Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01519 · Session 4

Save Scotland's Seals

Closed Submitted 5 Mar 2014 Environment & Energy
Signatures
0
12,687 online signatures with a country
Comments
685
Considered
4 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

Calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to stop issuing licences permitting salmon farming, salmon netting and salmon angling interests to shoot and kill seals in Scottish waters and instead require that salmon farmers either move their farms into on-shore tank systems or legally require marine salmon farmers to install and maintain the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets they require to meet their legal obligation under the Animal Health & Welfare (Scotland) Act 2006 to protect their stock from the attention of predators. We further ask that the Scottish Parliament ask the Scottish Government to legislate to close down all salmon netting stations in Scottish waters thus allowing tens of thousands of Atlantic Salmon and seatrout to return to their native rivers to breed.

What the petitioner did first

We have written to the relevant Government Ministers and Marine Scotland on numerous occasions over the last four years asking them to stop licensing the killing of seals in Scotland and to make it illegal to kill seals. Sadly our requests have all been turned down and we now wish to show that there is public support for the end of legal seal killing in Scotland. We intend to contribute to the current fisheries review but we understand this is concentrating on issues raised by angling interests, many of which are pro seal shooting, and not very relevant to our campaign to end seal shooting.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 17 Jun 2014
    1 mention
  2. 28 Oct 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 3 Dec 2014
    Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee
    Community Empowerment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1
    1 mention
  4. 10 Dec 2014
    1 mention

Signatures by country

12,687 online signatures
  1. England3,507 27.6%
  2. United States2,305 18.2%
  3. United Kingdom1,622 12.8%
  4. Scotland1,268 10%
  5. Australia726 5.7%
  6. Canada403 3.2%
  7. Wales227 1.8%
  8. Germany212 1.7%
  9. Netherlands184 1.5%
  10. Spain156 1.2%
  11. 111 other countries2,077 16.4%

Comments

685 comments, oldest first
685 comments · showing 251–300
  1. Rose Barden 28 Apr 2014
    unless 'humans' STOP Killing we will Never learn to Live in Peace
  2. Arthur Barden 28 Apr 2014
    Compassion must reign over Cruelty, if we hope to EVOLVE!
  3. Rachel 28 Apr 2014
    Killing seals is wrong.
  4. jacquie walker 28 Apr 2014
    Protect the seals please! They have the right to eat!!
  5. Bethany Hunt 28 Apr 2014
    Fishermen maximising their profits does not justify mass slaughter!
  6. Alicia Ogburn 28 Apr 2014
    This practice is wrong, please evolve and show the world how compassionate Scotland can be.
  7. Ivan 28 Apr 2014
    I am not from Scotland but I think Scotland can lead the way for other nations to stop this barbaric and cruel practice. Please stop!
  8. Anne-Marie Lindblom 28 Apr 2014
    Please stop this meanless killing
  9. Dianne Baxter 28 Apr 2014
    Salmon farming is possible without culling seals...the law has to recognise how important all of our wild life is, especially the Seals...culling must be banned!
  10. Miranda Morrison 28 Apr 2014
    There is no need to kill these seals, other ways can be used that are humane to move the Seals along. This is needless slaughter of beautiful creatures that of course will eat fish! How dare you as Humans have the right to cull fellow beings just because it gets in the way of your profits. Start ow in showning your humanity. You know there are other ways to solve this problem and it isnt in crucifying another specie simply for existing in theri own land. And you The Scots dont see the irony of this. Leave them alone.
  11. Mr Greer Hart, senior 28 Apr 2014
    It is cynical to proceed to allow unnecessary seal slaughter to placate a strident fishing industry. The conservation of our wild fish stocks are essential for future generations, but we should minimise the killing of other creatures that depend on such resource for their survival. Conservation ethics teach that a harvester of a natural resource, should be content with what remains after natural predation.
  12. Jill Pesqueira 28 Apr 2014
    This is so wrong. Please stop!
  13. kiwiriauk 28 Apr 2014
    I am, to be frank, absolutely GOBSMACKED that they shoot seals, issue licences that people can abuse, and not make the farmers farm OFFSHORE. This is rediculous.... Its like setting up a cabbage patch in the middle of a rabbit warren.... I mean REALLY.
    Or how's about setting the farm up with better fences instead of killing the local wildlife. I am astounded.
    Signed and shared
  14. DENISE SMITH 28 Apr 2014
    Please just listen to the views of the public......
  15. Cristiana 28 Apr 2014
    People around the world are shocked by the unnecessary and cruel killing of seals in Scottish waters. Alternatives exist for the coexistence of wildlife conservation and salmon farms. I'd like to see Scotland stop issuing licenses to shoot seals, make the high-strength, high tension predator exclusion nets mandatory or make the farmers move salmons in an on-shore tank system. Instead of allowing the seal slaughter and the ecosystem destruction, Scotland should protect the wildlife in its waters. Please, do the right thing.
  16. Colin Parker 28 Apr 2014
    I am a UK Citizen although I do not live in the UK now. I still think this is a despicable way to treat any animal and it is about time the World stopped killing living creatures like this.
  17. Gina Gow 28 Apr 2014
    There is no place in our society for an unnecessary cull of wild animals that can be controlled by other non-lethal methods such as ADDs.
  18. Mary Foley 28 Apr 2014
    please stop killing the seals wildlife is important to the ecosystem and for tourism there is no excuse for this cruelty
  19. Christine Antle 28 Apr 2014
    With each seal killed...so is humanity
  20. Sharon Mistic 28 Apr 2014
    "culling" seals is inhumane!
  21. Ronald H Freeman 28 Apr 2014
    Was going to vacation in Scotland this year. WAS going, now....I don't think so.
  22. Phillip Anderton 29 Apr 2014
    Please don't follow the lunatic policies against British wildlife as exempified by the ConDem's in Westminster!
  23. Birgit Caminada 29 Apr 2014
    These animals have every right to live out there !
  24. Dr swati kumar 29 Apr 2014
    We are not living in stone age. Be humane. Ban seal slaughter
  25. Jennifer Skirpan 29 Apr 2014
    This is horrific & cruel!!!!
  26. Tara Walters 29 Apr 2014
    We are connected to this earth and we all animals and humans have the same right to live. Please STOP the killing of defancless creatures. This is their home too!
  27. katey hart 29 Apr 2014
    Can't believe anyone would think this is ok!
  28. Linda Moore 29 Apr 2014
    There are options to the salmon farmers. Please, please don't shoot the seals, please!
  29. Mathew 29 Apr 2014
    Why? Why would you do this to any living thing, let alone seals? This is really bad and it has to stop.
  30. Martin 29 Apr 2014
    See there are hardly any signatures from Scottish compared to elsewhere even though this is a local issue
  31. gordon mason 29 Apr 2014
    no more wildlife killing in the name of fish monger profits from salmon please.
  32. Mary Erasmus 29 Apr 2014
    Scotland is responsible for persecuting innocent precious wildlife ... Shameful
  33. Pauline Maclean 29 Apr 2014
    Well done to Sea Shepherds for protecting these voiceless beautiful creatures x
  34. Libby Potts 29 Apr 2014
    THERE HAS TO BE AN ALTERNATIVE --PLEASE.
  35. Anne-Marie Boyle 29 Apr 2014
    I was shocked to learn that a 'caring' government is happy to sanction the 'legal' killing of these innocent creatures. I would urge the SNP to review and disregard their present policy which is I would regard as barbaric.
  36. liz Revuelta 29 Apr 2014
    Shame on Scotland for allowing the killing of seals to happen.We are grateful for the dedication of the Sea Shepherds who are protecting the seals.
  37. Iris Koch 29 Apr 2014
    Seals have a right to live! Humans don't own this planet...
  38. Annabel Gardner 29 Apr 2014
    Please please please use non-lethal ways of scaring the seals off. Killing the seals is so unecessary and barbaric and must be stopped!
  39. Elizabeth Trueman 29 Apr 2014
    This is barbaric you need to stop shooting the seals
  40. anne whitaker 29 Apr 2014
    cruel and no need for it
  41. Dawn Bliss 29 Apr 2014
    Absolutely no need for this!
  42. Mykel Warmack 30 Apr 2014
    What kind of people are we if sit back and do nothing about the seals being killed, they deserve our protection.
  43. Sandra Hajek 30 Apr 2014
    I really wish all this evil killing would stop. What happened to the world we used to live in and human compassion for animals. Please stop this madness! You can change this! Do the right thing!
  44. mary howes 30 Apr 2014
    how can a country do this in the 21st century- it brings shame on you
  45. Suzanne Locklin 30 Apr 2014
    SOBS
    - please save our beautiful seals
  46. Amy Keeper 30 Apr 2014
    This breaks my heart, having just been on a wildlife holiday to Scotland, I can't bear to think that some of those incredible creatures will be killed unnecessarily. Scotland attracts nature lovers from all over the world and the abundance of seals are a big part of that. We don't have that many large mammals left in the UK we need to look after those we have!
  47. binnie shaw 30 Apr 2014
    Time to take a stand to Stop loss of biodiversity!
  48. Nandita Shah 30 Apr 2014
    Its a shame that Scotland does not respect its wildlife. The whole world is moving towards stronger animals rights rules too. Scotland will and should catch up
  49. LISA YATES 30 Apr 2014
    There is no need to do this nature takes care of itself and doesn't need mankind sticking its nose in.
  50. simon lazarus 30 Apr 2014
    Stop and look around !!! destruction, destroys!!