Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 351–400
  1. Gerald Hallam 3 Jan 2015
    We need to increase the measures we take to conserve fish stocks and allow them to increase.
  2. Callum S. S. Highet 3 Jan 2015
    I have to say even though I have only been salmon and sea trout fishing for the last 5years, there is a noticeable decline in fish numbers entering the Scottish rivers and waterway systems. I am passionate about salmon fishing and would love to share future experiences with my children. However, I fear that the continuing of netting and killing of fish is not aiding any improvements to save our wild stocks. An additional thing to consider is the livelihoods of the ghillies who profession it is to put us as clients over the fish. If there are no fish, then less and less fishermen or women will be participating in this amazing sport. I have to say I personally have no interest in keeping salmon I catch. The satisfaction I receive from releasing a fish is worth more than its weight on the table. I do also understand that it is nice to have a fish for the table now and again, but when I see large hen fish being killed it really gets to me. Imagine all the salmon that could potentially have that DNA to grow big and strong.

    I would love to spend days fishing for salmon with my children one day which is why I strongly agree with this petition.
  3. Bob Turner 3 Jan 2015
    Salmon are far more valuable to the Scottish economy alive rather than dead.
  4. Dale Robinson 3 Jan 2015
    i won't be returning to fish in Scotland until something is done about netting
  5. Rich Knoles 3 Jan 2015
    Wild Salmon stocks are very important to me as a visiting angler. Surely the tourism dollars have a bigger impact on local economies.
  6. John Rogerson 3 Jan 2015
    Refuse to sign on this occasion. Associating rod anglers alongside nets is categorically wrong! Anglers are the Salmons only remaining 'friend' yet we always feel the full force of useless restrictions which only paint the false picture that the authorities care! Sorry.
  7. Peter Gavan 3 Jan 2015
    Preserving and enhancing wild fish stocks must have a higher priority from this and future governments. The current neglect is similar to the delay in officially recognising the health dangers of smoking.
  8. Martin Webster 3 Jan 2015
    The situation is dire. Please take action to rebuild this vital element of your rich environment and to protect the livelihood of huge numbers of people dependent on fishing tourism.
  9. Jamie Lindsay 3 Jan 2015
    Thanks Ian. All the best
  10. Andy DICKSON 3 Jan 2015
    This is even more essential after 2014 seasons disastrous salmon run
  11. IAN ROBINSON 3 Jan 2015
    the free run of wild Scottish salmon is an essential part of the Scottish Spirit and continued economic survival of the countryside
  12. Christopher Bruyns 3 Jan 2015
    Tourism or Salmon, Scottish Government that's what this is really about. You cannot have both ! Tourism and it's benefits will always win. Leave the fish alone ! ! !
  13. Wilhelmina Wilson 3 Jan 2015
    There are so few fish about and a lot of jobs are at stake if netting started again. It is pretty bad without the netting
  14. david hutchinson 3 Jan 2015
    last year was the first for many years we did not visit Scotland as fish stocks have dropped at an alarming rate, before this we visited for 3 or 4 weeks every year, all netting must be stopped
    we removed 2 nets and gave to keeper on our last visit .
  15. John Mangelschots 3 Jan 2015
    Beide the ban on netting, also a regulation for ecological salmon farming and a limitation on catching migrating salmon on high seas must be instaled.
  16. Anton Pousar 3 Jan 2015
    If you're not up for the enviromental side, please take a look on economical side of salmon. Hundreds of anglers around the world, like me, come to Scotland just because of salmon fishing. You don't wan't loose your moneys.
  17. Ian Bunch 3 Jan 2015
    Salmon fishing is getting worse every year. It would be great to actually catch a fish in order to return it.
    There are plenty of reared fish without depleting stocks of wild fish by netting.
    Hope your petition works
    - good luck
  18. John Leigh 3 Jan 2015
    Well done Ian Gordon a high profile fisher leading the fight on behalf of Fishers and Conservationists
    Keep up the good work
  19. John Lewis 3 Jan 2015
    Yes, we must certainly deal with the problem of over-netting and other methods, but the Scottish Government and its agencies (SEPA, SNH, etc.) must also take a much firmer stance against fish farms with respect to sea lice infestations and the use of toxic pesticides, which scientific research has clearly shown to have disastrous effects on wild salmon both at sea and in spawning rivers close to fish farms. This is an acute problem along the whole of the West Coast of Scotland and its islands. I know because I live in this area of Scotland!
  20. Allan mcleod. Paphos Cyprus ex Arbroath Scotland 3 Jan 2015
    My plan's were to come back to scotland fishing every year specifically on the North Esk,Tay and Dee. Unfortunately until the goverment take some actions and provide help for our rivers instead of throwing nets up for a few fishermen on the coast to profit from i will not be back.
  21. Nick Millard 3 Jan 2015
    The rivers become emptier as the years roll by. Such a pity for all those concerned in game fishing. Such a pity for the Atlantic Salmon essentially.
  22. Suzanne Kelly 3 Jan 2015
    Last May I went out with USAN to see their salmon netting operations. I found it cruel but still better than the life farmed salmon get. Fish are trapped, hauled up and clubbed to death as they suffocate. They may only be fish, but they are assuredly sentient and they were terrified and they suffered. The bigger picture is the low number of salmon making it from the sea back into the rivers and happily the Scottish Govt agreed something needed to be done. Ian Gordon's petition was a success, salmon now can't be killed before April. He's now trying to push for a shorter season still. I am convinced that too many wild salmon are taken from the research I have done. The nets are massive we are no longer talking about the simple heritable right to fish, this is on a huge scale.
  23. RICHARD BRAMBLE 3 Jan 2015
    Help save dwindling wild Salmon stocks, let the fish run up the rivers to spawn, conserve what wild Salmon we have left for future generations, rather than netting what we have left for short term financial gains. No wild salmon means no fisherman and the loss of sustainable vital jobs and income to Scottish communities.
  24. hector maclennan 3 Jan 2015
    it might be possible to monitor the taking of wild fish by net by obtaining information about the availability of salmon at wholesale distributers such as Billingsgate. Trout and Salmom Mag reported that at one time the price in mid summer of wild fish at Billingsgate stood at £2 a lb suggesting a glut of fish and a netting bonanza as low rivers resulted in high concentrations of fish in netting areas. I suggest that it is just possible that all netting returns are not quite accurate! It might be possible to monitor their catch through available market statistics?
  25. Richard Collins 3 Jan 2015
    Security question impossible to read from very substandard photograph.
  26. Dr David William Wall 3 Jan 2015
    Unless firm action is taken we will find that wild Atlantic salmon become extinct. The coastal salmon nets need to come off as they have a devastating effect
    - as figures for salmon entering the rivers in 2013 and 2014 are now showing.
  27. william feltham 3 Jan 2015
    hope you win.
  28. carl ohrman 3 Jan 2015
    I have been forced to travel to oversea destinations to catch a salmon-- when i would prefer my money went to the Scotland.
  29. Andy morris 3 Jan 2015
    What's sad is that the goverment can spend millions discussing the future of scotland, spend millions on a swanky parliament building , spend millions discussing its green commitments and credentials but yet they cannot commit to clear obligations around the most sought after asset they have ever had the responsibility of protecting . The wild Scottish salmon is and hopefully will remain an opportunity for the Scottish parliament to lead the world in protecting this important fish that will always be synonymous with Scotland . The alternate strategy is to simply not act and the income Scotland enjoys from the salmon industry shifts to other countries who work harder to protect migratory fish. Lets all act now to repair the levels and protect the income for Scotland
  30. Rune Rudolf Runnerstrom 3 Jan 2015
    Think of the future. They will thank you for thinking of the wild Salmon.
  31. Robert Burkhard 3 Jan 2015
    I will not visit Scotland until the Scottish Government move to conserve the wild salmon and sea trout. Netting spawning salmon is killing off, not fishing.
  32. Keith Robertson 3 Jan 2015
    Netting is only one of the problems radical action needs to be taken before the scottish rivers are debunked of migratory fish.
  33. Jeff Hirst 3 Jan 2015
    Netting contributes little to the economy and negates conservation of the salmon. Natural predators need to be controlled as well.
  34. Nicholas Forman Hardy 3 Jan 2015
    Wild salmon stocks are following a continual decline and the action of the Scottish Government not to accept the situation and to everything they can to try and protect this seriously threatened species is a disgrace and a blow to the Scottish economy in the Highlands. It is time they got their act together and behaved responsibly
  35. sean nason 3 Jan 2015
    we must do everything possible to protect future stocks.
  36. sean nason 3 Jan 2015
    my last few fishing visits to scotland have been so poor i will have to consider where to spend hard earned cash if things dont improve in a big way.
  37. Matt Harris 3 Jan 2015
    The future of local economies up and down Scotland as well as future of the wild salmon itself depends upon the Scottish government recognising that we must protect these fish by every means possible. Please recognise this and act immediately and decisively to save Scotland's wild salmon stocks before it is too late.
  38. John Richardson 3 Jan 2015
    must stop all coastal netting immediately
  39. Gary Keys 3 Jan 2015
    Good luck Ian Gordon, supporting you from Northern Ireland, keep up the fight.
  40. Jonothan Croft 3 Jan 2015
    Is it not the time that Politicians realised that aside from the direct conservation of an endangered species, the economic benefits of Salmon conservation far out way the specific needs of nets man who can be compensated.
  41. Jonathan Ellerbeck 3 Jan 2015
    How long will it take to get the Scottish Government to realise the long term harm they are causing. The numbers travelling to Scotland are already dwindling. The impact on local economies, and therefore communities, will be far reaching. It's so sad to see a lack of response by those given the responsibility of leadership.
  42. charles auld 3 Jan 2015
    The combination of stopping coastal netting along with compulsory catch and release policy as seen on the Dee would transform salmon fishing in Scotland to its former glory
  43. Christine Ilesley 3 Jan 2015
    I would plead with the Scottish Government to safeguard and protect this wonderful wild species. Please look at what countries like Iceland and Norway have done to preserve and protect both Atlantic Salmon and the tourism associated with it. To allow netting to resume would be short term and foolish and would decimate both salmon stocks and the tourism industry.
  44. Mike Heaps 3 Jan 2015
    Given the disastrous year for salmon fishing in Scotland last season the Scottish Government must do all in its power to protect this valuable resource for the benefit of the economy
  45. Tom Sterling 3 Jan 2015
    Please act to protect this iconic species which is so much a part of what is the very essence of Scotland and Scotishness. Remember too, that all over the world, Scotland is perceived to be the home of salmon angling, the place where the sport was developed, so it must be in the forefront to protect this wonderful creature!
  46. Stephen Hey 3 Jan 2015
    Keep up the pressure!! Rod fishing is currently an underestimated economic resource if your a Salmond supporter!
  47. Noel Kelly 3 Jan 2015
    Scotland should protect its treasures and The wild Salmon are such treasures
  48. Mark firth 3 Jan 2015
    I believe Scottish Salmon to be at a tipping point. All sides must put away petty politics and unite in protecting such a precious asset, which should not be at the mercy of incompetence, petty jealousies, factional politics or intolerance. The ability and will is there to address this positively. Failure to do so will lead to condemnation of those who have the opportunity at their fingertips. There should be no sides In this debate. surely we all want the same thing. Scotland needs salmon. End of.
  49. Lauren Kingsley 3 Jan 2015
    Unless netting is prohibited, the jobs, the tradition, the tourism, and the legendary sporting destinations -- will all be gone, and gone for good. Yet nothing compares to the certain loss of this magnificent wild creature that has been struggling against aquaculture and illegal netting all over the north Atlantic. Scotland, please be an example, please lead the world in smart conservation of a resource that in many ways has been part of your cultural identity.
  50. Robert D Richard 3 Jan 2015
    Save the Atlantic Salmon from becoming extinct. Stop the coastal netting and help preserve a way of life.