In our submission, we quoted a figure from SNH, which “reports that 84.2% of features on designated sites ... are in favourable or recovering condition”. There is a great deal of information that seems to conflict. Another figure that we quote in our submission is that “248 out of 957 Sites of Special Scientific Interest are in unfavourable condition”.The fact is that there are designated sites where there is further work to do, which is why we have 10 section 7s and why there will probably be more, as well as possibly some section 8s. The environmental improvement in those sites is the driver behind section 7. It is not all bad news, but we still have a long way to go. As I said earlier, deer management groups are taking that on board and adapting their management plans to allow the environmental requirements of the designated sites in their areas to be a significant part of their future planning. I am convinced that we can continue to proceed along an improving trend.
Official Report · Committee
Deer Management
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Rob Gibson SNP 39
- Richard Cooke Association of Deer Management Groups 38
- Alex Fergusson Con 29
- Duncan Orr-Ewing RSPB Scotland 27
- Mike Daniels John Muir Trust 25
- Dr Keegan 24
- Jamie Williamson Scottish Land & Estates 19
- Nigel Don SNP 13
- Graeme Dey SNP 13
- Claudia Beamish Lab 9
- Richard Lyle SNP 7
- Jim Hume LD 6
- Alex Hogg Scottish Gamekeepers Association 6
- Angus MacDonald SNP 4
- Cara Hilton 2
- Dr Maggie Keegan Scottish Wildlife Trust 1
The record
262 contributions · showing 201–262I phoned a stalker last night who stays at the top of a glen that is 10 miles long. Every two or three miles along that glen, there is a house where a stalker and their family lives. It shows the benefits to that community. We were talking about designated sites—he has one on his ground. For years, SNH and others were saying, “Look at the erosion with those bloomin’ deer, especially up on the peat hags.” They fenced off the area, put 4 inch boards in and excluded the deer altogether for a year. The boards are filling up with peat, so it is now absolutely certain that the issue is weather erosion. Before, it was, “It must be the deer.” All these wee things need to be tried to get answers.
I will build on that point. In my deer management group, we have two special areas of conservation: Creag Meagaidh and Monadhliath. In Creag Meagaidh, the condition of the blanket bog has been categorised as “Unfavourable No change”, even though all the sheep have been removed and most of the deer have been removed since 1987.On the Monadhliath special area of conservation, we have challenged SNH on its standard method of assessment, which says that the condition is “Unfavourable No change” and that that is probably due to deer. Anecdotally, all the crofters and shepherds have said that, actually, there is far more vegetation on the exposed peat now than there was before. After we went together to SNH, funding was provided for an environs study, which concluded, from studying the aerial photographs of the area from 1946 and from 2005, that there is 46 per cent less exposed peat now than there was in 1946. That indicates that the condition of the area is improving.A scientific study that was undertaken by MLURI compared areas from which the deer and sheep were not excluded with areas from which deer and sheep were excluded with fencing. The study was conducted in three areas: Caithness, the Monadhliath special area of conservation and the Ladder hills. The conclusion was that, over a period of 10 years, there was no significant difference in erosion between the areas from which deer and sheep were excluded and the areas from which deer and sheep were not excluded but there was a slight increase in exposed peat. Therefore, MLURI’s conclusion was that the change was to do not with herbivores but with climate change. In SNH document 421 “Peat erosion and the management of peatland habitats”, the conclusion states:“there was no clear evidence to indicate that densities of large herbivores were associated with the incidence, severity or type of erosion”.We have challenged SNH by querying its standard method of assessing blanket peat bogs, which we think is flawed because it contradicts the anecdotal evidence, the historical evidence and the scientific evidence. Therefore, we have asked SNH to go back and relook at the way in which it assesses whether things are in poor condition.
Thank you. I think that that covers both points.
On that point, having seen the ground at Forsinard, I know that areas near to fences that the deer regularly use as a route across are far more difficult to rewet than those where there has not been a heavy tread. That is one reason why, in some areas, trees and fences have been removed to allow for a variety of routes for the deer to travel. Actually, there is clear evidence there that some parts of the peat bog are in much poorer condition because of deer. We could argue about that a lot of the way, but that is the set of facts that I have.We will move on to deer management groups, on which Alex Fergusson has a question.
Gentlemen, you will have heard the evidence that we were given in the previous session about the perceived failings of the effectiveness of deer management groups, on which I have one or two questions. As an institution, the Scottish Parliament works on the principles of openness, transparency, accessibility and accountability, which are principles that I strongly believe in. Some of the evidence that was put to us suggested that deer management groups have a bit to do before they become open and transparent, particularly in terms of their membership, how often they meet, how they can be contacted and all that sort of thing. Can I get your reaction to that? Do you think that improvement could be made in that direction, so that people can have confidence that the deer management groups are open, accessible and accountable?
Of course, in assessing how open and accountable deer management groups are, there is a range that goes from good to bad. There is certainly more work to be done in that respect, and that is the culture change that the code is in the process of bringing about.Deer management groups certainly need to be more inclusive. By the principles that it has offered, the ADMG has set out its intent to lead deer management groups to a more inclusive approach. Earlier this year, I wrote an article for Scope, which is one of our newsletters, that encouraged deer management groups to include in their discussions all land management interests, whether or not they are within the boundaries within which the deer can be found, so that the impacts on other economic interests such as farming and forestry are taken into account.12:45
I also recommend to deer management groups that they should maintain their business meetings for discussing business; nuts-and-bolts management discussions about the number of deer that they manage, how they manage them, how they should be culled and how they are meeting the objectives that they have set need to be held between the people who are directly involved. However, every deer management group should, in the foreseeable future, have an external communications policy that offers representation at local community councils, for example, to discuss its management plan. The management plans should be available for those with an external interest to see, and the deer management group should be prepared to stand up and justify and explain the content of those plans.One of our most difficult problems in the land management industry as a whole is that we are not well understood by the wider public. We must take responsibility for that. Communicating effectively what we are about and that we are on their side, so to speak, is really important. I completely buy the premise on which you asked your question. We need to be more open and accountable.
What response have you had from deer management groups to the article in Scope that you mentioned?
It has been mentioned on a number of occasions when I have been at meetings. It has been acknowledged, and it will be built into deer management plan development and revisions. It will therefore take a little while to get to exactly where we want to be. However, give us a year or two, and you will, I hope, see a significant change from the present situation.
I would like to continue that point. I am grateful for your explanation, but a layman who is looking in on the situation might find it rather odd that some deer management groups have no plan at all, although I think that they would find it understandable that the rest of them are at various stages.You mentioned that a process of transformation is going on in the world of deer management. Indeed, your submission to the committee says something very similar; it talks about“the substantial process of change that is occurring in the deer sector”.Can you envisage a time when all deer management groups will have a plan in place that people can access and at least take part in discussions on, if not influence? If so, is it possible to put a timeframe on when that might be achieved? I appreciate that doing so is difficult.
Yes, in response to the first question and don’t know in response to the second. The larger, mainstream deer management groups are moving very quickly in that direction. The document that I held up earlier is available. I also referred earlier to the Cairngorms/Speyside plan, which is more map based and has less text. It will become available on the group’s website, if it is not already available on it. The ADMG has offered a service to its members that means that, if they cannot afford to develop and manage their own website, they can use a page on our website to provide a link that will enable them to provide information about their deer management group, including their deer management plan. We are therefore moving forward, but there is work to do.
Can you point to any other ways in which the process of transformation is taking place? Will you expand on that a little bit?
I have referred to the habitat service, which is really important. Going back to the natural capital, it is important, as was said in the previous session, to know what the base resources are that we depend on for economic as well as other outputs. It is very welcome that people in Alex Hogg’s profession are learning the basic skills of measuring the beneficial and negative impacts of their management on the habitat so that they can modify their management accordingly.
One has to appreciate that there are areas where the sporting estates or the land ownership provide some 80 per cent of the employment. If, within a discrete deer population area, there are only four or five estates and their owners, keepers and farm staff are engaged and, no doubt, represented on the community council as well, they often do not need a deer management plan per se, because they are all engaged in the process.Our deer management group has 40-odd members. We go to the community councils, but most of them are not really interested. When they are asked to comment on deer issues, they often pass the request to one of our members and ask them to produce a response. Crofters come in and we will certainly deal with them, but for the most part there is no point in pestering someone and saying, “Please come,” if they are not that interested.
Equally, I think that you would accept that, if an interested party did ask to come, they should be able to do so.
No problem. Yes. We are all-inclusive. The fact that they do not all come is a problem.
Understood.
Before I ask a broader question about voluntary and statutory management plans, I have a question for Richard Cooke. We were given the figure that only 16 or 18 of the 42 deer management groups have active management plans. How many of them have come to the fore recently? Has the fact that there is to be a review next year focused minds or would they have come to the fore anyway?
I do not know that there is going to be a review of deer management planning as such. Deer management planning has been around for quite a long time. Initially it was crude, but it is becoming increasingly sophisticated as it goes along. I refer to the map-based approach of three of the groups, and the habitat aspects, too.The catalyst for the significant increase in uptake has been the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011 and the code. As I said earlier, in my view, there are 24 plans and not 16. Many deer management groups are functioning at a smaller level, which is right, as they should focus on local issues, and many sub-groups now have their own deer management plans, which feed up the pyramid, so to speak, into a bigger plan. There are also 12 in development, as I said, so by my calculation the number of deer management groups that are actively involved in deer management planning is 36 and not 16.That is not to say that all the groups have a completed plan, which is what the figure of 16 was all about, but they are all actively involved in the process. That is the important thing. In management planning, the process is often as important as the output because it can have a catalytic effect on the ways in which the deer management group operates and the neighbours relate to each other. The next stage is that the plans should be updated, monitored and adapted to circumstances.
Thank you. More broadly, I ask the panel to respond to the comments in written evidence to the committee that“the current system of voluntary deer management structures in place in Scotland is not fit for purpose”and that DMGs should be brought under statute. You have already provided examples of where the system works well, but will you comment on whether the groups should be brought under statute?
I represent not only the Association of Deer Management Groups but the lowland deer network Scotland. In my paper on that, I drew out the major difference between highland and lowland deer management. A one-size-fits-all approach does not work when it comes to deer. It does not work between lowlands and highlands, but it does not work even at the more local level. Going around deer management groups, one is constantly struck by how different they are. The issues that they talk about may be common up to a point, but the ways in which they operate and their characteristics are different. They reflect the circumstances in which they have evolved. As a result, a statutory framework would not aid the process of resolving conflicts between neighbours who have to find a common way forward; indeed, it would not improve matters at all. It would simply make things grossly more bureaucratic and costly. You will expect me to say this—indeed, I have said it in writing—but I am convinced that the deer management groups’ voluntary basis is fit for purpose and will continue to improve and deliver more public as well as private benefits.
Does anyone else wish to comment on that?
Only to endorse those comments. Our concern is that if you put more and more regulation on an industry, investors eventually walk away. That is the case even with field sports. At the moment, the field sports industry benefits from people investing well beyond the financial return that they make from it. Of course, people also enjoy it. They keep cull numbers down. When we compared ourselves and Creag Meagaidh in terms of how the public sector would deal with the problem of deer, we worked out that it would take six times as many man-hours to cull every deer in Creag Meagaidh as it would for us. That can be dealt with only by the public purse. We think it far better to have what is in effect a private and public sector partnership in which the private and public sectors make an investment, and the voluntary code makes the whole thing very much cheaper for the public sector and the taxpayer than if we simply handed it all over to the public sector.
I will take a couple of supplementaries from members, but then we will have to move on rapidly.
Convener, I would just like to say that gamekeepers and stalkers have been involved in the best-practice project and that there are now 80 or perhaps 82 best-practice shoots. The project, which is the envy of the rest of Europe—in fact, other European countries have asked to introduce it—has all been done in our free time over the past five years. A lot of work has been done on it, enthusiasm for it is high and I simply do not think that it would be the same if it was put on a statutory footing.
In its written submission, the Scottish Gamekeepers Association says:“Socio-economic needs of communities are, in our view, best served by a voluntary deer management system rather than a statutory one. Without proper input into a statutory system, local communities are more likely to feel that their ability to have a balancing say over their futures has been removed.”Can you clarify how you think local communities would not be involved? My understanding is that the move to a statutory system is not about centralisation but about enabling all stakeholders to come together on a more formal footing.
That already happens at the moment, but I have to say that people have had enough of red tape and that, if this became law, they would just throw in the towel and pack it all in. Everyone has to be involved in these things and, when they become law, the situation becomes more difficult. People get uptight about having to do something and would rather not do it. At the moment, we have managed to get everyone involved.
Alex Hogg has partly answered this question but, in view of the previous panel’s suggestion that the deer management code was not really doing anything because it was not statutory, what are the witnesses’ views on progress with the code?
As I have said, all strands of the industry, including the NGOs with an interest, were involved in developing the code. SNH took input from all people with a relevant interest, and we were very happy with how it turned out. Indeed, I find it enormously useful in focusing minds when I am talking to deer management groups about how they should regard their future responsibilities on deer management. It is certainly very early days to conclude that it is not fit for purpose. On the contrary, it has been hugely important, and I am sure that we can raise our game in order to meet its objectives.13:00
The previous panel commented that, in effect, the code is only for SNH and so on. It has been very much endorsed by the private sector and by the deer management groups and deer managers. It has been useful for us when we have gone to SNH and reminded it about the factors that we must balance and the way in which we must go forward. It has allowed deer management groups and deer managers to talk on a level basis and say, “Right—these are our objectives, this is what we have to achieve and this is the way we should achieve it. Now let’s go forward and do it.” The private sector has bought into the code almost more than the public sector has.
That is very interesting.
I want to pick up on Mr Cooke’s point that the current deer management plans are fit for purpose. If you are still waiting for deer management plans to come forward from some areas, how can you say that the current system is fit for purpose?In addition, you said in response to Alex Fergusson’s question that you could not provide a timescale for the completion of all DMPs. If you do not know the timescale for the introduction of deer management plans, is there an argument for a statutory duty on landlords to come up with a DMP, with SNH producing statutory deer management plans?
As I said, it is early days, but a culture change is taking place. We are making good progress and I believe that we can, in the medium term, deliver deer management planning in every deer management group. I cannot say that we have fixed it already, but I can say that we are working on it and making progress.
First, I would like a definition of the medium term. Secondly, Alex Hogg spoke about everyone being involved under the voluntary set-up, but we heard evidence from the previous panel of witnesses that, from their perspective, not everyone is involved, and there is a feeling that they are not welcome in deer management groups. That is the view that they have—rightly or wrongly—expressed. What will you take away from the evidence that you have heard today that will drive your thinking going forward to ensure that everyone ends up being involved in deer management groups?
It is essential that the NGOs get involved, as they are landowners and their management objectives are as legitimate as anybody else’s. They need to be part of the mix, and they must attend meetings. If they need support to attend meetings, they can have it. Unless we include everybody, we will come up with only half the answer.
And do you have a definition of the medium term to which you referred?
I would like to think that we will be well on the road by the end of five years and will have arrived from A to Z at the end of 10 years; that we will have active and forward-looking deer management plans that are kept under regular review; that we will have developed our skills to assess the quality of the habitat on which the deer and other resources are living; and that we will have learned to get on with each other better than we sometimes do at present.
That is useful—thank you.
My question naturally extends from that point. Mr Cooke, you said that, although someone can have a management objective within a certain area, they will, if their deer are just going to wander across into someone else’s area and come back when they feel like it, always have to consider what is outside. Am I right in thinking therefore that one of the biggest problems is how you manage outside your boundaries and manage the conflicts of interest between different deer management areas?
An individual deer manager must think about his deer at two levels. He must think about what the deer mean to him as a resource and about what they mean in the context of the whole herd to which he has only partial access. He must come to a reasonable accommodation with his neighbours as to what he can achieve without detriment to neighbouring interests, and that is where we sometimes run on to the rocks. An example of that has been given today—I will not mention the A word—but we will get through that. There is a process to deal with it that requires the Government agency to get involved, and it has the power to do so under sections 7 and 8 of the 1996 act. That power has yet to be tested, but I have no objection to its being tested, because it is high time that we found out just how regulation and the voluntary principle can operate together. Once we have learned the lessons from that, that will inform other situations in which such problems arise in the future.
I wonder whether I can push you slightly. Because I am in the same profession, I recognise a diplomatic and guarded answer when I hear one. You have told us that 36 out of the 46 deer management groups already have deer management plans and—if I heard you aright—that it will take five or six years to get the other 10 groups on board. Do you recognise that, from my side of the table, that sounds like an awfully long time?
I recognise that and I am trying to take a pragmatic view of what is possible. It is a matter not just of bringing in the people who are not in the system but of continuing to improve the plans that already exist. In the past, we have been accused of having deer management plans that are written by a consultant, read by a few people and put on a shelf to gather dust. They need to be of far more value than that, and there are examples—some of which I have given—of where that is already the way in which deer management plans are being used. We need to refine them as well as introduce them, and I am giving myself a reasonable period of time in which to bring the number of plans up to the 100 per cent level that you are looking for.
I am asking you, given your position, to recognise that, if there are 10 areas out there that you feel are not going to play ball very quickly, that might explain why some of the earlier witnesses want some kind of statutory system. Not doing something within five years sounds like not doing it, and that sounds like not voluntary action but voluntary inaction.
I assure you that there is no foot dragging going on. There is absolute determination to deliver the plans as fast as is practically possible. Nevertheless, I must take a practical view as to what is possible. I will list some of the deer management groups that do not have plans at the moment. The Harris and Lewis deer management group has an interesting innovation in that one of its members is a community body. However, its deer management planning skill is pretty rudimentary and it has a long way to go. The Glenartney deer management group is a little one that runs extremely well and is the only group that I can think of whose members all have a predominantly sporting interest. There is no circle to square in that case—all the group’s members are pointing in the same direction and do not have the conflicts to resolve or the management objectives to balance that almost all other groups have. The Islay group also works pretty well although it does not have a deer management plan. As I have said, it has a high deer population that is within the carrying capacity of the land, and that is evidenced by the good condition of the deer.The fact that a group does not have a written deer management plan does not mean that deer management thinking and planning does not take place there. In such a group, every member knows where every other member is coming from and they do not need to put that on a piece of paper. However, it is an objective for us to get that on a piece of paper where people want to see that deer management planning is, to some extent, formalised and regularised.
Thank you. It is useful to get a paragraph or two about that on the record.
It might be useful to refer to Sir John Lister-Kaye’s proposal that“a land ethic needs to require all sporting estate owners to sign up to an absolute minimum of 15% (but ideally much more) of their hill unit, dedicated to natural restoration for twenty-five years.”Do you think that, if that had been applied in the mid-1990s, we would not now be trying to draw up deer management plans?
If it had been applied by diktat, it would have been extremely difficult to make it happen in practice. It is happening, not perhaps quite in the way that John Lister-Kaye anticipated—with a quota approach—but because of the mix of objectives that deer management groups now constitute. Having come from a single objective base, they are now multi-objective, and the fact that deer management groups usually have five or six different interests, and that a significant proportion of their management objectives are environmental, means that we are moving into a thoroughly healthy mix that will produce environmental improvements, as well as meeting the other requirements of the code.
It depends what you mean by natural restoration. You must remember that most of our hills had virtually no trees on them 200 or 500 years ago. The trees disappeared 5,000 years ago, and we have now transformed the land by putting far more trees on it. If we are asking what is natural, we should also ask whether it is natural to heavily cull all the herbivores or to remove all the sheep. If we remove all the herbivores, we will get woody vegetation but we will also get more wildfires. You really have to go back to John Lister-Kaye and ask whether he had a romantic view of it five years ago, 100 years ago, 500 years ago, or 5,000 years ago, and then work back from that to decide whether it is sensible to restore the environment to that position.
To be clear, he was talking about a hill unit, not a lowland area.
Most of the hill units have been bare of trees for the past 5,000 years. We are trying to bring them back after something like 5,000 or 6,000 years.
Well, we could debate that point, and I have no doubt that the committee will do so, but we have time constraints as it is.
Could I revert to Nigel Don’s question and make a supplementary point? There is part of our submission that I would like to read, because I think that it is important. “A question which ADMG is currently addressing is what constitutes an effective DMG and how this can be evidenced. In broad terms we would include:Regular well attended meetings with representation of all land management interests and appropriate public agencies.An up to date and effective forward looking Deer Management Plan based on consensus between members.Reference to the ADMG Principles of Collaboration.A statement of commitment to the Code.A commitment to promote Best Practice to ensure deer welfare and public safety.Agreement as to Group practical actions including deer counts, habitat monitoring and cull setting and allocation.A commitment to Competence represented by DSC 1 and 2; also “trained hunter” for venison production.An external communications policy to ensure that relevant interests, particularly local interests, are kept regularly informed about deer management in the DMG area and have an opportunity to comment on, for example, the Deer Management Plan.”The point that I want to make is that the sign of a healthy, effective and publicly responsible deer management group is not just to do with the deer management plan, although that is important. There are a lot of other aspects. That is the aspiration that we intend to deliver in respect of our members.
In the medium term?
In the medium term.
Richard Cooke touched on section 7 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996. I would like to ask all panel members about the effectiveness of control agreements and why they have not been followed up in any way under section 8, and whether that is related to the burden of proof point that I made earlier, or whether there are other reasons.
Following the introduction of the 1996 act, I was a member of the Deer Commission for Scotland, which oversaw the introduction of section 7 agreements. I must say that, as a private land manager representative on the Deer Commission, I was quite concerned about those agreements—it all seemed a bit of an imposition. I confess to that now, because I actually think that they have been an enormous success. Some issues—not a huge number, but some—have been done and dusted and gone away. The legislation provides a good framework for people in a critical situation who do not agree, first as to whether there is a problem, and secondly as to what to do about it and how to apportion the tasks. It has proved to be a good vehicle for that. 13:15
On why section 8 has not been used, I know that it is said that it would not stand a legal test, although that remains to be seen—I am not a legal expert, so I do not have a view on that. However, it is a sign of the success of the voluntary principle that section 7, which relates to agreements rather than orders, has generally been used to take strong steps towards solving the problems at the local level that the section is meant to address. One area that springs to mind is Caenlochan, which was mentioned earlier and where, relatively unusually, the problem is in summer rather than winter, as the deer gravitate to the top. With SNH in the chair, so to speak, all the estates in the area have got together and reduced the deer population more or less to target. It has been considered necessary to extend the section 7 agreement, and despite the fact that concerns were expressed this year in the media about the area, all parties have now signed up to an extension of the agreement. That is a good example of how careful consensus building within a helpful framework can deliver the necessary outputs when it comes to environmental improvement.
Could you tell the committee—not today, because of everyone’s time commitments, but perhaps in writing—about the outcome of other section 7 agreements that you are aware of and whether the resolution has been satisfactory or unsatisfactory?
I can do that, but it perhaps makes sense for the committee to hear what SNH says on the matter next week, because it is in the best position to judge. I can certainly give you my take on it, however.
That is fine. That order would be perfectly acceptable.Finally—if we are lucky—the deer management groups are being asked to help with wildfires, which we have heard about. Without commenting further on that issue, will you say whether the groups as currently structured and resourced can take on extra roles successfully?
Resources are an issue. Deer management groups raise their own operating funds and enough money to pay the association to represent them. A number of them have difficulty with that. Until now, because they are groups, they have not qualified for access to Scottish rural development programme funding, although that fund is probably relevant to their work. In the common agricultural policy and SRDP review, we have made representation that that should change, and I understand that similar representations have been made by other organisations, particularly Forest Enterprise. I understand that the Scottish Government is taking that as a recommendation to Europe. If that comes through, it will be helpful when deer management groups undertake projects such as putting together a deer management plan, which they often do not have capacity to do themselves.
I am chairman of my local fire protection or wildfire group and of my local deer management group, both of which are groups with no constitution but of like-minded people who have got together to deal with a common resource or threat. There is no Government input of funding.In the past, we have found that the fire brigade is not geared up to deal with heath and woodland fires, whereas the vast majority of keepers, particularly on estates with grouse moors where there is regular heather burning in the spring, have Argocats and fire fogging equipment; they also have experience. Actually, with most such fires, we find that the keepers have far more experience and equipment than the local fire brigade. In 2003, when we had huge numbers of fires, the fire brigade used to phone up the fire protection group or wildfire group to order machinery. The fire brigade would arrive with no four-wheel-drive or cross-country vehicles or fire fogging equipment, but we could sometimes place five, 10 or 15 machines at its disposal on remote sites, which proved invaluable. I think that more could be done on that.
As those final points really are final points, if the witnesses need to say anything more to us, they can certainly send the committee that in writing. I thank the witnesses for what has been an extremely detailed response to our inquiries.I shall shortly ask the public gallery to be cleared and move the meeting into private, as previously agreed, to consider our draft report on scrutiny of the 2014-15 draft budget. At our next meeting, the committee will hold its final evidence session on deer management from stakeholders and consider its draft letter to the Scottish Government on climate change adaptation and behaviour change. We will also consider our approach to the scrutiny of the Agricultural Holdings (Scotland) Act 2003 Remedial Order 2014.I also note that, because of the shortfall relating to the uplift of €223 million in the CAP allocation for the United Kingdom, the committee has agreed to request as a matter of urgency a meeting with the UK Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Owen Paterson MP.13:21 Meeting continued in private until 13:34.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Nov 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Deer Management Committee business · 262
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.