Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Deer Management

Wednesday 13 November 2013 Rural Affairs, Climate Change and Environment Committee About 10:00 Committee business 262 contributions · 16 speakers

Speakers

Showing Alex Fergusson only · show everyone

Alex Fergusson’s contributions

29 contributions
Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Convener, I am sorry to interrupt, but I seek clarification. I understand what Maggie Keegan said about the voluntary arrangements that have been in place for 30-odd years. The code of practice for deer management that came out of the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011, which had full parliamentary scrutiny, states that“Sustainable Deer Management is about managing deer to achieve the best combination of benefits for the economy, environment, people and communities for now and for future generations.”Will you confirm that deer management is about a combination of benefits, and not about one benefit to the exclusion of others?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I simply point out that the code of practice has been in operation for less than two years. I know that we will come to that later, but it is an important point. You agree that we are talking about a combination of factors and not one to the exclusion of others.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I would like to tease out the question of numbers. I do not disagree that the key question in the area that we are looking at is the impact on the biodiversity of the country, but the numbers are important. In my experience as a former sheep farmer, the carrying capacity of the ground that I farmed depended on the stocking rate of the sheep that I put on the hill. Each area of hill has a natural carrying capacity. I suggest, therefore, that the numbers are quite important. What is more important than the total number of deer is the density of the deer in the country and their impact on the natural environment. I do not think that anyone would argue with that.10:30

I will take a second to look at the figures in the Scottish Parliament information centre briefing, as I find them interesting. There is a comprehensive chart of deer counts over the years, going right back to the 1960s in some cases. As I am not a mathematician of Nigel Don’s ability—he could probably just look at the chart and reel off the figures—I have had to do a bit of paperwork on the matter.If we take the pre-1970 counts, which I think the witnesses will agree were done mostly on the ground, and look at the area over which the counts took place, we see that there was a stocking density of 6.66 deer per km2. That is evident from the figures that we have been given.The most recent figures have been done from the air, which is probably more accurate than ground counting, and they give a stocking density of 8.31 deer per km2. That is a difference of 24 per cent between the pre-1970 counts and now, which is a very different figure to the suggested increase in total numbers that we have been given.Back in the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s, one was counting over a certain amount of ground and coming up with the numbers of deer that were on it, which is perfectly reasonable. However, I do not think that anyone can argue with the fact that, as we are now able to cover a much greater area of ground by air counting, we are bound to find more deer.I contend that the stocking density increase suggests that the increase in the number of deer is not quite as great as might be suggested by looking at the figures in another way. Of course, figures are always difficult. However, I find it interesting that there is scientific evidence to suggest that counts by air are 24 per cent more accurate than counts on the ground, which—remarkably enough—is exactly the same difference as has been shown to exist between the pre-1970 counts and the current count.I would like your comments on the stocking density, which I contend is the most important figure that we need to look at when we discuss the subject.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I have a couple of brief supplementaries, but I must first thank the witnesses for their responses. I absolutely accept that there are local differences in deer population, but my understanding of local deer management groups is that they were set up to look at such issues.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

In my opinion, they need to be given time to work.Going back to my former farming experience, I have to wonder why, if overgrazing is such a problem, we get the kind of wild fire that I think happened in the Assynt area in 2011. Herbage will never burn like that if an area is as overgrazed as you seem to be suggesting. In that light, I think that we need to focus on stocking density rather than overall numbers as far as damage to the areas that interest you is concerned.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Sheep farmers have to accept that because the problem is exactly the same with sheep. In a hard winter, you lose more sheep on the hill—it is as simple as that.I will not extend my questioning, convener, but I think that some points have been raised that we will need to come back to later.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The evidence that we have been sent shows that there are clearly two sides to the argument in this debate. I have to say, from a personal point of view, although I was not involved in the committee in the previous session, that I cannot help feeling that we have heard all those arguments in the recent past and that, like it or lump it, Parliament came to a pretty clear conclusion and introduced the code of practice in the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011, which went through full parliamentary scrutiny. Given that the code of practice has been in place for less than 18 months,

I find it difficult to understand how you can argue that it is ineffective. You have described the current system of deer management as unfit for purpose. You made all these arguments two years ago—very forcefully, I am sure, if not convincingly—and I wonder how you can continue that argument less than two years after the code of practice has come in.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I understand that entirely. However, with great respect, the Parliament decided—in its wisdom or otherwise—to pass the Wildlife and Natural Environment (Scotland) Act 2011, the consequence of which was the introduction of the code of voluntary practice less than 18 months ago. I return to my question: how, after that period of time, can you be so sure that the code is unfit for purpose? It seems an extraordinary accusation to make against a piece of legislation that went through the Parliament with full scrutiny in this committee—I am not biased, because I was not a member of the committee at the time—and I find it astonishing that this debate is continuing after such a short period of time.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Surely the whole point of deer management groups, where they exist and where they have a plan, is that all stakeholders—public and private—come together to discuss the issues involved and work out a local management plan to address the issues, all under the auspices of SNH. It has had a very short period to work. You have not really answered, to my satisfaction, why you think that it is not working.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I will have one last go, if I may—I do not want to encroach into the next question.You raised the subject of section 8, which suggests that there is a measure of statutory regulation implicit in the WANE act and the code of practice. Before a section 8 scheme is implemented or brought into being—whatever the right terminology is—SNH would have to identify a problem, agree that it is a problem and go through the whole process laid out in the code of practice. That is bound to take some time. I repeat that we have had the code of practice for less than 18 months, which is not an unreasonable amount of time to identify a problem and try to address the issue of what to do about it. I understand that there may be a section 7 agreement in the offing; strangely enough, for one of today’s panellists, it is a possibility. Surely it is natural that these things take an element of time to highlight and bring to fruition.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I will finish here, convener, and thank you for your indulgence. I think that we could argue quite strongly that the fact that a section 8 scheme has not been introduced in all the time that it has been available would suggest that there is a measure of success in the voluntary arrangements of deer management practice.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Some of the figures that Mr Lyle referred to concern what has become known as the 12:4 dilemma. That is black and white; I think that I am right in saying that—in a nutshell—stalking interests say that they require a stocking density of 12 deer per km2, whereas you suggest a density of four deer per km2 to allow the regeneration of woodland and for other aspects of your interests, without the need for fencing. I live in south-west Scotland, which has had a massive amount of forestry regeneration—although some of it is not particularly attractive—and none of that would have happened without fencing, but perhaps that is for another debate. How do you solve the 12:4 dilemma, which involves two very different interests?11:15

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I will not go into the benefits of getting into the leeward side of any woodland, which provides shelter, but I take your point.You have conceded that fencing provides part of the answer. I am interested to hear that you are happy that fencing has a large part to play in livestock management. Deer are livestock—the issue comes down to that, to an extent.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

It is clear that you are not happy with the operation of deer management groups. How involved are you with them? Mike Daniels mentioned the situation at Ardvar. Are you involved in the group there?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Do you still attend local deer management group meetings?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

What is your experience of working in those groups and discussing in them the issues that you have brought to our attention?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

From the two examples that you gave, it seems that the model can work.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I will be brief, convener.I would like clarification. I note that Scottish Environment LINK’s written submission is in the name of the Scottish Environment LINK deer task force and that it lists at the end eight organisations that I presume are members of that task force. Are any other organisations in Scottish Environment LINK members of it?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Why does such a big landowner with a good record of land management not support the submission?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I would like to do so. Thank you very much.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Gentlemen, you will have heard the evidence that we were given in the previous session about the perceived failings of the effectiveness of deer management groups, on which I have one or two questions. As an institution, the Scottish Parliament works on the principles of openness, transparency, accessibility and accountability, which are principles that I strongly believe in. Some of the evidence that was put to us suggested that deer management groups have a bit to do before they become open and transparent, particularly in terms of their membership, how often they meet, how they can be contacted and all that sort of thing. Can I get your reaction to that? Do you think that improvement could be made in that direction, so that people can have confidence that the deer management groups are open, accessible and accountable?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I would like to continue that point. I am grateful for your explanation, but a layman who is looking in on the situation might find it rather odd that some deer management groups have no plan at all, although I think that they would find it understandable that the rest of them are at various stages.You mentioned that a process of transformation is going on in the world of deer management. Indeed, your submission to the committee says something very similar; it talks about“the substantial process of change that is occurring in the deer sector”.Can you envisage a time when all deer management groups will have a plan in place that people can access and at least take part in discussions on, if not influence? If so, is it possible to put a timeframe on when that might be achieved? I appreciate that doing so is difficult.

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Can you point to any other ways in which the process of transformation is taking place? Will you expand on that a little bit?

Alex Fergusson Con Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Equally, I think that you would accept that, if an interested party did ask to come, they should be able to do so.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
  3. 10:00 Deer Management Committee business · 262

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.