Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01519 · Session 4

Save Scotland's Seals

Closed Submitted 5 Mar 2014 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
12,687 online signatures with a country
Comments
685
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop issuing licences permitting salmon farming, salmon netting and salmon angling interests to shoot and kill seals in Scottish waters and instead require that salmon farmers either move their farms into on-shore tank systems or legally require marine salmon farmers to install and maintain the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets they require to meet their legal obligation under the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 to protect their stock from the attention of predators. We further ask that the Scottish Parliament ask the Scottish Government to legislate to close down all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters thus allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed.

What the petitioner did first

We have written to the relevant Government Ministers and Marine Scotland on numerous occasions over the last four years asking them to stop licensing the killing of seals in Scotland and to make it illegal to kill seals. Sadly our requests have all been turned down and we now wish to show that there is public support for the end of legal seal killing in Scotland. We intend to contribute to the current fisheries review but we understand this is concentrating on issues raised by angling interests, many of which are pro seal shooting, and not very relevant to our campaign to end seal shooting.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Jun 2014
    1 mention
  2. 28 Oct 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 3 Dec 2014
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
    1 mention
  4. 10 Dec 2014
    1 mention

Signatures by country

12,687 online signatures
  1. England3,507 27.6%
  2. United States2,305 18.2%
  3. United Kingdom1,622 12.8%
  4. Scotland1,268 10%
  5. Australia726 5.7%
  6. Canada403 3.2%
  7. Wales227 1.8%
  8. Germany212 1.7%
  9. Netherlands184 1.5%
  10. Spain156 1.2%
  11. 111 other countries2,077 16.4%

Comments

685 comments, oldest first
685 comments · showing 151–200
  1. June Linarts 23 Apr 2014
    Please stop this slaughter of innocent creatures.
  2. Phil Barlow 23 Apr 2014
    Cruel and unnecessary
  3. Cristina Mendes 23 Apr 2014
    Stop this now!!
  4. Bee Evans, Earthling 23 Apr 2014
    Humans have gone far beyond insanity in their greed to "harvest" sea life, to suck every large animal & even the oil from the oceans. There is no "competition" with seals, it's theft & slaughter, by industrial apes with killing machinery. Restore the oceans, stop the killing.
  5. Jane Alexander 23 Apr 2014
    Embarassed to be Scottish!
  6. sharon hesford 23 Apr 2014
    Seals eat fish that is nature. Stop killing seals salmon farmers should protect their salmon from predator attack by the use of nets not kill seals
  7. Michael Bate 23 Apr 2014
    We are no better than than the Canadians by your actions stop barbaric act
  8. Jayne M 23 Apr 2014
    This needs addressing!
  9. Elaine Roft 23 Apr 2014
    JUSTICE FOR ALL SCOTLANDS SEALS KILLED BY SCOTTISH WILD SALMON COMPANY (USAN)
  10. stephanie Mandrusiak 23 Apr 2014
    Any mass species loss will affect the community of which we are resident. The more species that dies out the weaker the ecosystem becomes. Stop the killing. Think over solutions. Innovation is the key not the killing.
  11. valentina piscioneri 23 Apr 2014
    "Wake up" thank you.
  12. Jeremy Duxbury 23 Apr 2014
    There has to be a better solution than just shooting the seals. Come on, Scotland! Show the world what you stand for.
  13. Petra Hoefer 23 Apr 2014
    It's time for humans to stop interfering with wildlife and nature. Every time we do it hits us back. We have no right to kill seals, deer, badgers, hare, pheasants or whatsoever for agriculture or so called sport. Culling and hunting are murder and nothing else.
  14. Judith Findlater 23 Apr 2014
    Disgrace and sickening please put a stop to this killing. Get more fish farms up the employment.
  15. Cesaria 23 Apr 2014
    Sir, it is your duty to save nature and wildlife. Those seals have the right to live and belong to this planet as much as you do. Prove me wrong!
  16. Kristie Stephens 23 Apr 2014
    I think it's so cruel what they do to seals n they only do it for fun n these poor little animals stuffer so much
  17. Paul C. 24 Apr 2014
    So many fish are wasted by over fishing quotas generally and the farmed salmon industry causes lot of pollutants to foul the water yet seals are blamed for eating their natural food source and slaughtered for this ?

    The nitrogen and phosphorus discharged from Scotland's 350 marine salmon farms, whose salmon are fed on fish meal pellets, pose a risk to fish, mammals, shellfish and other wildlife in what were until recently pristine waters, says the report commissioned by the World Wide Fund for Nature.

    The report by Malcolm MacGarvin, an independent ecologist, uses new criteria used by Ospar, the intergovernmental body for the North East Atlantic, to calculate the extent of pollution. On one sample year salmon farms produced 7,500 tons of nitrogen, equivalent to the annual sewage from 3.2 million people, and 1,240 tons of phosphorus, comparable to sewage from 9.4 million people. The ecological result is effectively greater than the sewage produced by Scotland's 5.1 million humans.

    Nutrients stimulate plant growth and contribute to toxic algal blooms, thought to be a factor in amnesic shellfish poisoning, a disease which led to the widespread closure of scallop farms this summer. Algal blooms may be toxic to wild fish larvae and marine mammals, such as porpoises and seals, according to the report. It also kills caged salmon on salmon farms.

    Excessive nutrients have contributed to the decline of eel grass beds, a habitat which has declined by more than 80 per cent, and is home to unusual species such as the pipefish, says the report. It follows a report for the Scottish Executive by Aberdeen Marine Laboratory, which said it had yet to prove that nutrients from fish farms were responsible for toxic algal blooms. These could occur naturally.

    Dr MacGarvin said: "The evidence available shows that you can't simply dismiss the impact of nutrient pollution from fish farming. To dismiss it out of hand is to ignore the science."
  18. Jenny Hooper 24 Apr 2014
    These deplorable practices should immediately cease.
  19. Barbara Muller 24 Apr 2014
    The seals are entitled to live in their habitat. Commercial interests do not take precedence over the welfare of innocent animals. Killing them is not the answer, have some compassion.
  20. Barbara White 24 Apr 2014
    Not only is it a sad and revolting sight to find bodies of dead seals regularly washing up on the beach but visitors stay away after witnessing this horror. It must be terrifying for pregnant seals who often abort from the fear of gunshots. As part of their contract the gunmen are obliged to recover the dead bodies but they don't and someone else has to do it or leave them to rot. Those shooting the seals say they stay within the limits of their contract but they may not be educated enough to be able to count. Please stop this unspeakable horror now and let places like Gamrie become a beautiful place to live and visit once again.
  21. Lea Silhol 24 Apr 2014
    My family won't buy anything coming from Scottish fisheries till you change your methods. And I cancelled my holiday plans near Loch Awe too.
  22. M.O. 24 Apr 2014
    I know people who have to collect the dead bodies because those shooting them have not. This is just wrong. There are seal-friendly alternatives
    - use them!
  23. Jacqui Russell 24 Apr 2014
    Seals are just another creature who inhabit this planet, no more or no less right to live in peace. As humans we neither need them for food or clothing and to encroach or their territory and pay someone to kill them (whilst pregnant or with young) is nothing short of barbaric!
  24. Amanda Bowman 24 Apr 2014
    Please stop killing our lovely seals when it's so unnecessary. X
  25. Margot Young 24 Apr 2014
    Wildlife is not a resource for us humans to use or destroy for profit or pleasure, This effects of this ideology have been devastating: Its had its day & its now time to live amongst other species not destroy them at will.
  26. Nadia Blaney 24 Apr 2014
    Why persist doing the obviously wrong thing when an alternative is there?
  27. David Burnett 25 Apr 2014
    No justification and Scotland should be an example to the rest of the world regarding animal treatment.
  28. Sue Edwards 25 Apr 2014
    The 'dolphin-friendly' campaign with tuna works, so isn't it about time we have 'seal-friendly' wild salmon
    - there is no reason why seals should be killed to provide private companies with more profit. Why do humans think they have the right to the fish in the sea
    - live and let live.
  29. Kristie Mullikin 25 Apr 2014
    I am not from Scotland but I think its just wrong to kill any animal. Makes me sick to my stomach. Hope all this stops!!
  30. Yvonne Lilley 25 Apr 2014
    This practice is barbaric and has no place in modern day society. Please Scotland lead the way in showing what a responsible and caring country you are.
  31. Daniela Bress 25 Apr 2014
    Your intention to slaughter seals is a disgrace for your country and your people. Such killings are pointless and do not belong in these times of loss of habitats, environmental pollutions, dangers caused by shipping, global warming, overfishing, etc., I always considered the Scottish people to be more farsighted than the Canadians. Too bad that I was obviously wrong.
  32. Rosemary V Bernier 25 Apr 2014
    Why are we so obsessed with killing sentient beings? God did NOT intend for this to happen yet we do it anyway :(
  33. jill adamson 25 Apr 2014
    Seals rely on fish to survive, we do not. Greedy humans yet again.
  34. fiona worrell 25 Apr 2014
    Please remove the right to slaughter seals for commercial gain in the whole of Scotland, and in particular refuse licences in conservation areas ie Moray Firth..there are enough areas with salmon that no longer sustain seals!
  35. Betty Keegan 26 Apr 2014
    I'm so very disappointed in Scotland
    Scotland has become Famous not because of her scenery or Golf, but as one of the countries that doesn't care for her wildlife, along with Taiji, Faroe's, Canada etc
  36. Margaret Morton 26 Apr 2014
    Seals are our British wildlife they are precious and should be protected....stop the killing!
  37. Mike Maas 26 Apr 2014
    Alternatives are available. Make them compulsory !
  38. Judy Sale 26 Apr 2014
    Not sure what right we have to deprive the seals of their food source-we have choices,they don't.Killing them is the wrong option,i understand fishermen have a living to make but slaughtering seals because they eat the profits of the fishermen?Sorry its wrong,very wrong.
  39. Melanie Hayward 26 Apr 2014
    For gods sake let's just stop killing ANIMALS
  40. Nathan Hudson 26 Apr 2014
    I detest animal cruelty of all kinds. I've been vegan for years and encourage others to do so. However, money talks, and this attacks the supply, not the demand. Animal protein is responsible for more cancers than any chemical carcinogen (and milk has pus in it). I sign this to bolster the cause, but fear everyone signing it may be barking up the wrong tree. Promote the ills of eating it, not hunting it, as they're hand in hand.
  41. Nicole Thibault 26 Apr 2014
    Please let all those marvellous sentient Beings live the life in Freedom like they were meant to live, just like us humans they have soul and feel pain. Thank You
  42. Valerie Peters 26 Apr 2014
    This communities need to wake up to the damage being caused by comercial fishing. Stop blaming the wildlife. The sea existed in balance long before humans came.
  43. Nancy Young 26 Apr 2014
    There has to be solutions. What is happening is morally wrong. Killing seals must be stopped.
  44. Larisa Konovalyuk 26 Apr 2014
    STOP THIS TORTURE
  45. Lindsay Tomlinson 26 Apr 2014
    This is so wrong! Please save the seals!
  46. Cesar Castro 26 Apr 2014
    Stop issuing licences permitting salmon farming
  47. Laura Hillman 26 Apr 2014
    Killing Seals is not the answer. There is always another solution that does not involve the slaughter of innocents.
  48. susanna minacheili 26 Apr 2014
    save Scotlands seals
  49. Paula Stein 26 Apr 2014
    This is a shameful act...almost as shameful as Canada's terrible, cruel and inhumane slaughter of east coast seals. Almost as shameful of the dolphin massacre in Taiji, Japan. Stop the killing!
  50. Joanna Langada 26 Apr 2014
    Sustainable fishing is a must. And it solves the problem of cruelty against seals. Everyone wins. Please do the right thing. Thank you.