Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1

Wednesday 3 December 2014 Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee About 09:30–13:15 Bill scrutiny 252 contributions · 22 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

252 contributions · showing 201–252
John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

That is a very challenging question. In the simplest terms, the meaning of community is about people who live together and the relationships that exist between people in that community—how they interact and live in the area and how they make their environment habitable and pleasant for all who are there.

I cannot remember all the parts of your question, but I would like to comment on SCIOs. The bill says that a SCIO must not have “fewer than 20 members”. That is particularly restrictive. We have a couple of SCIOs that are working very well, one of which has eight members and the other has 10. Are we now saying that, even though we know what the SCIO wants to achieve and we are doing everything that we can to support it, because someone in an ivory tower has said that the SCIO must have 20 members, it cannot continue? It does not have 20 members, but it is an active and progressive community and wants to make things happen, but it cannot, because it is barred. That issue needs to be addressed. Does the bill have to be prescriptive about having a minimum of 20 members on a SCIO?

12:45

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

That is in the 2003 act, as I understand it. Looking forward, we are listening to your comments.

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

Well, this is an opportunity to change it.

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

There are many aspects to your question.

We have always looked at community in the same way that John Mundell does. We come at this from a community-led regeneration perspective and we are interested in people who live in a place being proactive together to make positive change to that place. Our definition has always come from a geographical perspective. It is about community of place, rather than community of interest. I am not really able to comment on the community of interest side, because that is not something that we have ever got involved with.

If we are talking about community ownership, the whole thing about having a broad membership is that, whatever structure you put in place for a community-led organisation, the democratic control of that organisation is important in terms of being able to say that that organisation is accountable to the wider community through its membership. That is why we have always advocated that community anchor organisations, whether they are development trusts or not—not all anchor organisations are—should have as broad a membership as possible, because it is that membership that reflects the views of the wider community to the organisation, which then acts on their behalf.

There are a number of ways to do that: through a company limited by guarantee; through a SCIO structure; and through a community benefits society. In all those structures, the values of democratic accountability, membership and voting are represented. The other thing about being community led, from our point of view, is that the members should be able to get elected on to the governing body of the organisation, so that there is true ownership of the organisation from within the community. As I say, that can be achieved through a number of different structures.

We have always argued that decisions should not be made in legislation about one structure being better than another, because there are several factors that will influence which structure a community thinks is most appropriate for the things that it wants to achieve. For example, the reason that people may choose a community benefit society is that they may want to go down the route of raising finance through a community share issue. The only way that can be done is if the organisation is set up as a community benefit society. However, the membership of a community benefit society can be as broad as the membership of a company limited by guarantee or a SCIO.

As long as the values are built into the structure, which can be done, we do not think that the structure should be the limiting factor. It must be the structure that works best for the things that the community wants to achieve.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

It was suggested last week that new structures are being invented all the time and therefore there should be a broader definition of what the structure should embrace. Do you agree?

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

I think so. We can set out the values that we want the structure to adhere to and the principles to which it should operate and then see how that translates into several different structures. People often ask us what a development trust is and we say that it is not a physical thing but a way of working and a concept that demonstrates a certain set of values and approaches to how you are going to achieve the end result.

Communities are often ahead of the curve. The things that they want to do, and the aspirations that they have and the creative ways that they are thinking about how they can achieve their aims and objectives, are often limited by the legal structures that are available to them.

Having a degree of flexibility is really helpful, although my understanding is that that is there in the bill, because it says that any other structure that may come along could be added at a later stage. We would not like anything that currently exists to be excluded, but we would also want flexibility to add new structures in the future.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

John Mundell has to leave us at 1 o’clock and I wanted to bring him in on another matter.

Claudia Beamish Lab South Scotland
link

I do not need to come back to the panel, I am just interested in hearing their views.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Let us hear from Susan Carr and then David Cruickshank. I want to put a question to John Mundell after that.

Susan Carr Community Alliance Trust
link

Claudia Beamish’s question was very complex. My experience has been that communities define themselves and they evolve. They become almost redundant. Our community development trust came from an umbrella organisation that we set up for neighbourhood associations across the greater Craigmillar area. We first set up neighbourhood associations instead of tenants and residents groups because we believed that people identify themselves by where they live, not by who owns their house. We decided that we needed to bring those together, so we set up an umbrella organisation, called the community regeneration forum, which became much more strategic in its approach. We then discovered, when we met Alex Neil, that we really needed a community development trust. All that evolved over time.

It takes time for people to buy into these things. When we first spoke about a community development trust people just did not get it, because it was a new concept. You can get people to buy into these things only if they succeed. We had to get a few things under our belt before we got to the point at which people wanted to join. We started off with maybe 100 people wanting to join, but now our memorandum and articles of association say that every person who lives in our defined area is a member, so every person has the opportunity to have a say on how we are governed. It is something that evolves.

David Cruickshank Lambhill Stables Development Trust
link

I will give a practical answer to the question of how you define a community. The Big Lottery Fund wants you to define yourself when you apply for growing community assets funding, and the only solution that we found was to use the community planning partnership definition: in our case, we used Maryhill, Kelvin and Canal community planning partnership. The community was so nebulous and there were so many different communities in that interest group that it was difficult to define. It is very difficult to define a community scientifically, but you have to come up with some answer.

That leads to the whole issue of community planning partnerships, which we are not going to go into now—convener, I can see you saying, “Help!” In theory—although not in working practice—that is a significant area, and it needs a thorough overhaul and fresh input.

The other point to make is that there can be an inherent assumption that community is always a positive thing. It is not necessarily. You get communities of drug culture and communities of fear of asylum seekers. You get communities of all kind of territorial negativity at gang level, in which young men from one side of the street are prepared to kill people from the other side of the street, because they see that they have a territorial imperative to make their name by standing up for their side of the street.

There are communities that need intervention, but that raises a whole other issue. That is my tuppenceworth at this stage.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Before we ask a couple of questions on procedures and requirements, I want to touch on definitions of “abandoned” and “neglected” land before John Mundell has to leave us in a few minutes, because the issue is particularly interesting from a local government perspective.

Dave Thompson SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Good afternoon, panel. I would appreciate your views on the definition—or lack of one—of “abandoned or neglected land” and the fact that, unlike the crofting legislation, under which crofters who want to purchase land just have to show that the purchase would be in the public interest and would be for the good of sustainable development, the bill has an additional “abandoned or neglected” test.

There is another test on top of that. It has to be shown that

“if the owner of the land were to remain as its owner, that ownership would be inconsistent with furthering the achievement of sustainable development in relation to the land”.

Do you agree with me that those tests, taken together—we have heard evidence on this before—would make it almost impossible for a community in an urban setting to purchase the land that it wished to sustainably develop?

Susan Carr Community Alliance Trust
link

Craigmillar is a very deprived area and we have always been quite frightened by the fact that there is a lot of derelict land because there was so much demolition. The owner of the land is the local authority and, because we are based in Edinburgh, it would be nigh on impossible for us to come up with funding that would meet the local authority’s requirements for best value, so we are going right back to a situation where it comes down to funding.

I do not know about other local authorities but, in Edinburgh, land has such a high value—even if it is not as high as it might be at the moment—that people will not release it. We have been strong in our desire to make sure that none of the land is bought and land banked. In some respects, the fact that we have a regeneration company that has that red line has probably prevented land banking from happening, which is quite important.

How you would define the land very much depends on where it is. However, we can certainly identify buildings and so on that are just going to lie there until somebody thinks that there is enough value in the price to change things. I do not think that in bigger authorities such as Edinburgh we are ever going to be able to aspire to purchasing that land.

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

This is a very difficult issue. We have been spending tens of millions of pounds on regenerating our area, as most councils do anyway, and we have been transforming our area. I will give you an example of the difficulties involved. There is one site that is owned by an absent owner who is, I think, from the south of England. In fact, my most recent understanding is that he may well have passed on—I might be wrong on that.

Under the circumstances, there are all sorts of issues associated with that site. Strategically, from a planning perspective and from a regeneration perspective, it is a fantastic location. It is a site that the council and our community planning partners believe would be a benefit for the area. However, even with all the power and expertise that we and our partners have at our disposal, it is nigh on impossible to move that site on, so the site is blocked. That is the situation for us as a council.

I use that as an example and, in my mind’s eye, I try to put myself in the shoes of a community group that wants to access a particular site—we are talking about abandoned or derelict land. Obviously, Inverclyde, south of the Clyde, was a major shipbuilding area in the past. We have developed a lot of the riverside already and we still have a way to go. However, some of that land might look great but is heavily contaminated with heavy metals and all sorts of chemicals and pollution, and it costs millions of pounds to decontaminate sites and make them developable. There are all those abnormal costs for those sites—it is a high-risk issue.

I doubt very much that that issue exists in Susan Carr’s area to the same degree. Obviously, the sites in Craigmillar were predominantly housing and there is a lot of open space now where the sites have been cleared. However, there will still be an element of contamination. Bearing in mind when they were built, those houses could have had asbestos in them and all the rest of it. That is what can make the cost of developing those sites so prohibitive.

We have to be very careful about what we do. It comes back to the money again. It is about proper assessment of the sites, options appraisals, and coming up with the sources of funds. Who is going to pay? From our point of view, there is the land that is owned by us and the land that is owned by Peel Holdings or Clydeport, where we are in partnership with them through our urban regeneration company. From a professional point of view, the money involved for some of those derelict areas is mind blowing.

That said, trying to develop brownfield sites in urban areas is absolutely the right thing to do, because they are a blight. There is no doubt about that. They have to be brought into effective use for the community and for the urban areas in which they exist.

13:00

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Mike Russell has a supplementary. Perhaps it is for John Mundell.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

It is. It is always possible to find reasons not to do things. I understand the contamination question and such things, but let us take other examples of buildings. Local authorities will hold and own a substantial number of buildings, many of which they will attempt to sell but face difficulty in so doing because of the state of the market or the nature of the building. The authority will be spending substantial sums on making those buildings wind and watertight, which is often not possible to do properly, and secure.

Where does the balance lie in ensuring that buildings that the council does not want and which it cannot sell over a period of time can be utilised by communities for their own purposes? What active work is done on that? Sometimes it seems to me—certainly from my own local experience—that the council’s attitude is that the only difference between it and a property developer with a land bank is that it is just not very good at it. The council leaves stuff in a bad state that constantly gets worse, and the building is eventually bulldozed.

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

In Inverclyde, we have replaced every secondary school, and I know that other councils are doing the same kind of thing. We have completely rationalised our schools estate over the past seven or eight years. We still have a way to go but, nonetheless, that leaves a number of rationalised properties or properties that are no longer in current use.

The funding model for our schools is quite complex. Inverclyde has done the majority of that itself through reducing the number of schools and getting better numbers in schools, for example. Part of the funding model is the capital receipts that we were due to get when we first set up our schools estate management plan away back prior to the recession. We have factored in the values that were available at that time for the sale of those assets, which are no longer available. We took a conscious decision as a council—at least, the members took the decision, obviously—to say, “Right, we’re going to stop selling those assets at the moment until the market gets back up to an appropriate level, but we need that cash to service our funding model.” That was all part of the business plan for the schools estate.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

What if you never get the cash? That regularly happens.

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

I will come on to the issues.

I absolutely agree that there are appropriate types of assets that we could transfer. I say that the assets should be “appropriate” because, if they are a burden to the council in keeping them wind and watertight, they will be a burden to a community group. Who will provide the funding?

That goes back to what I said. It is the old drum that we all beat. There is not enough money. I know that there is more that goes beyond that but, nonetheless, if there is a wasting asset that is in poor condition and we believe that we must come up with a reduced footprint over our whole estate to provide services—in other words, we must bring its size in and operate from fewer buildings in a more efficient way—the most inefficient part is left.

If I am genuinely trying to help communities and community groups, I will not be comfortable transferring assets that are a burden. I would rather come up with a way of helping a community group or community groups to come up with a new asset. Perhaps we can raze the building to the ground and use the land that is available—if the building is an old primary school, it will be right in the heart of a community anyway. If the group is going to exist for 40 or 50 years or longer than that, it is appropriate that it, too, should have modern and efficient assets to operate from.

Michael Russell SNP Argyll and Bute
link

There are many circumstances in which communities will want to have those assets. They will believe that they have viable plans for them, and they may be assisted by bodies from which you cannot get assistance. For example, in the Highlands and Islands, HIE may assist communities to develop and take forward assets that the council could not get money for. In those circumstances, might the council facilitate communities developing their strength and ability to regenerate themselves, rather than simply judging them with the criteria that it uses and saying, “We don’t think you’re up to this, so we’ll just demolish the building”?

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

You have perhaps misunderstood what I said earlier. We are proactively involved with community groups now. I mentioned a couple of SCIOs, for example. We are working very closely with them. Officers go to regular meetings in the evenings to try to develop plans and, indeed, to help people to come up with appropriate funding plans. We are well advanced in building a new facility in Inverkip; it is going through the planning stage and there are one or two issues with it at the moment. We do that anyway; it is not new. If we can get another organisation involved—or if Highlands and Islands Enterprise can cast its net wider and it is called by a different name—that is fair enough.

However, it comes down to the funding, predominantly, and the will—the political will and the will of people like me to make sure that we understand that we are here to serve the people out there and to help them to get the right answer.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

Before John Mundell has to go, I have a brief supplementary to help us to get a feel for the issue.

In the evidence that we have taken previously, we have looked at the issue of not being able to identify who the landowner is. Perhaps you can help us to understand that issue in an urban context, given your experience as chief executive of a council. If we consider blight sites in your area, to what extent would there be an issue in identifying who owns them?

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

There are other areas that we are being consulted on in terms of the land register and so on. The philosophy behind completing the land register is absolutely bang on the button, but the aspiration to get it done within a five-year timeframe is overly optimistic; I think that it will take about 10 years. It is not a priority for us at the moment, given everything else that we are wrestling with, but it is absolutely the right thing to do. If we complete the register so that we know who owns all the bits of land across the whole of Scotland, that will make life an awful lot easier.

I include common good in that as well. There are areas in which there are shades of grey and it takes time to wrestle with the legal issues, including the transferring of assets to community groups, which is what we are here to talk about. That makes it quite difficult. The completion of the land register is a great thing to do—my professional association, the Society of Local Authority Chief Executives and Senior Managers, certainly believes that it is a great thing to do—but the timing is not on our side and the resources to deal with it are not available at the moment.

Graeme Dey SNP Angus South
link

To be clear, if the provisions in the bill were introduced right now, do you anticipate that there would be substantial issues in identifying the ownership of some of the sites that people might want to take over?

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

Yes. The issue of ownership comes up in the redevelopment work that we do now. A recent example involved Peel Holdings. I think that all the land right down along the waterfront—all the shipbuilding area—was transferred for £1 many years ago; at least, that is what some of the members tell me. We are paying millions of pounds through partnership to get such sites developed. At one site, we had a boundary fence around one of my operational depots, and we were challenged by Peel Holdings, which said that that was not where the boundary was. It cost a lot of money just to sort out one boundary fence—we are talking about a couple of metres’ difference on a site in an industrialised area that was heavily contaminated. It was a lot of cash, and that is a simple example.

Anything that can help us to simplify the process—or, indeed, clear the boards and make sure that we can start afresh with a full, detailed register that shows who owns what—has to be a good thing.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

You may notice in the Official Report other points that are made after you have left. Thank you very much for your evidence.

John Mundell Inverclyde Council
link

I apologise for having to leave.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Dave Thompson has questions on detailed procedures and requirements.

Dave Thompson SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

I will ask about the registration process and what the panel feels about communities having to register. In some instances, it might be very clear that there is a bit of land that the community wants, and an early registration would be something that it could anticipate and deal with. Often, however, pieces of land will come on the market suddenly. Last week, Holmehill Community Buyout gave us an example in which an area that everybody thought was a public park suddenly had a “For Sale” sign put up on it. There are places in relation to which people would never have thought about registering an interest in a community purchase.

At the moment, many applications are late registrations—they are almost becoming the norm. I would like to get the panel’s views on whether we need any kind of early registration or whether communities should just be able to register an interest once a building or land comes on the market.

Also, should communities be able to register a general interest for a purpose, rather than in relation to a particular piece of land or building? That would mean that, if a community wanted to develop some housing or a park area or whatever, it could form a group to register an interest in that purpose rather than in specific pieces of land that may never come on the market.

David Cruickshank Lambhill Stables Development Trust
link

I will backtrack briefly and give a case example that bridges to the registering proposal. In our community, we have a piece of land of 9.25 acres that was previously allotment land. It deteriorated in the late 1960s and was used for the kennelling of greyhound dogs for the local greyhound track. The area further deteriorated into a serious antisocial and criminal base where dogs were kept for dog fighting and guarding class A drugs. That situation perpetuated for 20 years until it was finally addressed through pressure from the local community council to get agencies such as the police, the council and the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals on board to support the move to take back the land.

The legal reality of the situation is that the land is owned by a trust. All the trustees are dead but their legal representatives are still negotiating, allegedly on behalf of a benefactor of the trustees of Possil estate. It is a complete nightmare to try to get to the bottom of the situation. There is no recognition of the damage that allowing that land to be a base for antisocial and criminal behaviour has done in the past 20 years. The idea that people should be responsible—publicly responsible—for the land that they own is a completely necessary prerequisite.

I simply say yes to Dave Thompson’s idea about registering. If a community says that it wants something, there should be a way in which it can make that known and then be supported to achieve that in the face of all the other players who have their agendas and who are usually much more powerful and better resourced than the local community group.

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

Dave Thompson raises a number of issues. The process of registration is quite onerous for community organisations. In rural areas, the 2003 act has opened communities’ eyes to the fact that they potentially have an ability to acquire land. Although not much has been acquired through the act itself—because it is actually fairly difficult to go through that process—the act laid down a marker for communities that acquiring land is a reasonable aspiration for them to have, that they have a right to own land and say that they are interested in it, and that they should be offered the opportunity to acquire it.

As the committee knows, for a community to register an interest, a body has to be set up in a certain way and there must be a certain level of support from the wider community in the registration of interest. In a small rural community, it might not be that difficult to gather that level of interest, but it might be harder in urban communities because, depending on how a community decides to define itself, there could be thousands of people in the area and they will often not be particularly engaged in democratic processes. For us, there is an issue about how a community organisation can get over that first hurdle that is put in the way, which is that 10 per cent of the community need to demonstrate support.

Secondly, once the registration is approved, the body will have to reregister the interest five years later and go through the whole process again. That puts people off. However, having to do it makes communities assess what assets they have and why they might want to register an interest in land. That encourages communities to start being proactive about the type of community that they want to live in and the things that they would like to be able to achieve as a result of owning assets.

The issue with late registration is a timing issue. If something comes up unexpectedly and a community has not thought about it in advance, it is difficult for the community to go through the process of gathering interest to support the first stage of registration and so on.

13:15

I am in two minds about the registration process. The need to register is a prompt for communities to think about how they would like their communities to develop and what opportunities they would like to have to influence how things develop. However, the process is onerous, as is the reregistration process. There is something to be said for having an easier process for registering interest if a piece of land comes up for sale that the community had never anticipated would come up for sale, because things happen that no one could have predicted. As the bill stands, it will be extraordinarily difficult for communities to do anything about such situations, which might involve the loss of a service or whatever.

I am not sure about getting rid of registration altogether, although I can see that that would have advantages. What is useful about having to register is that it gets community organisations to think about why they might want assets and what they might want to do with them. We might not want to lose that prompt if we were to go down the route of not having early registration of interest.

Dave Thompson SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

You think that the process should be greatly simplified.

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

I absolutely do.

Susan Carr Community Alliance Trust
link

I agree with Wendy Reid. I can give the committee two examples of something that happened in our area, just down the road. When the library moved, we expressed an interest in renting the building—we knew that we could not buy it, because there is a red line, in that the area is designated a development area. We had to go through the whole process, but we lost out for the sake of £150 a year because no consideration was given to why we wanted the library—we wanted it for a youth zone. Another bidder bid £150 more than we bid. We could have afforded to pay £150 more, but there was no acknowledgement that what we were proposing was advantageous for the whole area.

We lost out in the same way with another council-owned building a bit further along the road. I would like communities to be able to register their aspirations for the use of buildings. The two buildings that I am talking about have been taken over by private tenants and are closed for six out of the seven days of the week. Their being taken over has done little to enhance the quality of life in our area and we have missed two opportunities because we were not able to register the use to which we wanted to put the buildings.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We will move on to the hoops that communities have to jump through. You have given one example, in the context of trying to rent a property.

There is a double requirement in the bill, in that community bodies must show that they are

“furthering the achievement of sustainable development”,

and ministers must be satisfied that continuation of the current ownership

“would be inconsistent with furthering the achievement of sustainable development in relation to the land”.

Are those two tests fair? Do you foresee difficulties for communities in meeting the public interest and sustainable development tests?

Susan Carr Community Alliance Trust
link

An awful lot of that will come down to interpretation. As a community worker who has worked in the voluntary sector for 25 years, I can say that what we hear from the Parliament and the Government is often quite exciting, and we think, “Yahoo! They have listened; it is going to happen,” but, unfortunately, when the local authority interprets provisions, it somehow fits things into a little box whose sides cannot be moved. I do not want to sound too critical of the local authority, because it pays my wages, but there is no flexibility.

It will depend on how the local authority officers interpret the provision and how much that matches our interpretation. There are certain difficulties and I suspect that those are different for each local authority.

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

I would have thought that it will be easier for communities to demonstrate that their proposals pass the first test, because community organisations are mostly concerned with improving the areas where they live. It is very rare for a community organisation to try to acquire an asset to do something that people do not think is a good idea or that is not about improving general quality of life. The second test is more difficult, because how can a community prove that somebody else is not also trying to achieve the same thing? The second test would be much harder to meet than the first.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

It has been described as a “killer clause”. Do you think that that is the case?

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

Yes.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

The issue of duplicate applications arises where the Government or whichever body is responsible must consider different proposals. One application could be positive and the other could appear to be positive but could in fact be designed to stymie the first proposal. Have you had any experience of that in an urban context? Will that be a complication in the development of proposals?

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

I am looking to my colleagues who operate in urban areas to see whether they have any examples of that.

Susan Carr Community Alliance Trust
link

Some communities are very active in their own right. We have tried hard—by and large we have succeeded—to get cohesion in what we do, so that the process is open and local people are involved in decisions and the direction that we take. However, some people do not like change and sometimes it is difficult for people to buy into the process.

In our community, people have had years and years of others telling them, “Now you do this and then you do that. This is the money you’ll get and this is how we’ll do it.” Then things change in the next funding round and they are told, “Oh no, we’ve changed our minds; we’re doing it this way instead.” It is difficult for people not to be drawn to what gives the easiest access to funds, but the easiest funding option does not always mean doing what the community wants.

I have been working in a voluntary sector organisation for 25 years, and I have done everything from community engagement to employment and health—I am now working under a health grant. That is because we have to fit into what people are prepared to fund, rather than what we want to do. That is the difficulty. Also, we are often driven by targets that have been defined by someone else. We end up having to contort ourselves into the shape that will access the funds and benefit the community. In my case, we are funded to do A, B and C, but we also do X, Y and Z, because that is what the community wants. We have to do the first bit in order to do the second bit.

It is very difficult for communities to direct the funding. It is usually the other way round, with the tail wagging the dog.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Should there be specific mechanisms for dealing with different approaches? Say that there are two applications, there needs to be some means to weigh one up against the other.

Wendy Reid Development Trusts Association Scotland
link

As always, we cannot avoid competition and we cannot legislate for that. There must be a mechanism for judging two applications against the same criteria and working out which will be more in the public interest. People will always come back and dispute such a decision. That happens all the time and is not something that we can avoid. However, we should not use that as an excuse not to do things.

Some communities have not previously had the opportunity to register interest and put in an application to acquire assets or land. The process will allow them to express their aspirations. Our experience has been that the fact that people are able to do it means that things are often worked out at community level first. There have not been many cases in which there were disputes over the same thing, although that might happen more in urban areas than it has in rural areas. When it comes down to it, if we are talking about achieving sustainable development, we need to consider what that means and who sets the definitions. The test can then be how competing applications contribute to achieving that definition of sustainable development in a particular place.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Does Alan Miller think that everyone should be given a copy of the United Nations International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and classes on how to interpret it? It sounds to me as though empowering people at a local level, under that broader definition in relation to sanitation, food and housing, would be very valuable indeed.

Professor Miller
link

What I have learned from this evidence session and the previous one is that communities do not need much encouragement to empower themselves. It is the decision makers in authority who need to be more aware of their duties under those obligations. That greater awareness at the Government and parliamentary level would be much more helpful. Some of the experiences are about not so much capacity building as capacity releasing, and for me that says it all. Too often, decision makers make decisions with the best of intentions on behalf of those for whom they are making decisions. That has to be turned on its head, and we do not need international obligations or treaties to do that. It is just common sense, or it should be.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We shall hear a couple of final comments from Colleen Rowan and David Cruickshank.

Dr Rowan
link

I refer back to community planning partnerships, which are relevant in that there are three levels at which policies and strategies operate—on the ground with local people leading, at the local authority level and at the Scottish Government level, where policies are formulated. For our members and other third-sector organisations, where the system falls down is in the community planning partnership structure, because it bears little relation to what people define as their communities. There is a mismatch between the geographic interpretation of what the community is and the community’s view, and our members often do things despite what is happening in the community planning partnerships. In other cases, we work alongside CPPs. For example, in Glasgow, in relation to the single outcome agreement, we are working on the vulnerable people group and the homelessness and housing need group, and some good outcomes have been achieved.

That is a well-rehearsed discourse, and I know that those points have been made many times, but that part of the system really does not work. That is where it falls down a lot of the time.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

We are happy enough to take those ideas forward.

David Cruickshank Lambhill Stables Development Trust
link

Convener, you asked whether there had been any examples of competing interest for a given site. Funnily enough, the one example that I could come up with from our community was a case where a housing association wanted to build residential homes—that is what housing associations do—and the community wanted facilities for young people. There was no doubt about who the winner was, because the housing associations are equipped to move and deliver. I am not criticising housing associations, by the way, but you asked for an example and that is one.

Rob Gibson SNP The Convener · Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

Indeed—thank you.

We have covered a wide range of issues today. It is fascinating for us to get as many practical examples as possible. I thank the members of the panel for all their input. If you feel that you have any further points to make, you are at liberty to write to us afterwards. Thank you for answering a wide range of questions.

At our next meeting, on 10 December, the committee will take evidence from the cabinet secretary on the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill and will consider petition PE1519, on saving Scotland’s seals, as well as the committee’s report to the Finance Committee on the draft budget, the latter part of that item being taken in private.

We have a wide and varied interest in community empowerment, and our interest in urban development has extended the scope of the committee considerably, but today’s session has been most useful.

Meeting closed at 13:29.

  1. 09:30 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  3. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  4. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 18
  5. 09:30 Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 252

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.