Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

New Petitions

Save Our Seals Fund (PE1519)

Tuesday 17 June 2014 Public Petitions Committee About 11:30–11:45 Petitions 30 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

To understand the situation in Scotland regarding shooting seals we must look back at its history. Under the Conservation of Seals Act 1970, anyone who applied for a variation to a firearms licence could, as long as they used the correct calibre of rifle, shoot any seal at any time—apart from anglers, who could not shoot seals during the close seasons. You will see in our briefing paper, which you have in front of you, that the close seasons are three months in the summer for common seals and three in the winter for grey seals.

The reason why angling bodies could not shoot seals in those periods was that they did not have equipment to protect. Salmon netsmen have nets to protect from damage. The old Scottish Office also accepted that fish farms came under the same section, as they had cage nets to protect. They could shoot seals 365 days a year without a licence, but angling bodies had to get a licence if they wanted to shoot in the close seasons.

In the past, the only licence issued was the one for people who wanted to shoot in the close season. I remember having questions asked at Westminster about the number of seals that were shot in a year and the answer came back that it was 60. That was correct in that 60 seals had been shot under licence. The real figure had to be a guesstimate that I produced in the mid-1980s, which was that perhaps 6,000 seals were being shot per year in Scotland. That was an average of 10 per salmon farm and 10 per netting station.

I was at a fish farm conference in Inverness as a representative of a fish food sales company. The chaps from the fish farms were quite happy to talk to me because they thought that I was with the industry. One was quite happy to tell me, “We shot 60 seals last year.” That was at one farm unit.

We did a documentary for Channel 4 about the shooting that went on at the netting stations. A chap from Hopeman quite openly said that he shot 89 seals at one net in one season. That is the scale of it. My figure of 5,000 to 6,000 a year was not challenged, and I feel that it was conservative.

Then the Conservation of Seals Act 1970 was replaced by the Marine Scotland Act 2010. What worried me was that it was said that the 2010 act gave seals added protection in that everyone would have to have a licence to shoot seals. One or two licences have been refused, but once an individual has that licence, they can shoot seals 365 days a year up to the limit that is set on the licence. That means that angling bodies have an extra six months a year in which to shoot seals without going through the palaver of applying for a licence. Previously, they had to get the licence for the close season and many of them did not bother, so seals in estuaries would have protection during close seasons. Anglers would not shoot them while they were breeding but would do so at other times of the year. That protection has been removed.

Marine Scotland has come out with more spin than Malcolm Tucker on this one. It is saying that there is added protection when the opposite is the case. That piece of protection has been removed.

I made a submission when the Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) Bill was being brought in. One of the things that we pushed was the fact that fish are sentient. Fish feel pain and stress, and they react to adverse stimulus. After the Animal Health and Welfare (Scotland) 2006 was put in place, fish farmers, like any other farmer, inherited a duty to protect their stock from predators. That does not simply mean that you have to stop the fox from getting in and taking a chunk out of your chicken. The fish farmers have to stop the seals from getting to the nets and biting the fish, but they also have to stop them from getting close enough to cause the fish stress.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Excuse me, Mr Robins, but your five minutes is up. We have time for questions. I hope that we can pick up the rest of your points then.

You have argued that 1,000 seals are shot under licence each year and that that is cruel and unnecessary. What assessment have you made of the effect of your proposals on salmon farming, for example?

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

That is a fair comment.

I think that I caught the Channel 4 documentary that you mentioned. It is clear that there are issues with netting stations, and I believe that the Government is looking at them. It looked at them during consideration of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill and is still looking at them. Could you develop your argument about netting stations? For example, should the Government buy out all the netting stations and put an end to netting altogether?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I think that you are suggesting that we do a bit more homework before we refer the petition.

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

Up to 1,005 can be shot this year. We are talking about an industry that has a history of not having to tell anyone how many seals are shot. The farms are in very remote areas. No one polices the shooting. We take the farmers’ word for it that they are shooting only X number of seals. Strangely enough, they increase the request for how many seals they want to shoot and Marine Scotland has reduced the number that they are allowed to shoot. I do not see how that balances.

The other thing is that, under the new act, a farmer has to protect their fish but they cannot do that by shooting seals. They would have to get someone who could shoot day and night to stop the seals getting near the salmon. The only way to do that is to put up external barrier nets to stop the seals getting in close.

11:45

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You have predicted my next question. You talked about installing high-tension predator exclusion nets. I know that it is very hard to be explicit about the costs for that, but what would it cost for an average fish farm?

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

I think that that is the best way forward. If a salmon netsman gets a salmon in his net and bangs it on the head, he will get £70 to £100 for it. If a salmon gets into the estuary and up the river, it will be worth £2,000 to the Scottish economy, as it will be caught perhaps two or three times before it gets to the head of the river. Anglers come in and stimulate the tourism industry, as they spend money. That is the estimated value. There is £70 if the person bangs the salmon on the head at the net and £2,000 once it goes up the river.

The approach that has been mentioned would make a lot of sense. Usan Salmon Fisheries says that it is trialling a new acoustic device, and it is working. It would be nice to follow that through and see whether it does work but, unless an external body properly audits what is going on, I do not have a lot of faith in the industry at all. I am not accusing any specific company; the whole industry is simply too remote and secretive, and it needs to be monitored.

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

I can be very accurate. We asked the American Government to ban the import of salmon farmed in farms that are allowed to shoot marine mammals, which is not allowed in the United States. The US has a great law whereby if a non-American producer is producing something unfairly compared with domestic producers, the Government can stop any of its imports. The Canadian branch of Marine Harvest brought in exclusion nets that cost 120,000 Canadian dollars for one farm. That is a lot of money but not a great deal given the size of the industry.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

For completeness, what happens to the seals that are shot?

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I suggest that we ask the Scottish Government, Marine Scotland and the special committee on seals for their views.

Chic Brodie SNP South Scotland
link

I declare an interest in that I have worked with a company that is about to introduce an onshore salmon fish farm and a company that has developed a submersible for tidal power that manages to avoid killing seals or any other marine life.

I think that we will see more and more onshore fish farms. However, in terms of the technology, can you explain the acoustic deterrent device and tell us how successful it has been?

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

Ideally, they should be brought ashore and autopsied but, as far as I am aware, only one has been in the past three years. That might be something to do with a Scottish Government meeting that was held in Inverness four years ago, I think. You have heard of the Scottish seals forum, which is interested in whether seals should or should not be shot. It is weighted 3:1 in favour of organisations that actively shoot or support the shooting of seals. I tried to access that forum four times and was refused four times.

A chap from Australia was brought over, and he spoke for five minutes at the meeting in Inverness. He was the keynote speaker, and he thanked the Scottish Government: he had never before flown on the class of flight from Australia that he had been on, and he had really enjoyed the trip. He was enjoying being back in Scotland and seeing his old colleagues. The best bit of advice that he gave to the people who were sitting around—the meeting was to do with the Moray seal management plan—was, “If you’re going to shoot seals, do it in the morning when there are no tourists about.” He was brought from Australia to tell people that. The attitude has been, “If you’re going to do it, do it quietly.”

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

We should also write to the Scottish salmon association—I am trying to think what it is called. I know that there is a national body that covers the industry.

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

There are various options of acoustic devices, some of which are better than others, and some of which are still on trial. I went to a fish farm where the manager said, “We’ve got two acoustic devices. When we see seals in the area, we turn them on—they scare the seals away. We don’t have to do any shooting here.” I think that it was two years since the farm had last shot a seal. I went on to the farm and I heard a generator on one of the barges. I said to the farm manager, who lived on a floating house on the farm, “I hear you’ve got the acoustics on. Any seals about?” He said “Naw, we don’t get seals here. I’ve been running that 24/7 for the last three years.” What that means is that seals are being moved away from their natural habitat. That farm was within a quarter of a mile of a traditional seal rookery and haul-out site, but it got planning permission to be there, just as farms get permission to be put at the mouths of salmon rivers in the estuaries. If the industry started today, that would never be allowed.

The acoustic devices work on some farms—some come back and say, “Yes, they’re working”—but, again, the question is how we police that. There is nobody there to see exactly what is going on.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for that.

Unless colleagues have any other questions, we will go to summation and look at the next steps.

It seems to me that there are two main things that we can do. We can either continue the petition and ask the relevant bodies questions, or refer it to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee, which has recently looked at the bill that became the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Act 2013. It is a matter for members. I think that at least one member of this committee is on the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee.

My view is that it is probably worth referring the petition to the Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee but, again, I will take advice from committee members. Should we refer the petition to the committee that recently looked at the subject area?

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

I think that it is now called the Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

Good morning, Mr Robins. Your petition covers quite a number of issues. My colleague Chic Brodie has already mentioned the high-strength, high-tension predator exclusion nets, which I have seen at first hand. They have been introduced by Marine Harvest and I saw them on some of its farms up in Lochaber. Those nets have already been introduced by major salmon farming companies, although I believe that there have been some initial difficulties with them. The industry certainly seems to be heading in the direction of the onshore tank farms that Mr Brodie mentioned as well as of moving salmon farms further offshore out into the deeper water. There are developments in the industry that are going to address the issues that you are concerned about.

Angus MacDonald SNP Falkirk East
link

I would be keen to seek the views of the Scottish Government and Marine Scotland first, before we refer it to that committee. As you say, it recently scrutinised the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill, so the issue is still fresh for it.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Yes. We should write to that organisation, too, to seek its views on the petition.

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

We have to be careful when we talk about anti-predator nets. Some farms are getting bigger cages and putting stronger-tension nets around the cages. That means that seals cannot push the net in far enough to grab a salmon, but they can get close enough to panic and stress the salmon. There should be an anti-predator barrier perhaps 50m away from the inner cage, so that seals cannot get close to it.

The onshore fish farms are probably the best way forward as they do not have lice or predator problems and, instead of the pollution lying on the seabed, it is bagged up and sold as fertiliser. That is the way forward. It was started in Otter Ferry on the Argyll peninsula. A chap who was a director of the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals was in charge of that. The problem was that he made a big mistake and started to dabble in genetically modified salmon. He killed his business. His son now farms halibut onshore and is making a damn good business out of it, because that has a higher value. He cannot compete with salmon and bring them onshore, because it is currently still cheaper to do that work in the sea. That is because we do not regulate it properly, although we could. Marine Scotland could say, “If you want a marine fin-fish farm, you must put in predator exclusion nets.” However, that simply does not happen.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do members agree to the suggestions?

Members indicated agreement.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank Mr Robins for his evidence and for the technical advice that he has given us. Obviously, we are continuing the petition, so we will keep him up to date with developments and discuss the petition again at a future meeting.

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

I quickly point out that I have read the SPICe briefing paper and found two or three major errors in it.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Could you perhaps send us a note, and we will have a look at that?

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

I will do.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for coming, Mr Robins.

11:55 Meeting suspended.

11:55 On resuming—

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

PE1519 is by John F Robins, on behalf of the Save Our Seals Fund, on saving Scotland’s seals. Members have a note by the clerk, the SPICe briefing, the petition and a submission from the petitioner.

I welcome Mr Robins: thank you for coming along and sorry for delaying you.

John F Robins Save Our Seals Fund
link

No problem. Thank you for inviting me.

David Stewart Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I invite Mr Robins to make a brief presentation of a maximum of five minutes, after which I will kick off with a couple of questions before I ask my colleagues to ask further questions.

  1. 09:30 Current Petition Petitions · 76
  2. 10:15 New Petitions Petitions · 101
  3. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 35
  4. 11:30 New Petitions Petitions · 30
  5. 12:00 Tackling Child Sexual Exploitation in Scotland Committee business · 12
  6. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 19
  7. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
  8. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 12:00 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
  11. 12:00 Current Petitions Petitions · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.