Are the measures sticking plasters? What you are suggesting is a massive cull of deer. From Nigel Don, I think, we heard that we need 60,000, but we have got 400,000. I am not averse to that culling, because I am hearing that the deer population is damaging the natural habitat. I was previously against culls, but I will have to think about that.I will move on to the question that I really should be asking you. We have two sides: you are saying one thing, and the Scottish Gamekeepers Association is saying another. In relation to making deer management statutory, the SGA submission states:“It also presupposes that those with the requisite skills to manage the land and its deer properly are not the skilled working people native to that land area but appointees by central government.”You are not appointees of central Government and you are suggesting that we have to look at the issue seriously. I take the point—I was not on the committee when it considered the WANE bill two and a half years ago, but I think that, as you suggest, it is not working. How would you respond to the Scottish Gamekeepers Association’s critique of what a change to statutory deer management might involve? How would a statutory system balance social, economic and environmental considerations? You are not Government appointees and your suggestions about what we need to do to manage the problem are different from those of the SGA.
Official Report · Committee
Deer Management
Speakers
Showing Richard Lyle only · show everyone- Rob Gibson SNP 39
- Richard Cooke Association of Deer Management Groups 38
- Alex Fergusson Con 29
- Duncan Orr-Ewing RSPB Scotland 27
- Mike Daniels John Muir Trust 25
- Dr Keegan 24
- Jamie Williamson Scottish Land & Estates 19
- Nigel Don SNP 13
- Graeme Dey SNP 13
- Claudia Beamish Lab 9
- Richard Lyle SNP 7
- Jim Hume LD 6
- Alex Hogg Scottish Gamekeepers Association 6
- Angus MacDonald SNP 4
- Cara Hilton 2
- Dr Maggie Keegan Scottish Wildlife Trust 1
Richard Lyle’s contributions
7 contributionsSo we really need everyone to sit down and work together. We really need to involve the people who say that they are not really bothered about the WANE act or that they are not going to do anything about it. I liked your earlier point, Dr Keegan, about going on to a website and being unable to find the policies or the action plans. I have been informed that in some areas there are 55 deer per km2. You are suggesting that five deer per km2 is the best ratio but that in some areas there are nine.
Given the numbers of deer that we have, can we not increase the number of jobs and the opportunities for the general public to go on a shoot instead of people in what I call the establishment spending £5,000, or whatever it is? I have to say that I do not share the Scottish Gamekeepers Association’s concerns; we can improve the local economy by increasing the number of jobs and exports of venison, which, I have to say, I have never tasted in my life.
So you are on the establishment’s land.
I cannot get my head round the figures that have been provided. In 1963, there were 150,000 deer on the hills; now, there are 400,000. You say that not 4,000 but 15,000 stags are being shot.
I would love to know where you get those figures from; they range wildly.In relation to what Mr Williamson said, I think that it is a great idea to get people to visit for £200 or whatever. Landowners should do what hotels do—rearrange their prices to encourage people to come. It is true that they have to be licensed to shoot; I am sure that there are many people who are.In Scotland, we are improving our food production, but the only place that I have seen venison is Harrod’s in London. I have not seen it in my local supermarket. Interruption.
The fact is that we have got this number of deer. As we asked Alex Hogg, is there an opportunity to employ more people and develop the business better?
In this meeting
Everything on 13 Nov 2013 →- 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 10:00 Interests Procedure · 3
- 10:00 Deer Management Committee business · 262
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.