Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Protecting Wild Salmonids (PE1598)

Thursday 30 June 2016 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:00 Petitions 50 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

50 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

I welcome everyone to the Public Petitions Committee’s second meeting in session 5. I remind everyone to turn off mobile phones to avoid any interruptions or interference with the sound system. Apologies have been received from Maurice Corry.

Agenda item 1 is consideration of four new petitions, two of which we will take evidence on. The first new petition is PE1598 by Guy Linley-Adams on behalf of Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland, on protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms. I welcome Mr Linley-Adams, who is joined by Andrew Graham-Stewart, the director of Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland, and I ask him to make a brief opening statement of no more than five minutes before we move on to questions.

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

First, I thank the committee and its predecessor. This is the third petition that Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland has sent the committee’s way. The previous petition—PE1547, on coastal netting of salmonids—led ultimately this year to salmon conservation regulations with which we are delighted. The petition before that, which was also on aquaculture, was fed into the run-up to the passing of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013. That process was good; it shows the value of the committee’s work, and I thank it for all those efforts.

I also thank the clerks for the excellent guidance that we received before today. They told me strictly not to repeat the content of the petition verbatim. I will not do so; instead, I will bring the committee up to date with developments since we lodged the petition in December last year.

As the committee might know, sea lice data is published three months in arrears by the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation. It is aggregated data that explains the levels of sea lice on fish farms in the previous three months. In December last year, the percentage of Scottish production of salmon—the capacity of the farms in the affected regions—that had figures over the sea lice threshold in the “Code of Good Practice for Scottish Finfish Aquaculture” was 58.8 per cent. Since then, that percentage has risen. In the most recent data that we have, which is from March this year, the figure hit 66.4 per cent. In other words, two thirds of the production of Scottish salmon farms is operating at above the code of good practice threshold for the average number of female sea lice per fish—they are the egg-producing lice that cause the problem for wild fish by producing many juvenile sea lice.

The inexorable rise in sea lice problems continues and the control methods do not appear to be working. It is a problem that the data is aggregated, because any particular region can have up to 20 farms, so we do not know which farms are performing badly. Some better farms are controlling their sea lice well, but the flipside of the coin is that some very poor farms are completely failing to control sea lice, and we cannot identify them. Those issues were all aired at the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee in the run-up to the passing of the 2013 act, and that committee’s view was that the position should be kept under review and that farm-specific sea lice data should perhaps be published.

I should draw the committee’s attention to the fact that, only this week, the Norwegian Food Safety Authority has released an online real-time sea lice database that is accessible to the public and which contains farm-specific data on treatment and where the problems are. That is far in advance of the Scottish system and I commend it to committee members if they have time to investigate it. Unfortunately, the website is only in Norwegian at the moment, which makes it a little more difficult to use.

Touching briefly on another issue, I note that the committee has received a submission from Callander McDowell. There are all sorts of other debates about the science, such as whether there is an effect and whether we can show an effect on wild populations. Marine Scotland science, the Government’s fisheries science division, has produced a useful five-page summary of the science document. The clerks have a copy of that document, which I hope will be circulated to the committee after the meeting.

That summary says:

“Salmon aquaculture can result in elevated numbers of sea lice in open water and hence is likely to increase the infestation potential on wild salmonids. This in turn could have an adverse effect on populations of wild salmonids in some circumstances. The magnitude of any such impact in relation to overall mortality levels is not known for Scotland. However, concerns that there may be a significant impact of aquaculture have been raised due to declines in catches of both salmon and sea trout on the Scottish west coast. There is scientific evidence that individual Scottish sea trout can experience physiological detrimental burdens of salmon lice in areas with salmon aquaculture but the effects on populations in different areas is not known. Scientific evidence from Norway and Ireland indicates that early protection against salmon lice parasitism results in reduced absolute marine mortality, increasing recapture rates of experimental salmon, and reduces the time spent at sea, indicating that salmon lice can influence the population status of wild salmon.”

I will read that last bit again:

“salmon lice can influence the population status of wild salmon.”

That is not our conclusion nor the conclusion of the aquaculture body but the conclusion of Marine Scotland science. If it is able to conclude that, we suggest that we need a precautionary approach and as strict a control as possible on sea lice in Scottish aquaculture in order to protect an extremely valuable asset for Scotland: the wild salmonid population.

Only this month, the North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization met in Germany. Scotland was represented, and the Scottish Government came forward with proposals for higher thresholds for escalation plans and potentially reducing biomass at farms. However, the levels at which those steps would take effect were much higher than all the other aquaculture nations represented thought was sensible. Scotland’s system for the control of sea lice is recognised as being the most lax, compared to the Norwegians, the Irish and so on. We would like to see the system tightened up and brought into line with the other salmon farming and producing nations.

Our petition asks for a statutory duty to be placed on Scottish ministers to regulate farmed fish for the express purpose of protecting wild fish. At the moment, all the legislation is pointed at the health and welfare of the farmed animal, not wild fish, and we think that ministers should have such a duty and the requisite powers. We would like the relocation programme, which identifies farms that are in the wrong place, to be rejuvenated. It rather ran into the sand in 2008 and has not gone much further. We believe that if that could be done, an awful lot of progress could be made.

I want to put it on record that Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland is not trying to shut down the aquaculture industry. We get accused of that a lot, but we are not in that business. We recognise just how important aquaculture is to Scotland, and what we would like to do is to make it more sustainable so that wild fish can thrive alongside the industry.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, Mr Linley-Adams and Mr Graham-Stewart. You will be aware that, in the debates on the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill in 2013, it was agreed that the data on sea lice would be published voluntarily by the industry in 30 areas or thereabouts. That has been done; in fact, as was promised to the RACCE committee at the time, the industry has been reporting back on a three-monthly basis to the individual members of the committee, which has been helpful.

You mentioned some developments in Norway, which is Scotland’s nearest comparator country with regard to the salmon industry—Chile is perhaps the next closest—and which is now issuing the sort of farm-by-farm data that a number of stakeholders called for in the evidence sessions that took place here in 2013. Those methods are more robust than those we have in Scotland. Why do you think that farm-by-farm data is not publicly released here? Do you believe that that information is available?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Strangely, it is available in certain regions, by virtue of the fact that one or two regions have only a single farm. The aggregated data therefore relates to that one farm, which is unfair on those operators because it makes them clearly identifiable.

I think that the industry feels that its data is its own and that it should not have to share it. In some respects, there is a high-level principle here: why should it share that data with everyone? What is at the forefront of the industry’s mind is a concern that particular farms will be singled out.

A lot of the early farms were put in sheltered bays or at the mouths of estuaries, because it was a new industry and it was easier to control the cages if they were sheltered and close to land. Quite often, however, those are the farms that have problems. If we could identify those farms, we could talk to the local authorities and the industry and identify sites to which they could be moved. They have to be moved away from the mouths of rivers, as those are the migratory channels for the wild salmonids. The kit these days can be moved offshore into open water, where interaction with wild salmonids can be avoided. Moreover, if the cages are further out, biomass can probably be increased, as there is a better flow of water. The publication of farm-specific data will enable us to identify more clearly the farms that we would like to put forward for relocation.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Do you understand the industry’s concern that the issuing of farm-by-farm data and making such data widely available could have serious consequences for a farm’s viability?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

I understand that, to an extent, but I am not entirely sure why it would be correct to shelter a poorly performing farm from scrutiny just because it might cause the farm an issue.

Most supermarkets do not name the farm of production. Sainsbury’s and the Co-op are different in that they name the farm on the packaging of the smoked salmon products that they sell. However, an awful lot do not, and an awful lot of ready meals do not identify the farm of origin either. As a result, we would not be in a situation where consumer pressure was building against a particular farm and having an impact on it.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

As you know, enforcement notices can be served on individual farms. What do you know about the enforcement regime?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

The fish health inspectorate can serve a variety of different enforcement notices, but the purpose of those notices is to protect the health and welfare of the farmed animal.

In the second year of production, in particular, farmed fish can tolerate 10 or 15 adult female lice quite happily. That does not cause the farmer any economic problems, because the fish are about to be harvested. However, in those final few months of their lives when the fish are in the cages with the lice on them, a large number of juvenile lice are produced that then leave the cages and have an impact on wild fish. A fish might have a collection of adult female lice on it but, if the lice are not causing a health and welfare issue for the farmed animal, the fish health inspectorate cannot act. It does not have the legal powers to act expressly to protect wild fish.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

You state in your petition that you have met Marine Scotland on a number of occasions. It is fair to say that you are not impressed, given your comment about the lack of progress in protecting wild salmonids from harm caused by the industry. What more should Marine Scotland do to address the issue?

09:45

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Marine Scotland suffers from the same situation as the fish health inspectorate, in that it is still largely focused on the health and welfare of the farmed animal. Responsibility for the wild fisheries falls between two stools: the Scottish Environment Protection Agency deals only with the water pollution side of things, while Scottish Natural Heritage gets involved only with the European protected areas—the special areas of conservation, or SACs. The vast majority of fish farms are nowhere near the SACs. That is a gap in the law—no agency has responsibility.

I would not say that we are universally appalled by Marine Scotland—far from it. The staff are excellent and we have a good and quite jovial relationship with them, but they have a particular line to steer and we have ours. Nevertheless, we are making progress with them.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

That is good to hear.

You have made the general statement that

“Wild salmonids in the ‘aquaculture zone’ on the west coast are in trouble”,

but is it not the case that they are in trouble across the whole north Atlantic region, not just on our west coast? The decline in numbers was identified long before the salmon industry increased to the size that it is today.

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

I will ask Andrew Graham-Stewart to deal with that.

Andrew Graham-Stewart Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Wild salmon face three problems in Scotland. The first is declining marine survival, which is universal in the east, west and north. The decline in netting has influenced the level of returns to rivers, but aquaculture has also influenced matters.

In a new study of salmon rod catches in Scotland that we recently carried out, we found catches in the salmon farming heartland of the west coast lagging far behind those on the essentially farm-free east coast. The five-year average catch on the east coast—that is, between the Tweed and Cape Wrath—was up by 40 per cent between 1970 and 2014. In contrast, the five-year average catch for the west coast—that is, from Cape Wrath down to the Mull of Kintyre, including the Hebrides, which is the main salmon-farming area—had by 2014 declined to 76 per cent of its 1970 value. If the west coast catches had tracked the east coast ones, they would have been 80 per cent higher in 2014. In the worst area—Ardnamurchan down to Kintyre—the rod catch was by 2014 50 per cent of its 1970 value. I emphasise again that because of the decline in netting, the catch on the east coast has gone up by 40 per cent.

The great majority of west coast rivers are now in category 3, which is the new Government classification for salmon rivers. That means that, according to Scotland’s marine scientists, no exploitation of salmon is sustainable there. Recent extinctions of salmon in Scotland have occurred only in the west Highlands and Islands; indeed, I can give specific examples of extinctions. No similar extinctions have happened on the east or north coasts.

Sea trout, which are incredibly important to the rod fishing tourism industry on the west coast and the islands, have been hit far harder than salmon. All the large sea trout on which such fisheries depend have gone; they just do not exist anymore. Between June and September, those fish—and we are talking about fish of three and a half pounds—brought many thousands of anglers to the west coast and the islands, where tourism is extremely important. That sea trout tourism industry has gone; it has absolutely collapsed. There has been a decline in sea trout on the east and north coasts, but it is nothing like the decline on the west coast.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Hello, Mr Linley-Adams. I want to follow on from my colleague’s question and go back to the point about Marine Scotland. You will be aware that Marine Scotland has been able to inspect farms since 2007. Are you saying that it is ineffective and is not doing its job properly?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Our point is not that Marine Scotland is not doing its job properly. However, it is inspecting for the purpose of checking the welfare and health of the farmed fish, and it judges the parasite or sea lice control on a farm on that basis. If the farmed fish are okay, the farm is okay and there is no need for any sort of enforcement action. We are saying that a situation arises fairly regularly in which large farmed fish have a few parasites and the health and welfare of the farmed fish are not threatened but that still causes a very severe threat to the wild salmonids going past. Marine Scotland’s fish health inspectorate does a good job, but it does that within the constraints of its legal responsibilities.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is it too big a job for Marine Scotland to look at the wild fish as well? Is that outwith its scope? Are you saying that, legally, it cannot do that?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Legally, it cannot do that. Certainly, Marine Scotland has the expertise and its staff know what they are looking at when they go out to a farm. A lot of them will have spent many hours bobbing around on cages.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

So that is not in Marine Scotland’s remit.

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

It is not in its legal remit at the moment.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Okay.

What evidence do you have that some fish farms are not complying with the industry code? How do you know that they are not doing that properly?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

The aggregated sea lice data that is produced by the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation three months in arrears shows particular regions that are way over the threshold that is set in the code of good practice. The threshold is an average of either one or 0.5 adult female lice per fish, depending on what time of year it is. If the figure is up at 10, we can be sure that, within that collection of farms in a region, some at least must not be keeping sea lice numbers below the threshold. The code of good practice requires farmers to treat for lice when they hit the threshold—

Andrew Graham-Stewart Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

It advises that.

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Sorry. You are quite right—the code advises farmers to do that.

We can then look at the data that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency publishes on the Scotland’s aquaculture database, which lists when treatments are applied under particular controlled activities regulations licences. If we marry the two together, we can find regions where average lice numbers are way over the threshold but none of the farms appears to be treating. The implication must be that the farms are not responding to the voluntary code of good practice. It is difficult to point to a particular farm, because we do not have farm-specific data but, for an aggregation of 10 or 15 farms, we can say that pretty clearly.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

So specific monitoring is not available and it is not coming up to scratch.

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

It is there, but it is not publicly available. Under the Fish Farming Businesses (Record Keeping) (Scotland) Order 2008, fish farmers have to keep their own records for inspection by the fish health inspectorate. Unfortunately, because the records are held by the farmers and not by the Scottish Government or Marine Scotland, they are not accessible under freedom of information and environmental information regulations. The records are held by the farmers, ready for inspection, but they are not provided.

Andrew Graham-Stewart Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

I want to add something on the issue that Rona Mackay has been alluding to and the one that Angus MacDonald mentioned about five minutes ago. Clearly, enforcement notices may be served, but they do not seem to do any good. One example of that was in late 2014 when, in the area by Kyle of Lochalsh, the average number of adult female lice per farmed fish went up from around 10 to 15 and then 20, and it finally ended up at 40. By that point, when they went to slaughter, the fish would not have needed skinning—they cannot have had any skin left. However, for the farmed fish, that was deemed to be acceptable. One imagines that the fish health inspectorate sent out enforcement notices, but nothing happened. The farms just continued—this is Marine Harvest, with its farms by Kyle of Lochalsh—until such point as they decided to slaughter. When the level is at 40, the number of juvenile lice that would have been produced is mind boggling.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I might have missed this in the papers, but is there a treatment for sea lice, or is slaughter the only remedy?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

There are a variety of treatments, most of which are chemical-based. There is an in-feed treatment—something that is actually in the feed—but most of the treatments are bath-type treatments. An impermeable tarpaulin is hung around the cage, an organophosphate or a pyrethroid-based pesticide is put in the water and left for a couple of hours, then the tarpaulin is opened and the substance washes away. In that couple of hours, the organophosphate or pyrethroid kills the lice and they fall off the fish. It is a very difficult process—it is tough work.

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

Is it an expensive process?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Yes. As I said, it is also tough work. The operatives have to lug the tarpaulins around in what can be difficult weather conditions—it is not easy.

Andrew Graham-Stewart Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Figures came out recently for treating sea lice in the Faroes that showed that it costs the farmers there about €0.50 per kilo of fish. It is a substantial cost. The problem that we have with sea lice is that, as with any parasite, they are developing an immunity. In many areas, most of the chemical treatments no longer work for that reason, which is why farmers are trying things such as using wrasse as cleaner fish. However, the success of that has been patchy—when wrasse have been introduced, we have seen sea lice numbers increasing. It is a major problem.

Obviously, the farmers have their problems but the impact on wild fish continues. All that we are asking for is that, in those farms where the sea lice problem is out of control, something is done to make the farmers slaughter or cull early, or take drastic action to prevent large numbers of sea lice from spreading into the marine environment.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

Is there a danger to other sea life from the pesticides or chemicals used in the treatment?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

I started my association with aquaculture as a research student in 1991 in a laboratory in Aberdeen of what was then the Department of Agriculture and Fisheries for Scotland. To answer your question, there is strong evidence of resistance to the pesticides in non-target organisms. The pesticides are also extremely toxic to crustacea. That is what they are designed to do—they kill sea lice, which are a crustacean, as are lobsters, crabs and prawns. Therefore, there will be a negative effect on anything like that in the immediate vicinity when the tarpaulins are removed. Creel fishermen are alarmed by what they believe is a drop in the stock of their quarry because of the location of fish farms.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

So are you suggesting that culling is the most realistic solution?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Ultimately, the solution is closed containment, which means raising farmed fish in a way that ensures that they are completely biologically separated from wild fish. Marine Harvest is investing quite a lot of money in a “donut” project and an “egg” project—those terms relate to the shape of the construction. That firm is big enough to invest money in such projects, which are pointing in the right direction. The quicker we get to closed containment, the better. It will be better all round and will reduce the costs of production dramatically. Fish farming is a costly business. To train people to run open-net cages in hostile weather conditions all year round is an expensive business.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The petition calls for a threshold to be set on the number of sea lice on farmed fish to prevent damage to wild fish. The petition states that if the threshold is exceeded and treatment is not successful, farmers should have to harvest or cull the fish. What evidence is there to support adopting that approach in setting thresholds?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

The threshold is in the code of good practice at the moment, but the proposed subsequent culling or harvesting is not in it yet. However, that method is practised in Norway when they get a severe problem. It does not often result in the serving of a formal notice, because it is done informally. The Norwegian inspectors say, “We will serve a notice if you don’t do something here.” Early culling or harvesting is recognised in the industry as a way of ultimately dealing with a lice problem if it is out of control. We would like that approach to be taken not just when the prevalence of sea lice becomes a problem for the health and welfare of the farmed animal, but when it becomes a problem for wild fish. It is the gap between the two that concerns us.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The petition also refers to a relocation programme in 2008 that

“was allowed to run into the sand.”

What happened to that programme? Did any fish farms relocate?

10:00

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Relocating a fish farm is difficult. In the past, we have suggested that the Scottish Government should look at whether it has the requisite legal powers to assist with and facilitate the relocation of farms, because getting planning permission for a fish farm is a lengthy process. Fish farmers will obviously not want to relocate if they do not have to, because they have invested time, money and effort in getting the planning permission and various consents for their farm in the first place.

Farmers will admit privately that some farms are not ideal; they will say things such as, “That one is a particularly licey farm.” They would love to be away from such sites, because it would make their job easier, but getting consent and permission is difficult. However, we would not object if proper relocation occurred.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

You have said that there should be a renewed focus on moving to containment of all farmed salmon in Scotland, presumably with fish kept in tanks. Do you have any information about such an approach being adopted in other countries? Do you have any sense of what it would cost?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

There are closed-containment farms in operation in various locations. I can provide written information to the committee following today’s meeting. There are certainly examples in Norway. In fish farming journals, there are stories every other week about successful closed-containment operations starting up here, there and everywhere.

Ultimately, such an approach is bound to come in. If fish farmers have a closed-containment site, particularly on land, they do not need well boats, and they do not have to train their staff in detail on health and safety procedures involved in working at sea. They do not need all that life-saving equipment, nor do they face the difficulties of operating in the severe marine environment.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Presumably, a choice was made to set up fish farms as they are now rather than in the way that you describe. Despite all the downsides, fish farmers must have regarded that approach as better than the option that you are now proposing. Why would that be?

Guy Linley-Adams Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

At the time, it was the only option. I do not think that people believed that closed containment was possible, but the technologies have moved on. We have been farming trout on riversides in closed containment for years. Doing that for salmon is more difficult, but the technologies have moved on. I commend Marine Harvest for the amount of work that it is doing in that area.

Andrew Graham-Stewart Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

The initial capital cost for closed containment is substantial, but once that has been paid for, the on-going running costs are much reduced in comparison with the open-net systems.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you have any sense of the view of fish farmers as a community about that approach?

Andrew Graham-Stewart Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland
link

Marine Harvest is certainly very keen—it is investing very large sums in research into closed containment. There are various systems in Norway, and major programmes are under way.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Thank you—I think that we have covered all the questions. Are there any comments or suggestions about where we go next and any steps that we might wish to take?

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I would certainly be keen to hear the views of Marine Scotland and the Scottish Government, SEPA, the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation, the Atlantic Salmon Trust and the Association of Salmon Fishery Boards. Given some of the evidence that we heard earlier, I would also be keen to hear from the appropriate Norwegian ministry with regard to the farm-by-farm data system that it has introduced. Perhaps we could ask the Scottish Parliament information centre to look into that for us.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

It would be useful to get a sense of what is happening in other places, which are presumably wrestling with the same problems in terms of trying to get the balance right. Do members agree with those suggestions?

Members indicated agreement.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

In that case, I thank the witnesses for their attendance today. We will pursue the actions that we have described.

10:03 Meeting suspended.

10:05 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 50
  2. 10:00 New Petitions Petitions · 20
  3. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  4. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 20
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13
  8. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  9. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  13. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  14. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 14
  15. 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.