Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01519 · Session 4

Save Scotland's Seals

Closed Submitted 5 Mar 2014 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
12,687 online signatures with a country
Comments
685
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop issuing licences permitting salmon farming, salmon netting and salmon angling interests to shoot and kill seals in Scottish waters and instead require that salmon farmers either move their farms into on-shore tank systems or legally require marine salmon farmers to install and maintain the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets they require to meet their legal obligation under the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 to protect their stock from the attention of predators. We further ask that the Scottish Parliament ask the Scottish Government to legislate to close down all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters thus allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed.

What the petitioner did first

We have written to the relevant Government Ministers and Marine Scotland on numerous occasions over the last four years asking them to stop licensing the killing of seals in Scotland and to make it illegal to kill seals. Sadly our requests have all been turned down and we now wish to show that there is public support for the end of legal seal killing in Scotland. We intend to contribute to the current fisheries review but we understand this is concentrating on issues raised by angling interests, many of which are pro seal shooting, and not very relevant to our campaign to end seal shooting.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Jun 2014
    1 mention
  2. 28 Oct 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 3 Dec 2014
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
    1 mention
  4. 10 Dec 2014
    1 mention

Signatures by country

12,687 online signatures
  1. England3,507 27.6%
  2. United States2,305 18.2%
  3. United Kingdom1,622 12.8%
  4. Scotland1,268 10%
  5. Australia726 5.7%
  6. Canada403 3.2%
  7. Wales227 1.8%
  8. Germany212 1.7%
  9. Netherlands184 1.5%
  10. Spain156 1.2%
  11. 111 other countries2,077 16.4%

Comments

685 comments, oldest first
685 comments · showing 201–250
  1. Crystal Mathies (Scotsman in California) 26 Apr 2014
    Please stop allowing the seals to be killed. They are a valuable part of the ecosystem and nature in general. Killing them is cruel and unnecessary.
  2. Renee Peel 26 Apr 2014
    There is no need for all this aggression and there is certainly no NEED to kill the seals doing what is absolutely natural, the abuse by man to animals in their natural environment has become a crime against nature.
  3. susan ballarini 26 Apr 2014
    please protect the seals
  4. Aaron Ingebrigtsen 26 Apr 2014
    Stop killing defenseless seal babies! That's not Hunting, that's cowardly baby slaughter!
  5. Simon Nicoll-Griffith 26 Apr 2014
    Like the badger cull, you can not keep on killing the wildlife to suit your profit margins
  6. Barry Terry 26 Apr 2014
    If this is the price we pay for buying your farmed salmon YOU CAN STUFF IT
  7. sharon hesford 26 Apr 2014
    Please do not allow any further killing of seals in Scottish waters. It has no place in modern society seals will always eat fish it is up to the salmon farmers to protect their stock not kill seals for what comes naturally.. Thank you
  8. kathy hallinan 26 Apr 2014
    stop killing the seals, the tourists will come to see them.....the world is in favor of stopping killing them ..from san francisco, ca- in fishermans wharf they love the sea lions now....save your seals for the world to come and visit ....the salmon will be happy too
  9. Jill Goessling 26 Apr 2014
    Please STOP this travesty!
  10. Ashley Marie Reese 26 Apr 2014
    Scotland, stop this cruelty!
  11. Irene Galicia 26 Apr 2014
    God put animals into this world for human mankind to care for. What happened to human mankind? So, many are living in the dark vs the light. So many are following the dark vs the light. As the Bible says, "There are the evil and wicked in this world" God, vividly states in the Bible, "These are the ones He will send to the pit" I am a steward of His creation.
  12. s karg 26 Apr 2014
    unbelievable barbarians still living here in EU
  13. Sandra Williston 26 Apr 2014
    The Scottish Government needs to legislate the closure of all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters, allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed!
  14. Manu Vaillant 26 Apr 2014
    This is not a way to behave with our fellow earth inhabitants...
  15. kun kang 26 Apr 2014
    this is old ancient barbarian act. there are many ways humans can survive without this act. please stop.
  16. Sarah Plocek 26 Apr 2014
    These animals already have enough stress on their lives from global warming.
  17. PERSON christel 26 Apr 2014
    protection
  18. vicky frederick 27 Apr 2014
    have a heart close down
  19. Daniel Tham 27 Apr 2014
    stop killing seals
  20. Elizabeth Dana 27 Apr 2014
    This is an unnecessary act of barbaric species killing for profit to "special interests". We no longer need fur to keep warm or seal meat to keep from starving so why is this being done? Because Jennifer Lopez wants to show off her cosmetically altered body in dead fur and Japanese men think seal meat will increase their sexual performance??? Scotland has thousands of years of fighting injustice and She should pick up Her sword and fight this with a clean stroke of the pen !
  21. Karen Morris 27 Apr 2014
    I will do anything to make this world a better place to live!
  22. Abigail Bengston 27 Apr 2014
    I will actively promote the boycott of products from Scottish fisheries until the government stops issuing licences to kills seals.
  23. Janine Cowie 27 Apr 2014
    The killing of seals is not an appropriate solution. More foresight is needed to deal with this issue. I support the proposal put forward by John F. Robins on behalf of Save Our Seals Fund.
  24. orv lehman 27 Apr 2014
    go vegan
  25. Roddy 27 Apr 2014
    Save rthe seals , save the world
  26. Lesley Payne 27 Apr 2014
    An unnecessary and barbaric practice that needs to be stamped out. Makes me ashamed to be British.
  27. Jana Wiggins 27 Apr 2014
    Please stop your barbaric practices. The Seals were there first. Lead the way instead of lagging behind.
  28. Isabelle Giroux 27 Apr 2014
    This immoral killing of healthy animals, beautiful seals, MUST STOP immediately, it is a SHAME!
  29. Mia Elisdotter 27 Apr 2014
    Aren't we bigger than this? We live in the 2100 century and know by now that every animal has its place in the world. Please stop this horrendous killing and show the world that things can change.
  30. Viktoria Schmidt 27 Apr 2014
    I respect every single animal, just last week I rescued a common field cricket. I can't understand why someone can kill a seal or any other animal. All forms of killing (shooting, burning, cutting...) are unacceptable.
  31. Chasta Schneider 27 Apr 2014
    This must stop. Let's finally earn the name humanKind.
  32. DELAFOSSE Guillaume 27 Apr 2014
    I love Scotland and I like salmon
    - but not at any cost.
  33. Sarah 27 Apr 2014
    I am not from Scotland, but I am against any act of cruelty being performed on innocent animals. The fault does not lie with the seals but yet again with human interference.
  34. Audrey Manasterski 27 Apr 2014
    Every living thing has to eat. The overfishing is a human fault, not the seals. Killing them will not solve the problem. Stop eating wild salmon might be a solution. Slaughter isn't.
  35. Brigid Braun 27 Apr 2014
    Please stop this madness!
  36. mandy sharp 27 Apr 2014
    not here , not anywhere , its barbaric
  37. Ana Fantini 27 Apr 2014
    We are not in the 1800's....you know this is not right
  38. Colette Fontaine 27 Apr 2014
    Stop this killing once and for all!
  39. caroline 27 Apr 2014
    its wrong man has to feel like a man(not)to murder animals there is always an excuse pathetic
  40. Chloe Cameron-Carter 27 Apr 2014
    This makes me ashamed to be Scottish. It does not paint us in a good light. Sickening how anyone thinks that this is ok.
  41. Sarah johns 27 Apr 2014
    There is no valid reason for this to continue
    - it's an embarrassment to your country
  42. Jodi Domian 27 Apr 2014
    Please don't allow people to kill the Seals, they have a right to eat.
  43. Julie Williams 27 Apr 2014
    No more killing!
  44. Aaron P. D'Souza 27 Apr 2014
    pls save Mother Earth and the Seals of Scotland. stop the slaughter!
  45. Rebecca Hewitson 27 Apr 2014
    This is barbaric and entirely unjustified. Please end it, now.
  46. Jennett griffiths 27 Apr 2014
    These animals have a right to live their lives the same as you and me
  47. Lisa Scharin 27 Apr 2014
    When will the atrocious acts against other species END??? We are such a violent species and THE MOST destructive!! STOP the killing of helpless, innocent animals and learn to CO-EXIST with them! They are ALL vital to the health and survival of the ecosystems they live in and to the other species as well! Ultimately, we are destroying ourselves!
    I have also stopped eating any fish due to the negative impacts man has had on fish populations all over the world, as well as the enormous killing of "by catch"! All life is being threatened by TOO many issues! Time to begin GIVING back and STOP taking SO much and killing so much!!!
  48. Mary Smolders 27 Apr 2014
    I agree with all the comments below protesting the killing of seals. It is unnecessary, and they have a right to life as much as we do. We don't need their pelts or their meat. Let them live!!
  49. Sandi Murrie 27 Apr 2014
    This is so cruel!!! Why any animal has to suffer at the hands of humans...why??? Please stop this barbaric slaughtering of such beautiful animals!!! I am from England, but love to visit Scotland for it's wildlife!!! Please please stop!!!
  50. Alan downing 27 Apr 2014
    Start to listen to the people