Can you give us more detail about the effectiveness of the agreements under section 7 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996? You have referred to existing possibilities under that section, which I did not know about. There have not been any compulsory control schemes under section 8 of the 1996 act. Can you tell us in detail why that approach has not worked, perhaps because of the burden of proof?
Official Report · Committee
Deer Management
Speakers
Showing Claudia Beamish only · show everyone- Rob Gibson SNP 39
- Richard Cooke Association of Deer Management Groups 38
- Alex Fergusson Con 29
- Duncan Orr-Ewing RSPB Scotland 27
- Mike Daniels John Muir Trust 25
- Dr Keegan 24
- Jamie Williamson Scottish Land & Estates 19
- Nigel Don SNP 13
- Graeme Dey SNP 13
- Claudia Beamish Lab 9
- Richard Lyle SNP 7
- Jim Hume LD 6
- Alex Hogg Scottish Gamekeepers Association 6
- Angus MacDonald SNP 4
- Cara Hilton 2
- Dr Maggie Keegan Scottish Wildlife Trust 1
Claudia Beamish’s contributions
9 contributionsI want to tease out a few more issues. We have seen the ADMG principles of collaboration. Is something needed on the other public interest issues, as well as the jobs for stalkers and the local community, that need to be discussed in a deer management group? Would it be useful if that was codified more clearly?11:30
Do you know of any estates that have by culling more improved the balance of biodiversity but which still take a robust approach to the possibilities of having a stalking estate? Moreover, do you have any comments on the Harris model of communities working together on stalking?
Before I ask a broader question about voluntary and statutory management plans, I have a question for Richard Cooke. We were given the figure that only 16 or 18 of the 42 deer management groups have active management plans. How many of them have come to the fore recently? Has the fact that there is to be a review next year focused minds or would they have come to the fore anyway?
Thank you. More broadly, I ask the panel to respond to the comments in written evidence to the committee that“the current system of voluntary deer management structures in place in Scotland is not fit for purpose”and that DMGs should be brought under statute. You have already provided examples of where the system works well, but will you comment on whether the groups should be brought under statute?
Does anyone else wish to comment on that?
In its written submission, the Scottish Gamekeepers Association says:“Socio-economic needs of communities are, in our view, best served by a voluntary deer management system rather than a statutory one. Without proper input into a statutory system, local communities are more likely to feel that their ability to have a balancing say over their futures has been removed.”Can you clarify how you think local communities would not be involved? My understanding is that the move to a statutory system is not about centralisation but about enabling all stakeholders to come together on a more formal footing.
Richard Cooke touched on section 7 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996. I would like to ask all panel members about the effectiveness of control agreements and why they have not been followed up in any way under section 8, and whether that is related to the burden of proof point that I made earlier, or whether there are other reasons.
Could you tell the committee—not today, because of everyone’s time commitments, but perhaps in writing—about the outcome of other section 7 agreements that you are aware of and whether the resolution has been satisfactory or unsatisfactory?
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Nov 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Deer Management Committee business · 262
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.