To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-1348)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister's Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 5
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson 1
The record
11 contributionsLater today I will have meetings to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
Like the First Minister, I am old enough to remember the recession of the 1980s. I was a teacher in this city then, and I remember watching hope drain away from every youngster in the school in the face of that recession. That must not happen again. Now is the time that we must show confidence in our young people. In recent days, Labour ministers have announced thousands of new apprenticeships; bonuses for teachers in the most deprived communities; more help for students from poor backgrounds to go to and get through university; and an aspiration to reduce the number of unskilled workers in this country from 5 million to 500,000. However, that has not happened here in Scotland, under the Scottish National Party. What action will the First Minister take?
The Scottish Government is taking substantial action to do everything within its powers to combat the forces of recession. I point out to Iain Gray that the figure of 36,000 modern apprenticeships and skillseekers places in Scotland is far higher pro rata than the figure south of the border. Even with the most recent announcement, at least another 30,000 places would be needed in England to achieve the rate that we already have in Scotland. Incidentally, our target of 50,000 suitable training places over the next few years is far higher than anything south of the border.
I hope that Iain Gray will take the opportunity to apologise for James Purnell's attack on the Scottish Government for not using European social fund money. In fact, we announced that we would do so last August—five months before the Westminster Government.
I hope that Iain Gray will take the opportunity to apologise for James Purnell's attack on the Scottish Government for not using European social fund money. In fact, we announced that we would do so last August—five months before the Westminster Government.
The trouble is, what the First Minister says seldom reflects reality—just ask the Scottish Inter Faith Council. The SNP will not tell us what is counted in the 50,000 training places that the First Minister mentioned. The equivalent number south of the border is 7.5 million—a far higher rate.
Ask the tourism industry. Recently, the First Minister said:
"We need to take advantage of economic circumstances to give a substantial boost to the Scottish tourism industry, which is the greatest industry in Scotland."
That is what he says, but the reality is that the SNP has done away with adult apprenticeships in tourism—not just some, but all of them. The message to anyone over 18 is that there is no future for them in the "greatest" industry. Will the First Minister reinstate those training programmes now?
Ask the tourism industry. Recently, the First Minister said:
"We need to take advantage of economic circumstances to give a substantial boost to the Scottish tourism industry, which is the greatest industry in Scotland."
That is what he says, but the reality is that the SNP has done away with adult apprenticeships in tourism—not just some, but all of them. The message to anyone over 18 is that there is no future for them in the "greatest" industry. Will the First Minister reinstate those training programmes now?
Let us look at the increases in the number of the training places that the SNP Government has announced. There are key increases not just in engineering and the construction industry but across the college sector. Before he got to his fantasy figure of 7.5 million—he had better check that—Iain Gray omitted to inform us whether James Purnell, who presumably got his facts from Scottish Labour, was right or wrong to make an attack on the Scottish Government for not using European social fund money that the UK Government announced recently. Is it correct or incorrect—I have the details here—that that money and the enhanced training places for which it allows were announced in August? Am I right or wrong in saying that James Purnell and the Labour Party were five months out of date?
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
It is for Mr Gray to ask the questions. If I recall rightly, he asked about tourism.
Thank you, Presiding Officer. In his answer, the First Minister moved on to some of the traditional trades, so let us deal with those. Yesterday, Michael Levack of the Scottish Building Federation told the Parliament that, last year, it had more than 2,200 apprentices in trades such as joinery and plumbing. This year, the projected figure is just 1,500, with 250 of those facing redundancy.
This morning, I was contacted by a worried father of two apprentices. He told me of a company in Tranent and another in Musselburgh, in my constituency, that are laying off apprentices who are already in the third and fourth years of their time. In Northern Ireland, the Executive has given redundant apprentices a guarantee that they can complete their training. If my young constituents were in east Belfast rather than East Lothian, they would have a guarantee that they could serve their time and qualify. Can I phone that father back tonight and tell him that the First Minister will give the same guarantee?
This morning, I was contacted by a worried father of two apprentices. He told me of a company in Tranent and another in Musselburgh, in my constituency, that are laying off apprentices who are already in the third and fourth years of their time. In Northern Ireland, the Executive has given redundant apprentices a guarantee that they can complete their training. If my young constituents were in east Belfast rather than East Lothian, they would have a guarantee that they could serve their time and qualify. Can I phone that father back tonight and tell him that the First Minister will give the same guarantee?
We have announced 1,000 extra modern apprenticeship places in engineering and construction alone.
European social fund money is important. Almost 300 Scottish projects are already benefiting from the announcement; £200 million of the money that was announced in August is being used to support economic development, enhanced skills, increasing turnover and the creation of new jobs. At some stage, Labour MSPs will realise that the Labour Government's economic mismanagement might have something to do with the recession that is afflicting people in Scotland, or does Iain Gray think that "green shoots" of recovery are evident in the economic circumstances that we face?
European social fund money is important. Almost 300 Scottish projects are already benefiting from the announcement; £200 million of the money that was announced in August is being used to support economic development, enhanced skills, increasing turnover and the creation of new jobs. At some stage, Labour MSPs will realise that the Labour Government's economic mismanagement might have something to do with the recession that is afflicting people in Scotland, or does Iain Gray think that "green shoots" of recovery are evident in the economic circumstances that we face?
This is a global recession. What matters is the response that we make. In Northern Ireland, the guarantee that I mentioned has been given; I hope that my young constituents are watching so that they can see our First Minister ignore their plight.
We should go further in showing our confidence in Scotland's young people. Under Labour in England, every young person who is qualified for one and wants it will be guaranteed the right to an apprenticeship. Under Labour in Glasgow, every young person who leaves school this year with the appropriate qualifications will be entitled to an apprenticeship. Wherever it can do so, Labour is delivering a future for our young people, but here it is up to the SNP. Will the First Minister match Labour and guarantee an apprenticeship to every 16-year-old who qualifies for one and wants it, or will he let Scotland's youngsters down?
We should go further in showing our confidence in Scotland's young people. Under Labour in England, every young person who is qualified for one and wants it will be guaranteed the right to an apprenticeship. Under Labour in Glasgow, every young person who leaves school this year with the appropriate qualifications will be entitled to an apprenticeship. Wherever it can do so, Labour is delivering a future for our young people, but here it is up to the SNP. Will the First Minister match Labour and guarantee an apprenticeship to every 16-year-old who qualifies for one and wants it, or will he let Scotland's youngsters down?
Youngsters have the opportunity, through the more choices, more chances initiative, to take up a place in training or education in Scotland.
At some point, the Labour Party had better understand that the figure of 36,000 modern apprenticeships and skillseekers places in Scotland is far higher pro rata than the number south of the border. Lord George Foulkes is shaking his head, but I will send him the figures so that he realises that we have more of our young people in apprenticeships and training in Scotland than the Labour Government does south of the border. Given that Iain Gray could not bring himself to acknowledge the fact in a succession of three questions, is there anyone on the Labour benches who disputes that the social fund money was used by the Scottish Government in August? The projects that will benefit from that social fund money will affect community partnerships across Scotland. That is real, effective action by the Scottish Government.
Iain Gray suggests that Downing Street has nothing to do with the current recession. It is interesting that the current Prime Minister was able and willing to claim all the credit for the years of economic growth, but Iain Gray and the Labour Party want to disavow their responsibility for the downturn, which affects not only young people but the whole population of Scotland.
At some point, the Labour Party had better understand that the figure of 36,000 modern apprenticeships and skillseekers places in Scotland is far higher pro rata than the number south of the border. Lord George Foulkes is shaking his head, but I will send him the figures so that he realises that we have more of our young people in apprenticeships and training in Scotland than the Labour Government does south of the border. Given that Iain Gray could not bring himself to acknowledge the fact in a succession of three questions, is there anyone on the Labour benches who disputes that the social fund money was used by the Scottish Government in August? The projects that will benefit from that social fund money will affect community partnerships across Scotland. That is real, effective action by the Scottish Government.
Iain Gray suggests that Downing Street has nothing to do with the current recession. It is interesting that the current Prime Minister was able and willing to claim all the credit for the years of economic growth, but Iain Gray and the Labour Party want to disavow their responsibility for the downturn, which affects not only young people but the whole population of Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Jan 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 15 January 2009 Debate · 1
- Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 64
- Health Boards (Membership and Elections) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
- Gaza Questions · 6
- Urban Woodland Questions · 6
- Transport Developments Questions · 6
- Electricity Supply Interruptions (Compensation for Small Businesses) Questions · 6
- Public Transport (Roxburgh and Berwickshire) Questions · 6
- Shop Workers (Redundancy Support) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
- Financial Sector Jobs First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Homecoming Scotland 2009 (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Unintentional Homelessness First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Presiding Officer's Statement Procedure · 3
- Housing Associations Questions · 12
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Poverty and Income Inequality Questions · 8
- Care Home Staff (Fife) Questions · 4
- Southern General Hospital Questions · 6
- Telehealth and Telemedicine Questions · 4
- GHA (Management) Ltd (Regulation) Questions · 4
- Specialist Nurses (Motor Neurone Disease) Questions · 4
- Alcohol Misuse Services (Aberdeen) Questions · 6
- National Health Service Dentists (Grampian) Questions · 6
- Repossessions (Homeowner Support) Questions · 6
- “Financial overview of the NHS in Scotland 2007/08” Questions · 8
- Forth Crossing Debate · 120
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Bull Hire Scheme Members’ business · 34
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.