Petition · PE01503 · Session 4
Review of A9 speed camera proposals'
Signatures
0
Comments
192
Considered
3 meetings
What it asks
The A9 Safety Group recently proposed an Average Speed Camera System on the A9 in order to reduce fatalities. This group belives this is the incorrect decision based on official statistics which show that breaking thew speed limit accounts for only 2% of accidents on the A9, whereas overtaking manouvres account for nearly 50% of A9 accidents. We belive that the A9 Safety Group has not investigated adequate alternatives to deal with the majority cause of A9 accidents and the modelling used to propose the A9 system is flawed. We belive there should be a full parliamentary debate on the proposal along with the reformation of the A9 Safety Group to allow representation from car drivers, who make up over 95% of A9 road users, yet have not been involved in an A9 Safety Group meetings. We belive as the evidence is flawed and does not have full parliamentty support, the A9 Speed Camera System must be delayed indefinately until an investigation is carried out to look at the workings of the A9 Safety Group, Transport Scotland and investiagte other proposals which would have a direct impact on overtaking, which is the main offical cause of accidents on the A9.
What the petitioner did first
In response to the A9 Speed Camera Proposal, a Facebook campaign was set up to allow interested individuals to discuss alternatives as well as express frustration that the A9 Safety Group had not understood the real problems of A9 driving. This group has nearly 9000 followers, with the majority statistically being based in IV and KW postcode areas. It has been seen by over 1/2 million unique viewers since creation. It has comments in excess of 15,000 of discussion and debate on alternatives and photographic evidence of poor driving at low speed, poor road condition and other elements of driver frustration which Average Speed Cameras will not resolve. Official statistics show that Mean Speeds on all A9 data counters falls below the legal speed limit.
- A 20 point Interim plan for the A9 was published to discuss and investigate real alternatives to the Average Speed Camera proposal in August 2013. This included systems to prevent overtaking such as lane control, spacing control, improving visibility with vastly improved maintainence of the road and roadside, alternatives to drivers who wish not to use the A9 until dualling is complete and options for other A9 road users. This was sent to Transport Scotland and MSP's but was never debated in parliament nor did Transport Scotland issue a response despite having a working group dealing with the plan.
- An independent Survey Monkey was set up due to continuing blocking tactics of the Scottish Parliament Petitions department to allow A9 users to make their view heard and also suggest alternatives. This has so far received over 1700 responses with 91% stating they believe A9 Average Speed Cameras will not address safety in the current climate on the A9.
- An MSP was approached to help the campaign proceed with their official petition at the Scottish Parliament who we believe did approach the Petition Team and was assured there was no obvious reason why the petition was continually being blocked.
- A media campaign has been set up to publish information gleaned from FOI requests which prove that speed is not the main factor in A9 incidents, Police Scotland state they do not record Incident Speeds in the 544 page FOI document received on every A9 incident since 2007. It also appears that Transport Scotland had advanced plans for an A9 Average Speed Camera system for some years in advance of the announcement and an FOI request in still in progress to ascertain the level of engagement and lobbying there may have been with such companies.
- Voters have been encouraged to write to their MSP's on the issue and we belive this has been done, though there has still not been any public debate in parliament on the proposal nor has there been any delay whilst flaws in evidence and statistics are debated as well as alternatives, which FOI shows have not been investigated.
- Campaign groups have offered to meet the Transport Minister, who has ignored all correspondance personally with the campaign, whilst the Chief Executive of Transport Scotland, David Middleton, has refused 2 times to personally meet campaigners to discuss the concerns raised by nearly 9000 A9 users.
- The campaign offered to set up a cross political party, cross agency conference to discuss the campaign and also alternatives to the A9 Average Speed Camera system. The Transport Minister and the A9 Safety Group never responded to the invitation to the conference whilst MSPs and Transport Scotland did so. Therefore the conference could not proceed.
- A 20 point Interim plan for the A9 was published to discuss and investigate real alternatives to the Average Speed Camera proposal in August 2013. This included systems to prevent overtaking such as lane control, spacing control, improving visibility with vastly improved maintainence of the road and roadside, alternatives to drivers who wish not to use the A9 until dualling is complete and options for other A9 road users. This was sent to Transport Scotland and MSP's but was never debated in parliament nor did Transport Scotland issue a response despite having a working group dealing with the plan.
- An independent Survey Monkey was set up due to continuing blocking tactics of the Scottish Parliament Petitions department to allow A9 users to make their view heard and also suggest alternatives. This has so far received over 1700 responses with 91% stating they believe A9 Average Speed Cameras will not address safety in the current climate on the A9.
- An MSP was approached to help the campaign proceed with their official petition at the Scottish Parliament who we believe did approach the Petition Team and was assured there was no obvious reason why the petition was continually being blocked.
- A media campaign has been set up to publish information gleaned from FOI requests which prove that speed is not the main factor in A9 incidents, Police Scotland state they do not record Incident Speeds in the 544 page FOI document received on every A9 incident since 2007. It also appears that Transport Scotland had advanced plans for an A9 Average Speed Camera system for some years in advance of the announcement and an FOI request in still in progress to ascertain the level of engagement and lobbying there may have been with such companies.
- Voters have been encouraged to write to their MSP's on the issue and we belive this has been done, though there has still not been any public debate in parliament on the proposal nor has there been any delay whilst flaws in evidence and statistics are debated as well as alternatives, which FOI shows have not been investigated.
- Campaign groups have offered to meet the Transport Minister, who has ignored all correspondance personally with the campaign, whilst the Chief Executive of Transport Scotland, David Middleton, has refused 2 times to personally meet campaigners to discuss the concerns raised by nearly 9000 A9 users.
- The campaign offered to set up a cross political party, cross agency conference to discuss the campaign and also alternatives to the A9 Average Speed Camera system. The Transport Minister and the A9 Safety Group never responded to the invitation to the conference whilst MSPs and Transport Scotland did so. Therefore the conference could not proceed.
Where it was considered
Official Report-
28 Jan 20141 mention
-
22 Apr 20141 mention
-
17 Jun 20141 mention
Signatures by country
2,007 online signaturesComments
192 comments, oldest first192 comments · showing 101–150
-
Fiona Russell 24 Nov 2013Having traveled up and down the A9 several times lately the average speed we did was 45 mph due to the huge tailbacks of traffic. why waste money on speed cameras when it could be better allocated to the upgrading of the A9.
-
Tommy Bryson. 24 Nov 2013Plz sign folks. Need more signatures.
-
Ross 24 Nov 2013I accept duelling is very costly but you could also look at a central barrier on particular bad sections to stop overtaking or better policing. We can't forget Education, Enforcement and Engineering.
-
Jonathan Innes 25 Nov 2013As someone who drives the A9 almost every week I would totally disagree with speed cameras. Overtaking is the main cause of accidents not speed. With lorries sitting at 40mph on the road car users become very frustrated and I believe that the only solution is dualling the road. Speed cameras will have the effect of slowing the route, thus increasing costs to business and also will not stop the frustration of Drivers sitting behind lorries at 40mph. An alternative is to put haulage on the train to Inverness and reduce the number of lorries on the road. A journey that takes me 3 hours driving all the time within the speed limit can already take me 4 and half when stuck behind lorries I hate to think what it would take me with average speed cameras.
-
William Shanks 25 Nov 2013What is the length of dual carriageway that could be constructed for the same cost of installing these ineffectual cameras?
-
Craig Bruce 25 Nov 2013Average speed cameras are not the answer. A better more consistent standard of driving is the answer.
-
Peter Henderson 25 Nov 2013The money this would cost would be better spent on making the A9 dual carriageway.
-
Jason Robertson 25 Nov 2013Speed DOES NOT kill
inappropriate speed, inattention, ignorance selfishness and do gooders proving a redundant view, being fatigued through a multitude of reasons. Not speed -
Tim Bugler 25 Nov 2013Average speed cameras should not be installed between Dunblane and Perth where the A 9 is already dualled. The problem here is the junctions not the speed of traffic, and traffic speed through the junctions is likely to actually increase because drivers will no longer slow for them as they strive to maintain the maximum legal average.
-
Moira McCarrell 25 Nov 2013As a very regular user of the A9, average speed cameras are definitely not the answer. Every near miss which I have witnessed (and there have been many over the years) have been caused by drivers taking undue risks as a direct result of impatience following sitting in long queues caused by inability to overtake large vehicles. Duelling the A9 is the only answer to this problem.
-
Helene Bost 25 Nov 2013No!
-
John Ligertwood 25 Nov 2013Average speed cameras over a long distance, will create havoc and unacceptable frustration to good drivers.
-
Patricia Hutchison 25 Nov 2013Don't think speed cameras will make any difference to this black spot area it won't stop people driving silly or over taking where they shouldnt
-
CJW Robson 25 Nov 2013nothing wrong with road
- its peeps who cannot drive except on dual carriageways!!
sight lines need cutting back to what they were originally! -
Bill Ross 25 Nov 2013Average Speed cameras are not necessary
- better signage and dualling of the road is better together with forcing trucks to enter lay-by's to let cars pass. -
John Clark 25 Nov 2013The A9 is one of Scotlands only two major arteries north of the central belt (the A90 being the second). Unlike the A90, it is also a major tourist route and sees a higher than average amount of foreign drivers as well as caravans. We cannot seriously look to the future of our nation without making this road safe and fit for purpose. Personally, I agree that the accident problem is typically lack of attention by the road user, but a complete dual carriageway between Perth and Inverness still makes the most sense. Meanwhile, Westminster wants to spend £Billions on upgrading an existing rail link between London & Birmingham just to shave a few minutes off the journey time.
-
Norman MacLeod 25 Nov 2013We all want something done about the A9 but this is the wrong 'something'. The figures prove it: overtaking and turning cause accidents, speeding is not an issue. Anyone who drives in an extended Average Speed Camera zone knows what a miserable experience it is. After 120+ miles of speedometer watching people will be driven to madness. Those with cruise control will be daydreaming, reading, sleeping or -more likely- toying with their smartphones in convoys at 58mph!
-
Bob Thomson. 25 Nov 2013HGV's MUST be allowed 50mph.
Apart from police stopping drivers who break the speed limit they should be stopping drivers who drive unnecessarily slow and cause tail backs which in turn causes dangerous overtaking manoeuvres. -
Alexander Stuart Dow 25 Nov 2013Investment saves lives
-
Alexander vDow 25 Nov 2013Inverness since awarded city status for the turn of the last milenium has been one of Europes most rapidly growing towns or cities per head of population. Nigg has reopemed Europes largest dry dock for the fabrication and mantance for North Sea development just North of Inverness. I hate Westminster Governed Scotland though the
-
IM 25 Nov 2013Having used the A9 for over 30 years on a regular basis my travelling time has not changed from the old road to the modernised route due to the increase in traffic. I have, however, noticed that there is a distinct lack of speed limit signs especially coming off a section of dual carriageway which may confuse foreign tourists and cause accidents. I also use the A77 regularly to Stranraer. This road is completely different from the A9 and any comparison would be invalid. The only viable solution is for the Scottish Government to dual the A9 instead of wasting money on average speed cameras.
-
A.S.Garden 25 Nov 2013Speed cameras are not going to address the main cause of accidents
- risky overtaking. Improve the road markings to make it more obvious which sections are 2-way, and put on additional visible police patrols. -
Michael Napier Bartlett 25 Nov 2013Just driven both directions on A9. Found absolutely no problems whatever. Accidents can only be due to bad driving. Speed cameras just a cop-out by the authorities.
-
Russell Buchanan 25 Nov 2013I think ther should be a debate in Edinburgh,but I still think the new bridge could have been held until the A9 was fully addressed
-
Stacie Ann Stewart 25 Nov 2013Who's idea was this anyway? Some jobs worth from the central belt who only knows the a9 from a map!
-
Mary McFadyen 25 Nov 2013Upgrading needed not cameras.
-
Christopher Gell 25 Nov 2013Poor driver attitude and lack of basic road craft (such as an inability to plan and safely execute an overtaking manoeuvre) mixed with a diverse range of road users (locals, tourists, business drivers and freight) are the key issues on the A9. Average speed cameras will have no impact on these factors and, I believe, will increase driver frustration due to 40mph HGV's
- potentially causing an increase in serious accidents and fatalities. The proposal is a misuse of £2M public money and must be stopped. What is required is a highly visible police presence on the route. -
Chris Leaney 25 Nov 2013Duel the A9 NOW
-
Marie Feeney 25 Nov 2013Totally agree with plans to enforce spacing between HGVs and no overtaking on dual sections and overtaking lanes
-
Mark Barnes 25 Nov 2013Stop wasting money on trams and other pointless ideas and duel the A9 . Cameras won't help , and could cause people to force silly overtaking manoeuvres b4 they reach the next camera . Cough up the coin and make it duel carriage way . It's the only safe option
-
David M Edes 25 Nov 2013Lorries need to be allowed to do 50 mph on single carriageway but forbidden to overtake on dual sections Distance chevrons similar to the M6 would help,
-
Andrew Shand 25 Nov 2013Perhaps the saftey group should spend some time driving on the road rather than studying statistics
-
roy cleary 25 Nov 2013Dual it all the way. If you can afford trams and forth bridges that arnt as bad as you first thought the A9 should be come a national priority to b3 dual carriageway from Perth to Inverness 100 %
Speed is not the issue however being able to a constant maximum speed limit is on such a long trunk route -
bboy 25 Nov 2013Nothing more than a cash generator.
-
Samuel MacLeod 25 Nov 2013Average speed cameras are a cynical attempt to cover up the real issue of lack of proper investment on a crucial artery of our road network. Spend more outside the Central Belt. Lives are being lost due to inept policies of all political parties in Scotland. No cameras, just cash and dual carriageway.
-
Ryan Forbes 25 Nov 2013I am extremely concerned at the possibility of AVERAGE SPEED CAMERAS on the A9. This will restrict business and is a complete waste of public money. The Scottish Government should be pressing ahead with Dualling the A9 and not wasting millions of pounds on an unworkable plan that penalises us in the Highlands.
-
Robert Agnew 25 Nov 2013Speed Cameras do NOTHING to stop bad driving and reckless overtaking!!!!!
-
Richard White 25 Nov 2013The problems are the drivers who sit at 40mph EVERYWHERE!!!! it's a straight road so do the limit if the conditions suit.
-
Tom jackson 25 Nov 2013Increase the road signs and road markings. It's no rocket science.
-
Graham macpherson 25 Nov 2013Cameras are not going to solve the problems on the a9 A waste of money
-
steven corry 25 Nov 2013Such a sad waste of our money
-
Douglas Ross 25 Nov 2013Frustration causes accidents. Frustration comes by not beimg able to overtake easily. Non dualed A9 causes regular travellers and forgein travllers to take risks.
-
Steven Wright 25 Nov 2013Instead of wasting millions on the Edinburgh Tram Project they should have dualled the A9 and the A96 to create a proper roads network which would support industry, improve tourism and most importantly improve road safety!!
-
mrs EA Roberts 25 Nov 2013Myself and my husband regularly travel the a9, we live north of inverness but weekly commute to the central belt. I'm worried speed cameras will cause impatience north and south of the camera zones as drivers try to make up lost time causing accidents in these areas. I'm also worried tourists will then not travel as far north due to extended travel times.
-
Brian Chalmers 25 Nov 2013Introducing speed cameras will have little or no effect on reducing accidents, the statistics support this, it seems the decision to install the cameras without a proper independent study is ludicrous. My support would be to make the A9 dual carriageway as a minimum between Perth and Inverness
-
Bert 25 Nov 2013Shocking decision I cannot think of any plausible reason for this. Except maybe finance !
-
Eddie 25 Nov 2013It would help if HGV's were forced to pull in when a tailback has built up behind them
- say 10 vehicles. -
Duncan Graham 25 Nov 2013I would suggest that the biggest root cause of accidents on the A9 is vehicles slow driving. Lorries at 52MPH are understandable but car drivers should be liable to prosecution. Slow moving vehicles on a trunk road today are a travesty. Instead of wasting time on his wee braveheart dream Mr Salmond should focus on decent infrastructure: roads from Inverness to Perth and Edinburgh to Newcastle.
-
Kristoffer Wishart 25 Nov 2013Why spend money on this when you can spend it fixing the road and upgrading the infrastructure of the highlands
-
Harry Monroe 25 Nov 2013People can still stay within a speed limit, at whatever level, and perform dangerous overtaking manoeuvres