Petition · PE01503 · Session 4
Review of A9 speed camera proposals'
Signatures
0
Comments
192
Considered
3 meetings
What it asks
The A9 Safety Group recently proposed an Average Speed Camera System on the A9 in order to reduce fatalities. This group belives this is the incorrect decision based on official statistics which show that breaking thew speed limit accounts for only 2% of accidents on the A9, whereas overtaking manouvres account for nearly 50% of A9 accidents. We belive that the A9 Safety Group has not investigated adequate alternatives to deal with the majority cause of A9 accidents and the modelling used to propose the A9 system is flawed. We belive there should be a full parliamentary debate on the proposal along with the reformation of the A9 Safety Group to allow representation from car drivers, who make up over 95% of A9 road users, yet have not been involved in an A9 Safety Group meetings. We belive as the evidence is flawed and does not have full parliamentty support, the A9 Speed Camera System must be delayed indefinately until an investigation is carried out to look at the workings of the A9 Safety Group, Transport Scotland and investiagte other proposals which would have a direct impact on overtaking, which is the main offical cause of accidents on the A9.
What the petitioner did first
In response to the A9 Speed Camera Proposal, a Facebook campaign was set up to allow interested individuals to discuss alternatives as well as express frustration that the A9 Safety Group had not understood the real problems of A9 driving. This group has nearly 9000 followers, with the majority statistically being based in IV and KW postcode areas. It has been seen by over 1/2 million unique viewers since creation. It has comments in excess of 15,000 of discussion and debate on alternatives and photographic evidence of poor driving at low speed, poor road condition and other elements of driver frustration which Average Speed Cameras will not resolve. Official statistics show that Mean Speeds on all A9 data counters falls below the legal speed limit.
- A 20 point Interim plan for the A9 was published to discuss and investigate real alternatives to the Average Speed Camera proposal in August 2013. This included systems to prevent overtaking such as lane control, spacing control, improving visibility with vastly improved maintainence of the road and roadside, alternatives to drivers who wish not to use the A9 until dualling is complete and options for other A9 road users. This was sent to Transport Scotland and MSP's but was never debated in parliament nor did Transport Scotland issue a response despite having a working group dealing with the plan.
- An independent Survey Monkey was set up due to continuing blocking tactics of the Scottish Parliament Petitions department to allow A9 users to make their view heard and also suggest alternatives. This has so far received over 1700 responses with 91% stating they believe A9 Average Speed Cameras will not address safety in the current climate on the A9.
- An MSP was approached to help the campaign proceed with their official petition at the Scottish Parliament who we believe did approach the Petition Team and was assured there was no obvious reason why the petition was continually being blocked.
- A media campaign has been set up to publish information gleaned from FOI requests which prove that speed is not the main factor in A9 incidents, Police Scotland state they do not record Incident Speeds in the 544 page FOI document received on every A9 incident since 2007. It also appears that Transport Scotland had advanced plans for an A9 Average Speed Camera system for some years in advance of the announcement and an FOI request in still in progress to ascertain the level of engagement and lobbying there may have been with such companies.
- Voters have been encouraged to write to their MSP's on the issue and we belive this has been done, though there has still not been any public debate in parliament on the proposal nor has there been any delay whilst flaws in evidence and statistics are debated as well as alternatives, which FOI shows have not been investigated.
- Campaign groups have offered to meet the Transport Minister, who has ignored all correspondance personally with the campaign, whilst the Chief Executive of Transport Scotland, David Middleton, has refused 2 times to personally meet campaigners to discuss the concerns raised by nearly 9000 A9 users.
- The campaign offered to set up a cross political party, cross agency conference to discuss the campaign and also alternatives to the A9 Average Speed Camera system. The Transport Minister and the A9 Safety Group never responded to the invitation to the conference whilst MSPs and Transport Scotland did so. Therefore the conference could not proceed.
- A 20 point Interim plan for the A9 was published to discuss and investigate real alternatives to the Average Speed Camera proposal in August 2013. This included systems to prevent overtaking such as lane control, spacing control, improving visibility with vastly improved maintainence of the road and roadside, alternatives to drivers who wish not to use the A9 until dualling is complete and options for other A9 road users. This was sent to Transport Scotland and MSP's but was never debated in parliament nor did Transport Scotland issue a response despite having a working group dealing with the plan.
- An independent Survey Monkey was set up due to continuing blocking tactics of the Scottish Parliament Petitions department to allow A9 users to make their view heard and also suggest alternatives. This has so far received over 1700 responses with 91% stating they believe A9 Average Speed Cameras will not address safety in the current climate on the A9.
- An MSP was approached to help the campaign proceed with their official petition at the Scottish Parliament who we believe did approach the Petition Team and was assured there was no obvious reason why the petition was continually being blocked.
- A media campaign has been set up to publish information gleaned from FOI requests which prove that speed is not the main factor in A9 incidents, Police Scotland state they do not record Incident Speeds in the 544 page FOI document received on every A9 incident since 2007. It also appears that Transport Scotland had advanced plans for an A9 Average Speed Camera system for some years in advance of the announcement and an FOI request in still in progress to ascertain the level of engagement and lobbying there may have been with such companies.
- Voters have been encouraged to write to their MSP's on the issue and we belive this has been done, though there has still not been any public debate in parliament on the proposal nor has there been any delay whilst flaws in evidence and statistics are debated as well as alternatives, which FOI shows have not been investigated.
- Campaign groups have offered to meet the Transport Minister, who has ignored all correspondance personally with the campaign, whilst the Chief Executive of Transport Scotland, David Middleton, has refused 2 times to personally meet campaigners to discuss the concerns raised by nearly 9000 A9 users.
- The campaign offered to set up a cross political party, cross agency conference to discuss the campaign and also alternatives to the A9 Average Speed Camera system. The Transport Minister and the A9 Safety Group never responded to the invitation to the conference whilst MSPs and Transport Scotland did so. Therefore the conference could not proceed.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
28 Jan 20141 mention
-
22 Apr 20141 mention
-
17 Jun 20141 mention
Signatures by country
2,007 online signaturesComments
192 comments, oldest first192 comments · showing 151–192
-
Vanessa Ling 26 Nov 2013They have signs saying that frustration causes accidents so they know it's not speed per se, but overtaking without having enough clear space to do so safely, because you've lost it after following something slow for what feels like hours.
-
chris dowling 26 Nov 2013accidents will be reduced by more dual carriageway
-
Mike Rogers 26 Nov 2013A very cheap 'fix', what is needed is complete dualling of the road.
-
Tim Walker 26 Nov 2013Average Speed Cameras are likely to lead to greater frustration and an increase in accidents.
-
Shepherd 26 Nov 2013Speeding is not the problem...it is caused by bad driving....taking that risky overtaking manoeuvre.
-
IDRIS FRANCIS 26 Nov 2013BELIEVE NOT BELIVE! OTHERWISE EXCELLENT
APART FROM "SHOW LESS COMMENTS" SHOULD BE "SHOW FEWER COMMENTS" -
Caroline Angus 26 Nov 2013The speed camera is irrelevant on this road. Too much traffic sitting at 40 mph (ie tesco lorries) causing annoyance and hazards. Duel carriage way and solve the issue.
-
Peter Anderson 26 Nov 2013Putting in average speed camera's wont stop the accidents I have driven the A9 for over forty years seen plenty of accidents and loads of near misses. This road has dual carriageways dotted all along it's length and most of the accidents occur in between these carriageways. If you want to cut the accident rate make it all dual carriageway and difference will be seen right away. The big problem with it just now is you think your still on the dual section and your not I will hold my hand up and say I been guilty of thinking that same thing, ready to overtake and then realized that it's not what you think it is.
-
Alan Ogilvie 26 Nov 2013In my experience if traffic is moving at 60 or 70 mph over long stretches of road there are less incidences of overtaking. However, when traffic bunches up behind a slow moving truck or car towing a caravan that's when the problems start and other drivers become frustrated.
-
Bill Gillespie 26 Nov 2013Drivers (private and commercial) driving too close together is a major issue, and not speed per se. This can often result in drivers "taking on" potentially hazerdous overtaking of multiple vehicles, but I have yet to hear of anyone being cautioned for creating the danger viz: driving too closely together.
-
Malcolm Heymer 26 Nov 2013Agree speed cameras not the answer. Raising HGV speed limit might help to reduce need to overtake.
-
Terry Hudson 26 Nov 2013If there was no speed limits, there would be no 'speeding.'
But you would still have dangerous drivers!
Why punish everybody with longer journey times for the mistakes of a very few? -
Jason Hoffman 26 Nov 2013Speed camera's are not the solution to the A9's problems. Bad driving is bad driving, and will continue until the road is dualled.
-
Andrew 26 Nov 2013Speed or Average cameras are not the answer because if people are continually concentrating on there speed a lot they will be more likely not to pay attention to the road ahead, this is a key point in speed camera effectiveness in that it diverts vital concentration from the road ahead to a fixation with the speedometer.
On the A9 this is a very dangerous move on a single land road where people are overtaking a lot and there are heavy goods vehicles going slower.
If average cameras are installed then people will be less likely to overtake in fear of going over the limit, causing more tailbacks, more frustration, and ultimately more accidents. -
Dave 26 Nov 2013I recently attended a talk by Transport Scotland where it was stated that they could prove a "business case" for dualling the A9 by reducing journey times, accidents and driver frustration. Pretty obvious really, so I think what they are trying to do in the interim by introducing cameras is to increase journey times, accidents and driver frustration so that their "business case" can be more easily proved! Why do we need a "business case" anyway
- its a rubbish road, its outlived its design life
- get it dualled! -
Andrew mcdonald 27 Nov 2013Do not out camera's on the A9 it will a bad road worse
-
David Hannah 27 Nov 2013The majority of accidents caused on the A9 are as a result of the lack of investment in Scotland's road network. Instead of looking to upgrade an obsolete road the government should be looking to provide a new motorway direct from Stirling to Thurso. This would link into the existing motorway network to England and Europe.
The A9 should be improved to dual carriageway from Perth to Wick thereby providing an alternative for those wishing to travel more slowly and enjoy the route leaving those of us with more urgent business need to get on. -
E Frew 27 Nov 2013Increase the speed of ALL the heavy goods vehicles for a start, they are the main cause of frustration, anger and accidents. An exception for them on the A9 only would solve most if not all the problems on this road
- AVSC's will only exaggerate the problem and cause further problems with having to continuously check the speed dial. -
colin mcintosh 27 Nov 2013Cars do 60 and can overtake a lorry doing 40 a lot easier than one doing 50 (56). So whats the problem
-
Bob the Greyhound 27 Nov 2013Another made-cap scheme by those completely detached from the real world.
-
Roger Crawford 28 Nov 2013SPECS System cameras on the A9 will not solve the accident rate problem it is just another classic knee jerk reaction,.the cameras will be a total nightmare especially during May 'thro September.
-
Nigel Crawford 28 Nov 2013Yet again, those in positions of responsibility have no concept of how to deal with a problem. Through a short cut and lack of detailed investigation into the true cause of accidents on the A9 they come up with a hair brained scheme rather than looking at the logic and hard fact that impatience and the inevitable rushed overtaking on the A9 is the big problem. It appears the do-gooders have invaded another area of our precious world!!
-
Brian Sharp IAM 28 Nov 2013Average speed cameras will only lead to more frustration and more accidents. The money should be spent on bringing dual ling forward.
-
cynthia bruce-gordon 29 Nov 2013By the time they get round to completeing the dualling the A9 it will be obsolete--just like most other DC's in Scotland.
Speed cameras will do absolutely nothing to prevent accidents on this road.
As it stands, much of the frustration is caused by ignorant drivers or bloody minded drivers.
This is seen daily when slow drivers hold up laden vehicles (hgv's and caravans etc) on the approach to the hilly sections of the road. They don't seem to realise that such vehicles require to get a run at the hills in order to maintain reasonable progress and minimise tailbacks. -
Nichola 30 Nov 2013There are other safety measures that can be put in place: if it was compulsory to have your headlights on driving on A roads, everybody would appear more visible. If there were more visible police then it may deter tailgaters and lane hoggers, and pick up on others incompetent driving, giving advice, warnings and no doubt fines, however possibly overall improving some people's skills and attitudes to driving, therefore reducing the risks and frustrations to the rest of us. Maybe the "wear your seatbelt" sign should be replaced with "when did you last read the Highway Code", cause lets face it we all know a seatbelt can be a lifesaver but some people don't even know that a solid white line in the middle of the road means no overtaking.
-
Aubrey Moore 2 Dec 2013Frustration is the main cause of accidents on the A9. Whilst average sped cameras on the A77 may have reduced accidents tree one cannot compare the 2 roads. If I,in my car, am stuck behind a lorry travelling at 40 mph for 2 miles, can I then drive at 80 mph for another 2 miles?
More frequent stretches of dual carriageway or overtaking lanes are required. The few temporary mobile signs indicating dual carriageway ahead certainly calm drivers nerves. -
Benjamin Ashworth 4 Dec 2013Even where speed is a factor in accidents, it is never the sole cause. Average speed cameras do not look at drivers who are uninsured, do not have licences, are driving vehicles in an unroadworthy condition, are tailgating, are carrying out dangerous overtaking maneuvers, are using handheld mobile phones and are generally driving dangerously and carelessly while not actually averaging more than the speed limit. Speed has not been the main factor in any of the accidents that have occurred on the A9 and it's unlikely any of them would have been prevented by cameras.
As for the overtaking issue in itself, much of the section the cameras will cover is dual carriageway where overtaking isn't an issue. On the single carriageway roads people will be reluctant to overtake even the slowest vehicles because of the fear they have of the cameras watching them. Others will accelerate past the long lines of slow moving vehicles before slowing down to lower their average speed. The result will be greater speed differentials and even more erratic and dangerous overtaking and than there is now which will result in more impatience and thoughtless acts of carelessness and more collisions.
One of the initial primary arguments for the average speed cameras was to force HGV drivers to stick to their 40mph limit on the single carriageway sections. HGV drivers have proposed a protest where they actually will stick to 40mph just to show what the road will be like when they are all constantly forced to abide by the limit rather than being flexible and exceeding it to help traffic flow. This has led to a policy rethink where trials of a 50mph limit for HGVs will be carried out, going back on the idea that HGVs exceeding 40mph is incredibly dangerous. How can there be an unswerving attitude that all speeding is dangerous when the policy makers are admitting they have to allow some drivers to exceed their current limit just to keep the road operating in a practical and safe way? -
James Wemyss 4 Dec 2013Overtaking will be more dangerous if SPECS cameras are introduced. More serious accidents will occur on the dual and 2 + 1 sections of the A9 so the fatality rate will NOT drop but probably go UP!
-
Dave 7 Dec 2013The introduction of a 50mph limit for HGV's is unlikely to make much difference as it will merely legalise the status quo. HGV's operasted by large supermarket chains are still going to be limited to 40mph by their companies.
-
Craig Bruce 9 Dec 2013Don't go up the A9 often but in 24 years of driving still my 2 closest experiences to death if i hadn't braked to a halt to avoid a crazy overtaking move coming the other way.
-
Norman Lauritsen 9 Dec 2013It is impossible to understand what this will. Achieve, except to waste money which could be better spent on genuine safety improvements. The presence of so many HGVs on the road makes it impossible for the motorist to exceed the AVERAGE speed limit on this road. The real danger is from overtaking on the single carriageway sections. Forcing people to concentrate more on their speedometers rather than watching the road ahead will do nothing to improve safety.
-
Dave 13 Dec 2013Unfortunately the average speed cameras don't work over the whole length of the road
- only between adjacent pairs so your average between Perth and Inverness might only be 45mph but on the one stretch where you've manged to overtake a few slow moving cars at 65mph average between 2 cameras
- you've committed an offence!!! -
Murdo graham 16 Dec 2013As a regular user of the A9 I fed up being stuck behind slow moving lorries no curtice very few pull to allow overtaking as far as roads we are the poorest country world I have driven it a lot of different places even in3 country they have better roads than us .
-
John MacDonald 16 Dec 2013More visible police traffic patrols would prevent a lot of these accidents. In most cases accidents are caused by instances of drivers becoming imatient and trying to overtake when the circumstances are wrong.
-
Graham Thompson 16 Dec 2013Frustration causes accidents, not speed! Bring the A9 upgrade forward instead of wasting money on cameras!
-
Scott Mckenzie 16 Dec 2013Average speed cameras are not the answer as car drivers do noy know how they work so wont overtake fast enough as they will think they will get done for speeding therefore travelling along on the wrong side for a longer time making accidents more limely to happen
-
Roy Cleary 16 Dec 2013waste of money better to spend it dualing the road all the way. So much for independence and infrastruture
-
Darren faulkner 17 Dec 2013Its revenue that the government are more intrested in.
-
Carol 17 Dec 2013As a regular traveller on this road I have regularly witnessed extremely dangerous overtaking manoeuvres and near misses, people driving at faster speeds stop tailbacks when faced with slow vehicles.
-
Alex Ayers 17 Dec 2013When towing a caravan on this road at the prescribed speed limits 50 and 60 mph, solo cars overtaking pose real danger to my family and on coming vehicles. Speed limits and their enforcement is a mess in the UK
-
Calum Mackinnon 18 Dec 2013The money for cameras n all the hype that goes with it would be better spent on dialling the A9 now, notin years to come. They can find money for disasters all over the world, why not spend it on the disaster that is the A9. As is is a disaster for the families of everybody killed on it every year, no matter the cause......if Alex Salmond lived in Inverness it would be done, same as it has been done from Edinburgh to Ellon a few miles from his home........rant over
-
Fiona MacQueen 18 Dec 2013Look to prevent hgv's travelling together
- happens frequently
- makes it a massive and dangerous overtake!!