Good morning. So far, we have heard only general broad assertions about the situation. Can you provide the committee with specific examples to illustrate the impact of deer and current deer management practices on the Scottish Government’s economic, social and environmental policy targets?
Official Report · Committee
Deer Management
Speakers
Showing Graeme Dey only · show everyone- Rob Gibson SNP 39
- Richard Cooke Association of Deer Management Groups 38
- Alex Fergusson Con 29
- Duncan Orr-Ewing RSPB Scotland 27
- Mike Daniels John Muir Trust 25
- Dr Keegan 24
- Jamie Williamson Scottish Land & Estates 19
- Nigel Don SNP 13
- Graeme Dey SNP 13
- Claudia Beamish Lab 9
- Richard Lyle SNP 7
- Jim Hume LD 6
- Alex Hogg Scottish Gamekeepers Association 6
- Angus MacDonald SNP 4
- Cara Hilton 2
- Dr Maggie Keegan Scottish Wildlife Trust 1
Graeme Dey’s contributions
13 contributionsIs there a part of the country that you can point to, say that the deer management agreement in that particular area is not working and tell us what its impact is? Do you have examples?
Being realistic, given that the code of practice has been in place only for two years, are we being unreasonable in our expectations of what improvement should have been made during that period, or is the situation so bad that it has been proven that the code does not work?
Is the panel saying that out of 49 DMGs, not one is functioning in a way that could be held up as an example of good practice?
Mike Daniels, on the previous panel, asserted that in his experience DMGs were a “stag club”, and did not take into account the impact on biodiversity and the environment in determining their approach and planning. I accept that Richard Cooke has effectively challenged that point, but I invite him to provide some examples of how DMGs are taking account of the need to protect the environment and natural habitat.Others have referred to the ADMG’s principles of collaboration. Bullet point 1 mentions“a shared commitment to a sustainable and economically viable Scottish countryside”.What does the term “sustainable” mean in that context? Is it about protecting the environment or simply about protecting the number of deer that are available to shoot?
Taking that a bit further, how do you, in your role, use it as a best practice example and encourage other DMGs to adopt that type of approach?
Given your presumably considerable experience of attending DMG meetings, do you recognise the description of someone who wants to speak up for environmental habitat interests feeling intimidated in such settings?
At the risk of going off at a tangent, I am intrigued by the price of venison. The figures that are quoted as what you get for a carcase seem extremely low compared with what the consumer pays to purchase venison. It strikes me that someone is making a killing, and it is not the estates or the gamekeepers who benefit.
To follow up on Alex Hogg’s point about electric fences, I have seen those in operation in the National Trust for Scotland Ben Lawers reserve, where they work extremely effectively.Who pays for the fencing? Is it paid for from the public purse or does the landowner pay for it? Do we fence the deer in or do we fence them out?
I should perhaps clarify that I was asking who should pay for the fence, rather than who does pay for it.
First, I would like a definition of the medium term. Secondly, Alex Hogg spoke about everyone being involved under the voluntary set-up, but we heard evidence from the previous panel of witnesses that, from their perspective, not everyone is involved, and there is a feeling that they are not welcome in deer management groups. That is the view that they have—rightly or wrongly—expressed. What will you take away from the evidence that you have heard today that will drive your thinking going forward to ensure that everyone ends up being involved in deer management groups?
And do you have a definition of the medium term to which you referred?
That is useful—thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Nov 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Deer Management Committee business · 262
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.