Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01519 · Session 4

Save Scotland's Seals

Closed Submitted 5 Mar 2014 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
12,687 online signatures with a country
Comments
685
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop issuing licences permitting salmon farming, salmon netting and salmon angling interests to shoot and kill seals in Scottish waters and instead require that salmon farmers either move their farms into on-shore tank systems or legally require marine salmon farmers to install and maintain the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets they require to meet their legal obligation under the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 to protect their stock from the attention of predators. We further ask that the Scottish Parliament ask the Scottish Government to legislate to close down all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters thus allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed.

What the petitioner did first

We have written to the relevant Government Ministers and Marine Scotland on numerous occasions over the last four years asking them to stop licensing the killing of seals in Scotland and to make it illegal to kill seals. Sadly our requests have all been turned down and we now wish to show that there is public support for the end of legal seal killing in Scotland. We intend to contribute to the current fisheries review but we understand this is concentrating on issues raised by angling interests, many of which are pro seal shooting, and not very relevant to our campaign to end seal shooting.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Jun 2014
    1 mention
  2. 28 Oct 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 3 Dec 2014
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
    1 mention
  4. 10 Dec 2014
    1 mention

Signatures by country

12,687 online signatures
  1. England3,507 27.6%
  2. United States2,305 18.2%
  3. United Kingdom1,622 12.8%
  4. Scotland1,268 10%
  5. Australia726 5.7%
  6. Canada403 3.2%
  7. Wales227 1.8%
  8. Germany212 1.7%
  9. Netherlands184 1.5%
  10. Spain156 1.2%
  11. 111 other countries2,077 16.4%

Comments

685 comments, oldest first
685 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Kirsty Macdonald 13 Apr 2014
    When Scotland's commons are in severe decline I can't even begin to understand why this should go ahead.
  2. Linda Kemp 14 Apr 2014
    No No No!
  3. p dellow 14 Apr 2014
    Since I found out that the Scottish government allows the Scottish salmon farmers to kill seals so the farmers don't have to put their hands into their money filled pockets to put up proper fencing, I have cancelled my plans to have a nice long holiday in Scotland, I have stopped eating Scottish salmon and cheese and anything else that comes from Scotland. I will continue this until the murder of seals is stopped. Hurry up as I miss the good stuff!
  4. Paul Rawnsley 14 Apr 2014
    I was planning a FAMILY HOLIDAY in East Lothian until I was told allow the SLAUGHTER of SEALS. We will be nolonger coming to Scotland and will not be until this barbaric practice is stopped. I am also asking all my family and friends not to go to Scotland and as ANIMAL LOVERS they will follow my actions and pass the message on.
  5. Elena 14 Apr 2014
    Stop this!
  6. Eada J Webb 14 Apr 2014
    Please stop allowing the killing of seals who are just trying desperately to survive alongside mankind. It's enough that we are taking a disproportionate amount of resources for ourselves already.
  7. Jenny 14 Apr 2014
    This is disgraceful, Scotland should be ashamed if this goes ahead
  8. Hazel Taylor 14 Apr 2014
    This is barbaric non-essential action and shames Scotland in its inhumanity. I will no longer be visiting Scotland, nor will any member of my family. I will boycott Scottish products and urge my family, friends and their friends to do likewise. Please, have a heart as big and beautiful as your country and stop the slaughter!!!
  9. Linda Ray 15 Apr 2014
    Please stop this awful and unnecessary cruelty. Please lead the way to being kind to seals. Why is this allowed to happen. I thought Scottish people were good people until hearing of these cruel torturous beating to death of natures beautiful seals! Please stop!!!!
  10. marie grenu 15 Apr 2014
    why not for once use the power we have,humans,to protect and save those seals ...it will not only contributes in keeping nature arround in Scotland as beautiful as ever, but makes us feel so good...so as we sadly always need a conpensation for our acting,just let only emotions be our reward ,it has an unestimated value !!!
  11. Duncan Jones 15 Apr 2014
    Please don't cull seals. There are other ways to alleviate the conflict between the Salmon farmers and the seals.
  12. vanessa hill 15 Apr 2014
    STOP IT NOW! HORRIBLE PEOPLE!
  13. Jessie Tribe 15 Apr 2014
    Lovely animals,so nice to see up on the rocks resting and sunning themselves
  14. Blair Frazer Smith 15 Apr 2014
    If you are looking for a Yes vote on independence from me in September that will all depend on if you continue this barbaric and totally unscientific 'cull' of Seals.
  15. vicki bilden 16 Apr 2014
    To beat these babies to death is Barbaric.
  16. Dorothy Lawson 16 Apr 2014
    What a disgrace, can't abide cruelty.
  17. Joanne Prandle 16 Apr 2014
    Stop this mindless slaughter of our beautiful indigenous wildlife before it TOO late.
  18. Malcolm Fisher 16 Apr 2014
    Killing wildlife is an ignorant and shameful activity.
  19. Leigh-Anne Adams 16 Apr 2014
    Seals have as much right to the river systems as we do, they were here before mankind. Human means having compassion and empathy. Please keep the seals safe and let them live in the environment they were intended too.
  20. Helen 16 Apr 2014
    Disgusting
  21. Tanmayi 16 Apr 2014
    Please stop killing innocent animals for human greed. Stop.
  22. Sue Starkey 16 Apr 2014
    Just take the necessary steps to ensure they & the salmon are kept apart and safe
    - there is no need to kill them at all
    - its barbaric
  23. Martin Ekdahl 16 Apr 2014
    This has to stop immediately!
  24. Nicole 16 Apr 2014
    Death for greed is not a policy, it's immoral.
  25. David Palmer 16 Apr 2014
    The shooting of seals is abhorrent. Do not let greed win. Save our seals!
  26. Ruby moon 16 Apr 2014
    How can we try to stop the terrible slaughter going on in Canada of seals when we are just as bad! The seals have more right to live in the environment they were born into than the greedy salmon farmers who shoot them they should make the nets stronger after all we are the ones with the technology leave our seals alone!!!!!
  27. Tony 16 Apr 2014
    Live and let live. STOP exploitation and cruelty to innocent animals.
  28. kevin 16 Apr 2014
    How awful, uncompassionate barbaric and selfish. you will also kill the tourist trade in Scotland if this happens, the world is aware of this lack of compassion it reflects poorly on the rest if the British Isles.
  29. Rosario Rodriguez Leon 16 Apr 2014
    We must evolve to be better persons, not only with our own human especies, but with the nonhuman species too. They' inhabitant The Earth too. We must learn to be humane and compassive. In killing there's no mercy. There's no compassion in killing a conscious being, human or not.
  30. Janice Sinclair 16 Apr 2014
    I have supported animal cruelty charities most of my life and cannot believe that I didn't know that this is going on in my own country, the Scotland I love and support. I abhor mans inhumanity that some humans will stop at nothing for their own greedy ends, the animal kingdom kill to live, we are the only species that kill for sport or greed! We ought to hang our heads in humble shame for the injustice we do to the living creatures on our earth, I feel the shame on behalf of those cruel, greedy profiteering people!
  31. Muir Murdoch 16 Apr 2014
    I feel as strongly about this as I feel about Estate workers poisoning falcons. There is quite simply no need at all. It must stop.

    How can we be proud of our wealth of natural produce if we abuse our environment while doing so?
  32. Linda 16 Apr 2014
    Why do we always have to destroy every other creature that 'gets in our way'? Seals bring in tourists, who contribute to the economy. We need to find another solution.
  33. silvia herrera 16 Apr 2014
    no more blood, no more cruelty and torture, save lives, not eliminated, they also are part of this land as all living beings
  34. CRISTINA,SPAIN 16 Apr 2014
    OH GOD,I FEEL SO SAD!STOP THIS CRUELTY LORD PLEASE!
  35. mark schram 16 Apr 2014
    its time we as humans adapt, and stop killing and capturing animals
  36. Elaine Roft 16 Apr 2014
    1,000 seals are shot and killed under Government Licence in Scotland each year. These deaths are totally unnecessary and an international embarrassment to Scotland. We would like to see Scotland lead the way with seal-friendly salmon farming using techniques such as on-shore farming in enclosed tank systems and proper predator exclusion nets around marine farms.
  37. Pauline Hayward 16 Apr 2014
    Scotland England Wales I believe are sn example to the world. We are a nation of animal lovers and we need to respect all creatures.
  38. John Graham 16 Apr 2014
    Don't know if I would want to vote "yes" for independence if such a government condones such treatment of seals
  39. Victor Beattie 16 Apr 2014
    Angling is more valuable to tourism than betters who steal what others have sown. Seals are beautiful creatures and are also a great tourist pull. If you allow netting and culling on the Ythan Estuary, Shame on you. If You vote SNP whilst they allow this-Shame on you!
  40. Dona LaSchiava 16 Apr 2014
    IT'S THEIR WORLD TOO!
  41. GINA CHRONOWICZ 16 Apr 2014
    It is the duty of salmon farmers to comply with the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006. The Scottish Government must stop issuing licences to any Tom, Dick and Harry who wants to shoot these seals.
  42. Dave White 16 Apr 2014
    Disgraceful. Who is invading who's space? They have as much right to live in their own natural habitat.
  43. Michelle Morris 16 Apr 2014
    Please STOP killing these beautiful creatures.
  44. Arnim van Bracht 16 Apr 2014
    Save the seals cause they are a part of Scottland.
  45. Andy I 16 Apr 2014
    Appalling, never even knew this was permitted!
  46. Michael Archer 16 Apr 2014
    For humanity to evolve we need to take a leap of faith and stop killing things.
  47. Christine Forbes 16 Apr 2014
    Mankind always has to interfere with nature, time it stopped.
  48. Fiona hargreaves 16 Apr 2014
    I wish to sign this petition but was unable to so as my ipad did not recognise the security captcha challenge
  49. LINDA BRADY 17 Apr 2014
    How dare they kill seals for hunting for food? The seals have more right to the seas and rivers than we do. The human race is a virus to the animal world. We kill for greed NOT need. Let the seals forage in their ocean in safety. Would we like to be shot for foraging in our supermarkets?
  50. Kathy J 17 Apr 2014
    I did not believe it when I was told ... Scottish people are civilised said I ... how wrong can one be ... hope you get independence then we can put sanctions on Scotland just like Canada