The second new petition is PE1497, by Ellie Harrison, on behalf of Say No to Tesco, on supermarket expansion on local high streets. Members have a note by the clerk, the SPICe briefing, the petition and a submission from the Scottish Retail Consortium. Sandra White MSP had hoped to attend the meeting, as she has a constituency interest in the petition but, as a member of the Justice Committee, which is meeting now, she is unable to attend and has asked that her apologies be noted.I welcome our witnesses, who are the petitioner, Ellie Harrison, and Paula Fraser from the Say No to Tesco campaign. I invite Ms Harrison to make a short presentation of a maximum of five minutes, to set the context for the petition. After that, I will kick off with a couple of questions and then my colleagues will ask questions.
Official Report · Committee
New Petitions
Supermarkets (High Streets) (PE1497)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Chic Brodie SNP 22
- Paula Fraser Say No to Tesco 21
- Ellie Harrison Say No to Tesco 18
- David Stewart Lab 10
- Jackson Carlaw Con 9
- John Wilson SNP 4
- Anne McTaggart Lab 1
- Angus MacDonald SNP 1
The record
86 contributionsI am a resident of the west end of Glasgow. I am joined by my friend and colleague, Paula Fraser, with whom I have worked over the past year on the Say No to Tesco in Scotland campaign. The campaign, which has been completely run by volunteers such as us from around our local communities, developed in response to our frustrations in trying to prevent two new Tesco stores from opening in our area, where there are now 10 within just 2 miles. Nearly all of them have been new over the past decade, and store number 11, which we seem powerless to block, is due to open this year.We are here to present our petition, which has been signed by more than 2,000 people and which demands that the Scottish Parliament take urgent and decisive action to empower and encourage councils and communities to stop this reckless and unwanted supermarket expansion on our local high streets. That expansion is having a devastating impact on independent food suppliers; destroying the vibrant and distinctive qualities of our favourite cities and towns; and, most worryingly, slowly but surely handing over monopoly control of our food supply to a handful of massive corporations.It is important to stress that our petition is concerned with safeguarding one of the most fundamental human needs—our easy access to healthy and affordable food. The petition is supported by at least three MSPs—Sandra White and Patrick Harvie from Glasgow, and Alison Johnstone from the Lothian region. They will be joining us outside the Parliament at 12, following this meeting, for an official handover to John Wilson. I encourage all members who support the petition to attend that.I will provide a bit more context. I am sure that members are aware that community backlash against the supermarket giants is not a new thing. However, in the past, campaigns have been in opposition to large out-of-town superstores, which have sucked economic activity out of city centres and created what are known as Tesco towns. Examples of that are Perth, where 51 per cent of the grocery market goes to Tesco, and Inverness, where 52 per cent ends up in Tesco’s pocket.Our petition aims to address a new problem that has emerged only over the past decade—the proliferation on our local high streets of the small local and express stores, whose size is typically under 280m2. The supermarket giants—Tesco, Sainsbury’s and now Morrisons—are well aware that there is strong opposition to their expansion, which is why they are so pleased to have found a new and far stealthier way of increasing their market share. The approach allows them to skirt round the regulations, as they do not require planning permission at all, provided that they open on an existing shop site, and nor do they require a retail impact assessment, which is compulsory only for shop floors of more than 2,500m2.I am sure that members have seen with their own eyes the alarming rate at which mini-supermarkets have been opening all round us over the past decade. Sainsbury’s, which opened its first local store only 15 years ago, is opening new stores at a rate of two a week across the UK. Tesco, which is the biggest of all the retailers, has more than 3,000 stores across the UK, and the majority of them—1,600—are in the express format. Morrisons is playing catch-up. It launched its M Local stores in 2011 and has announced plans to open 100 of them across the UK this year.Those small and supposedly more benign shops pose more of a direct threat to small independent grocers and newsagents than their superstore predecessors ever did, because they are opening right alongside the independents on local high streets, which were the few remaining places where those independents could afford to operate. The big supermarkets are surrounding the independent shops in a pincer movement, and that is a deliberate attempt to snuff out all competition.The big supermarkets’ defence is always the same—that they are creating jobs. However, it is important to acknowledge that that is a zero-sum game because, for every new minimum-wage job that is created working for one of these ruthless corporations, another far more rewarding and empowering job is lost elsewhere, as small family-owned businesses are forced to close.The more we allow these soulless clone shops to replace alternative food suppliers that provide varied and unusual produce, the more we lose the sense of place and community and the distinctiveness of areas. Key planning documents, including the new national planning framework, seem to hold those things dear, but you in the Parliament seem unable to uphold them.With the petition, we demand that you acknowledge the long-term threat that is posed to our society and take urgent steps to intervene before it is too late. This is a unique opportunity for Scotland to take the lead in implementing new policies to address a new problem. We need policies that can halt the relentless onslaught of the supermarket giants.10:15
I will conclude with a few suggestions. First, we must be allowed to take into consideration the cumulative shop floor space that one company operates in an area, in order to make retail impact assessments compulsory for the opening of new stores. Secondly, members should follow the lead of George Ferguson, the mayor of Bristol, in demanding a change in the use classes of shops to put large chain stores into a separate class and thereby make planning permission for their new stores mandatory. Those changes to the planning process would make things far less frustrating for people such as us and would allow the valid concerns that communities raise to be acted on in order to prevent unwanted new stores from opening.We call on the Parliament to help us to preserve diversity and choice in our food supply, which is important, and to support the local businesses that are at the heart of economic recovery, stability and the wellbeing of people in Scotland.
Thank you. If Paula Fraser wants to respond to any questions, she is welcome to do so. For the record, I understand that you are referring to all large national or multinational chains and not just to Tesco. We must be careful about the legality of the comments that are made today.The Scottish Retail Consortium does not share your views, does it? I have read carefully what it says. It says that large retailers bring lower prices and that the real problems are business rates, squeezed household incomes and a loss of consumer confidence. How do you react to its comments?
We have read its submission and we have done some research on who the Scottish Retail Consortium is. We discovered that it is affiliated to the British Retail Consortium, whose members include Tesco and all the other big supermarkets, so it is obviously biased.We make it clear that we are thinking about the long term with our petition. The rate at which the supermarkets are opening stores is terrifying, and we run the risk of there being a monopoly power whereby the big four supermarkets and the newcomers, Aldi and Lidl, have a monopoly over our food supply, at which point—as we have seen in the energy sector—they will act as a cartel and hike up prices. Things may be cheaper at the moment, but that may not be the case in the long term.Another point is that these small stores are not any cheaper. They use the Tesco brand, which people associate with out-of-town stores that stock all the cheap products but, when people go in, they find that the stores do not stock the same products. They stock more expensive products deliberately, so they end up being more expensive than local independent grocers.
Is it fair to say that you see the solution as being to use planning powers to protect smaller businesses?
Yes—absolutely. You said that the Scottish Retail Consortium mentioned business rates. Addressing rates is part of what can help local independent businesses, but it is definitely not all that is needed to protect small businesses. The large corporations have a lot more money and a lot more say, and they provide incentives to councils through the developments that they propose. They can do a lot that small independent businesses cannot do, and changes in planning legislation are the only thing that would make a difference for the small independent businesses.
Good morning. I do not think that you have helped your case today. Using words such as “soulless”, “ruthless” and “cartel” is not a constructive way of approaching the issue. I have no truck with large supermarkets and would like to see fairness in competition, but do you think that they really are “soulless” and “ruthless”?
I think that the way in which these—
Do you think that they are “soulless” and “ruthless”?
I think that they are soulless. There is a new Tesco at the end of my street, which we could not prevent from opening. It is a clone of all the other Tesco Expresses in the area, of which there are now 10, as I mentioned. In comparison with all the other shopfronts down the Great Western Road in Glasgow, that Tesco shopfront uses very bright lights, and it has lines of fridges, which create a completely different atmosphere from that of all the other shops.
How Tesco brands and markets its products is part of competitive practice. Why have you picked on Tesco?
It is not only Tesco that we have a problem with—
Hold on—your petition says that it is“on behalf of Say NO to TESCO!”
That is what we called our campaign when it began, because it started with the proposed opening of a new Tesco Express in our area. That sparked things off, but that does not mean that we are interested in stopping only Tesco.
Have you considered the competition law implications of what you are asking for?
I do not think that two people lodging a petition is picking on the biggest retailer in the whole UK, which, after all, takes £1 in every £8 that is spent on shopping. That is not just groceries—
Have you considered—
I do not think that we are picking on it.
My question is—
Somebody has got to stick up for the small shops that are closing.
Would you answer my question? Have you considered competition law in your attempts to stop supermarkets having smaller shops on high streets?
We are not trying to completely stop supermarkets from doing anything.
You are—you are saying, “Say no to Tesco.”
No. There is of course competition law, but we have to look out for the smaller local independent retailers and do something that recognises that the buying power of the chain superstores is unfair for those retailers.
I know that you are talking about only food, which I will come back to in a minute, but what would you say to Debenhams and Marks and Spencer?
We are talking just about food—
Why?
Because it is one of the fundamental things that we need to consume.
So is clothing.
Food is different from all the other things that are sold on our high streets in that every human being needs to buy it week in, week out. People can do without buying new clothes if they really need to, but food is an essential human need.To come back to your comment about our homing in on Tesco, I think that if you had listened to what I said in my introduction—
I listened very attentively.
If you had done that instead of speaking over me, you might have noticed that we flagged up the fact that the problem is not just with Tesco; it is also with Sainsbury’s. In the west end of Glasgow, where we come from, Tesco is employing incredibly aggressive tactics in opening new stores; in Edinburgh, Sainsbury’s is employing the same tactics, and very soon other supermarkets will be doing the same in other parts of the country. As I mentioned, Morrisons intends to roll out its chain of M Local stores over the course of the year.In different areas, different supermarkets are getting the dominant share of the market. That is what we want to try to avoid. We are not saying, “An end to all supermarkets!”; we are simply trying to prevent them from getting a monopoly in certain areas and snuffing out all competition in the form of local independent businesses.
Can you tell me what the results of Tesco, Sainsbury’s and Morrisons were in comparison with those of Aldi and Lidl over the past financial year?
Well, I looked—
Can you tell me what the results were?
Are you referring to the fact that they are not doing as well as the other companies that you mentioned?
That is correct.
Given the profits that they are still making, I do not think that that is a consideration when we are talking about their opening more and more of these stores and snuffing out local independent businesses.
There is no evidence that they are snuffing out those businesses. Let me ask you another question—
I am sorry—there is no what?
There is evidence—there is evidence at the end of my street. I have spoken to the local newsagent and the grocer, both of whom say that, since the shop that we mentioned opened, their sales have dropped. They will see how it goes for the next couple of months—the shop only opened in December—but they might well pack up.
I am sorry, but there is a lot of evidence. Before the store opened, a store that we failed to stop opened on Queen Margaret Drive, where the newsagent on the corner and another newsagent on the same street lost 70 per cent of their sales. The fruit shop is struggling and another shop on the corner had to close and was sold to someone else, who hopes to carry on.The opening of express stores is closing small businesses. Account is not being taken of the jobs that are lost just because Tesco creates a few jobs.
We can debate jobs, but we are talking about town centres. Where do the people who work in Tesco Expresses spend their money? What other shops do they go into?
We are not talking just about town centres; I want to pick you up on that. We are talking about areas outside city centres—local high streets in areas where people live, where they want to be able to buy food within walking distance of their flats. As I said in my opening remarks, those are areas in which independent businesses can afford to operate. They cannot afford to operate in city centres, but they can afford to do so in the outskirts. Tesco is coming into that new market and is posing a direct threat to those businesses.
In relation to the legal situation and competition, where is your evidence that the six supermarkets are in a cartel?
I was talking about what could happen in the future if we—
No, you said that there is a cartel.
No, she did not.
No. I was talking about what could happen in the future if we do not address the issue. I referred to the energy sector, because the direction in which the energy sector has gone over the past 20 years is one whereby the big six energy companies all put their prices up at the same time. Interruption. They do all put their prices up at the same time; do not shake your head.
What relation does that have to the expansion of supermarkets on high streets?
We cannot afford to allow that to happen to our food supply. Given the rate at which small supermarkets are opening and the rate at which Tesco, Sainsbury’s and Morrisons are monopolising our food supply, we run the risk of going down the same path. Eventually, they will have complete control and we will have no alternative in where to buy our food.There is a chapter in this—
Can I interrupt you for a second? This is all very interesting, but we are short of time and I am keen to bring in as many members as I can.
Once again, many of the questions that I would have liked to put to the witnesses have been asked. As Mr Brodie did, I urge the petitioners to temper some of their language, because what they say will appear in the Official Report. I know that some of the comments that have been made—such as those about Tesco and minimum-wage jobs—are untrue. Tesco does not pay much above the minimum wage, but it certainly does not pay its staff the minimum wage. The witnesses need to be careful about using such language, because that will be picked up on, although they have a good case to present.What evidence do you have to show that if Tesco, Morrisons, Sainsbury’s or the Co-operative takes over a retail unit in, say, Great Western Road, it is not filling a vacuum or a hole in the retail outlets in the area? A big problem is that, on some of our high streets, we have plenty of empty shops and a reduction in retail. What should we do with those empty shops and empty spaces?
That issue is why we need choice and statutory powers that councils can use in different areas. The situation is different in different streets. Many streets do not face the problem with empty units that you are talking about and do not need a Tesco or a Sainsbury’s to fill a space and bring footfall back to the area.In the streets that we are talking about, there are plenty of places in addition to the local independent businesses, including many supermarkets. Bringing in more express stores will just result in those local independent businesses closing down, so it will do nothing good for our community. You probably know that about half the turnover of an independent retailer goes back into the local community, whereas only about 5 per cent of the money that is spent in chain supermarket stores goes back into the local community. There is no comparison.10:30
One of the difficulties with that response is that you are asking the Scottish Government to take action. When the Scottish Government takes action, I expect that action to be consistent throughout Scotland. I do not expect the Government to say that certain pieces of legislation apply only in the high streets of, say, Falkirk and Stirling. We expect legislation to apply everywhere. How would we get the correct legislation in place to ensure that the policy was adopted throughout Scotland? Of course, if it were adopted throughout Scotland, it would be to the detriment of some high streets, if we follow the main thrust of your argument.
I do not think that the proposal would be to the detriment of some high streets. The legislation would apply across Scotland and it would mean that, in the planning process, we had some way of stopping more of the express stores opening on streets that we do not need them to open on. When we consider the cumulative square footage of supermarkets, we will be able to see which high streets have no supermarkets and need one to open. Applying the legislation in such a high street would not be a problem, and it would enable people to limit the number of supermarkets in high streets where they would cause problems and where people do not want them. A retail impact assessment would enable people to be consulted and allow a consideration of the situation in the area.
As I have said, the issue for me is that we are talking about some of the major retail chains, such as Tesco, Asda, Waitrose and Sainsbury’s, and I wonder whether the same objection would have arisen if Lidl or Aldi intended to move into the retail unit on Great Western Road. Would it have?
Yes, because we have enough of the big supermarkets. If an Aldi or a Lidl were to open on that site, in the form of one of the express or local stores, it would pose a threat to the independent businesses that we are trying to support.
Miss Harrison, could you say a wee bit more about the situation in Bristol? Does the policy cover the whole of Bristol, or is it broken down to cover only specific streets and areas, as John Wilson suggested?
The position was taken by the new mayor of Bristol last year. There have been riots in Bristol where the community have not wanted a Tesco to open but it has done so, against their will, and they have felt that they have had no choice but to riot outside. The mayor is trying to stop the proliferation of those small stores and is proposing that the use class of big chain stores be changed so that, if a small, independent business shuts down and Tesco wants to move into that unit, planning permission would have to be granted, as there would be a change of use from one class to another. He sees the problem that exists and proposes that as a solution.The policy would halt the proliferation of the stores to an extent. The problem at the moment is that the chains can do what they like and can open as many stores as they want. No one can stop them.
The mayor wants the policy to cover the whole of Bristol. He wants there to be a special planning deal from Westminster, so that there would be an experimental by-law that could be used to distinguish between applications from supermarkets and applications from local independent traders.
When I was a young boy growing up in the 1960s, most high streets had a Templeton’s, a Galbraith’s or a Co-op. Those stores then disappeared. Have we not just come full circle? Similar stores are now back on the high street in the form of Tesco and Sainsbury’s stores. In terms of their size, their product offering and their contribution to local high streets, are the chains not simply bringing back Templeton’s, Galbraith’s and the other supermarkets that I remember being on streets in Glasgow’s west end such as Queen Margaret Drive and Great Western Road? That is partly where I grew up, as I was at school there and lived there for some time. Have we not just come full circle, with a move away from out-of-town stores to chains once again being represented in our local communities?
Even if we are seeing those stores coming back, I do not see how that is a good thing for local independent traders who are trying to sell their goods and are already supplying what we need. The new stores are unwanted.
I am trying to suggest that your perspective is somewhat limited to quite a short timescale. I know where you are, so I will give you two examples: Giffnock and Troon. My constituents have been dancing in the streets since local branches of Tesco, Sainsbury’s and other chains opened in their communities. Invariably, they moved into abandoned Woolworths stores, which had lain empty since the demise of Woolworths. In Giffnock, we then saw the American Whole Foods Market store arrive, the butcher, deli and grocers are all prospering and a kosher food shop has opened. In Troon, the butcher, deli, fish shop and baker all thrive perfectly happily alongside a small Tesco that has moved into an abandoned Woolworths unit. I begin to wonder whether you are inviting us to legislate for Great Western Road and Queen Margaret Drive.
No. I think that you are completely wrong—
Well, I am not completely wrong because I have just identified two communities that contradict your argument.
You are wrong in that we are not trying to legislate for Queen Margaret Drive and Great Western Road. There is a bigger problem. If you look at the number of people who are campaigning against big supermarkets opening stores, particularly express stores, you will see that it is a problem not just in those two streets.
Do people shop in them?
Of course, some people shop in them. Some people are given no choice because of all the local independent businesses that have shut down.
That is where I invite you to help the committee. I would like you to submit written evidence that details specifically which shops have closed in Great Western Road and Queen Margaret Drive directly as a consequence of a small local Tesco opening.
Okay. It might be too early for Great Western Road—
I understand that 10 such stores have opened—they have obviously been crippling. Shops close all the time for a legion of competitive reasons, so I have not been persuaded, but I am willing to follow up whether other stores in the community have closed entirely as a result of the advent of a local Tesco.
I will be able to give you evidence of the ones that have closed on Byres Road, as well—not only because of Tesco. As I said, the issue is not only about Tesco; it is about there being so many such stores.
Byres Road now has a Waitrose, and it used to have a Somerfield. It has always had supermarkets.
Yes, but it has not always had the number of supermarkets that it now has. It now has Marks and Spencer and Tesco Express alongside Waitrose, Iceland and Farmfoods. Those are all in the same street.
When I was younger it had as many stores as that, they just had different names. Although you have identified the modern branding of those stores, historically there were other stores, which I have named, that operated in exactly the same communities. People shopped in them, too, but the other, independent, food retailers survived perfectly happily alongside them because there were people who preferred to go to those independent stores. However, I am willing to see the evidence and follow up the number of stores that say that they closed for that reason alone.
The witnesses will have picked up that we have, unfortunately, run out of time. However, I ask you to hold on for a few seconds, please. We are at the summation stage, so there will be no further questions to you or us. Jackson Carlaw has recommended that we seek further information.
Sorry, convener. I did that rather off my own cuff, without going through you.
Not at all—it was a very sensible suggestion that we seek further information from our witnesses. Do members agree to that?
It must be definitive. Shops have faced an economic situation, so the evidence must be definitive and applicable, as Jackson Carlaw said. If the witnesses do not mind, I would also like to know what the implications are for the customers in terms of price competition. It must be fairly rabid if there are six stores sitting next to each other.
Do members wish us to get that information before deciding whether to ask the Scottish Government and the Federation of Small Businesses in Scotland for further information, or should we do those things in parallel?
I think that we should do those things in tandem. We need to write to the Federation of Small Businesses in Scotland, as a number of small retailers are members of it and we might get further evidence to back the petition. The petition indicates that the number of small businesses has declined due to the encroachment of some major retailers.Given that the discussion has concentrated on the Glasgow area, I suggest that we write to Glasgow City Council, asking for its views on the petition and whether it has identified any impact from the number of express or small outlets of the major chains. Marks and Spencer has expanded quite dramatically in the city centre, never mind in the outlying Byres Road and Great Western Road area.I also suggest that we write to local authorities that have town centre managers, asking for their views on the encroachment of Tesco Express, Sainsbury’s, Waitrose or Morrisons stores, to find out whether we are seeing a large development of small retail units being used by the major supermarket chains.
Do members agree to that?Members indicated agreement.
I agree with John Wilson’s view that we should contact town centre managers and put in a pitch that we should approach Falkirk Council. A very good team works in town centre management there, and I am sure that it would be delighted to provide some evidence.One of the most salient points that we have heard this morning is the need for a retail impact assessment focusing on the cumulative effect of smaller stores on a particular area. When we write to the Scottish Government, I would like us to ask its opinion on the introduction of a retail impact assessment for smaller stores in a particular area, as that might help.
Do members agree to that?Members indicated agreement.
The witnesses will have picked up that we are continuing the petition. We will write to a number of relevant bodies, including the Scottish Government, the FSB and town centre managers. We will also ask the Scottish Government specifically about retail impact assessments, and we have asked the witnesses to supply us with a bit more evidence.Thank you both for coming along and giving us evidence. It was a very dynamic and stimulating debate. There are strong feelings on the issue, and you put your case very well.10:42 Meeting suspended.
10:44 On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jan 2014 →- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 71
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 86
- 09:30 New Petitions Petitions · 58
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 11
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 2
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 1
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 3
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 6
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 8
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 4
- 09:30 Current Petitions Petitions · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.