Jan 2015
    Regardless of sporting activity, the very survival of the Atlantic Salmon is at great risk without urgent action.
  11. Laurent Bonetat 4 Jan 2015
    I think that I wouldn't come back to Scotland for salmon fishing if nothing is really done to save wild scottish salmon. The scottish government should prove that he wants to save one of most inconic scott's animals.
  12. Michael Martin 4 Jan 2015
    The fish farms have decimated the Salmon stocks and the resumption of netting will further add to the salmons decline so if you wish to have a future fishing tourist industry stop any moves to reopen any netting and move all the salmon cages from all river with a run of sea trout or salmon Catch and release can help but only it it is strictly enforced and that is not always the case due to lack of manpower within the enforcing bodies.A total ban on all rod caught fish and a tagging system as we have in Ireland can hinder the poachers considerably and massive fines for any one purchasing illegally caught fish can reduce the outlet for poachers to cash in..Proper river enhancement and a genetic stocking programe can work wonders on rivers where populations are threatened with extinction.
  13. Alan Smith 4 Jan 2015
    I cannot imagine the reasons for this lack of
    joined up thinking by Government.
    The Welsh Parliament have made a similarly ludicrous decision and are allowing double tide
    netting whilst exhorting anglers to return all fish.
    You couldn't make it up!!!
  14. PJ Lewis 4 Jan 2015
    A limited period catch-and-release is a sensible precaution and ending netting for good is sound economic sense given the far higher value of rod caught fish relative to netted fish. But these measures should be accompanied by longer term measures to increase, not reduce the powers of those who know how to run Scottish Angling, which isn't Holyrood.
  15. Derek Wofinden 4 Jan 2015
    Having seen salmon catch rates decline on Scotland's rivers, if Scotland's Parliament need to take drastic action sooner rather than later.
  16. Francis Mildmay-White 4 Jan 2015
    The wild salmon stock situation in Scotland is extremely concerning. The government needs to take action immediately before it is too late.
  17. Robert Garnett 4 Jan 2015
    All mixed stock netting stations and estuary netting stations should be closed until salmon make a sustainable recovery in all rivers in the UK.
  18. William de Burgh 4 Jan 2015
    It just makes common sense. Without the ability to come back to the river to spawn there will be no future salmon. The species becomes extinct river by river. So please be smart and prevent all netting of salmon returning to the rivers.
  19. Packie Mc Dermott 5 Jan 2015
    Scotland without Salmon,is 100 times worse than Scotland without it's Whiskey
  20. PEYROT Francis 5 Jan 2015
    Thanks, Ian, for your implacation.
  21. Steen Mortensen 5 Jan 2015
    Keep up the good work in fighting agains netting for wild salmon and seatrouts. Live and wild salmon in the rivers is by far the best for all Scotsmen an brings value to you Country.
  22. david pease 5 Jan 2015
    salmon fishing provides such a source of income to Strath Glass. It would be a severe blow to so many people our catches continue to decline.
  23. Jim Bumby 5 Jan 2015
    Netting is devastating our wild fish stocks. In 2013 the North east MSF nets killed more than 16000 salmon and 40000 sea trout, this is more than the recorded number of fish that run the Tees, Wear, Tyne and Cocquet in total! This can't be right. Many of these fish would also be destined for Scottish rivers. Consequently anything that can be done to reduce, and ideally remove, the threat netting poses to our wild fish stocks along both the Scottish and English Coast has my full support.
  24. GRAHAM SALISBURY 5 Jan 2015
    Scotish Government has to regognise the true value of salmon angling to the Scotish economy 160 million PA and the hundreds of jobs it supports. How can it justify netting and a handful of seasonal jobs it needs to get its act together and quickly, we have booked no trips back to Scotland this year and are looking further afield.
  25. Richard Brown 5 Jan 2015
    Although I live in North Wales I fish in Scotland hence my signature on a Scottish issue.
  26. Marcus Lidster 5 Jan 2015
    The stopping of all coastal netting will help the long term viability of the salmon rod fishing tourist industry. I also stopped holiday fishing in Scotland due to unreliable particularly sea trout fishing.
  27. Nick Winter 5 Jan 2015
    Salmon numbers are very low and this measure would surely help. Anglers are eternally optimistic, but if there really is no hope of catching a Scottish salmon, anglers won't come and that will be a huge loss to the Scottish tourism industry. I may not be typical but in my experience each rod-caught salmon must be worth at least 500-1000 pounds to the Scottish economy, and many or most are returned. Apart form the moral imperative to conserve these magnificent fish, even in narrow accounting terms it surely must be a no brainer.
  28. chris Sutcliffe 5 Jan 2015
    I seem to catch less and less fish (salmon and sea trout) year on year.
    My visits to the rivers of Scotland as a result have diminished over time.
    I am concerned for the future of both salmon and sea trout
    - why should I bother going to Scotland if it appears that the Scottish Government is not bothered?
  29. Michael Charles Gordon-Lennox 5 Jan 2015
    The petition as drafted must make sense
  30. Alan Jones 5 Jan 2015
    It may already be too late to stop the netting, but it is worth the effort to try and prevent all netting around our coasts and then to target other EU and North Atlantic Ocean offenders. Support the cause!
  31. Alan Jones 5 Jan 2015
    In addition to the action on netting and rod catches, it is time that the EU and the Scottish government acted to reduce the number of seals around our coasts. It is only a matter of time that they will start to starve to death due to the lack of fish stocks.
  32. Hans van Manen 5 Jan 2015
    Absolutely right to organise this petition, salmon stocks are worldwide endangered. I come from the Netherlands, salmon is extinct there and it use to be widespread!!!
  33. Alfred George Pope 5 Jan 2015
    As a riparian owner I am extremely concerned about Salmon Stocks. I believe in 100% Catch and Release and the moving of all farmed salmon cages to land based farms. All Scottish netting must be banned until stocks recover. Also there must be a thorough checking of the by catch of pelagic trawlers.
  34. Alison Alston 5 Jan 2015
    Our wild Scottish Salmon are a precious and valuable resource that must be put before politics.
    To not do everything to protect them is to let down Scotland's future.
  35. David Hanbury 5 Jan 2015
    I have at least 3 fisherman friends who go to Scotland every year to fly-fish for salmon. They are beginning to think seriously about not going in future, as the stock of salmon has sunk to such low levels. Hotels, ghillies, etc, will therefore lose much revenue.
  36. Christopher Edmondson 5 Jan 2015
    It is nothing short of a tragedy what has been done to the salmon.
  37. Jeremy Sharp 5 Jan 2015
    One successful spawning gives rise to thousands of new potential fish. Why deplete already low stocks by netting?
  38. Peter Brogan 5 Jan 2015
    To avoid the future extinction of indigenous Wild Atlantic Salmon borne from Scottish Rivers, please put a stop to indiscriminate netting !
  39. David Crawshaw 5 Jan 2015
    Why when the Spring and early Summer run is almost non existent did you go for a 1st July date. The bulk of the run is after this date. I would have supported a date of one month later. The Dee "catch and release" of the last fifteen years has shown that even a total catch ban on a river has not been the answer. A look at their returns for the last five years shows that the problem is not with the angler but elsewhere, but the one who is paying the price in this new legislation.
  40. Jean-Paul Javerzat 5 Jan 2015
    In the Dordogne river (France) we lost our last wild salmon decades ago. Efforts to re-introduce salmon from other rivers have failed. I've spent some time in Scotland: beautiful and friendly. It would not be exactly the same anymore if you were loosing your Salmon. Please protect your Salmon!!!
  41. Jee Yul Yoon 5 Jan 2015
    I can't believe salmon industry trying to whitewash wild stock extinction. It acts like species and ecosystems unimportant and farming salmon are much better than sustainable harvests of wild populations. The nefarious fact twisting is disgraceful.
  42. Guy Hollis 5 Jan 2015
    Used to visit Scotland regulalrly to fish
    - seldom go now as salmon stocks have been destroyed by total lack of understanding and miss management by the Scottish Governemnt . They don't seem to understand their own country and what makes it function outside Glasgow and Edinburgh ! Oil is not the only natural resource!
  43. James Edwards 5 Jan 2015
    I fish Scotland each year for Salmon, last year (2014) was perhaps the worst ever with hardly any spring fish showing, it is inconcievable that netting is allowed, especially when the angler is not even allowed to take just 1 fish.
  44. Niall Riddell 5 Jan 2015
    How can we expect other countries not to net Scottish salmon, if we cannot put our own house in order
  45. Michael Lynch 5 Jan 2015
    The most amazing fish on this country, it is education needed not nets. The Wild Salmon are not ours to take, we must nurture them and look after them. That is our responsibility not netting them at river mouths or sea.
  46. olivier allais 5 Jan 2015
    With the end of wild salmon I look sadly at my trips in scotland and probably put an end to these ...
  47. Daniel Hoda, Switzerland 5 Jan 2015
    In Switzerland, the Atlantic Salmon was elected as the fish of the year 2015. This is bad because only endengered species will be nominated for this election. One reason for the tragedy see Atlantic Salmon Documentary
    - Salmon Farms in Canada & Diseased Salmon
    - on youtube.
    It is time to think about a lot of things to help this beautiful fish and his Pacific brothers to survive. I hope my sons and grandsons will have the opportunity to fly fish for the Atlantic Salmon too. Tight lines.
  48. Matthias Uphues 5 Jan 2015
    Wild salmons are too valueable just to eat. Take your time and go fishing for one yourself! Enjoy nature! Best regards.
  49. Dr Tom Gibson 5 Jan 2015
    It is very sad that Spring Salmon have almost vanished within my lifetime
  50. John Noel Hulmston 5 Jan 2015
    It is vital that commercial fishing interests are not permitted to destroy game fishing. In Wales tourist fishing is worth over £150 million per annum
    - Scotland far more. Without a tourist trade many more jobs upon which many local folk rely for to make a living will be endangered. I, for my part, would not be able to bring fishermen to Scotland. No salmon in the rivers means no visiting fishermen!