Parliament Workbench

Petition · PE01503 · Session 4

Review of A9 speed camera proposals'

Closed Submitted 29 Jul 2013
Signatures
0
2,007 online signatures with a country
Comments
192
Considered
3 meetings
in the Official Report

What it asks

The A9 Safety Group recently proposed an Average Speed Camera System on the A9 in order to reduce fatalities. This group belives this is the incorrect decision based on official statistics which show that breaking thew speed limit accounts for only 2% of accidents on the A9, whereas overtaking manouvres account for nearly 50% of A9 accidents. We belive that the A9 Safety Group has not investigated adequate alternatives to deal with the majority cause of A9 accidents and the modelling used to propose the A9 system is flawed. We belive there should be a full parliamentary debate on the proposal along with the reformation of the A9 Safety Group to allow representation from car drivers, who make up over 95% of A9 road users, yet have not been involved in an A9 Safety Group meetings. We belive as the evidence is flawed and does not have full parliamentty support, the A9 Speed Camera System must be delayed indefinately until an investigation is carried out to look at the workings of the A9 Safety Group, Transport Scotland and investiagte other proposals which would have a direct impact on overtaking, which is the main offical cause of accidents on the A9.

What the petitioner did first

In response to the A9 Speed Camera Proposal, a Facebook campaign was set up to allow interested individuals to discuss alternatives as well as express frustration that the A9 Safety Group had not understood the real problems of A9 driving. This group has nearly 9000 followers, with the majority statistically being based in IV and KW postcode areas. It has been seen by over 1/2 million unique viewers since creation. It has comments in excess of 15,000 of discussion and debate on alternatives and photographic evidence of poor driving at low speed, poor road condition and other elements of driver frustration which Average Speed Cameras will not resolve. Official statistics show that Mean Speeds on all A9 data counters falls below the legal speed limit.
- A 20 point Interim plan for the A9 was published to discuss and investigate real alternatives to the Average Speed Camera proposal in August 2013. This included systems to prevent overtaking such as lane control, spacing control, improving visibility with vastly improved maintainence of the road and roadside, alternatives to drivers who wish not to use the A9 until dualling is complete and options for other A9 road users. This was sent to Transport Scotland and MSP's but was never debated in parliament nor did Transport Scotland issue a response despite having a working group dealing with the plan.
- An independent Survey Monkey was set up due to continuing blocking tactics of the Scottish Parliament Petitions department to allow A9 users to make their view heard and also suggest alternatives. This has so far received over 1700 responses with 91% stating they believe A9 Average Speed Cameras will not address safety in the current climate on the A9.
- An MSP was approached to help the campaign proceed with their official petition at the Scottish Parliament who we believe did approach the Petition Team and was assured there was no obvious reason why the petition was continually being blocked.
- A media campaign has been set up to publish information gleaned from FOI requests which prove that speed is not the main factor in A9 incidents, Police Scotland state they do not record Incident Speeds in the 544 page FOI document received on every A9 incident since 2007. It also appears that Transport Scotland had advanced plans for an A9 Average Speed Camera system for some years in advance of the announcement and an FOI request in still in progress to ascertain the level of engagement and lobbying there may have been with such companies.
- Voters have been encouraged to write to their MSP's on the issue and we belive this has been done, though there has still not been any public debate in parliament on the proposal nor has there been any delay whilst flaws in evidence and statistics are debated as well as alternatives, which FOI shows have not been investigated.
- Campaign groups have offered to meet the Transport Minister, who has ignored all correspondance personally with the campaign, whilst the Chief Executive of Transport Scotland, David Middleton, has refused 2 times to personally meet campaigners to discuss the concerns raised by nearly 9000 A9 users.
- The campaign offered to set up a cross political party, cross agency conference to discuss the campaign and also alternatives to the A9 Average Speed Camera system. The Transport Minister and the A9 Safety Group never responded to the invitation to the conference whilst MSPs and Transport Scotland did so. Therefore the conference could not proceed.

Where it was considered

Official Report
  1. 28 Jan 2014
    1 mention
  2. 22 Apr 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention
  3. 17 Jun 2014
    Public Petitions Committee
    Current Petitions
    1 mention

Signatures by country

2,007 online signatures
  1. Scotland1,741 86.7%
  2. United Kingdom203 10.1%
  3. England50 2.5%
  4. Wales4 0.2%
  5. United States1 0%
  6. Austria1 0%
  7. Togo1 0%
  8. Netherlands1 0%
  9. Northern Ireland1 0%
  10. Ireland1 0%
  11. 3 other countries3 0.1%

Comments

192 comments, oldest first
192 comments · showing 51–100
  1. Leslie McLaggan 24 Nov 2013
    The A9 does not need average speed cameras
  2. Tam Reid 24 Nov 2013
    There are other issues that are causing accidents on tnis road and speeding isnt the issue , I have seen accidents on this road and it hasnt been speeding thats caused it
  3. colin capp 24 Nov 2013
    cameras are not the answer up the speed limit off hgv and duel the A9 inverness to perth
  4. David Moore 24 Nov 2013
    It is BAD driving that causes the problems on the A9. Drivers who are ignorant in their manouvers and drivers who pay NO attention to the road. Also since the A9 was designed and built the vegitation has closed off many of the designed in lines of visability to make it a safe road. Also poor sighting of road signs have also made visability worse.
  5. Tricia Adie 24 Nov 2013
    Seems to me that the brains behind this idea are not regular users of the A9 or they'd know it's not the solution.
  6. Adam Beck 24 Nov 2013
    The issue is not with drivers speeding, it's them not going fast enough. Therefore frustrating other drivers into making mistakes by not being able to overtake.
    What does worry, though, is that an investigation would end up costing as much as the cameras themselves.
    The road clearly needs to be duelled.
  7. chris 24 Nov 2013
    Dual carrige is only option but exspensive so the average speed cameras is a easy and cheaper wsy to save face and forget about the problem
  8. Andrew Murdoch 24 Nov 2013
    No need for this rubbish get the30MPH and 40 MPH to get of the road they cause most accidents and get the lorry drivers to pull in and let traffic flow when they see 6 vehicles behind them
  9. Andrew Cecil 24 Nov 2013
    Selfish and aggressive driving need to be addressed, speed cameras will not do this. I have had cars that close i could not see their headlights, un-marked patrols would be better.
  10. Donna Beck 24 Nov 2013
    This road should have been dualled a long time ago instead of wasting money on the trams. How many people have died because of this. As far as I am concerned having driven this road many times it is the overtaking that is the issue. Ok may be average speed will work in that people won't necessarily overtake for fear of messing with thier average BUT I have driven so slow in this road that the average speed is prob lower than the speed limit due to congestion! This will NOT help!
  11. John Sehar 24 Nov 2013
    If anyone from the southern end of the A9 had to use the road daily they would sigb this petition without hesitation! !!
  12. Dawn Morrison 24 Nov 2013
    Average speed cameras will encourage more dangerous overtaking due to longer time required to pass vehicles.
  13. Darren Hunt 24 Nov 2013
    Put the monet from buying cameras towards another stretch of dual carriegeway..
  14. Jonathan Oxley 24 Nov 2013
    As a regular user of the A9 over many years, I cannot see how the installation of these average speed cameras will have a positive effect on road safety on the A9. The road has such a mixed range of traffic
    - speed and type
    - that such a flawed proposal will merely serve to increase frustration among road users and lead to riskier overtaking manoeuvres.
  15. Wendy Pieroni 24 Nov 2013
    Average speed cameras will cause frustration and make a dangerous road even more dangerous.
  16. Stuart Roxburgh 24 Nov 2013
    Whilst I am all for reducing the number of accidents on the A9, average speed cameras are not the answer.
  17. Paul Dunnett 24 Nov 2013
    Cameras are not the answer.
  18. Mike 24 Nov 2013
    If the government were serious about saving lives they would upgrade the full A9 to dual carriageway. I note instead they chose to waste millions on a tram system that doesn't even replace ONE bus route and won't save a single life.
  19. Alan mackay 24 Nov 2013
    Years of advancement on technology and engineering and no advancement on the speed limit
  20. Robert J S Christie 24 Nov 2013
    The problems on the A9 are due solely to a total lack for foresight on the part of the planners etc in the 70s when the " old " road was upgraded. The reason for then then upgrading was the impact the (then) embryonic oil industry was having on the North of Scotland. Had some of the oil revenues been ring-fenced to do the job properly then, this road would NOT have had the dreadful litany of death and carnage which the original lack of foresight produced.
  21. Drew Reid 24 Nov 2013
    more traffic bunching would occur,no real thought given to affects on those actually travelling on the road.
  22. Alan Bell 24 Nov 2013
    Get a grip an just get it duelled!
  23. Philip Burgin 24 Nov 2013
    Dangerous and risky overtaking manoeuvres, in part brought about by the inherent frustration caused by the necessity to follow or be part of a following convoy behind HGVs is responsible for the vast majority of road accidents on the A9. The proposed introduction of average speed cameras is not only ill advised but irresponsible as this WILL promote MORE of these same overtaking in.
  24. John Luckwell 24 Nov 2013
    Accident are caused by mechanical failure or bad drivers. Not all drivers who keep within the speed limits are GOOD drivers and not all drivers who exceed the speed limit are BAD drivers. When cameras become sophisticated enough to tell the difference between these two types of driver, I will support them.
  25. Wayne A Munro 24 Nov 2013
    I am against the proposals in their current form, and believe there will be little to no improvement, also that the funds could be better spent to actually save lives.
  26. graeme cuthbert 24 Nov 2013
    The implementation of these cameras will fundamentally increase accidents,choke the traffic flow,there are other ways of improving traffic safety,but prior to implementing any please consult the people that use the road and take facts from them,as opposed to the facts being taking from a road in Ayrshire That bears no direct similarity
  27. John bell 24 Nov 2013
    Bring in a law where trucks must travel at least 6 truck lengths apart or only 3 trucks in 1 mile stretch
  28. jim wilson 24 Nov 2013
    I travelled Inverness to Perth return last thursday my average speed on the way down was 43mph and that was with Hgv's travelling at 50mph god now's what it'll be if they drive at 40mph. Lets throw down the gauntlet to the MP's requesting average speed cameras, get them to drive invernes to perth return every day for a month then ask they if it should be dualled!!!!!!
  29. Andrew Hamilton 24 Nov 2013
    Caithness is in Scotland too. The A9 must be dual carriageway all the way from Inverness to Thurso. Please do not discriminate against us.
  30. Angela Windsor 24 Nov 2013
    I would like to reiterate my concerns regarding the A9 cameras. The traffic flow is such with the varying types of traffic on the A9 that the cameras will endanger the economic prosperity of all north of Perth (before Perth there is continuous dual carriageway). I am concerned that my views were not asked for that this is an imposition and if this is the new Scotland then I am very unsure that my views will be taken regard of. Please consult widely within the community and I really need to be sure that you are listening to the ROAD USERS.
  31. john binnie 24 Nov 2013
    slow vehicles are the problem not speed
  32. Jill Belch 24 Nov 2013
    These camera will not do anything but add to frustration. Start dualing the carriageways sooner, or have more of the three lanes with one clearly single and other clearly double. These latter could make a huge difference in allowing safe passing and decreased frustration, as the few there already do. Pls think this thro!
  33. Mathew Mackay 24 Nov 2013
    Incorrect decision.
  34. John Macdonald 24 Nov 2013
    Police need to concentrate on the absolutely shocking overtaking that goes on. It would do no harm either to pull over some of the slower moving traffic now and again, I don't mean the lorries here, more the caravan tourists who don't use mirrors often enough to see the traffic building up behind them. Really, the traffic using the A9 should not be looked on as a means of collecting revenue by way of speeding tickets, it's a pointless exercise if the real aim is preventing accidents.
  35. Karen peters 24 Nov 2013
    Improve the road not the cameras, I drive the A9 every day.
  36. Rory Forrest 24 Nov 2013
    Speed does not cause accidents. Poor judgement by frustrated and poor drivers does. Average speed cameras will make no difference and will increase frustration.
  37. Marlen Fairweather 24 Nov 2013
    Scotland
  38. Paul Gallagher 24 Nov 2013
    It appears that the proposal for average speed cameras is little but an attempt to shirk the responsibility for taking real action. Any user of the A9 will know that accidents are caused by a combination of slow vehicles, limited opportunities to overtake safely, and the impatience caused by such long stretches where their are neither duel carriageways nor opportunities (and incentives or compulsion) for slow vehicles to pull in and allow other vehicles to pass safely. If the budget does not allow for immediate duelling of the A9 then at least suitably long pull-in lay-bys could be constructed, that would allow slow vehicles to use them efficiently without constantly having to stop. These are used effectively in other countries in conjunction with rules that say that slow vehicles must let queues clear. It is difficult to believe that anyone involved with transport planning could be unaware of this and seriously believe that a stretch of road well over a hundred miles long could seriously benefit from average speed cameras that have only been designed to be used with roadworks.
  39. Paul Gallagher 24 Nov 2013
    It appears that the proposal for average speed cameras is little but an attempt to shirk the responsibility for taking real action. Any user of the A9 will know that accidents are caused by a combination of slow vehicles, limited opportunities to overtake safely, and the impatience caused by such long stretches where their are neither duel carriageways nor opportunities (and incentives or compulsion) for slow vehicles to pull in and allow other vehicles to pass safely. If the budget does not allow for immediate duelling of the A9 then at least suitably long pull-in lay-bys could be constructed, that would allow slow vehicles to use them efficiently without constantly having to stop. These are used effectively in other countries in conjunction with rules that say that slow vehicles must let queues clear. It is difficult to believe that anyone involved with transport planning could be unaware of this and seriously believe that a stretch of road well over a hundred miles long could seriously benefit from average speed cameras that have only been designed to be used with roadworks.
  40. Donna Webster 24 Nov 2013
    Frustration will just make the road more dangerous to drive on
  41. carol humphrey 24 Nov 2013
    I am against average speed camera's they are not the answer spend the money on duelling the A9
  42. Irene McLean 24 Nov 2013
    Just put up speed limit signs! But they wouldn't make as much money in fines!
  43. Fiona Macdonald 24 Nov 2013
    driving over the speed limit is not the reason the A9 is a bad road
  44. Ian lane 24 Nov 2013
    Average speed cameras will not solve any problems on the A9, and will only exacerbate the existing problems with slow moving traffic. If cameras are installed, we're all going to be stuck behind convoys of slow moving HGVs, thus increasing the risks of dangerous overtaking by a few idiots. Almost all accidents on the A9 have been caused by frustrated, and impatient, drivers trying to get past slow traffic. Slowing HGVs down to 40 mph will only make things worse. When will the bureaucrats who think up these 'bright' ideas wake up to reality?
  45. James Gordon 24 Nov 2013
    No average speed cameras. Need to get lorries going at 50 mph first and the dual it all. Lorries frustrate motorists at 40 and then one goes for it!
  46. Steven Munro 24 Nov 2013
    Average Speed cameras on the A9 are not the answer, just ships how out of touch with reality politicians. No snp vote for me after this awful idea.
  47. James Gordon 24 Nov 2013
    Lorries at 40 frustrate and cause accidents. Average speed cameras are another frustration. Dual carriage is the way forward.
  48. Douglas Alexander 24 Nov 2013
    enforce a rule that says if more than six? vehicles behind you you should pull over and let them pass. Also with modern braking system the trucks should be allowed to travel at 60mph.
  49. Ann Smerncki 24 Nov 2013
    Speed cameras are a complete waste of resources..save that money for duel carriageways. No excess money should be spent on investigations either. All resource should be to upgrade with immediate effect!
  50. Darren Boa 24 Nov 2013
    Get it duelled ASC will do nothing for the road