Petition · PE01547 · Session 4
Conserving Scottish wild salmon
Signatures
0
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.
What the petitioner did first
The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
17 Feb 20151 mention
-
4 Mar 20151 mention
-
11 Mar 20151 mention
-
28 May 20151 mention
-
3 Jun 20151 mention
-
9 Mar 20161 mention
-
30 Jun 20161 mention
Signatures by country
8,768 online signaturesComments
795 comments, oldest first795 comments · showing 701–750
-
John Hickman 19 Jan 2015All salmon and grilse should be returned to the rivers through catch and release to ensure they survival. All Netting for salmon should stop with immediate effect if we are going to stop this magnificent creature from becoming extinct.
-
Norman Hall 19 Jan 2015If you close fish farms atlantic salmon may have a chance
-
Jos Wace 19 Jan 2015Thank you Ian and the S and T A
-
Edward Thomson 19 Jan 2015SEA LICE are the biggest problem!
-
Nigel Swiffen 20 Jan 2015Allow Salmon Hatcheries on the Spey,
Dredge the Spey mouth to allow the Salmon to run freely,
Reduce Seals in the estuary -
sid knight 20 Jan 2015I tried but kept getting the spoken numbers wrong
-
Mark Williams 20 Jan 2015Netting Wild Salmon to this extent when numbers have collapsed is madness. Please give the species a chance to survive.
-
Robert Clemen 20 Jan 2015Reduce the predators and a Lot more salmon will return into the rivers !
-
julian millerchip 21 Jan 2015the salmonid species has inhabited this planet a lot longer than humankind, we have no right to exterminate them
-
frederick richardson 21 Jan 2015its all for our future generations and our chance to make shure that nature is preserved and do not take a chance that it might never happen
-
robert Laird 21 Jan 2015Many years ago I lived in New Elgin in Morayshire and knew an Ian Gordon then. Just wondered if Ian had any connection with Elgin. Glad to sign your petition, but sadly domiciled in England these days, but recall many fine trips out after the Sea Trout on the River Lossie. Good luck with the petition.
Regards
Robert -
Peter Austin 21 Jan 2015Having only recently taken up salmon fishing I have missed the good times and in consequence seem destined never to take a wild one for the table. However, so many passionate anglers support this petition to do our bit to save the species and deny ourselves so hopefully setting an example that I feel Scottish Government is surely morally bound to follow. But maybe their morals have been corrupted and all we'll get are the usual weasel words and our efforts will be in vain. The netsmen kill all the fish in their nets and do nothing by way of conservation. We would all like to see a return to plentiful stocks and maybe even some bulging nets but we must act before the number of spawning fish falls below a critical level, i.e. now.
-
Kevin Smith 22 Jan 2015glad to help. I used to kill salmon for a living,providing great food to man. they must be saved. if the rivers die.. we die. think about it.
-
Anthony Steel 22 Jan 2015This is one important cog in the wheel of improvement that should be done to our wild salmon stocks for the sake of the tourism economy.
-
Charles Allen 22 Jan 2015This problem is not just confined to Scottish rivers. a similar collapse has been experienced in Iceland in 2014. Government and the agencies that control these matters should listen to the experts and those who have dedicated themselves through their sport to the preservation and health of the salmon.
-
Richard Hutcheon 22 Jan 2015In addition to over exploitation at sea by mankind, can something be done to reduce seal numbers in estuaries in times of drought?
-
Graham Rait 22 Jan 2015I have fished the Deveron for over 60 years and last year was probably the worst. All the conditions were favourable apart from there being no fish. If the netting is not stopped soon there will not only be no salmon but there will no salmon fishing tourists either. Anglers will not pay for fishing, tackle and accommodation if there is very little chance of hooking a fish.
-
George Hunter 22 Jan 2015The major problem is not within our rivers and the salmon angling fraternity. it lies with indiscriminate fish farm locations and what happens out at sea. Which sucessive governments have failed to deal with. if by releasing salmon over this period it does something to help great.
-
ewan bell 22 Jan 2015The Scottish Government are directly responsible for virtually destroying salmon runs on the Lochy by licensing even more salmon cage farms along Loch Linnie and up the Sound of Mull amounts to culpable negligence,by government. Last years lack of fish running many of Scotland's East coast rivers is caused by a combination of negative marine factors , one of them is human exploitation which is something government can do something about . Do not play politics with one of Scotland's main tourist attractions
-
Archie Stirling-Aird 22 Jan 2015It is time to take some action to protect this magnificent fish
- without doubt one of Scotland's greatest natural resources. -
Charles McPherson 22 Jan 2015Salmon netting is awful, no prisoners taken and if it continues the species will be wiped out, all for greed.
It should and must be banned. Fishing has to be 100% "Catch and Return" also. -
nicholas hastie 23 Jan 2015Salmon are an endangered species due mainly to the Scottish Government's lack of interest, i.e., netting at sea, removal of predators' both in the rivers & estuaries, seals, saw billed ducks, etc. damage to spawning beds by beavers, lice infestations from salmon farms, pollution, water abstraction from forestry & agriculture, etc., I am afraid that this is the same old store, of a species' about to be lost, due to mans incompetence & greed.
-
ken bird 23 Jan 2015Lets have action on this NOW before its too late !
-
Sir George Forbes-Leith 23 Jan 2015If something is not done I fear that wild salmon will be as rare as rhinos in Africa
-
Mr James French 23 Jan 2015The netting of wild Atlantic Salmon should be banned completely, not just for a shorter season.
-
Jan Olsson 23 Jan 2015This is another example of us humans being stupid and short term minded. With the right political decisions it is not hard to make the salmon prosper...
-
Pete Newell 23 Jan 2015Sustainability before profit.
Think of the future, act now and show some backbone! -
Mick Purdy 24 Jan 2015From tiny acorns
-
Andrew Ryan 24 Jan 2015If action is not taken to rescue the treasured atlantic salmon they will be reducedvto extinction
-
Martin Glennie 24 Jan 2015Salmon are a Scottish National Treasure--don't waste them on the dinner table they are worth a lot more in the water waiting for a fly.
-
Anita Smith 24 Jan 2015We need more salmon coming home to spawn
-
Andrew MacGregor 24 Jan 2015Seems the Government report famously promised by then leader notably friendly to netters and fish-farmers in February 2014 for September 2014 actually has been published at notable low profile launch
- so what is 'anyone' doing about it. Further report was S.Government stating it would take three more years to implement "too little too late"? -
Eamon Mcgee 24 Jan 2015Will be going to Scotland to fish but if it's not reverse no point in spending my hard earn money to fish in Scotland if netting resumes, fishing is good for tourism more money will be spent on hotels, bed amd breakfast and shops alot more on netting.
-
Ray Jarman 24 Jan 2015This will help to preserve the future of our wild Salmon for future generations.
-
Clive Bruton 24 Jan 2015We owe it to future generations to ensure the survival of this magnificent fish! Do not prejudice its survival!
-
Dion Docherty 24 Jan 2015I would like to see all the netting of wild Salmon and Seatrout stopped for good
-
William Loth 24 Jan 2015Salmon fishing brings a lot more money to Scotland than netting
- do what's best for business
- let the anglers catch the fish and spend money locally. -
William Gavin Telfer Dunbar 24 Jan 2015I want everything to be done to conserve the Wild Salmon stocks of Scotland. They are under threat from netting, both costal and at sea. Predators also need to be kept down. The Scottish Parliament has a central role and needs to listen to those who care.
-
Bob Turner 24 Jan 2015The benefit to the Scottish economy is great for rod caught salmon, it makes no sense to jeopardise that.
-
Donald W. Henderson 24 Jan 2015We must preserve our natural ecosystems. The Atlantic salmon is a vital and historic part of the cold-water river systems entering the North Atlantic.
-
Ewen Brodie 24 Jan 2015There is no other sensible alternative.
-
Smets Koen 24 Jan 2015Good luck !
-
Ryland Thomas. Midland Flyfishers 24 Jan 2015I can not conceive that any intelligent and responsible minister, wth no conflict of interest, can turn this down.
-
Sir John Lister-Kaye 24 Jan 2015The principal predator is man, both directly and indirectly. This conservation measure is vital.
-
William Storey 24 Jan 2015Well done to all the time and effort Ian has put into this cause, as individuals we don't make much noise! All of the dedicated salmon fishing people who have come together have made a huge bang!!!! well done Ian
-
Gerald Spiers 24 Jan 2015Good effort Ian.
-
Leonard russell 24 Jan 2015Scotland has more wild salmon than any other country. Numbers are severely down. Why ruin this with netting?
-
Jack Welch 24 Jan 2015Salmon stock are a key indicator of not only the health of Salmon, but also the river system and Scotlands environment. Salmon must be protected to allow future generations to enjoy both fishing and seeing wild fish in the river systems.
-
Tony Murphy 24 Jan 2015we must stop the damage that is done by fish farms, and stop the wholesale harvesting of sand eels and crill
-
Bruce Noble 24 Jan 2015Crucial work Ian and full of gratitude and admiration for your persevering with this important cause. After a poor year on the rivers last year, the thought that netting would begin in the estuaries and surrounding coastline is ecological myopia and would certainly further damage fish stocks. Petition part two signed.