The third new petition is PE1503, by Mike Burns, on behalf of the average speed cameras on the A9 are not the answer campaign, on a review of A9 speed camera proposals. Members have a note by the clerk, the SPICe briefing and the petition.Members will wish to be aware that Mr Burns has sent the clerking team 10 emails with a large number of attachments. The attachments are correspondence to and from a third party and Transport Scotland, freedom of information requests, two documents of 608 and 544 pages, and minutes and other papers relating to the A9 safety group meetings. It appears that, in all, Mr Burns has sent more than 1,000 pages.The emails have been forwarded to committee members, but I understand if they have not had the time to consider them. The clerk has asked Mr Burns to summarise the numerous emails and attachments to highlight the main points that he wishes the committee to consider.I welcome Mr Burns and thank him for coming along to the meeting. I invite him to make a short presentation of a maximum of five points to set out the context, after which we will move to questions.10:45
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
A9 Average Speed Cameras (PE1503)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mike Burns 25
- David Stewart Lab 12
- Jackson Carlaw Con 10
- Angus MacDonald SNP 4
- John Wilson SNP 4
- Chic Brodie SNP 3
The record
58 contributionsThank you very much for giving me your time today. The 600 and 500-page documents are almost identical, so the larger of the two will give you all the information.I am the creator of a Facebook page that started off as a gripe against the proposal to install average speed cameras along the entire length of the A9 from Dunblane up to Inverness. The campaign developed into something that I did not expect—indeed, sitting here is beyond what I expected to happen with the campaign.We are not anti speed cameras. It is very clear that we cannot say that there is no speeding on the A9. Our problem is that, on the basis of the evidence that we have received through freedom of information requests for statistical analysis and road modelling, the proposals do not accurately cover what causes the vast majority of accidents on the A9. The petition is not about dualling the A9; we are well aware that that will take a considerable time, although it is a disservice for any Administration, past or present, to say that another Administration is to blame. The problem has been going on for decades. Enough is enough—the Highlanders are fed up.We are sitting here watching billions of pounds being poured into infrastructure projects in the south of Scotland, such as the M74 and the Forth bridge. At the last count, the Minister for Transport and Veterans advised that £138 million had been spent on the A9. That was an advance of around £88 million on the initial £50 million figure that Transport Scotland had used to justify the proposals.Average speed cameras do not address the main problems because, according to the official accident statistics, in the previous nine years more than 550 accidents were caused by bad overtaking manoeuvres and fewer than 30 were attributed to excessive speed. Transport Scotland and the Scottish Government have a moral and legal obligation to address directly the known root causes of accidents in order to prevent deaths on the A9.The road is a vital artery to the north of Scotland. Inverness and the Highlands have undergone relentless expansion, as has green industry, and we do not have the infrastructure to cope with those expansions. We are asking the Public Petitions Committee to review all the evidence, the modelling, the timelines that are being used by Transport Scotland and the composition of the A9 safety group to ensure that it is completely and utterly satisfied that every effort has been made to address the fundamental root cause of the majority of accidents, which is overtaking, until the dualling of the road is complete.
Thank you very much, Mr Burns. You managed to keep to your time, which is impressive. I have two quick questions. Have you looked at how average speed cameras work in the rest of Europe?
Yes. We have been looking at average speed camera systems. We focused on the A77, which is the example that Transport Scotland and the A9 safety group focused on. The average speed camera proposal in its original incarnation, which was 136 miles, would have been the second longest on the planet. There is nothing to compare to it except in Australia, which has vastly different road conditions and design from what we have in Scotland.We have also looked at alternative camera control systems that would address more directly issues such as overtaking and manoeuvring into spaces that are left between lorries.
Clearly, you have issues with the A9 safety group. In the autumn, I attended one of its meetings along with a number of other MSPs. Is the composition incorrect? Should ordinary drivers who use the road be involved? What is your main issue with the group?
As far as we can work it out, the A9 safety group has, in essence, worked behind closed doors since its establishment back in 2012. Its minutes show that the safety group set up a communications sub-group to develop a website to share information. However, that did not appear until after the campaign had started and there was significant media interest. We also note that the A9 safety group has not published any meeting minutes since August 2013, with the possible exception of two evidence pieces in October, so we have not been kept up to date with what is going on.The board’s composition does not include any group that can realistically represent the car drivers who make up more than 95 per cent of the traffic on the A9. There is no involvement of, for example, the Automobile Association or the Institute of Advanced Motorists, which has also been very critical. The composition seems to focus primarily on councils, Police Scotland, Transport Scotland, heavy goods vehicle groups and public transport groups.
You are enthusiastic about trying to get reform of that group so that it is more representative of ordinary drivers.
In order to instil public confidence in the decisions that it has made, it is imperative that the group is representative of those who use the A9. As a campaign, we received an invitation not to participate in the group but to comment on how its communication could be improved. There was no formal offer of involvement, although I would not personally seek that because I do not believe that I can represent every A9 user—I can represent only the people who have signed up to the campaign.
Good morning. I think that we understand the anguish of people who travel or who have travelled on the A9. I live in Ayr. I have lived there since before and after the installation of the average speed cameras, and I have noticed that the average speed has dropped considerably. I participate in and ensure that. Why could that measure not work for the A9?
The statistical evidence that has been produced shows that none of the mean speeds on the A9 breaches the speed limit, according to Transport Scotland’s official website. The formula, which was provided by the Transport Research Laboratory, suggests that average speeds would drop by at least 6mph. There are distinctions within that modelling and the statistics that have been used, but that suggests that the current average speed is already below the legal speed limit. The biggest problem with the A9, which came across loud and clear through the Facebook campaign, the online petition and the independent survey that we paid for and ran, is frustration with slow-moving traffic.There have been developments. The 50mph HGV trial that has been announced has been a massive boost to our campaign, and we are starting to think that people understand the issues. However, average speed cameras will not stop bad overtaking. The proposed spacing for the model, which clearly does not yet exist—according to freedom of information responses, no design or model of a speed camera system for the A9 exists, which raises the question how they managed to come up with such a proposal when they have not decided on physical locations for the cameras—would have 4-mile gaps between cameras, meaning that a car could easily do 80mph for 2 miles and 60mph in the next 2 miles and still have an average speed that probably would not activate an average speed camera.
It works between two cameras, however. On the A77, a person can do 80mph and then 60mph between one set of cameras and average the speed over whatever distance they travel.
Yes, but the point is that overtaking is deemed to be the major cause of incidents on the A9, and average speed cameras do not stop bad overtaking. Anecdotally, they may reduce the desire to overtake, but they do not directly prevent people from performing the lethal overtaking manoeuvres that anybody who drives up and down the A9 will have seen on an almost daily basis.
That is not my experience on the A77.Do you not think that there is a lot of experience and a lot of analysis in all the groups that are represented on the A9 safety group? Why do you disavow that group?
I disavow it because it does not represent the 95 per cent of A9 users who are car drivers. I am not disputing the job that it has done, and it certainly has a lot of experience. The current head of the A9 safety group, Stewart Leggett, was a member of its previous incarnation—the A9 road safety group—back in 2006. That group considered proposals that we reintroduced in the 20-point interim plan, but nothing has been progressed since 2006. That is eight years in which proposals to improve safety have not been advanced although there has been continuity between the two groups, with the same person having been a member of both.
You made an interesting point about the fact that the AA, the RAC or the Institute of Advanced Motorists do not sit on the board of the A9 safety group. Have you made any approaches to elected representatives in your area to suggest that they should be on the A9 safety group?
We certainly made the point directly to the chair of the A9 safety group when the campaign started. Because the A9 safety group had in essence been working behind closed doors, with no website or public displays of information and no minutes published, people did not know what was going on and were caught by surprise. It was only when the big announcement came out of the blue that people sat up and said, “Hang on, how have they reached this decision?” I believe that Transport Scotland then worked frantically to get the information out, but it was information that the group itself said should have been put out more than a year earlier. Why did it take a campaign to force the information out?I believe that Transport Scotland’s offer to invite me and Conor McKeena, who is involved in the heavy goods vehicles at 50mph campaign, to address the A9 safety group was meant in good faith and was well intentioned. However, the fact that campaigners were invited to address a committee on its poor communication rather than to engage and talk about why the safety group has got its strategy wrong indicates a significant lack of understanding about why people were so frustrated and angry about the proposal when it was launched last year.
Did you accept that invitation?
The meeting did not proceed. Transport Scotland said that it would speak to the A9 safety group to clarify that the invitation would be okay. That is referenced in one of the freedom of information requests—document 13/01358, I think. It never advanced past that point. I asked for a formal invitation to be sent to ensure that everything was kept above board and that people knew what was going on, but that was never received.
I have driven on the A9 regularly for the past 30-odd years and I have seen drivers taking some hair-raising chances when overtaking that were pretty akin to playing Russian roulette. Your original submission refers to the dualling of the A9 that is planned but not imminent. You also refer to the need for“realistic interim solutions which address real issues”.What should those interims solutions be? Can you give the committee some examples?
I can certainly give some examples. We published a 20-point interim plan. I do not claim that the plan was right and I do not claim that it was wrong. The aim of everything that we have done was to promote a national public debate on the A9 that has needed to happen for years. Some of our suggestions were deliberately controversial, because we found out that other things were happening in the background. For example, at a practical level, respondents to the surveys on Facebook said that we need more speed limit signs because there are multimodal speed limits—the limits can vary for a car-derived van, a passenger car, a coach or a lorry. However, from reading the A9 safety group minutes, it looks as if speed limit signs have been removed during the past two years to remove roadside furniture. That causes problems for people who are not familiar with the area.We also had the suggestion of the double chevron system, which is used primarily on dual or triple-carriageway roads. However, the added benefit would be to people who are unfamiliar with the A9, particularly those from continental Europe, in showing them the actual direction in the centre of the carriageway. We raised that idea and, thanks to Perth and Kinross Council, we found that it was considered in 2006 but never progressed as an idea for the A9. It was the fourth item on the agenda on 15 June.We also looked at whether there are ways to get people off the A9 as an interim solution. We have a Highland railcard scheme from Inverness that works for the north and west Highlands. As a stopgap, that could be offered to people who are travelling to the south of Scotland from Inverness to encourage modal shift and get people off the road. As someone who drives the A9 every week, I hate driving that road. I know that I am taking my life in my hands, not due to my driving but due to people making hair-raising overtaking manoeuvres. I would be comfortable saying that, as I drove down this morning, I saw at least two or three people nodding off and swerving on to the other side of the road. It is just shambolic having to deal with that.We came up with other solutions. One was the deliberately controversial idea of banning cyclists from the A9. Personally, I do not see why someone would want to cycle on the A9, but lots of cyclists do. When we delved into that a bit further, cyclists said that they were using the road because the A9 cycle path is not fit for the job so they are forced on to the A9 to complete the Land’s End to John O’Groats ride, for example.There is a wide range of issues. There are systems that are used on the continent that enforce spacing between slow-moving vehicles to avoid platooning and allow safer overtaking. There is also the perceived poor maintenance of the A9. Road surfaces have been average at best, although there seems to have been a bit of an effort recently to improve them south of Pitlochry. However, many overtaking lines are obstructed by overgrown trees and foliage that has not been cut down for decades. The video “A9 Highland Highway”, which was made when the road was constructed, shows that, in the original design of the road, there should be very clear overtaking distances. However, this morning, for example, I counted six tree canopies that blocked off a mile and a half overtaking view on a corner just north of Bruar.11:00
I sympathise and agree with everything that you have said about the A9 and the need to dual it. I was in the motor industry for 25 years and saw some of the horrendous wrecks that arrived, some of which had involved fatalities. Is the point of average speed cameras not that they allow more reaction time by having motorists drive at a slower speed? I understand what you say about the facts showing that only 2 per cent of accidents were the result of speed as opposed to 50 per cent being the result of overtaking manoeuvres, but that might disguise the fact that the overtaking manoeuvre led to an accident because of the reaction times of other motorists.However undesirable average speed cameras might be as an alternative to dualling, they slow down traffic—as they do on some motorways, where the restriction is 50mph—and have been chosen entirely because the judgment is that motorists will be able to react better at that restricted speed than at the normally allowed speed. Might it not be that average speed cameras allow people to react better in the event of the sort of inappropriate overtaking that you talk about and that the ultimate consequence of that might be that some accidents are avoided?
That might be the case. When we look closely at the figures that Transport Scotland has provided, it seems to be anticipated that accident rates will rise for the first year or two after the installation of any system before they fall. Average speed cameras might allow more reaction time, but they do not stop platooning or enforce spacing to allow people who have done the slower-move overtake to pull in safely. Regular drivers of the A9 have seen that problem alarmingly frequently.It is unfair to pinpoint HGVs only. Slow-moving traffic can be in the form of caravans and tourists who are not familiar with the area enjoying the scenery. Why not? We encourage tourism in the Highlands. Average speed cameras might slow down the traffic, but the effect of slowing down the traffic further when the average speeds are already slow is to increase frustration. According to the people whom we surveyed, that is more than likely to increase risky overtaking manoeuvres even if they are at a slower speed.The other side of the coin is that Transport Scotland and the A9 safety group were adamant that no traffic would divert on to alternative routes as a result of the scheme. The independent survey that we carried out showed that nearly 50 per cent of people who responded would consider moving to routes such as the A82 as an alternative. Those roads are already struggling and do not need extra traffic to be diverted on to them as a result of drivers seeking to avoid an average speed camera system.
That would be as a result of their experience. I did not actually identify HGVs in my comments.
No, but I was just trying to cover it.
I simply return to the point that a motorist is better able to respond to an unexpected incident when driving at 50mph than when driving at 70mph. If your argument is that the introduction of speed cameras will not prevent all accidents, that has to be correct, and I do not dispute it. However, I am not wholly persuaded—I would like to find out more—that introducing a lower average speed limit will not ameliorate the consequence of some of the inappropriate driving that you say happens. I am not wholly persuaded, because drivers who are restricted to 50mph will be able to react to that inappropriate driving safely in a way that they cannot do when they are driving at 70mph. On balance, I am not entirely persuaded that it is such a black-and-white argument as you are making it.
If someone overtakes at 70mph, that will probably not even activate an average speed camera. The problem is that we would then be relying on an expectation that drivers will adapt their behaviour and slow down. The point of the camera is to catch somebody. If somebody does an overtaking manoeuvre at 70mph, they will still get away with it.
No—with respect, it is not. I have lived in Troon for some time, so I am familiar with—
I lived down in Glasgow and used the A road for five years, so I know it as well.
The introduction of cameras was not about catching people speeding; it was about getting people to adjust their behaviour. Indisputably, that has happened. Cars now drive to a 50mph restricted limit and not to a higher limit. Drivers do not speed up between cameras. They understand that they have to adjust their behaviour. I was not a big fan of the introduction of cameras, but it is not technically correct to say that drivers have not adjusted their behaviour. I think that they have.
In that case, the question that I would pass back to you is: what is the tourist volume on that road compared with, for example, the A9? An important point that has arisen from Transport Scotland—
I would say that the tourist volume is fairly great.
Is it as great as that on the A9, where people have been stuck in queues for four hours?
I am sorry, convener. I know that you do not want us to get into this discussion, but I have to say that those who try to go down that road on a sunny day will soon realise that most of Glasgow is going in the same direction. I think, therefore, that the tourist volume is as great as that on the A9.
This is important because, according to information released by Transport Scotland on the patterns of speeding offenders, the vast number were not in cars registered in Scotland but in hire cars registered in the Birmingham and West Midlands area. If Transport Scotland’s A9 safety group is going to launch a speed awareness campaign, will it be taken into all the car hire depots for people who are about to drive their hire cars away? That is the level of awareness raising that we need. After all, we have seen evidence of and, indeed, experienced people who are unfamiliar with the road driving dangerously on it because they do not understand the set-up or lane control. Some of them do not even know what the speed limits are, because the signs have been removed.
I accept what you say, but I think that, if I were to be confronted with one of those motorists, I might be able to adjust my manoeuvring more easily if I were restricted to 50mph than I would be if I were driving at 70mph. All I am saying is that a lot of accidents happen as a result of reaction times as much as anything else, and the average speed camera proposal is designed to give people more reaction time on what is, as you have accurately identified, an extremely dangerous road about which drivers feel huge frustration. I just wonder whether you are right to dismiss the contribution that speed cameras could make.
I have never dismissed their contribution—
But you are obviously opposed to them.
I am opposed to them as the only solution. The campaign has made it clear from the start that it does not object to the use of average and fixed speed cameras as part of a wider model. For example, fixed speed cameras have been used successfully on the A90 at Laurencekirk to slow traffic on the dual carriageway to 50mph. Transport Scotland knows that there are problems at junctions on the A9 and could, as Highland Council has suggested, quite easily slow down speed limits at the junctions to address those issues.
I am afraid that we have run out of time, Mr Burns, but I ask that you hold on for a couple of minutes.
I just want to make two quick points, convener. First, I remind Mr Burns of the heavy volume of traffic on the A77, which after all is one of the main routes from Ireland into the UK. The traffic going in the other direction is also quite heavy. Secondly, in the evidence that you provided with the petition, you refer to FOI requests to Transport Scotland and say that“only 28 accidents according to Transport Scotland ... are due to breaking the speed limit”but “550 accidents in the same time frame were caused by overtaking.”What timeframe are we talking about?
From 2004 to August 2013. We do not have any figures from that point, because the freedom of information request took two years.As for your comment about the A77, all I would say is that it is not 136 miles long. The length of the A9 means that the effects are amplified severely. If the scheme were to apply to only single carriageways, there might be more public acceptance of it but, as it stands, the public is not convinced that anyone knows what is really going on on the A9.
Did Transport Scotland provide any figures on how many of the accidents caused by overtaking happened on the A9’s dualled and single-lane sections respectively?
Not specifically, but they are in the 600-page document that details all the accident figures. My understanding is that 77 per cent of the accidents on the A9 were on single carriageways, and that that is where the problem seems to be.
That 75 or so per cent of accidents could be down to drivers’ frustration at having to travel behind slower-moving vehicles.
Yes. Those of us who have had to drive for four or five hours to get the 100 miles from Inverness to Perth will agree that that is undoubtedly the case.
I am sorry, but I will have to cut you off there, Mr Wilson.This is not a question but just a number of observations for the record. I am sure that you will agree, Mr Burns, that the statistics show that our safest roads are motorways, followed by dual carriageways and single carriageways, with single-track roads at the bottom of the heap.
Yes.
Like you, I am a regular traveller on the A9 and my experience is that the mixture of dual and single carriageways and two-plus-one stretches makes things quite confusing, particularly for tourists who are not familiar with the road. They are probably thinking, “Am I still on the dual carriageway?” or, “There’s an overtaking lane opposite me, but I’m on the single carriageway.” That can be dangerous and there is no doubt that it can cause or contribute to accidents.
Absolutely.
We now move to the summation. There will be no more questions or points, Mr Burns, but I ask you to stay where you are for the moment.A number of points have been raised and I think that it certainly makes sense to talk to the Scottish Government and Transport Scotland, particularly the A9 safety group, about the issues in the petition. Does the committee, first, agree with that course of action and, secondly, wish to suggest any other groups that we might write to?
It has been suggested that we ask the AA, the RAC and the Road Haulage Association for their views on the petition.
We should also hear from Police Scotland. Moreover, I suggest that, when we write to those groups, we ask for the most up-to-date and latest information on the A77.
It would be sensible to have that as a comparator.
When we write to the A9 safety group, would it be possible to ask whether it has considered inviting the AA and the Institute of Advanced Motorists on to it? I also suggest that we write to the Freight Transport Association as well as the Road Haulage Association.
I think that it would be good to get the views of the Institute of Advanced Motorists.Do members agree with the various options that have been suggested?Members indicated agreement.
As you will have picked up, Mr Burns, we will continue your petition and write to all the organisations that have been mentioned. We will discuss the matter at a future meeting and the clerks will keep you up to date with developments. We are certainly keen to find out the further information that your petition seeks. The issue is important; after all, as I think you pointed out, the A9 will be the longest stretch of average speed camera road in Europe.
It will be second longest in the world. The longest is in Australia.I should also say that we have carried out private surveys and have offered the results to all the bodies that are involved. If the committee would like to access those results in full, I would be happy to provide them.
On behalf of the committee, I thank you for that offer.Thank you for coming along, Mr Burns. I suspend for a minute to allow the witness to leave.11:11 Meeting suspended.
11:12 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jan 2014 →- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 71
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 86
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 58
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.