First, I thank the committee and its predecessor. This is the third petition that Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland has sent the committee’s way. The previous petition—PE1547, on coastal netting of salmonids—led ultimately this year to salmon conservation regulations with which we are delighted. The petition before that, which was also on aquaculture, was fed into the run-up to the passing of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013. That process was good; it shows the value of the committee’s work, and I thank it for all those efforts.
I also thank the clerks for the excellent guidance that we received before today. They told me strictly not to repeat the content of the petition verbatim. I will not do so; instead, I will bring the committee up to date with developments since we lodged the petition in December last year.
As the committee might know, sea lice data is published three months in arrears by the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation. It is aggregated data that explains the levels of sea lice on fish farms in the previous three months. In December last year, the percentage of Scottish production of salmon—the capacity of the farms in the affected regions—that had figures over the sea lice threshold in the “Code of Good Practice for Scottish Finfish Aquaculture” was 58.8 per cent. Since then, that percentage has risen. In the most recent data that we have, which is from March this year, the figure hit 66.4 per cent. In other words, two thirds of the production of Scottish salmon farms is operating at above the code of good practice threshold for the average number of female sea lice per fish—they are the egg-producing lice that cause the problem for wild fish by producing many juvenile sea lice.
The inexorable rise in sea lice problems continues and the control methods do not appear to be working. It is a problem that the data is aggregated, because any particular region can have up to 20 farms, so we do not know which farms are performing badly. Some better farms are controlling their sea lice well, but the flipside of the coin is that some very poor farms are completely failing to control sea lice, and we cannot identify them. Those issues were all aired at the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee in the run-up to the passing of the 2013 act, and that committee’s view was that the position should be kept under review and that farm-specific sea lice data should perhaps be published.
I should draw the committee’s attention to the fact that, only this week, the Norwegian Food Safety Authority has released an online real-time sea lice database that is accessible to the public and which contains farm-specific data on treatment and where the problems are. That is far in advance of the Scottish system and I commend it to committee members if they have time to investigate it. Unfortunately, the website is only in Norwegian at the moment, which makes it a little more difficult to use.
Touching briefly on another issue, I note that the committee has received a submission from Callander McDowell. There are all sorts of other debates about the science, such as whether there is an effect and whether we can show an effect on wild populations. Marine Scotland science, the Government’s fisheries science division, has produced a useful five-page summary of the science document. The clerks have a copy of that document, which I hope will be circulated to the committee after the meeting.
That summary says:
“Salmon aquaculture can result in elevated numbers of sea lice in open water and hence is likely to increase the infestation potential on wild salmonids. This in turn could have an adverse effect on populations of wild salmonids in some circumstances. The magnitude of any such impact in relation to overall mortality levels is not known for Scotland. However, concerns that there may be a significant impact of aquaculture have been raised due to declines in catches of both salmon and sea trout on the Scottish west coast. There is scientific evidence that individual Scottish sea trout can experience physiological detrimental burdens of salmon lice in areas with salmon aquaculture but the effects on populations in different areas is not known. Scientific evidence from Norway and Ireland indicates that early protection against salmon lice parasitism results in reduced absolute marine mortality, increasing recapture rates of experimental salmon, and reduces the time spent at sea, indicating that salmon lice can influence the population status of wild salmon.”
I will read that last bit again:
“salmon lice can influence the population status of wild salmon.”
That is not our conclusion nor the conclusion of the aquaculture body but the conclusion of Marine Scotland science. If it is able to conclude that, we suggest that we need a precautionary approach and as strict a control as possible on sea lice in Scottish aquaculture in order to protect an extremely valuable asset for Scotland: the wild salmonid population.
Only this month, the North Atlantic Salmon Conservation Organization met in Germany. Scotland was represented, and the Scottish Government came forward with proposals for higher thresholds for escalation plans and potentially reducing biomass at farms. However, the levels at which those steps would take effect were much higher than all the other aquaculture nations represented thought was sensible. Scotland’s system for the control of sea lice is recognised as being the most lax, compared to the Norwegians, the Irish and so on. We would like to see the system tightened up and brought into line with the other salmon farming and producing nations.
Our petition asks for a statutory duty to be placed on Scottish ministers to regulate farmed fish for the express purpose of protecting wild fish. At the moment, all the legislation is pointed at the health and welfare of the farmed animal, not wild fish, and we think that ministers should have such a duty and the requisite powers. We would like the relocation programme, which identifies farms that are in the wrong place, to be rejuvenated. It rather ran into the sand in 2008 and has not gone much further. We believe that if that could be done, an awful lot of progress could be made.
I want to put it on record that Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland is not trying to shut down the aquaculture industry. We get accused of that a lot, but we are not in that business. We recognise just how important aquaculture is to Scotland, and what we would like to do is to make it more sustainable so that wild fish can thrive alongside the industry.