Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01547 · Session 4

Conserving Scottish wild salmon

Closed Submitted 12 Dec 2014 Rural Affairs
Signatures
0
8,768 online signatures with a country
Comments
795
Considered
7 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government
(i) in the interests of salmon conservation, and on a precautionary basis, to request Scottish Ministers to use their powers immediately under the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003 Act to ensure that no Atlantic salmon are killed in Scotland for a period of five years from 2015 if possible, by 2016 if not
- by either nets or rods
- before 1st July; and
(ii) in the case of fishing for salmon by coastal netting, to take such steps as are necessary to bring to an end the exploitation of wild salmon by Mixed Stock Fisheries at any time of year, in line with Scotland’s international commitments and obligations.

What the petitioner did first

The Petitioner has been very heavily involved over many years with the Scottish Government in both formal and informal consultation in order to promote the conservation of early-running wild Atlantic salmon.
The Salmon & Trout Association (Scotland) gave very detailed evidence to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, both written and oral, during the passage of the Aquaculture and Fisheries Act 2013, to the Wild Fisheries Review (‘the Thin Review’) on how the conservation and management of Scottish wild salmon may be improved and in direct relation to the date to which exploitation of wild salmon should be prevented by Scottish Government under Annual Close Time Orders and Salmon Conservation Regulations.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Feb 2015
    1 mention
  2. 4 Mar 2015
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2
    1 mention
  3. 11 Mar 2015
    1 mention
  4. 28 May 2015
    1 mention
  5. 3 Jun 2015
    1 mention
  6. 9 Mar 2016
    1 mention
  7. 30 Jun 2016
    1 mention

Signatures by country

8,768 online signatures
  1. England2,885 32.9%
  2. Scotland2,433 27.7%
  3. United Kingdom1,288 14.7%
  4. Northern Ireland226 2.6%
  5. Ireland224 2.6%
  6. United States219 2.5%
  7. Germany184 2.1%
  8. France180 2.1%
  9. Wales180 2.1%
  10. Canada170 1.9%
  11. 61 other countries779 8.9%

Comments

795 comments, oldest first
795 comments · showing 301–350
  1. Brian Scott 23 Dec 2014
    why have we as humans hunted so many animals to near extinction then only do something about it when it's too late. Let's not make this the case with Atlantic Salmon
  2. John Moses 23 Dec 2014
    stricter control of salmon farms and their positioning
  3. Peter Morris 23 Dec 2014
    We MUST give the wild Atlantic Salmon a chance to survive.At the present rate of progress it won't and our generation will be to blame!!!
  4. Ian Cooke 24 Dec 2014
    I firmly believe that this action is neccessary to protect an iconic species that is on the brink. For many years we have tinkered with the problem of falling salmon numbers and not really addressed the key issues. We know we have a major problem with salmon survival at sea so the very least we can do is ensure that returning salmon have the best possible chance of completing their life cycle whilst we continue to the science and investigations at sea to undersatnd just what is going on. I'm afraid that the loss of jobs in the salmon netting industry will come all to soon if we choose not to take meaninful action.
  5. Michael Abbott 24 Dec 2014
    Stop coastal netting
  6. John Siddons 24 Dec 2014
    Ban all coastal and river mouth nets and stop netting at sea for 5 years. Rod caught fish are not the problem !!!!!
  7. Simon Bostock 24 Dec 2014
    We are seeing yet more evidence of man's endless damaging activities which threaten yet more this wonderful fish. We have the scientific research and evidence to know what to do. In this instance it is to limit the level of exploitation, especially by netting. Angling too must play a part. There must be no killing of fish by either method before 1 July each year pending evidence of a full recovery of stocks. I urge full support of this petition.
  8. Robin Whysall 24 Dec 2014
    In addition to this petition greatest effort must be made to prevent trawling salmon at sea. This must be the greatest cause of their demise than any other single factor.
  9. Willam Hartnett 24 Dec 2014
    Salmon fishing in Scotland is a serious concern the fish are not in the abundance that they once were, predation by birds of the juvenile fish in rivers, feeding habits offshore, contamination from farm fish cages plus general diminishing fish population and then the outmoded netting practices are killing this natural phenomena
    the Scottish government should encourage the ban and take action in regard to safeguarding this wild species
  10. Richard Ferrier 25 Dec 2014
    The future of the wild Salmon is in our hands, so act today and secure its future for all to enjoy, fishers and non-fishers.
  11. Brian Fraser 25 Dec 2014
    In our area of Wester Ross the last nets man told me that he started fishing the nets just as the fish farm was getting started and admits he hadn't got a clue what he was doing and caught over 3.000 salmon. Ten years later he did know what he was doing and struggled to catch 300 fish that was in his opinion the effect fish farms had on the salmon and trout in Wester Ross.
  12. Patrick Cowan 25 Dec 2014
    It has all been said many times before, and now it is imperative that action is taken
  13. David Watson 26 Dec 2014
    Please take action to stop the Scottish Government continuing to be the world pariah on Atlantic Salmon conservation.
  14. Harold Tonge 26 Dec 2014
    its the salmon by catch that is the ultimate destroyer of these, we need marine protection areas and passages where no fish can be caught and sold.
  15. David Cosh 26 Dec 2014
    We must give the salmon chance to run the rivers and regenerate.
  16. Alex Barnes 26 Dec 2014
    Please sort this out before we have to put Salmon on the endangered species list.
  17. John L Pape 26 Dec 2014
    all coastal netting should be banned
  18. Colin West 26 Dec 2014
    With no quotas on salmon netsmen, they take unlimited numbers of salmon and seatrout . This, along with the damage done by sealice from salmon farms are placing an unsustainable strain on the survival of these wild populations. Protection for them is essential.
  19. Cecil John Duguid 27 Dec 2014
    Not only must the coastal netting be stopped till at least the end of June the netting stations must have strict quotas to adhere to and a fish tagging system should be seriously looked into in the UK. Plus a international restriction of the plundering at sea of the food supply which all salmon need when they smolt. The food which is taken by the factory ships is not controlled in any way and this is used to feed Farmed Salmon, in the esturys which is causing pollution on the bottom and
    #sea lice numbers are NOT being controlled or dealt with. Which the powers that be are turning a blind eye to for a short time gain. As for hatcheries and all the talk from scientist,s about hatchey fish being inferior, the more fish that go to sea assuming they have food to eat when they get to the feeding grounds will return, the fish that do return cannot be that inferior. The Icelandic smolt rivers are doing very well from there progammes. Goverments please note it.
  20. James SD leach 28 Dec 2014
    Simply not killing fish is only half the answer. More has to be done about the habitat
  21. Jim McLanaghan 28 Dec 2014
    Whilst this course of action is certainly required there also needs to be some action on salmon farming around the coast of Scotland as whole. The Government should take note of this!
  22. Peter Keeling 28 Dec 2014
    Fish stocks are very low these days and anything to preserve the numbers.
  23. Stephen Ottridge 28 Dec 2014
    The Scottish Government need to act now to reduce the numbers of wild salmon being killed predominantly by both netsmen and through the effects of the aquaculture industry
    - as a matter of some urgency. Anglers, who play a significant part in supporting Scotland's tourist industry, are currently releasing in excess of 75-80% of salmon caught in the interests of salmon conservation. It is now time for the Scottish Government to lead by example in the interest of salmon conservation too as a failure to act now would be seen as being grossly irresponsible.
  24. Catherine Horgan 29 Dec 2014
    Great idea, to slow down life is important as it will have larger benefits for the future, its one of our main challenges for our children, wishing all luck to all!
  25. Linda Martin 29 Dec 2014
    The Atlantic Salmon is severely threatened. Game anglers on my local river are practising catch and release, taking fish only for "stripping" for breeding purposes, or abstaining from Salmon fishing altogether. Without an equivalent commitment from the net-fishermen, this magnificent animal may well become extinct. This situation has not been helped by the increase in the seal population, and the harvesting of sand-eels for fuelling power stations. Compensate the netsmen if need-be, but let us do what we can for the Atlantic Salmon and hope that it is not too late.
  26. Hamish Mackenzie 29 Dec 2014
    I fully support this petition.
  27. Peter McDermott 30 Dec 2014
    We must do all that we can to preserve our salmon.This must include full on lobbying to the international predators of the Atlantic Salmon during its ocean life cycle. Both the species and its food source are being plundered to extinction.
  28. James Scott-Clarke 31 Dec 2014
    I hope the pollution caused by the fish farms is part of this.
  29. Stuart Wright 31 Dec 2014
    The Scottish Government should immediately stop all coastal netting if they want to ensure the long term viability of the salmon rod fishing tourist industry.
  30. mark husson 31 Dec 2014
    without further control of netting, the latest generation of gillies, guides, river keepers, hoteliers, inn keepers, caterers, estate cleaners etc, will be the last. the relatively small number of netsman will have to be offered retraining.
  31. Chris Bowers 31 Dec 2014
    I will never visit Scotland again until the Scottish Government takes positive action to conserve the wild salmon and sea trout stocks. Part of my holiday was to fish for these species, there is no point in travelling to Scotland just to play golf.
  32. John Allen 31 Dec 2014
    I will not be spending any more of my hard earned visiting Scotland until I see sustained action by the Scottish Government to redress the damage they have caused and continue to cause to wild migratory fishing.
  33. Ann Allen 31 Dec 2014
    I will never visit Scotland again until the Scottish Government takes positive action to conserve the wild salmon and sea trout stocks. Part of my holiday was to fish for these species, there is no point in travelling to Scotland just for the scenery you get see that in many other places and play excellent links golf courses.
  34. Nicholas LeRougetel 31 Dec 2014
    We have a duty as custodians for future generations to protect all wild fish.
  35. Colin Scott-Dempster 31 Dec 2014
    Well done. All strength to your cause in working for us all. I have longer for some action in this vital battle against the Scottish Government's dire attitude and hypocritical stance,
  36. Steve Smith 31 Dec 2014
    Less Salmond and Sturgeon... more salmon! I wont be spending my money in Scotland until this lunacy stops.
  37. Hugh Berridge 31 Dec 2014
    Should not similar restrictions be placed upon the killing of seatrout whose numbers have declined steeply over the last 30 or so years, and particularly so since 2000?
  38. Charles van der Lande 31 Dec 2014
    Following the decline in Salmon catches in recent years, I have decided not to return to Scotland in 2015 with my usual party of fishers.
  39. Michael Bullough 1 Jan 2015
    Excellent plan to save the salmon and the many jobs that go with the visiting fishermen
  40. Lionel Young 1 Jan 2015
    It is difficult to justify the very high cost of salmon fishing in Scotland when the catches continue to decrease year on year. This high revenue earner for the local economies will soon cease unless the Scottish Parliament acts decisively on the matter.
  41. David Coates 1 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Government should understand the value of salmon fishing to the wider community.
  42. Charles Homan 2 Jan 2015
    For over 25 years six keen fishers have injected many tens of thousands of pounds into the local economies along with many others. We have not killed a fish for a long time nor in the last few years hardly caught any! We request the Scottish Government to take urgent action to prevent the looming extinction of a beautiful wild animal. If there is no positive legislation to slow the demise of wild salmon in Scotland, then like like many others we will sadly follow our salmon fishing interests abroad. Very regrettable for us but more hurtful to the local communities and economies that game fishing supports.
  43. Wolfgang Lehnert 2 Jan 2015
    God will be safe the nice scottish nature, i hope!!
  44. Patrick Hoy 2 Jan 2015
    I first learnt to love Scotland as an apprentice in 1951 and my annual fishing holiday is something I treasured. I find it hard to believe that those promoting such short sighted change are in the real world.
  45. Richard Vainer 2 Jan 2015
    How can you justify sticking a hook into a wonderful creature as a Salmon towing it around a pool and often damaging it in the release process.......rather than debasing it to the level of a mere toy it wouldd be far more honest to suspend fishing entirely for a period in tandem with proper predator control and a more honest governmental approach to the problem1
  46. Alistair ferguson 3 Jan 2015
    Soimple idea but high time it was put in forse
  47. Simon Evans 3 Jan 2015
    Although I live in Wales, I currently spend over 2,000 pounds each year fishing for salmon in Scotland. Unless numbers are protected at a time of record low marine survival there will be no reason for me to bring my money to Scotland.
  48. Duncan Gordon-Colebrooke 3 Jan 2015
    The Scottish Govt. has done enough damage already. Please let us stop them doing any more.
  49. David Ward 3 Jan 2015
    Apart from the control of netting and rod caught fish, there also needs to be control of the seal population which has got totally out of hand. When you see hundreds of seals sittiing on the sands in some areas and then do some simple maths to estimate the amount of fish they eat per day, it is amazing any fish make it into the rivers.
  50. alan.roe 3 Jan 2015
    They also need to be getting rid of those vastly polluting Norwegian salmon farms of the west coast you notice that the Norwegian Government won't allow them in their waters!!!