Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Forth Crossing

Thursday 15 January 2009 Meeting of the Parliament Debate 120 contributions · 24 speakers

Speakers

Showing Andy Kerr only · show everyone

Andy Kerr’s contributions

9 contributions
Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
The cabinet secretary referred to a "not-for-profit scheme". Did he not mean a non-profit-distributing model?

Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
I think the member will find that the ruling in of tolls was done by her—the measure was not suggested by any Labour member. However, for clarity, Iain Gray has resolved the matter.

Did the member stand on a manifesto that said that the Scottish Futures Trust would fund the crossing?

Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
I do not recall any procrastination, but I will take the member's word for it. She talked about the need for definitive commitments to projects. The First Minister said:

"If we have a new bridge, a bond issue is definitely the way to do it."

Does the member share that definitive view?

Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
Over the past few months and years, we have watched the unravelling of the Scottish Futures Trust, and today's debate marks the end of it as a meaningful Government policy. I will explain why in a minute.

Many members have already dealt with some key aspects of the Scottish Futures Trust. It is the mark of this debate that I am left convinced that the Government is not sure what to build and why it is building it. It has clearly lost its mechanism for funding the project—the Scottish Futures Trust. I share Murdo Fraser's view that the Government is seeking to blame someone else for its own fiscal incompetence. Ministers must be prepared to admit that it is their actions that are causing pressure on capital budgets across Scotland and which will lead to other projects being cancelled. Unless the Government reinvents the financial strategy called the Scottish Futures Trust and makes it work, its argument about its so-called rational approach to the Treasury will not stack up. That goes back to Murdo Fraser's point—that the Government's argument seeks to disguise the fact that it could not get its proposal to work.

The First Minister said at question time today:

"when a minister gives a commitment, that commitment is met. That is how the process works."

Those words will come back to haunt him in many different ways, particularly in relation to the Scottish Futures Trust. It is not other ministers but the First Minister himself who is on record as saying:

"If we have a new bridge, a bond issue is definitely the way to do it."

Even though he said today that

"when a minister gives a commitment, that commitment is met",

we know that, on this occasion, that is not the case.

Fergus Ewing said:

"Financing the scheme through a bond issue under the SNP's proposed Scottish Futures Trust is seen by experts"—

I say that laughingly; I do not know who they were—

"as significantly cheaper"

and the

"preferred option … a replacement crossing is vital, we must ensure that we use"

that method. Again, even though the First Minister said today that

"when a minister gives a commitment, that commitment is met",

that is not the case here.

Mr Swinney, too, is guilty. The Herald reported:

"Mr Swinney said the government intended to use the planned Scottish Futures Trust to pay for the bridge as an alternative to the Public Private Partnership."

Of course, we all know that the Government cannot get the Scottish Futures Trust to work, and that it has shrivelled away to a minor quango, which will merely draw together some projects, doing a job that our civil service used to do—without the £23 million that will be necessary to fund the SFT. From that great idea of Scots all buying their patriotic bonds and the Scottish Futures Trust crowding out all other funding methods, the SFT is now reduced to being something whose purpose is, as Mr Swinney said on "Good Morning Scotland",

"to essentially bring about collaboration between different projects of a smaller scale."

Gone is the mighty idea that was the Scottish Futures Trust.

As we have progressed through the debate, members have pointed those matters out. On the exchange between Jeremy Purvis and Stewart Stevenson about the details of various websites that they had sought to use in evidence, I never knew that accounting could be so exciting. However, everyone in the street, and indeed everyone in the financial industries in Scotland, including contractors and consultants, knows that the Scottish Futures Trust is doomed to failure.

Many other members rightly pointed to the need for a multimodal shift.

Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
The cabinet secretary fails to recognise that we have not advocated the use of PPP for the Forth road crossing. If he is willing to open the books, I would be happy to come to a conclusion on the matter. We have said that the crowding-out mechanism of the Scottish Futures Trust has not worked. It is the cabinet secretary and his Government that are endangering our hospitals, schools and roads.

On the viability of PPP, I point out that the Limehouse link, the docklands light railway and the Jubilee line used traditional funding mechanisms but were massively over budget and hugely late. Why does the cabinet secretary think that the traditional model that he describes will somehow work perfectly? If we read the National Audit Office's report comparing PPP projects with traditional models, we find that 70 per cent of the traditional models unfortunately came in over budget and not within the required timescale.

There are many benefits to the use of PPP, such as risk transfer and certainty of delivery. I state again—for the record and so that the cabinet secretary understands it clearly—that I am not advocating its use for the Forth replacement crossing. However, he and his Government have ruled out that mechanism of finance, which leads them to try to blame Westminster for the lack of delivery that will result on other infrastructure projects.

Many other members also asked what happened to the £900 million of end-year flexibility that should have been put into the project—perhaps the cabinet secretary can deal with that point when he intervenes. We all knew that the bridge was the biggest project set to hit the capital budget in Scotland and that it had to be funded. However, £900 million came up the road to Scotland and is now gone; £650 million was saved in the budget from the Edinburgh airport rail link and is now gone. What exactly has the cabinet secretary done with the money and why was he not planning for the biggest ever project that the Government would have to deal with?

Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
I apologise, but I will need to wait for what the Treasury has to say about that. However it chooses to deal with the rules on PPP/PFI, the fact that it is off balance sheet is not the only reason why one would entertain the use of that financial mechanism. Whatever the Treasury says on the matter, it does not matter for the bridge because there are other methods of funding projects that deliver for the taxpayer far more safely.

On the cabinet secretary's first point, the SNP has the biggest ever Scottish budget, the additional EYF money and money saved in budgets all over the place but, when it wrote its manifesto and said that the bridge would be funded by the Scottish Futures Trust, it knew that this was the biggest project that it would have to deal with. Of course, it now knows that it cannot deliver and has sought to blame Westminster for its own incompetence.

We have talked about childish games—I think that Tricia Marwick brought that up. The Labour Party is not being childish about this important project. For two years, the SNP said that it had a funding mechanism and then, two weeks before it made the announcement, sent a letter to the Treasury. I have asked before what engagement Scottish Government finance officials had with Treasury officials prior to that letter being sent, because I am sure that they knew the answer in advance.

Andy Kerr Lab East Kilbride
link
I would like to move on.

On rewriting history, I found it ironic when some members criticised PPP. They should have attended some of the previous debates in the Parliament. Unison, the Cuthberts and Allyson Pollock all have equal criticism and condemnation of the original Scottish Futures Trust model. Indeed, the cabinet secretary was forced to admit that it was simply a member of the PFI/PPP family.

Murdo Fraser asked whether the Government was incompetent, attempting to bounce the Treasury into saying yes or even hoping that it would say no. I share his view that it is some, if not all, of the above. The Government sought to have a fight with Westminster to get a scapegoat. As we all understand, sending a letter to the Treasury 14 days in advance of the debate was simply unacceptable.

I would have liked to reflect on many other speeches, but I have run out of time.

The mighty Scottish Futures Trust and the patriotic bonds have shrivelled away to an expensive quango, doing a job that civil servants used to do. In no way is anyone other than the cabinet secretary and his colleagues responsible for any impact on the budgets for schools, hospitals and roads, which have been put at risk. They are responsible—it is their incompetence.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 15 January 2009 Debate · 1
  2. Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 64
  3. Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
  4. Gaza Questions · 6
  5. Urban Woodland Questions · 6
  6. Transport Developments Questions · 6
  7. Electricity Supply Interruptions (Compensation for Small Businesses) Questions · 6
  8. Public Transport (Roxburgh and Berwickshire) Questions · 6
  9. Shop Workers (Redundancy Support) Questions · 6
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
  11. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  13. Financial Sector Jobs First Minister’s Questions · 8
  14. Homecoming Scotland 2009 (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Unintentional Homelessness First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Presiding Officer's Statement Procedure · 3
  17. Housing Associations Questions · 12
  18. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 8
  19. Poverty and Income Inequality Questions · 8
  20. Care Home Staff (Fife) Questions · 4
  21. Southern General Hospital Questions · 6
  22. Telehealth and Telemedicine Questions · 4
  23. GHA (Management) Ltd (Regulation) Questions · 4
  24. Specialist Nurses (Motor Neurone Disease) Questions · 4
  25. Alcohol Misuse Services (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
  26. National Health Service Dentists (Grampian) Questions · 6
  27. Repossessions (Homeowner Support) Questions · 6
  28. “Financial overview of the NHS in Scotland 2007/08” Questions · 8
  29. Forth Crossing Debate · 120
  30. Decision Time Decision time · 31
  31. Bull Hire Scheme Members’ business · 34

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.