The first continued petition is PE1319, from Willie Smith and Scott Robertson, on improving youth football in Scotland. Before we discuss the petition, I should let members know that I have been aware of the petition since my time as the member for Glasgow Pollok and I have known Willie Smith for many years, not just through the petition but through his work in youth football in that community.
The petition is one of the oldest that we have before us, and it is evident that a lot of useful work has been done on it. That said, I am keen for us to make progress on the issues that remain outstanding and to be proactive in seeking views and information from relevant stakeholders. The Scottish Football Association and the Scottish Professional Football League have outlined the actions that they intend to take, and we also have a response from the Scottish Government—a letter from the minister Aileen Campbell. The suggestion from the Government, the SFA and the SPFL is that time should be allowed to see how the measures work before external regulation is considered. It would be useful to ask the Government, the SFA and the SPFL for information about the timetable for introducing the measures and assessing whether they are working.
It is fair to say that other stakeholders have a different view on whether the measures that have been suggested adequately address the concerns that the petition raises. It would therefore be useful to get views from the Professional Footballers Association Scotland and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, as well as youth and school football organisations. We know from correspondence that the petitioners and others do not feel that the views of the Scottish Government, the SFA and the SPFL reflect what is actually happening. I would welcome comments or suggestions from members.
There is an issue in football with the turnover of children under the age of 16 through clubs and the way in which that is sometimes handled—that has always been a bit of a concern. Clubs identify kids as young as nine, 10 or 11 and cull them annually. I am concerned about the impact that that has on the kids and their ability not just to participate in football but to move on to other sports. I make the general comment that the way in which many football clubs deal with youth is not particularly helpful.
The petition highlights the issue, but it only scratches the surface. It pertains particularly to football, but there is an impact across all activity. The rejection of kids that happens in football clubs has been shown anecdotally to have a negative impact on youth across the board.
A number of issues have been raised through the petition, but the live issue is the ability of clubs to take young people on one-year contracts that end up being three-year contracts, under which they are not paid and are not allowed to play for their local teams. One thing that exercises the petitioners is the idea that the clubs will retain that right, even under the proposals that have been made by the SFA, the SPFL and the Scottish Government. Under those proposals, although players could play for their local teams, there would be a welfare clause. If we give the football clubs a welfare clause, they will exercise that if they want to protect their investment.
I think that Brian Whittle is referring to the issue of clubs bringing in a number of children in order to get one that they think might be a star. The clubs then reject the rest, which puts those children off sport and does not allow them to be involved in sport locally.
I note that quite a lot of kids are allowed to play only for their club but do not get a chance to play for that club. What kids at that age want to do is kick a ball, but they are not getting the opportunity to do that in a competitive environment. How do we deal with that? If someone aged 13, 14 or 15 is not getting a game and all that they are doing is sitting on the bench, that has to be a welfare issue. When do they get the opportunity to play football?
It is a question of managing the tension between local football teams nurturing young people and big clubs coming in and taking them. Competition is an issue. There are a lot of complicated issues, but my sense is that the petitioners do not feel that the responses that they have received on what is to happen next genuinely reflect where the organisations are. Do committee members have specific proposals for action?
I agree with your suggestion, convener, that the relevant people should be brought in and listened to. We could invite PFA Scotland, the Scottish Schools Football Association, the Scottish Youth Football Association and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland to give their views.
It might be an idea to give the clubs an opportunity to put their case across. I am not suggesting that we invite all the SPFL clubs, but we could invite one or two in order to understand what they are trying to do.
Others will know more about this than I do, but I sense that the SFA and the SPFL are at the mercy of what the clubs want. They may have a policy, but it will be for the clubs collectively to agree to it, and that might be slightly more challenging.
The players union is quoted in Aileen Campbell’s letter as having been actively engaged, but it would be worth checking with it what its level of engagement is.
Given the responses that we have had from the SFA, the SPFL and the minister, it would be worth while for us to ask the other organisations that have been named for their responses and to take further evidence. As members have said, we could ask for more information from the petitioners, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, the PFA Scotland, the SFA and the Scottish Youth Football Association with a view to having an evidence session later.
William Smith and Scott Robertson dispute a number of the minister’s comments—particularly the claim that
“PFA Scotland were included in ‘extensive discussions’”
with Scottish Government officials. The letter goes on to raise other concerns about statements in the minister’s letter. I am keen to have the minister’s response on those disputed comments to help to move the situation forward.
That is another excellent suggestion. We are clear that we want to continue to look at the issue and to explore further the gap between what the minister believes to be the case and what the petitioners and others believe to be the case. Is that agreed?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.