I want to look at the numbers. I am not suggesting that it is all about numbers; we have already touched on many issues and we will come back to them. However, numbers are clearly part of the discussion. I want to put to you a wee calculation to see whether it makes sense to you. It seems to be consistent with what we are being told. I will draw some conclusions from it and see whether you agree with them. The calculation goes like this. If I have a herd of 1,000 red deer—it could be any kind of deer, but I will talk about red deer—I might reasonably assume that half are hinds and half are stags. If I assume that of the 500 hinds, 400 are of reproductive age and if I accept the number that everybody gives me, some 30 per cent of those will produce a calf each year. That suggests that a herd of 1,000 will produce 120 progeny each year. If I work on the basis that half the progeny are male, then I will get 60 stags a year. The figure of 60 stags from a herd of 1,000 deer every year suggests that I need 16 stags in a herd as a multiplier to get me the one stag that I might want to shoot. Okay? That is my first calculation.If I am allowed to work on the 30 per cent progeny rate, which is the number that really matters in all of this, it suggests that I would need only eight stags in a herd to produce one calf. Therefore, to provide a sustainable herd on any scale I would need to kill in one way or another one in eight of that herd each year. I note that the figures on page 18 of the Scottish Parliament information centre report show that, solely for red deer, the cull over the past 20 years has been about 60,000. If I am allowed to use my multiplier of eight, then I arrive at a figure of 480,000 deer in Scotland pretty much every year over that period. That seems to be higher than any estimate that we have. Forgive me for saying that it is about numbers at the moment, but can the panellists please comment on that calculation and say to what extent I have that right and what it might tell us about the number of red deer in Scotland?
Official Report · Committee
Deer Management
Speakers
Showing Nigel Don only · show everyone- Rob Gibson SNP 39
- Richard Cooke Association of Deer Management Groups 38
- Alex Fergusson Con 29
- Duncan Orr-Ewing RSPB Scotland 27
- Mike Daniels John Muir Trust 25
- Dr Keegan 24
- Jamie Williamson Scottish Land & Estates 19
- Nigel Don SNP 13
- Graeme Dey SNP 13
- Claudia Beamish Lab 9
- Richard Lyle SNP 7
- Jim Hume LD 6
- Alex Hogg Scottish Gamekeepers Association 6
- Angus MacDonald SNP 4
- Cara Hilton 2
- Dr Maggie Keegan Scottish Wildlife Trust 1
Nigel Don’s contributions
13 contributionsI would like to pursue that, unless anybody else wants to disagree. I am grateful for your confirmation, but I would like to explore why the panellists feel that there is any demand whatsoever for having those numbers of red deer if people on sporting estates want to shoot only 4,000 stags. Other folk will have to get out there with their guns and shoot another 60,000 stags, which seems to me to be a quite disproportionate excess. I do not want to comment on anybody’s motives, but that seems to be entirely inappropriate.
Good morning, gentlemen. I am very grateful that you were here for the first panel, because I will not to have to do the maths again. I wonder whether I could get your perspective, please. As I said then, I realise that numbers ain’t everything in this, but we keep coming back to them. Perhaps we could try to get some consensus on what the range might be at least.I put two propositions to the previous panel. The first was that, in order to have a stag to shoot this year, a herd of around 16 is needed. That seems to be the multiplier using the sums that I used. Equally, if I say that only a multiplier of eight is needed for the cull—I was talking about red deer only—the average cull over the past 20 years appears to be around 60,000, according to the numbers that we have, so I multiplied the figure up to something rather nearer half a million. Those are the raw numbers. Having heard the raw arithmetic, can you enlighten me as to whether that is a correct kind of conclusion?
So you would be prepared to accept that, on any calculation, the total population of red deer must lie somewhere between 300,000 and, say, 450,000. I am not arguing which end of that range the total should be.
That is very helpful.Let me then address the other point that I drew from that. If the total sporting take is 4,000 stags a year, which is the number that we have been given, that suggests that we would not need anything like that total population. However, I take the point that Mike Daniels made that you would want some spare—in fact, you would want some spare by a multiplier—because, if you had only the right number of stags out there, you would be hunting for them mighty hard so I can see why you would not want to do that. My proposition is that there may be more total accessible deer than you really need for the sporting take.
Can you give me an estimate of what the multiplier might be—this will be a very woolly number, but it would still be nice to have a clue—if you wanted to be able to find, say, 15,000 stags? How many more would you need out there in order to be able to find the 15,000 within any reasonable timetable?
If I take your numbers—we are dealing with round figures, and I respect that—your suggestion is that the population is about right.
I am sure that colleagues will want to explore that.
To an extent, the questions that I wanted to ask have been covered, so I will go back to the general issue. Alex Hogg said that he has 40 years’ experience. We have spent the past two and a bit hours talking, in effect, about what has happened in our hills over the past generation. Alex, given that you heard all that was said in the earlier evidence session, what is your perspective on what has or has not changed regarding the numbers or the environment in which you have worked over the past generation?
My question naturally extends from that point. Mr Cooke, you said that, although someone can have a management objective within a certain area, they will, if their deer are just going to wander across into someone else’s area and come back when they feel like it, always have to consider what is outside. Am I right in thinking therefore that one of the biggest problems is how you manage outside your boundaries and manage the conflicts of interest between different deer management areas?
I wonder whether I can push you slightly. Because I am in the same profession, I recognise a diplomatic and guarded answer when I hear one. You have told us that 36 out of the 46 deer management groups already have deer management plans and—if I heard you aright—that it will take five or six years to get the other 10 groups on board. Do you recognise that, from my side of the table, that sounds like an awfully long time?
I am asking you, given your position, to recognise that, if there are 10 areas out there that you feel are not going to play ball very quickly, that might explain why some of the earlier witnesses want some kind of statutory system. Not doing something within five years sounds like not doing it, and that sounds like not voluntary action but voluntary inaction.
Thank you. It is useful to get a paragraph or two about that on the record.
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Nov 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Deer Management Committee business · 262
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.