Petition · PE01519 · Session 4
Save Scotland's Seals
Signatures
0
Comments
685
Considered
4 meetings
What it asks
Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop issuing licences permitting salmon farming, salmon netting and salmon angling interests to shoot and kill seals in Scottish waters and instead require that salmon farmers either move their farms into on-shore tank systems or legally require marine salmon farmers to install and maintain the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets they require to meet their legal obligation under the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 to protect their stock from the attention of predators. We further ask that the Scottish Parliament ask the Scottish Government to legislate to close down all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters thus allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed.
What the petitioner did first
We have written to the relevant Government Ministers and Marine Scotland on numerous occasions over the last four years asking them to stop licensing the killing of seals in Scotland and to make it illegal to kill seals. Sadly our requests have all been turned down and we now wish to show that there is public support for the end of legal seal killing in Scotland. We intend to contribute to the current fisheries review but we understand this is concentrating on issues raised by angling interests, many of which are pro seal shooting, and not very relevant to our campaign to end seal shooting.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
17 Jun 20141 mention
-
28 Oct 20141 mention
-
3 Dec 20141 mention
-
10 Dec 20141 mention
Signatures by country
12,687 online signaturesComments
685 comments, oldest first685 comments · showing 101–150
-
Tarja Arpalahti 17 Apr 2014Stop salmon farmers from polluting the waters and killing the seals, and stop anyone killing the seals.
-
zarina alex monerief 17 Apr 2014Stop killing Salmons and Seals i yre people all over the world to come forward and Help their lives and Help save Nature
-
Helen Graham 17 Apr 2014"He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals."
--Immanuel Kant -
Neil McDonald 17 Apr 2014I am apalled that this is allowed to happen in Scotland.
-
Jan Vosdellen 17 Apr 2014Its important for the world
-
Diane Larowska 18 Apr 2014There must be a saner way than killing native wildlife, horrified by this sanctioned killing of seals.
-
Bruce Sanelli 18 Apr 2014Really? At this day and age???
-
Gretchen Ochs 18 Apr 2014Having visited Scotland I love the gorgeous country and I love animals to live free from harm.
-
Myriam Seyfarth 18 Apr 2014Are you going to behave like the Japanese killing whales??? I thought Scotland was a better country.
-
RAMONA PAOLINI 18 Apr 2014JUST BECAUSE HUMANS HAVE RIGHTS DOESNT MEAN WE HAVE THE RIGHT TO ABUSE AND KILL OTHER SENTIENT BE INGS..... WE ARE ALL CONNECTED. STOP THE MURDERING THE INNOCENT
-
Kristina Ruiz-Mesa 18 Apr 2014Please do not allow this bloody stain on your country to continue.
-
Louise Vijn 18 Apr 2014Signed
-
Wendy Waterreus 18 Apr 2014Not only are they beautiful and endangered, there is a long folklore associated with them.They are symbolic of these regions and those who live there .
I hope they can survive us -
Carmelina Mascia 18 Apr 2014Just another tale of human greed, another animal being killed in the name of farming, just like the Badgers in somerset. Discusting.
-
Donna Cunningham 18 Apr 2014Stop these terrible killings
-
Susan Baillie 18 Apr 2014Please stop the shooting of seals
-
Lynn Thomas 18 Apr 2014Fairly typical really
- wildlife looses out to monetary gain. The seals were there before artifical salmon farms. -
melissa wall 18 Apr 2014I am so sick of the way people treat animals!!!
-
Sue Horne 18 Apr 2014I spent 9 years living on the north east coast of Scotland I was on many occasions called out to record dead seal, often with aborted seals hanging out of them. No one has the right to kill animals on this scale, the seas of their homes and we visit them. As usual we blame animals for everything that goes wrong, low salmon stocks, never think that it is us humans that have over fished for decades, and what do we do, we kill them. They are left rotting on Scotland's beautiful beaches for the public to see and smell. It has to stop. Britain is home to half the world's population of grey seals, something we should be proud of, not so. How many successful prosecutions have there been for unlawful shooting, as far as I know 1. I have witnessed first hand the inept justice system to bring about prosecution for this offence. It is a joke. Stop the issuing of the licences. please
-
Susanne Greenhowe-Weis 18 Apr 2014Whatever reason you think you have for killing seals, it doesn't fly
- it's just murder. Canada has similar issues and claims the seals are killing the fishing industry. That's absolute rubbish
- it's the flagrant greed of the fishing industry and the waste they perpetrate when discarding all fish caught that is not immediately marketable. Humans cannot stand competition and prefers to commit murder than accept it's own involvement in the problem. Stop it! -
Angel Dominguez 19 Apr 2014I´m pretty sure that my venerated master Sir David Attenborough will be agree with this petition.
-
Isabelle Gagnage 20 Apr 2014Desesperee de certain etre humain qui semble soit prendre du plaisir, soit n'avoir aucun respect pour toute forme de vie. Cette planete appartient à tous etres vivants. Tuer pour faire de l'argent ? Quel dommage. Meme 1 million de dollar ne vaudra jamais la vie d'un phoque pour moi.
Desperate for some human being who seems to be taking pleasure, or have no respect for any form of life. This planet belongs to all living beings. Kill to make money? What a pity. Even $ 1 million will never be worth the life of a seal for me. -
Daniele Halle 20 Apr 2014I live in Canada and I know the heart ache I feel for the Canadian seals, no babies should die for this abject need for the fashion industry
-
Jennifer Hobson 21 Apr 2014I believe the Scottish government is far better than to allow this to continue. They should stop salmon farming. It's unnatural and poisonous.
-
Angelique Lagarde 21 Apr 2014Such a disappointment to learn about Scotland killing seals. Please stop this!
-
Laura 21 Apr 2014Stop killing these animals...we live in 2014, not 1014, so you don't need to kill them!! Get your food somewhere else that don't kill animals. How old are you? You guys are not 10 years old.. You are grown ups, so behave like grown ups and have a little more respect for the seals!! It has to end!!!
-
DEBORAH FUCHS 21 Apr 2014Scottish people are civilised. Their is a minority in every country who are acting wrongly to our wildlife.we have to stop this and making it public and naming and shaming can be a way forward.
-
LINDA BRADY 22 Apr 2014How dare they kill seals for hunting for food? The seals have more right to the seas and rivers than we do. The human race is a virus to the animal world. We kill for greed NOT need. Let the seals forage in their ocean in safety. Would we like to be shot for foraging in our supermarkets?
-
Jane Cartney 22 Apr 2014STOP allowing commercial fish farming interests to persecute animals in the natural environment. SEALS ARE NOT VERMIN.
-
John urquhart 22 Apr 2014Please sign and help our seals
-
Roberta Helen Smith 22 Apr 2014Lots of love and luck x
-
William Norwood 22 Apr 2014Scotland must stop this disgraceful cull. Does commercial gain really come before nature?. This is disgraceful.
-
Jessica Adams 22 Apr 2014Seals are one of the reasons people visit Scotland. How on earth can you shoot them? That's 1000 tourists in the bank, with 1000 seals. Minimum.
-
Linda Hill 22 Apr 2014it's not just about giving the seals protection, in a way it protects the fish stock as well. seals hunt to not be hungry, to live., Man hunts to make a profit, by selling to those who can afford the luxury that salmon and trout are.
-
Maria Koutsoumanis 22 Apr 2014Seals are a wonderful tourist attraction. Why would you want to kill them? Embrace them. The tourists will come. Kill them and the tourists will stay away. V bad for your economy.
-
David Wright 23 Apr 2014Killing Seals is bad enough, lying, cheating & extortion is completely unacceptable.... bad business Scotland...
-
annette erdtsieck 23 Apr 2014It's bad enough that Perth WA are culling innocent sharks. Seals and sharks just do what comes naturally...move the salmon out of their reach. Simple.
-
Alec Connah. 23 Apr 2014Stop this abuse please.
-
EILEEN MACLEOD 23 Apr 2014It must come to a time of reason, killing the whales over here, killing the sharks in Australia, surely exclusion nets would be the solution. Having just seen ' Islands on the Edge ' here, it was a shock to read of this planned culling of seals. We have plundered fish stocks globally now we want to shoot the seals ???? Sad news indeed .
-
peter smith 23 Apr 2014As a frequent visitor to Scotland I am appalled by your cruel and barbaric behaviour towards your wild life shame on you
-
Adman 23 Apr 2014Don't blame the seals, look closer to your own actions and get better in the future.
-
Laura 23 Apr 2014This must stop here in Canada they have the baby seal hunt where they club them to death, it is discussing and needs to stop. They say it is taking away from the natives tradition and way of life. Time to change tradition.
-
Marjorie Caruso 23 Apr 2014Please stop killing. Why must we kill everything in sight, there's always a better way. Thank you.
-
Rachael Pankow 23 Apr 2014Just sad...there is not point to it...just wrong. The fishermen should try to keep their fish outta their reach..or Mayb they should just give sum to them
-
b. knowles 23 Apr 2014to shoot seals for the benefit of commercial salmon farms is morally bankrupt.
i have debated long and hard about wild fish stocks and realize some form of husbandry is required.
this is not the case for the sole benefit of commercial and questionable fish farm practices is not good husbandry.
the farms are the problem more than the seals. -
filip nuyttens belgium 23 Apr 2014We try everything to get them and keep them before the coast. Don't kill them. Let them live...please
-
Colin bird 23 Apr 2014Seen the results of salmon netting in Thurso Bay. Netting has been going on for years by local company. a London bases company obtained licence and within weeks most if not all the Common seals in the Bay were shot.And these were all very young seals and goes a long way to explain why the Common seal population has crashed.
-
Paula Howarth 23 Apr 2014Killing wildlife because they are doing what comes naturally ie eating to survive, disgusting...stop it right now please!!!!
-
Sylviane Roncins 23 Apr 2014I really like Scotland and I like to spend holidays there (I come from Belgium). But I can't understand such a cruelty. Please stop it.
-
Jo 23 Apr 2014This is barbaric and has to stop