To understand the situation in Scotland regarding shooting seals we must look back at its history. Under the Conservation of Seals Act 1970, anyone who applied for a variation to a firearms licence could, as long as they used the correct calibre of rifle, shoot any seal at any time—apart from anglers, who could not shoot seals during the close seasons. You will see in our briefing paper, which you have in front of you, that the close seasons are three months in the summer for common seals and three in the winter for grey seals.
The reason why angling bodies could not shoot seals in those periods was that they did not have equipment to protect. Salmon netsmen have nets to protect from damage. The old Scottish Office also accepted that fish farms came under the same section, as they had cage nets to protect. They could shoot seals 365 days a year without a licence, but angling bodies had to get a licence if they wanted to shoot in the close seasons.
In the past, the only licence issued was the one for people who wanted to shoot in the close season. I remember having questions asked at Westminster about the number of seals that were shot in a year and the answer came back that it was 60. That was correct in that 60 seals had been shot under licence. The real figure had to be a guesstimate that I produced in the mid-1980s, which was that perhaps 6,000 seals were being shot per year in Scotland. That was an average of 10 per salmon farm and 10 per netting station.
I was at a fish farm conference in Inverness as a representative of a fish food sales company. The chaps from the fish farms were quite happy to talk to me because they thought that I was with the industry. One was quite happy to tell me, “We shot 60 seals last year.” That was at one farm unit.
We did a documentary for Channel 4 about the shooting that went on at the netting stations. A chap from Hopeman quite openly said that he shot 89 seals at one net in one season. That is the scale of it. My figure of 5,000 to 6,000 a year was not challenged, and I feel that it was conservative.
Then the Conservation of Seals Act 1970 was replaced by the Marine Scotland Act 2010. What worried me was that it was said that the 2010 act gave seals added protection in that everyone would have to have a licence to shoot seals. One or two licences have been refused, but once an individual has that licence, they can shoot seals 365 days a year up to the limit that is set on the licence. That means that angling bodies have an extra six months a year in which to shoot seals without going through the palaver of applying for a licence. Previously, they had to get the licence for the close season and many of them did not bother, so seals in estuaries would have protection during close seasons. Anglers would not shoot them while they were breeding but would do so at other times of the year. That protection has been removed.
Marine Scotland has come out with more spin than Malcolm Tucker on this one. It is saying that there is added protection when the opposite is the case. That piece of protection has been removed.
I made a submission when the Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) Bill was being brought in. One of the things that we pushed was the fact that fish are sentient. Fish feel pain and stress, and they react to adverse stimulus. After the Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) 2006 was put in place, fish farmers, like any other farmer, inherited a duty to protect their stock from predators. That does not simply mean that you have to stop the fox from getting in and taking a chunk out of your chicken. The fish farmers have to stop the seals from getting to the nets and biting the fish, but they also have to stop them from getting close enough to cause the fish stress.